well what about the developments popping up in the shannonside ?
- This topic has 2,478 replies, 127 voices, and was last updated 14 years, 11 months ago by
Griff.
- AuthorPosts
- August 8, 2005 at 6:05 pm #753278
ShaneP
ParticipantAs for the Edward St. apartments – got a few questions about that image – where did it come from? It appears somebody was fairly creative on the auld photoshop or else it’s an entirely different project to the one that has just been completed there. The apartments that have just been built, face directly onto Carey’s Rd (overlooking the Junction with Lord Edward St.) and so the houses in the background should not be visible in the image or else would be to the right of the apartments as viewed from the park!
August 8, 2005 at 6:24 pm #753279dave123
Participant@ShaneP wrote:
As for the pile of “poo in the Park” got a few questions about that image – where did it come from? It appears somebody was fairly creative on the auld photoshop or else it’s an entirely different project to the one that has just been completed there. The apartments that have just been built, face directly onto Carey’s Rd (overlooking the Junction with Lord Edward St.) and so the houses in the background should not be visible in the image or else would be to the right of the apartments as viewed from the park!
poo in the park – 😀 i don]www.Murrayolaire.com[/url] , there is two pics of it, there were the ones i tried to post, but as you can see you can’t see it lol 😀 oh well i try looking elsewhere 🙂
I’ll have to visit town soon, as i have’nt been there in a while , to see for myself whats bold and new and ugly 🙂
August 8, 2005 at 6:30 pm #753280ShaneP
ParticipantAs far as I know the properties on Liddy St all belong to Roches, so it’s entirely up to them what happens there. IS there any plans for the Dunnes stores site? All that’s been mentioned in the local press is that the remaining traders in the area are having a pretty diifficult time keeping the doors open. I tihnk there may have been some talk, a few years ago about relocating the Belltable down there, which sounds like a great idea -think a few Bolton St. architecture thesis explored the issue too, might see if there’s any possibilty of getting them on line.
August 8, 2005 at 6:31 pm #753281dave123
Participantlast comment for the day , has anyone got pictures of the the revamped Royal George hotel?
your right about that Shane, and the council have been talking with Roches stores to use the units, but no sign of anything happening soon. what a pity!Over the next few days I’ll try get some stuff on the Park canal project.
August 8, 2005 at 6:46 pm #753282ShaneP
ParticipantTa – although i’m still perplexed, it just doesn’t make any sense on a number of levels, still dont know if it’s the same project – surely Murray O’laoire couldn’t be responsible, what with having designed so many other great projects, tourist office, shannon airport, and the box in King john’s caslte etc. Shocking altogether – and it seems they did the new one at the top of William St. too. What’s going on?
August 8, 2005 at 6:59 pm #753283dave123
Participanti know Turbog asked a few weeks ago about the Royal george and who is designing it well I think its HKR achitects.
this image is small though
August 8, 2005 at 11:12 pm #753284Tuborg
ParticipantI think its really sad when you look back at all the fantastic buildings that this city has lost over the years,superb buildings such as cannocks, the old roches stores(mcbirneys i think was the name of the department store before roches moved in), the old todds building was another huge loss, i think i have some pictures of it somewhere! Unfortunately the photo i posted of cannocks a couple of weeks back seems to be only one i can find,i read somewhere that cannocks was demolished in the late 60s, i really cant find any reason why it should have been demolished, obviously just an horrendous decision by the planning authorities and one that the city centre is much the worse for now, the old roches building was destroyed by fire in 1948, one of a number of devastating fires to hit the city centre in that era, i think in a way the most tragic story of all is that of todds, a building of such character was destroyed and replaced with arguably the worst building ever to “grace” the city centre!
Shane you mentioned something about brown thomas “getting their act together” have you some inside info on hopefully a revamp of the building or are ya just talking about their new menswear dept!, i actually feel like getting sick whenever i pass bt, nobody should look directly at that building, it wouldnt do you any good!
Im found this in the limerick leader archives, ill also try and upload them pics soon, just as soon as i learn how to upload them directly instead of as attachments!
