malec

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 16 posts - 81 through 96 (of 96 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Eglinton Street Tower, Cork #780192
    malec
    Participant

    @Angry Rebel wrote:

    They were piling throughout late May and most of June. Not sure what stage they’re at currently.

    I can see the site from my window as we live up above Wellington Road but all I can make out is a large hole in the ground.


    Anyway, I think this thread needs a few images:

    I actually can’t wait until I can see the tower starting to rise. No doubt my family will complain about it blocking our views but I like seeing Cork’s progress from my window πŸ™‚

    in reply to: Cork Transport #779096
    malec
    Participant

    Sorry but I can’t see at all how cork airport doesn’t need this new terminal. Last night when I came back from Geneva (through Amsterdam) there were 9 planes parked there, 3 in front of the current terminal and the rest beside the new one. When we got inside it was absolutely jam packed at the luggage reclaim with around 4 times more people than what’s supposed to be there. I know I’m not quoting any figures or anything but from my arrival yesterday this new terminal look like plain common sense.

    in reply to: Manor Park’s Digital Hub Plan #778010
    malec
    Participant

    Definitely! If it was proposed for the docklands I’d be all for it since it something daring and with a bit of height is what’s needed down there. It would depend on the details aswell and we need a proper render for that.

    in reply to: Manor Park’s Digital Hub Plan #777994
    malec
    Participant

    @StephenC wrote:

    Also has anyone yet asked the question who would want to live ion the 51st storey…especially in recently rebranded ‘family-friendly’ SOHO

    I would.

    Seriously though, I’ve no problem with going tall, but this isn’t even a designated highrise zone so it’s in the completely wrong location.
    If they do build it though, they should add on an extra 5 floors a la dubai πŸ˜€

    in reply to: Manor Park’s Digital Hub Plan #777982
    malec
    Participant

    Wow, they definitely have balls to propose something like that. I’d like to see a proper render though before judging, in order to see the details of the design.
    Anyway, I’ll give it a 99.5% chance…

    of it being axed that is. πŸ˜€

    in reply to: developments in cork #759535
    malec
    Participant

    @lexington wrote:

    Just walked by this area this other day and decided take a look at the county hall since I hadn’t seen it with the renovations. I have to say I was impressed, it’s definitely got a much more fresh and modern look.

    This victoria mills phase 2 however, makes the first look like the world’s greatest masterpiece. I know this forum is to be kept civilised but the only description I can give is: “Worst pile of generic crap ever!! 😑 “
    The other student flats going up next to it are OK though, although I’m getting sick of all the wooden stuff going up everywhere.

    Great that eglinton street is now progressing. I didn’t need to see the pictures though since I can see the site from my window. :D. Should be great once the tower starts to rise.

    in reply to: developments in cork #759283
    malec
    Participant

    @paddyinthehouse wrote:

    Malec, I think it should be pointed out that the east elevation of the Webworks is a party wall, and as such cannot have any windows. The sites to the east of the building will all be redeveloped in the coming years, so the blank wall will no longer be visible.

    Attached is a photo from Lapps Quay, showing the Webworks in context with the adjacent classical buildings.

    Oh right, didn’t know that. That photo shows the best angle, the other side looks like crap (not just the wall but the south facing side aswell)

    in reply to: developments in cork #759278
    malec
    Participant

    @Radioactiveman wrote:

    As far as i’m aware, locations along the “Straight” Road, The Docklands and the city approach through Blackpool have been identified as locations where highrise buildings are suitable- according to the latest Development Plan.
    But the question arises — what is a highrise building??
    CSD supporters would propose to ban all “highrises” over three storey. Now, I don’t know many people who would catagorise a four storey building as highrise!! Utterly ridiculous!!

    By definition highrise means at least 12 floors, a 4-storey building is still a house.
    The problem I think is that CCC are letting too much crap go through which strengthens the “anti-highrise” people’s arguments. What I’m talking about is stuff like the new metropole hotel extension which is almost worse than what’s already there. Aswell after looking more closely at the crows nest development it does seem really average. Most people already hate the millions of student apartments going up near victoria cross and I realise now this is an important oppertunity that might convince people otherwise. A building with more of a landmark edge to it would be great, not necessarily tall but something with a fresh design.

