garethace

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 20 posts - 621 through 640 (of 947 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Cathedrals of Commerce #738917
    garethace
    Participant

    I was watching Rocky III last night and realised suddenly that all that Cold War stuff is sadly missing from sporting events these times.

    I don’t know if you have ever seen movies like ‘Steve Prefontaine’ and such, where the American used sport as a means to ‘take on’ the different political types around the globe.

    Same even back in Nazi Germany. I mean, in a way all the athletes drug taking etc, Sinead De Brun, was created out of the cold war 1970/80’s ideas of super human commies and Americans like Sylvester Stallone and that blonde Russian guy that the women always go wild after.

    (Yeah the terrible actor too)

    But the current thing now, where USA have no big contenders – doesn’t make for the best Olympic games.

    in reply to: Forum for Irish Urban Studies #739539
    garethace
    Participant

    I was dying with the flu, I made it to Trinity all right, but 10 yards from the Museum Building de-toured to the Buttery and just stayed there for an hour trying to nurse the worst head-cold I have had in yonks. Hope it clears up for Sat though – going to see the Lib?

    in reply to: Cathedrals of Commerce #738915
    garethace
    Participant

    I think you are pretty much on the mark there. However, they all seem to agree that the Olympics budget got totally out of control.

    I mean, OVER spending.

    Barcelona/Sydney done it without going to town money-wise.

    in reply to: Cathedrals of Commerce #738913
    garethace
    Participant
    in reply to: 32-floor building planned for Dublin #738685
    garethace
    Participant

    Couple of more images at the bottom of this thread, just click the links.

    http://www.cgarchitect.com/cgi-bin/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic&f=8&t=000061#000009

    in reply to: Gee, I really want to access this one. . . #739517
    garethace
    Participant

    No, but given big business gets so much better service in this country in general. . . . why was all UCD moved to Belfield to begin with?

    in reply to: 32-floor building planned for Dublin #738684
    garethace
    Participant

    Well how many calculations do you want? Earth Simulator can do roughly a thousand, thousand million sums per second.

    Basically it can simulate all the weather systems around the world, as they happen in real time.

    I have a bit of a talk going on here;

    http://www.aceshardware.com/forum?read=105065626

    about supercomputing too.

    But the whole area of digital storage technology is getting really interesting too.

    http://www.theinquirer.net/?article=13688

    So it will be possible to actually store a lot of high quality info.

    in reply to: 32-floor building planned for Dublin #738682
    garethace
    Participant

    I have a couple of images lashed out in the computer recently, but I forgot the damn disk again today – so tomorrow maybe.

    Computers are really a top alternative, when looking for ways to design those things to be ‘as perfect as you say’.

    It looks like Ireland is going the ‘Earth Simulator’ route soon, with the Science Federation Ireland thing.

    http://www.sfi.ie/content/content.asp?section_id=226&language_id=1&publication_id=1085

    My best guess, is that some heavily fortified bunker out in Sandyford industrial estate will house a big computer for scientists around Dublin to log into and run calculations.

    Apparently, this is a very lucrative area indeed – Japan currently lead in this field, beating the USA for a number of years now.

    Maybe, they could get a few little ‘Total Architecture’ games to work for us. 🙂

    in reply to: 32-floor building planned for Dublin #738679
    garethace
    Participant

    Actually you really have to get out and about around Dublin city, to really see how things like St. Patrick’s cathedral do provide that orientation function within the city of Dublin, even still today.

    I mean, St. Pat’s probably isn’t true medieval, medieval no more than ChristChurch. But the function it does in the urban fabric is quite similar.

    There is a nice Church in Dawson street, that really marks it spot quite well too – even if in years to come, it became a bank, or an office, or headquarters for a company – it would still function architecturallly within the entire city, in exactly the same way.

    So maybe there is an important lesson in studying religous architecture – for doing commercial projects.

    in reply to: 32-floor building planned for Dublin #738677
    garethace
    Participant

    Yeah, I really like the connection between medieval war fare, movement of troops etc and Beaux Arts architectural master plans, which was so great an influence on Louis Kahn.

