Major Traffic Flow Changes for St Stephen’s Green
- This topic has 42 replies, 8 voices, and was last updated 22 years, 5 months ago by
blue.
- AuthorPosts
- May 3, 2004 at 4:47 pm #707055
GrahamH
ParticipantOwen Keegan of the CC’s traffic department announced on the radio this morning that the whole traffic flow arrangement for the Green is to change on account of Harcourt St, Cuffe St and Stephen’s Green South all converging into a mere two lanes on the newly narrowed Green West on account of the Luas terminus.
Major changes are to be implemented which will involve the elimination of the left turn off Cuffe St to Green West, and significantly, the alteration of Green South into a two-way system, i.e. all traffic coming up Cuffe St will take this new route.
The substantial excess capacity of Green East will be utilised by making this into a two-way system also; Green North will also be changed to two-way.Hence to get to Dawson St from Cuffe St, traffic will be funnelled along Green South, left around the corner and up Green East, left along Green North, and right down Dawson St.
Green West will effectively become pedestrianised, as will Green North from Grafton St to Dawson St. The CC are still considering whether to provide access to buses and taxis, this is likely, esp at the right turn from Cuffe St and coming from Harcourt St.
There are also a substantial amount of bus stops along the Grafton-to-Dawson stretch to be considered.Keegan says that if anything, this system will work better than the current – they have assessed the traffic flows of the current and proposed systems and found the new one to be at least as good as the present, if not better, as it eliminates quite a few right-hand turns. It is unclear as to whether new ones will be generated however, for example if a right turn is allowed at the junction with Earlsfort Terrace.
Presumably Kildare St is still a no no, and Merrion Row from Green East.
What implications this has for the brand new island bus stop in the middle of Green South I don’t know – presumably it has to go.
The change is to come into place in July, with the operation of Luas, and other than total chaos ensuing will be kept as of late summer.
It is a sudden spur-of-the-moment move by the CC, and they expect it to be completely successful.May 3, 2004 at 11:21 pm #742614vinnyfitz
ParticipantThis is certainly radical – just wondering can you provide a source? What radio programme was it on?
Where can we see the details?
Normally DCC announce things by public edict – after consultation on draft plans. Can’t see anything on dublincity.ie about this yet.
May 4, 2004 at 2:32 am #742615Paul Clerkin
KeymasterIt is in The Sunday Times
May 4, 2004 at 9:58 am #742616notjim
Participantso, traffic coming north on harcourt street will have to turn right across the luas track? or will harcourt street become public transport and access only, running along SG west? What about access to the RCSI multistorey via glover street?
May 4, 2004 at 10:33 am #742617blue
ParticipantNo mention of Harcourt St becoming a public transport only street in the Sunday Times so yes the traffic would turn right over the Luas tracks to get to Dawson st. It will be possible to go straight on, as before, but only as far as the lane beside surgeons.
Traffic on Hume St and Ely Place may be reversed in the future so there would be a right turn from the Green east (which will be one way) on to Merrion row, allowing access to Merrion St & Baggot St without having to go down Dawson St and back up Kildare St.
I think its a great idea because it will make use of the increased road width on the east side of the green and make the whole area around the top of Grafton st more pedestrian friendly.
May 4, 2004 at 11:00 am #742618vinnyfitz
ParticipantThanks for the link, blue.
So SG west will be closed for July and Aug for rebuilding. I guess in this period buses and taxis will have to go anticlockwise along green?
Will vehicles wanting to turn right off the green into Merrion Row be allowed? I guess not – they’ll have to continue round, down Dawson, across Molesworth, up Kildare St and back out past the Shelbourne?
Vehicles coming up Kildare St and heading for Earlsfort Tce will probably have to go out Merrion Row as well and turn right up Ely place and Hume st…
I wonder will traffic be allowed turn right out of Hume St and head down Dawson?
This reform has the potential to make life a lot easier for cyclists around the green if there is a little imagination applied…May 4, 2004 at 11:23 am #742619blue
ParticipantSo SG west will be closed for July and Aug for rebuilding. I guess in this period buses and taxis will have to go anticlockwise along green?
Yes
Will vehicles wanting to turn right off the green into Merrion Row be allowed? I guess not – they’ll have to continue round, down Dawson, across Molesworth, up Kildare St and back out past the Shelbourne?
Initally no, but if this goes well in the future this will be allowed. They also plan to reverse traffic on Ely place to give easier access to Merrion Sq.
