Reply To: carlisle pier shortlist

For the sake of DunLaoire it is lucky that it is only on their website and that the competition process intervened to take it off the agenda.

It is a pathetic design i.e. The 1999 design,

all of the current finalist’s designs have significant merit.

I think it proves the benefits of architectural competitions as the finer points of each design can be examined much more thoroughly once direct comparibles exist.

It also proves that all the consortia to this process rejected the 1999 design. 🙂