    Kahn is one of these very problematic, poetic kind of guys to get into – so most people just do a very large detour.

    But my biggest problem with architectural ideas and the way they can be presented in education etc – is that poetic ideas, do not necessarily have to be understood in poetic ways – you can always use some kind of lever to ‘get you into the groove first’, and then just embellish it as much as you like then.

    I like the notion of medieval total war game – because it presents in a very no-bs fashion – an idea about space and architectural design I have grappled with for a while.

    That small tiny individual people, negotiate the environment around them, on foot, through both space and time – that give the necessary time, energy levels and direction – you can move people around quite a lot.

    I am thinking about books by Edmund Bacon here, who tried to deal with Medieval urban planning etc. But the problem is, that when most students hear about ‘Medieval urban planning’ they go ‘what a bore’.

    Fin has illuminated the topic quite well too.

    I mean, take this argument that architects constantly use – that cities are designed by vehicular traffic engineers – it just begs the question of ‘where were the pedestrian traffic engineers’.

    Hiding behind a bush, I have no doubt.

    in reply to: Forum for Irish Urban Studies #739535
    garethace
    Participant

    Thanks Phil, will do my best to make that – sounds interesting.

    in reply to: Gee, I really want to access this one. . . #739515
    garethace
    Participant

    Something which I never experienced going to college myself, in Bolton Street, was that whole notion of exterior spaces separating things like Libraries, canteens, laboratories, sports facilities, bars, bike parking, churches, residences etc.

    I mean, the outdoors rooms in Trinity actually perform the same function as corridors and foyers, in a normal one-block institution like Bolton Street. It is interesting, because given the climate here in Ireland, everyone thinks that outdoors is bad – outdoors is wet, outdoors is dangerous, dark and un-inviting.

    But O’Donnell and Tuomey even built a house in Athlone, where the corridor became an outdoor space literally and Trinity sort of works the same. I find UCD campus on the other hand, doesn’t have the same density yet – but given a couple of masterplans, thesis projects and inventness of architects – will some day I have no doubt.

    I am always conscious when looking at visualisations and photos of American campuses or business parks, by the acres of space around buildings. I think that, in turn draws the focus of the American architect to interior spaces a lot more than in Europe.

    I mean, because in America, you really need to be a fit, jogging, outdoor, treker, lumberjack type to hack walking from building to builing – not the short skirted type wearing brown seude botties in Trinity college – I think in American facilities they probably have grander interiors – so you don’t have to brave the outdoors as much.

    Same in Finland, there is practically forests growing between various buildings. Dunno if that could ever work in Belfield somehow – especially given the very dodgy nature of transport services. It is a real pity the LUAS did not pick up a university or two.

    What Luas did pick up though, was this huge, highly secured mega-techno park, banking, enterprise wonder world that is called the Sandyford Industrial Estate.

    I was walking around there last autumn photographing some of the nice new buildings out there, walking along a public road/thoroughfare, not far from Leopardstown race course – minding my own business – I think I was looking at a FKL building, or what looked like something FKL would do, when suddenly these heavies ambushed me ‘MTV Jackass style’ out of nowhere, and asked me my life story!

    Come’on guys! Is that Berties is building with all of our hard earned Euros. I once had a bicycle stolen in Trinity, but I was never ambushed.

    UCD campus is not as bad as that – I like the way that sports field are sort of integrated into the ‘campus’, the ‘environment’. Because they are specifically public in nature – But Sandyford industrial estate just freaks me out. And it gets a f*** 1 Billion LUAS right up to its doorstep? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?

    I dunno, DCU as well, but perhaps someone else has an opinion.

    in reply to: 32-floor building planned for Dublin #738674
    garethace
    Participant

    AI, well what Medieval Total war does, is it adjusts the AI for various units of soldiers – like some behave with a lot more cowardice than others do. On the other hand, some stay and fight, when perhaps they should actually run. You are expected to understand this yourself, and as a general you are expected to make the necessary adjustments.