Disastrous Limerick Fire
BUILDINGS gutted: many workers now unemployed.
ONE of the biggest fire disasters in recent times occurred in Limerick today (Tuesday, August 25, 1959), when the monster drapery house of Messrs William Todd and Co went up in flames.
It was the biggest fire in the history of Limerick.
The outbreak was first detected in the men’s wholesale department on the William Street side of the premises and within a matter of minutes this section was a blazing inferno.
Thousands watched as the Limerick Fire Brigade vainly fought to control the flames, but within half-an-hour this huge section of the building was completely enveloped with flames belching through the windows and threatening the adjoining shops until eventually Messrs Lipton and Messrs Burton were also destroyed.
The staff of Messrs Todds busied themselves with salvaging stock and books from the untouched portion of the building, but eventually had to desist because the task became too dangerous with portions of the upper floors threatening to fall in at any moment.
Men and women ran to and fro, salvaging whatever they could lay hands on, and despite a roaring wall of flames at their backs. Books were thrown on to the streets from the office windows.
Thirty minutes after the outbreak was first noticed, it spread to the upper storey of Messrs Burton’s Tailors and eventually so great was the heat that the fire engine in William Street had to be removed. One of the hoses caught fire, as volunteer workers were trying to haul it away.
When it was seen that the fire had gained such a grip that it was completely out of control, calls were sent to the brigades at Shannon Airport, Ennis, Rathkeale, and the garrison at Sarsfield Barracks was also quickly on the scene.
In all, 11 brigades were employed, including Cork, Kilmallock, Charleville, Fermoy, Ranks and Tipperary.
For over two hours hoses were played on the blazing four-storied building and on the adjoining shops to little effect. There were up to 30 hoses playing on the fire at 1.30pm. In Bedford Row, at 3.30pm, one hose became disconnected when crossed by a car, and onlookers were drenched.
The entire block of O’Connell Street, Thomas Street and William Street was cordoned off, and hundreds of volunteer workers assisted the brigades in manning the hoses, while all traffic was diverted.
At one stage there was a danger that the fire would spread across William Street to the garda barracks, but the gardai tackled the sparks that came in through the windows. The tyres of a bicycle lying outside the barracks went on fire.
About 15 minutes after the outbreak was first noticed, there was a huge explosion caused by the bursting of a fuel tank in the basement.
It was learned that the probable cause of the outbreak was the bursting of a fuel tank in the basement.
Just one hour after the alarm was raised there was a huge crash, and practically the entire facade of the premises crumbled to the ground. Fifteen minutes later the remaining portion caved in.
The property was wiped out in three hours, causing £1 million worth of damage, but some premises in the block were saved, including Nicholas’, Cromer’s, Gaywear, O’Sullivan’s licensed premises, the Grimsby Fish Stores, and the main offices of Messrs Todd and Co Ltd.
While Limerick Fire Brigade were battling with the outbreak, they were summoned to minor outbreaks at Cornmarket Row and Robert Street, and had to split forces.
Windows on shops opposite Todds on O’Connell Street cracked, and shopkeepers kept a bucket chain going to prevent further damage. The brigade also hosed down the premises.
Roches Stores removed all goods from its front windows, and other shopkeepers followed suit.
About 200 employees of Todds are now out of work, and another 20 from Lipton’s, plus others in the adjoining premises destroyed.
Todds fire was a watershed in the history of the city centre. Its stately interior, long and wide mahogany counters, and an all-round balcony with cast-iron ornamental railings, was a showpiece of another era.
Lipton’s, the noted general grocers, was noted for its meats and cheeses, carrying on a very old tradition there.
The end of Todds was the end of an era, heralding major changes in the city centre.
August 9, 2005 at 12:00 am #753285jimg
ParticipantI think it’s pretty obvious now that Cannocks was a huge loss. However, that’s just one building in that area. You can see also the beatifully curved Tyler’s jewelers (I think that’s what it was called) which was at the end of a terrace of Georgian buildings most of which were demolished to develop Arthurs Quay. I can remember those buildings existing. More recently the historic Cruises hotel was demolished. In thirty years time, I guarantee that people will be looking at old photos of Cruises the same way we’re looking at Cannocks now. It is easy to criticise the mistakes of the past (knocking Cannocks); it is more difficult to be honestly self-critical when it comes to the destruction of interesting buildings which has happened recently and even more difficult still to properly value the historical building which are left and feel protective towards them.