Vehicles coming up Kildare St and heading for Earlsfort Tce will probably have to go out Merrion Row as well and turn right up Ely place and Hume st…
Well the way I see it the traffic on Stephens Green East will be one way so this traffic will have to use Pembroke St and Lesson St to access Earlsfort Tce.
This reform has the potential to make life a lot easier for cyclists around the green if there is a little imagination applied…
Hopefully, the top of Grafton St is a bit of a lottery with lots of predestrians, buses & taxis stopping and two very tight lanes of traffic.
May 4, 2004 at 11:33 am #742620vinnyfitz
ParticipantOriginally posted by blue
Well the way I see it the traffic on Stephens Green East will be one way so this traffic will have to use Pembroke St and Lesson St to access Earlsfort Tce.
You may be right but they would be more sensible to keep SG East two way – the pressure on the Pembroke St – Leeson St junction will be unbearable if they do as you predict. Surely all the buses from Nassau St which pick up outside the OPW will have to continue to use the Green?
May 4, 2004 at 11:44 am #742621blue
ParticipantYeah – agreed. Maybe that is what is planned but it certainly didn’t come across that way in the ST article so we’ll have to wait and see the offical document.
May 4, 2004 at 12:02 pm #742622notjim
Participanti couldn’t realy make sense of the ST article, what Graham Hickey says makes much more sense, in particular, the ST diagram implied SG east would be one way the other way, but then, how would you get from Nassau Street to Cuffe St?
May 4, 2004 at 3:57 pm #742623Sue
ParticipantSt Stephen’s Green East will maintain its bus lane running north/south (i.e. from Ely Place onto Earlsfort Terrace). The rest of the traffic on East will be south/north.
To get from Nassau Street to Cuffe Street you go up Kildare Street, turn right at the top onto Merrion Row (still allowed), onto Pemroke Street, Leeson Street, down Stephen’s Green south (now 2-way) and thence to Cuffe.
Official document is available – this was all discussed at a traffic subcommitte meeting on Thursday with three councillors in attendance (D. Heney and C. Burke among them). Also a NewsTalk reporter… who made a hash of reporting this on Friday morning, much to the consternation of DCC.
quote:
Will vehicles wanting to turn right off the green into Merrion Row be allowed? I guess not – they’ll have to continue round, down Dawson, across Molesworth, up Kildare St and back out past the Shelbourne?
EXACTLY RIGHTquote:
Vehicles coming up Kildare St and heading for Earlsfort Tce will probably have to go out Merrion Row as well and turn right up Ely place and Hume st…
IF THEY TURN RIGHT UP ELY, THEY WILL BE DOUBLING BACK ON THEMSELVES – AT LEAST FOR THE MOMENT. COUNCIL MAY CHANGE DIRECTION ON ELY EVENTUALLYquote:
is a sudden spur-of-the-moment move by the CC, and they expect it to be completely successful.G. HICKEY IS RIGHT ON THIS. THERE WAS NO CONSULTATION EITHER, AND THERE SHOULD HAVE BEEN. THE CORPO IS USING SLEIGHT OF HAND BY BRINGING THIS IN AS AN “EMERGENCY” MEASURE, WHICH THEY WILL THEN SAY HAS WORKED AND MAKE IT PERMANENT.
Still, in Ireland consultation means argument and delay. Sometimes totalitarianism works best!!!May 4, 2004 at 4:08 pm #742624blue
ParticipantCheers sue, where is document? is it online? I couldn’t find it on any of the obvious sites?
I think the whole idea is to make it awkward for those who want to go from Nassau St to Cuffe st to put them off going that way!
May 4, 2004 at 4:56 pm #742625vinnyfitz
ParticipantLike blue I’d love to read the document – Sue if you have influence can you persuade DCC to post it on thier site?
I predict disaster if the proportion of traffic turning right at the top of Pembroke St to flow West towards the Green is doubled by this innovation.
In addition to the current heavy stream (esp evening rush hour) you will have
(a) the (non bus) flow that currently comes up Kildare St and along SG East
(b) the flow the comes up Merrion St and through Ely place onto the Green.Impossible to squeeze all of that into one lane at top of Pembroke St in my opinion.
May 4, 2004 at 7:00 pm #742626Anonymous
InactiveWhat are all those old dears with their jeeps dropping their kids into Loretto going to do now? I presume triple parking will be impossible now. 😀
Fair play,
Stephens Green West has been a disater since the LUAS went in, they are right to try it, they can always reverse it if it doesn’t work 😉
May 5, 2004 at 9:33 am #742627blue
ParticipantThey’ll have to buy a bus or a taxi sign and I wouldn’t put it past them.
