Postmodern architecture in Ireland
- This topic has 29 replies, 14 voices, and was last updated 20 years, 5 months ago by
.
- Posts
Hi.
I’m doing a project on cultural expression in Ireland focusing on postmodern architecture. What else is considered post-modern architecture other than The National Gallery of Ireland? If this is a naive question, forgive meOne place to start would be with the Group 91 architects pre 1990, particularly John Twomey (OPW) Children’s Court Smithfield, O’Donnell Twomey IFC and Photographic Archive Temple Bar, McCulloch Mulvin, IEI and Abbey Theatre extensions, Grafton Architects, Building on Ormond Quay, Shane O’Toole et al Rear of Ark, Temple Bar, Temple Bar Masterplan (in total); facade over content. Throughout the country there are other numerous examples. Also look at AAI awards Books for the era before the awareness of Spanish Rationalism in the 1990’s. Some of the work does not stand up to scrutiny today. The problem with fashion and awards that follow is best summarised in the words of Mao who when asked about the impact of the French Revolution, he replied it was too early to say.
are you saying the new extension to the national gallery is an example of postmodernism?
not to sound too technical here ciaran, but you mentioned both “postmodern” and
“post-modern” both of which mean different things in that realm of architecturl intellectualism. postemodernism was amovement in the 80’s and 90’s mainly in ireland which used references and motifs from ancient greece, rome etc. in a playful manner, in the hope that buildings would be able to relate to the general public’s ideas of what a building should be. largely laughed at in hindsight this was very popular in the area of new office developments in the 90’s which stick out as cheap facile monsters in most citeis around the world. i would agree that most of shadows examples fall into this category.What?, can you direct me to more information on the difference between ‘post-modern’ and ‘postmodern’ architecture. It sounds interesting.
Thanks
Phil
i think i read it in a piece by charles jenks. he’s written a lot of books on the subject as it relates to architecture. there are also other meanings for the word in other contexts like, literature and art.
Thanks for that what?. I have some stuff by Jencks so I will look through that again.
what?
Is this the only ‘real’ example of postmodernism in Dublin, if not Ireland, in terms of sheer scale and conformity with international trends of the time? A monumental pile of an office building (influences of Webb’s Govt Buildings in there!) on Herbert Street, just opposite the Pepper Cannister:
Certainly been here for a few years as I’ve passed it for a while now, but still looks scarily recent…
Any other examples?I guess another example is that building on Tara Street which is now next door to that bow fronted modernist building the Times is moving to.
Jervis Street Shopping Centre?
Martin Ryan Institute for Marine Science, NUI Galway?
‘postmodernism was a movement in the 80’s and 90’s mainly in ireland which used references and motifs from ancient greece, rome etc. in a playful manner’
Only references to ancient rome and greece?: surely it also includes any reference to local traditional styles – my understanding was that that was what made contemporary Galway the embodiment of postmodern pastiche (old pseudo-land)- the synthesis of new architectural materials and styles with references to traditional-local elements also.
St Stephens Green Centre has to fall into the Postmodern category – It’s very “late Venturi” vith it’s massive clock inside and applied facade decoration… On one level it’s a bit of fun and I can remember being blown away by the place when it was new and I was only 10 or something! On every other level its a nightmare though…
From the ridiculous to the simply banal – the Ulster Bank offices on George’s Quay are one of the worst examples of bog standard Postmodern – contrast with the building next door on Moss St/Townsend St. which is essentially exactly the same except without the applied decoration.
Busker Browns pub, Galway
The Galway irish Crystal Heritage Centre? Built in the 1990s, I think.
Yeah, Galway Crystal is a great/awful example! Its probably soon to be demolished though – the site is up for sale with residential zoning… What a site for something fantastic to go up, right at the gateway to Galway city! What are the chances though….
@BTH wrote:
Yeah, Galway Crystal is a great/awful example! Its probably soon to be demolished though – the site is up for sale with residential zoning… What a site for something fantastic to go up, right at the gateway to Galway city! What are the chances though….
Thats mad news. The western suburbs of Galway are really spreading out at a phenomenal rate. Classic case of the need for higher density development if ever there was one.
There’s an office block on Mount Street (Lower or Upper? The non-Peppercanister one) by Andrzej Wejchert that is undeniably Postmodern, a term I understand as being close to Mannerism (Italian 16th century version), in that it is playful and ironic and depends on a basic familiarity with the ‘rules’ of classicism. This building has columns flanking the main entrance that support no pediment or entablature, and a cutstone arch that is missing its keystone, to name two features. I actually quite like it though I’m not usually a fan of Postmodernism, but I know it’s not universally admired.
It’s opposite one of those horrible pubs (Howl at the Moon?) near the Merrion Square end of the street.I’m not sure if I’d class the Galway Crystal place as pomo- I always thought it was trying to be the real deal of classicism and failing miserably rather than having any jokey classical allusions incorporated. Not so much tongue-in-cheek as tongue-hanging-out.
🙂 You do get that impression alright. Yes the Lower Mount St building would be a good example – there’s surprisingly few ‘pure’ postmodern buildings about.
Obviously it’s a broad church, which is why this thread was raised again – to try and root out blatent examples of postmodernism as distinct from the likes of the Ulster Bank as BTH says, or Beresford Court, Watergold and even the Treasury Building – all of which bear references to the style, but are essentially watered down versions, if even that – what are more often referred to here as ‘early 90s stuff’ than ‘postmodern’.The Herbert St building is a classic example of pomo as executed on an international level, as is the Tara St building, but we don’t seem to have much else about the country. It’s either architecture that just attempts a ‘classic look’, or the opposite end of the scale that goes all out reproduction.
@ctesiphon wrote:
Postmodern, a term I understand as being close to Mannerism (Italian 16th century version), in that it is playful and ironic and depends on a basic familiarity with the ‘rules’ of classicism.
The beauty of postmodernism is the difficulty in defining it – it is as slippery as an eel. I know in the world of literary, visual and musical arts, postmodernism does not necessarily involve any reference to classicism per se. Rather, it involves a rejection of master narratives (unlike modernism and victorianism) and a sense of frustration at the difficulty of ‘coming up’ with something new. To that end, it revels in re-hashing the past, in juxtaposing styles that may or may not sit comfortably together (consider, for example, the drawing together of different musical traditions and cultural images in Madonna’s new hit ‘Hung-up’). From my understanding of the issue, in architecture that can involve the sowing together of different architectural and cultural referents and artefacts, some of which can have an explicit connection with the architectural traditions of the local area but are not necessarily informed by any concept of classicism. :confused:
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