August 9, 2005 at 12:37 am #753286Tuborg
Participant
This is the old todds department store, the one with the double decker parked outside it(if double deckers were used in limerick in the 50s, why arent they in use now with busses so overcrowded!), anyway it was indeed a fine,imposing building and would be a fantastic addition to the city centre had it survived,this whole block was destroyed in the fire,
What a disaster that was when you consider they replaced it with this heap of s***,

A sight for sore eyes 😮 , hard to believe this is supposedly the most upmarket and fashionable shop in the city, why the hell dont they do something about it, surely some imitation of a georgian facade could be put on it!
August 9, 2005 at 1:15 am #753287dave123
ParticipantThanks for that Turborg 🙂
It gives people a view of the forgotten history of Limerick!I’m a saddened by that picture to see it gone ! its goes to show how grand and impressive it was.
Yet we still walk that very street and there is no feel , or recollection of such ,there is still a few buildings still surviving on the street , i’ll post som tomorrow if I can, 🙂
I really do hope the Arthur’s Quay is demolished or something, cus it really dos’nt fit in well to the rest of the street, 🙁
looks of scale ,
terrible multi storey makes anything above eye level of the entire building dead! 🙁If they could only rebuiild it and build some sort of Monumental heritage or open public space with cafe style outlets, shops,apartements overhead and a decent buildiong put up and maybe repalce the car park underground ? I think anything of the above mentioned would be better !
When the pedstrianisation of the that section of O’Connells street that is coming on shorlty , they will have to do someting with Arthur’s Quay,SC along with the Arthur’s quay park.
August 9, 2005 at 1:24 am #753288dave123
Participant😀 Lol….. 😮
Its so terrible , its funny.
Thats where most of the buses park , ie for everyone to be reminded of how ugly the heap of s**** is ,I have always wondered ,even when i was young , thinking what the hell is on that building ! 😮
As a child , i used to think that thing on the building was 100s of windows lol 😀 , even then i thought the building was crappyIts Brown Thomas for god sake , cover it up quickl 😮 y
August 9, 2005 at 1:35 pm #753289ShaneP
ParticipantNo, no inside info. goin on here Tuborg, Was referring to the fact that the whole inside of BT’s has been done up which means there’s a better choice of things on sale and that along with the other new shops that have opened, there’s less need to go to Roches now, so that might force them to up their standard a bit. As for the facade of BT’s – well it’s hardly alone in warrenting criticism. Most of the buildings around there (which at present marks the very centre of the city) convey the image of a very drab place, Dunnes Stores on O’Connell St, Bank of Ireland, Ryans Jewellers, penneys/ Burger King, Arthur’s Quay SC are all fairly depressing and it would be fairly optimistic to think that they’re all going to change overnight into some kind of spectacular architectural marvel. But if they do, here’s a couple of interesting precedents that go a little beyond Georgian pastiche
August 9, 2005 at 1:55 pm #753290ShaneP
ParticipantWhere did the image of the new Royal George come from? Think someone said it was actually a new office on Henry st., some time back. It couldn’t be of O’Connell St., because the present elevetion is much narrower and is taller than it is wide. Is that the Shannon St. elevation? Also there is/was a for sale sign on the Henry St. side of the GPO, does anyone know anything about it? I believe the building was known as Roches Hanging Gardens which sounds like it must have had a fairly interesting history (again – sorry for the lack of pictures) It’s a redbrick single storey building just around the corner from the main part of the post office.
August 11, 2005 at 10:09 am #753291ShaneP
ParticipantFrom LImerick Leader, May 28, 2005 –
20 Years Ago
AN POST STORM BREAKS OVER MAGIC GARDENS
CONTROVERSY raged in Limerick this week as workmen moved in to begin the construction of a £1 million sorting office for An Post at the once famous Roches Hanging Gardens in Henry Street.