    I don’t know if I mentioned this in the past, but WWI relied heavily on improvements in defensive war, which were not met by equal but opposite improvements to offensive war.

    I.e.

    * Tinned food, soldiers fought through the winters.
    * Barred wire, stopped cavalry charges, which broke up dead-locks.
    * Hydraulic canon firing – no need to reset aim, meaning continuous rate of fire of heavy artillery.
    * Telephone – allowed better distribution and organisation of resources along a long front, making breakthroughs more difficult.

    Medieval warfare was beautiful – the archers when first introduced could just win on their own – so cavalry was needed to break up the archers, while spearmen were needed to resist cavalry.

    PowerRes is something similar to what you said, about submitting work online to do large calculations

    http://www.respower.com/news_2004_01_16_max6

    I can see, that would be the best direction for rendering and certain AI software like we are discussing.

    But in fairness, given the description of Medieval Total War gaming strategy above – I think that the best way to approach something like a building for the public, say it be part of a campus like in UCD, DCU or Trinity – or an extension to the National Gallery of Ireland, or an Olympic Swimming Pool, or a new National COnference centre – is simply to thing of the people using the institution as dynamic units.

    Doing so, by using computers to highlight pedestrian flow patterns etc, you could anticipate a heck of a lot more about a design, than simply worrying about the colour of the f*** blinds, mullions, carpets, which are nice to get right, but what architects devote much too large a portion of their time doing.

    I can never help when looking at these pictures;

    http://www.hughpearman.com/articles3/dublin5.html

    how much of the medieval pedestrian narrow street idea has been brought into the architecture there. How people move through the architecture – not like some really static wonder structure like a Mies van der Rohe. I guess people like James Stirling were also instrumental in bringing back some of this dynamic experience of architecture.

    Then I see pictures like this one;

    http://www.totalwar.com/community/bat9.htm

    And I am automatically reminded that the old architecture in those days was much more inhabited, vibrant with lots of characters and busy people. Than the experience you get nowadays of medieval, which is normally something rather desolate and barren, renovated by the OPW! 🙂 Yeah, they had the budget for the nice paving, but something is missing.

    Whenever, I come across bits of medieval embedded into parts of cities, that are still in use – I think that medieval architecture, streets and spaces really do still live. I think FIn mentions Italy being a place where that is the case – I know if I ever went there to visit, I would be looking at the architecture from that point of view.

    I am not sure what kind of public liability clauses they had in medieval times though, for people falling from ramparts etc, but it was much more fun!

    in reply to: Learning to wear the third skin. #736653
    garethace
    Participant

    http://www.theinquirer.net/?article=13477

    Article there about America and education.

    in reply to: Gee, I really want to access this one. . . #739513
    garethace
    Participant

    Yeah, I new there were some chart toppers in there. 🙂

    in reply to: Learning to wear the third skin. #736652
    garethace
    Participant

    BTW, I don’t think that I am any kind of expert to pass on any great knowledge via Archiseek. But if you just take that first point, about conversation – that is a big PLUS with this on-line stuff. You are at least getting somewhat more comfortable with the sound of your own thoughts and opinions. A bit missing from common third level courses out there, to say the least.

    in reply to: Learning to wear the third skin. #736651
    garethace
    Participant

    Originally posted by FIN

    There is often a weight of information heaped on students without any form of coherent evaluation. This may hinder the development of some or most. Speaking from personal experience and I have to go back and finish off yet. They are then reduced to thinking of a building in isolation or near isolation, with only the surrounding buildings as a guide instead of taking the whole area/city into context as well. This may seem to involve too much thought but I think it helps to at least consider it when designing. The language of the whole city then comes into play. This is where the item of clothing fits into the suit perfectly and one becomes trendy.

    Yeah, I lament the way that computers for instance are taught to young architects. I mean, you start off doing a small object, you might say model up or draw something like a door, a window and a roof. But you always get the impression that you are ‘too close’ to buildings and not thinking about environments. I mention the Total War series of PC games here and there, which are a great help at understanding how a computer visual can show dynamically moving people, across vast expanses. The mere fact, that you cannot just press a button and say ‘attack’. That the ‘units of soldiers, cavalry, infantry, spearmen, pikemen, archers and what not’ have to be organised, moved and ordered what to do in both space and time.