    By the way I’ll take back what I said about the Alberts Quay Webworks building since I just passed it the other day and the side facing the city hall is quite good. The only thing that really bothers me is that grey wall on the east facing side. If they just put in more windows it would have been fine.

    in reply to: developments in cork #759266
    malec
    Participant

    The only reason I said it was OK is because it blends nicely with county hall, other than that it’s very average.

    in reply to: developments in cork #759260
    malec
    Participant

    I was going to say this is just another half-arsed design but I quite like it now. I was thinking something more striking would be better in that area but this does fit nicely with county hall. It’s a bit too boxy and boring but if it wasn’t tthen maybe it would have clashed too much. I also think it looks better with the reduced height. I’ve nothing against tall buildings (in fact I love them) but I’d hate to see county hall’s stand-alone look go.

    I’m still waiting until we get a sexy 20-storey tower for the docklands. It’ll have to be something with curves, not square shaped. I’m thinking something along Paul Kenny’s The Treasury but in tower form πŸ˜€

    in reply to: developments in cork #759245
    malec
    Participant

    @lexington wrote:

    2.Albert Quay WebWorks

    Developer: Howard Holdings
    Architects: Scott Tallon Walker

    I have to say I’m not impressed at all by the new developments getting built around the city hall. I find the Albert Quay Webworks building looks a lot cheaper than I thought it would seeing those renderings. Also that new city hall extension is terrible. I thought it would look better once the glass was in place but was disappointed. I think the problem is the top of the concrete part. If they could knock off say, 3 metres off the top it would be fine. It’s just that concrete top makes it look unbalanced, also it can be seen sticking out over the city hall from the other side of the river. I’m still hopeful it’ll look better when fully complete but have my doubts.

    I hope the eglinton st tower will provide a huge improvement over the existing crap. The renders look great for it although I don’t think I should raise my hopes too much.

    in reply to: developments in cork #759211
    malec
    Participant

    I see that Quay House building every week from the window in Moores Hotel where I have my piano lesson and I have to say it looks quite good. In the render it just looks like more of the same but actually looks much better in reality,

    in reply to: developments in cork #759088
    malec
    Participant

    @POM wrote:

    Though I’m delighted that the Metropole proposal is a s further step in hopefully what will be a large-scale and long overdue much needed redevelopment of Patricks Quay, I am somewhat disappointed by the O’Mahony Pike design here. When you look at a proposal like Dennehys Cross and then this, its hard to put the 2 in frame as being from the same firm. I see and applaud what the architects is trying to do here, allow for varying parapet heights so as to break up bulk and compliment surrounding structures. I agree with malec, the site could do with a tall feature, but the overall resulting articulation is poorly executed and creates a very disjointed 20 car pile up. It reminds me of the proposal for Sunbeam with the 18 storey element lost in a jumble of block heights. As par lex’s post, the planner has demanded a redesign of the tower and limit on height as well as some elevational alterations. Maybe this will aid the scheme. Anyone know how the problem with the leisure lease worked out? If its not settled the scheme probably won’t be able to move until 2008 (???).

    Basically tall and slender is better than short and bulky I think. Aswell as you said it would create a better impression if the tower was out in front, facing the river rather than hidden away (although 12 storeys seems a bit too tall though)

    in reply to: developments in cork #759085
    malec
    Participant

    That picture is a thumbnail from imageshack.us. All you have to do is remove the .th in the url and here’s the pic:

    By the way to me this is one of the worst proposals in Cork. It just looks like a lump of boxes thrown randomly into something that looks like a pile of rubbish. The overall shape seems overly complicated and unbalanced and because of its bulkiness is even more out of scale than what’s already there now. I wouldn’t mind something quite tall going there (ie about 8 stories) but would have to be more slender so it wouldn’t seem so out of scale.

    Just thought I’d mention that last week I was in Limerick and was stunned by what they’ve done with the quayside. The new riverpoint building and clarion hotel together are stunning and I really hope the few highrise buildings in the docklands will be of a similar standard. Paul Kenny’s The Treasury development is definitely a step in the right direction. It’s definitely one of my favourites

    in reply to: developments in cork #758331
    malec
    Participant

    Hi. Any news on the waterstreet development?

    in reply to: Dublin skyline #747470
    malec
    Participant

    I’m new here so hope you don’t mind me joining in.

    I personally wouldn’t like to see 60 storey skyscrapers in Dublin, it’s too extreme compared with the rest of the city. I think it would be great however, if a nice cluster of 15 to 20 floor buildings were built at the docks. These are just mid-rises for most cities and I don’t see the problem with buildings this height.

Viewing 16 posts - 81 through 96 (of 96 total)