An Post have been accused of “sheer vandalism” as they intend knocking down most of the existing building, which they own.
But postmaster Bill Marnane pointed out that they had contacted An Taisce and other interested groups who had no objection to the new office going ahead.
Referring to the plans for the new sorting office on the 800 square foot site, he explained that the existing facade was being kept intact as was the stone spiral staircase and the first archway.
However, Captain Frank Parker, president of Thomond Archaeology Society, told the Limerick Leader that they would like to see what remains of Roches Hanging Gardens preserved in its entirety.
“A substantial part of the original vaulting which supports the terraces is still intact and any scheme for the redevelopment of the property now occupied by the Post Office should provide for the preservation of this vaulting as well as the facade,” he added.
Seamus î Cinneide, the Limerick antiquarian, is this Saturday bringing a group of archaeologists and historians from all over the country on a tour of the city, including Roches Hanging Garden.
Mr î Cinneide said that An Post should be stopped from demolishing any of the building. Such action would be “sheer vandalism”.
Mr î Cinneide said that the gardens were built in 1808 by William Roche, a Limerick banker, to the rear of his residence at 99 George’s Street – now O’Connell Street.
They were on top of a series of arches which varied from 45 feet to 25 feet high. By means of glass houses, heated by ingenious flues, Roche grew exotic fruits like oranges, grapes and pineapples in one of the gardens.
The garden cost Roche £15,000 to build. Their high position afforded him magnificent views of the Shannon and Clare hills.
Although his fellow citizens nicknamed the gardens ‘Roche’s Folly’, Roche was a shrewd businessman.
He profitably sold the vaults underneath the supporting arches to the Revenue Commissioners as a bonded stores for £10,000 and an annual rent of £300.
During the emergency, the Department of Defence, singled out the building as an ideal air raid shelter.
August 12, 2005 at 1:47 am #753292dave123
Participantsorry I haven’t been able to post some pics in the last few days , I will be able to get loads up news by the weekened , busy travelling the land,
looking forward to see some good news here , when i’m back 🙂 😉
August 12, 2005 at 12:16 pm #753293ShaneP
ParticipantFrom Limerick Post – 12/8/05
Demolition of St Mary’s Park?
Marie Hobbins
A LOCAL councillor’s claim that the 450 houses in St Mary’s Park will be demolished to make way for a new housing estate has been rubbished by Defence Minister, Willie O’Dea. He told the Limerick Post on Wednesday that such a plan is “definitely not on the Government’s agendaâ€.But Cllr John Gilligan categorically states that demolition of the houses, built in the 1930s, will proceed as part of a major regeneration plan for St Mary’s Park.
Confirming that a study has been prepared for the regeneration of St Mary’s Park, Noeleen Ryan, co-ordinator for the RAPID (Revitalising Areas by Planning Investment and Development) Programme for the inner city said: “This has gone to the Department of the Environment for approval but the Government has told us that we will get regeneration. In order to secure this we have to put a strategy in place to cover all aspects of the area – social, economic, environmental, educational, etc as the plan is to regenerate and lift the entire area.
“A project manager will be appointed and a company formed – all the relevant agencies will have an impact, not just the local authority,†she said.
Part of the regeneration plan would be the construction of another road into St Mary’s Park and the development of new business to create employment in the area.
“The study has to go before Cabinet as capital funding will be required,†informs Ms Ryan
Minister O’Dea has emphatically dismissed any demolition plan for the housing estate and the Council’s Housing Committee member, Cllr Joe Leddin contends that it does not make sense that with millions recently invested in installing new windows and doors in the St Mary’s Park houses and a planned programme of central heating installation due to commence soon, that demolition of the houses is on the cards.
“These houses are not lined up for demolition – it would be nonsense to have put new doors and windows at such a huge cost into the houses, not to mention the central heating that is due to go in and two years later demolish them,†he said.
A contradictory view from Ms Ryan is that the central heating programme will commence in Lee Estate but will not progress to St Mary’s Park.