May 5, 2004 at 10:35 am #742628Sue
ParticipantYes, the Loreto parents will be severely discommoded – the council factored that into their decisions!
The report is entitled Report to the Chairman and Members of the Traffic and Transportation Strategic Policy Committee, produced by the Roads and Traffic Dept. Given that it was presented to the traffic and transportation strategic policy committee, I don’t see why they wouldn’t hand it out.
They used the DTO Saturn model to provide an origin/destination matrix, and traffic count data from 2003 and 2004 to provide the traffic volumes for the Green. This found that the two dominant movements are Cuffe Street to Merrion Row (522 vehicles in the peak hour or 50% of Cuffe Street traffic) and Leeson Street to Dawson Street (855 vehicles in the peak hour or 67% of Leeson Street traffic). The former route is now made extremely difficult; the latter is being kept but going in a different direction along Stephen’s Green East.
I predict disaster if the proportion of traffic turning right at the top of Pembroke St to flow West towards the Green is doubled by this innovation.
QUOTE:
In addition to the current heavy stream (esp evening rush hour) you will have
(a) the (non bus) flow that currently comes up Kildare St and along SG East
(b) the flow the comes up Merrion St and through Ely place onto the GreenYES, BUT THERE WILL BE LESS TRAFFIC ON MERRION ROW DUE TO THE FACT THAT CARS CAN’T GO DIRECTLY ON TO IT FROM CUFFE STREET VIA STEPHEN’S GREEN WEST AND NORTH. AND, AS THE RESEARCH SHOWED, HALF OF ALL CUFFE STREET TRAFFIC IS DOING THAT.
One point I’d love to know: does anyone have a date as to when the Green was last two-way, even in part?
May 5, 2004 at 10:51 am #742629vinnyfitz
ParticipantSue thanks for the additional info.
I’m not sure what the Cuffe St flow has to do with my Pembroke St point however? We are talking entirely different cohorts of traffic.I take your point that Merrion Row willl be much calmer – do you think there is any chance they would install a contraflow cycle lane as a result?
As a matter of interest where do they think the Cuffe to Merrion Row traffic will mainly go instead? Dame St, North quays or Canal ring? None are all that fluid.
Me broadly in favour but goes off to request report to try and grasp details….
May 5, 2004 at 11:23 am #742630Sue
ParticipantQUOTE:
I’m not sure what the Cuffe St flow has to do with my Pembroke St point however.Doesn’t Merrion Row traffic go on to Pembroke Street via Lower Baggot Street, or am I mixing up roads?
QUOTE:
As a matter of interest where do they think the Cuffe to Merrion Row traffic will mainly go instead? Dame St, North quays or Canal ring? None are all that fluid.The report says: “Anyone wanting to get from Harcourt Street or Cuffe Street onto Merrion Row will have to go along Stephens Green South, left onto Stephens Green East, right onto Dawson St, right onto Molesworth St, right onto Kildare St, left onto Stephen’s Green North, and straight onto Merrion Row”.
Would you bother? I think only in an emergency….
May 5, 2004 at 11:38 am #742631blue
ParticipantI wonder why they don’t reverse traffic flow on Ely place and Hume St from the start? This would cut out out having to do “Dawson St, right onto Molesworth St, right onto Kildare St, left onto Stephen’s Green North, and straight onto Merrion Row”.
Who’s going to use Ely place/Hume St now anyway because you’ll have to turn right at the top and virutally back onto yourself?
May 5, 2004 at 11:45 am #742632vinnyfitz
ParticipantYou are mixing up roads I’m afraid.
Merrion Street runs past the back of the Dail and government buildings and joins at right angles to Merrion row. Its significance is that Westland Row (i.e. North City) traffic heading for Earlsfort Terace, Ranelagh and Rathgar etc use it intensively – esp at evening rush hour.On the second point I’m not expressing myslef clearly. Cuffe St traffic is not heading for Merrion Row itself – this is by far the most smooth flowing solution to go South from the South inner City. Say you are in either Temple Bar or on the north quays the smart way to reach e.g. Ballsbridge or Donnybrook is to head for Cuffe St and then its plain sailing around the green and down Baggot St (until now that is). The future options will be to follow the north quays to matt talbot and across or alternatively to take Clanbrasil St and turn left at Harold’s Cross and down the canal which is already wicked.
- AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