    When you look at battles in Brave Heart or The Patriot etc, you realise that it is not as easy as it looks – having played a game like Medieval Total war.

    On the subject of clothing

    What about the opposite to what you describe, the different native styles becoming replaced by a global Beneton look? I mean, Eskimos are not longer born in Igloos, except in Encyclopedias for kids and Walt Disney movies. It would seem that everyone wants to have a certain image nowadays. I noticed on the news though, that Arab womenfolk were protesting about not wearing their garments – so perhaps that ‘ethnic’ argument could creep into architecture too.

    But on the topic of something like a message boards, institutions and architecture in general. I have been observing this dynamic for a while now, how people behave online, and how it might even help them to behave or even relate in the real world. There is something missing in today’s Universities, even though they are real buildings as opposed to web sites, they have real people as opposed to Avitars, your time is strictly regulated and you always have someplace ‘you need to be’ at a certain time. But still the content seems like substituted food in ways.

    First Point:

    I find that family dinner table conversation have also become a poor substitute for what once was. A bit like having a fake leg having lost one in an accident – family conversations are in that same league. Communities, even if they are just online ones about a common interest – teach people a little bit about the value of discussion, in the absence of anything like that in today’s modern society. Real communication and discussion is a really healthy thing, and not valued enough anymore.

    Second Point.

    Then take institutions, like Universities for instance, or families, marriages etc – it is cool to run down all these things nowadays and one asks the question what were they for in the first place. Well, as someone pointed out only recently, it is natural that the younger generations always help out the older ones. Institutions at their very best facilitate this to happen – at their worst, you just witness the breakdown of this synergetic relationship between older people getting slower and less able, and young people with all the enthuasiasm to be of service to the older community or profession.

    Funny, because I had grown up with that all backways. I did imagine that in some strange fashion, that older people in Universities were meant to do everything for the young people. But that runs contrary to how nature has been working for centuries. I think the role of ‘mentor’ and ‘undergrad or understudy’ needs to be properly defined once again, in a way which is respectful to everyone.

    Third Point.

    I find, that after spending a full year visiting one about Information Technology, that a lot of really bad misconceptions I had about that whole area have been worked out properly. By the mere fact, I was able to access experts who really knew what they were talking about, and I could listen. That is, like Kahn says about schools – they started originally with some guy under a tree talking to young kids and evolved from that point.

    I have linked an article somewhere in the past, which tended to suggest the future for the ‘brighter’ young people in America, would be online learning and access to information. So this E-learning thing isn’t just pie in the sky either.

    That is, the policy of ‘leaving noone behind’ in current educational policies, has resulted unintendedly in ‘working at the pace of the slowest student’. This of course, has led to certain young people becoming very bored indeed.

    But my understand of higher level education in America, is that there is literally a phone box full of courses you can do. It is all about finding the correct one for your chosen direction – i.e. the fast lane and the slow lane – and not all youngsters have the advantage of choosing the right one.

    in reply to: Gee, I really want to access this one. . . #739511
    garethace
    Participant

    didn’t I see some new competition for a pier out there during the summer too? One of the newspapers had shots.

    in reply to: Gee, I really want to access this one. . . #739509
    garethace
    Participant

    I must keep an eye out for it, didn’t know he had one there too. Is it wood?

    in reply to: Gee, I really want to access this one. . . #739507
    garethace
    Participant

    I think you would like Louis Kahn then, there is a book called Unbuilt Master works or something about Kahn, where they digitally re-created alot of his big projects that were never actually built.

    http://www.cgarchitect.com/cgi-bin/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic;f=4;t=000427

    http://www.cgarchitect.com/ubb/ultimatebb.php?ubb=get_topic;f=4;t=000455

    using Lightscape Radiosity rendering technology.

Viewing 20 posts - 621 through 640 (of 947 total)