Adamant that demolition is very much on the agenda, Cllr Gilligan said: “The houses involved, built in the 1930s, are mass concrete – their life span is well past. Why shouldn’t they be demolished – it happened in Ballymun which was only built in the 1960s.â€
Pointing out that the often maligned RAPID Programme is at last beginning to yield results, the councillor said that money is now being released for various new projects for King’s Island.
“We’re getting 900,000 euro for a new creche in St Mary’s Park, 120,000 euro for the Widows Alms Houses,27,000 euro for a roof to the Star Rovers Club, 40,000 to rail off their pitch and 50,000 for an all-weather pitch for the club. There’s also been tens of thousands invested in the refurbishment of local schools. Money is being released but I’m looking forward to the big one, the regeneration of St Mary’s Park.â€
The Department of the Environment was not in a position to comment on the issue at the time of going to press.
August 15, 2005 at 10:33 am #753294ShaneP
ParticipantIrish Independent, Saturday, 13 August, 2005
Three contenders line up to build indoor arena
SUPERMACS owner Pat McDonagh faces competition over his dream to build a major indoor arena outside the capital.
Two Munster-based businessmen – one in Cork and the other in the Limerick area – are understood to be putting together plans for the development of a major indoor arena for a variety of entertainment events.
Both are understood to have completed feasibility studies on the project but have chosen separate locations, in Limerick and Cork, for their proposed arena.
Galway-based Pat McDonagh proposed to locate a €100m development, including an 8,000-seat indoor arena, a hotel and restaurants in Athlone, Co Westmeath, but this ran into planning difficulties and he is now considering a number of other locations.
He confirmed last night that he has looked at Galway, Limerick and “another midlands location” as alternatives.
Limerick appears to be a likely location, given the proximity of Shannon Airport, with its huge volume of European low-fares traffic, and the city’s improving infrastructure.
Limerick Mayor Diarmuid Scully believes the city should do all in its power to ensure it does not miss the opportunity to secure the development.
“We must put our best foot forward, roll out the red carpet to these people to make sure that we do not lose out.
“All you have to do is look at what the National Exhibition Centre in Birmingham did for what was up to then a pretty much run-down city centre.
“It revitalised the whole city centre, turning it into one of the most vibrant in Europe,” Mr Scully said.
The mayor predicted that a site on the outskirts of Limerick would be the likely location, although he did not rule out the possibility of it being located on the docklands.
“One way or the other, it will probably take both the city council and county council working together on this, but that would not be a problem,” Mr Scully said.
Eugene Hogan
August 15, 2005 at 8:14 pm #753295dave123
ParticipantHey there,
I must say Annacotty is one of my favoirite villages, anyone agree with me ??? its a real sucesss with the new hotel and apartements on the Mulkier River (spelling unsure)
I thought the conference centre for Athlone got refused?? Limerick would be an ideal place for a conference centre as its proximity to both Cork and Galway and Shannon airports 🙂
Well, I was In Limerick recently, and I seen the Lord Edward street dev. and I have to admit isn’t all that bad, if there was a few other new buildings gone up there, it would blend in, but frankly, it sticks out a bit. 😮
The Georges site, is coming on well to, there even building the entire block, practically 🙂
I was so amazed to see the Bedford row site, turned down, some sections is 6 storeys I believe, and the buildings is not even 20 years old, quite a big site, when this is finished it will really complete the grand henrys street, hopefully it will be an impressive building, like the new dunnes stores across the street.
The jetland centre on the Ennis Rd and is opening next month… I’ll get pics soon.
Dunne’s again is the main tenant :rolleyes: , along with nearlyHas anyone have any notion about the Corbally Link rd, I think its currently construction ?? :confused: near the canal and corbally rd and links the Dublin rd.
August 16, 2005 at 12:09 am #753296Tuborg
ParticipantYa its great to see progress being made on the savoy site, this is a really important development for the city centre and its completion cant come soon enough, my only hope now is that it lives up to all the hype and dosent become another flop, i suppose the fact that it’s a mixed use scheme will work in its favour, the hotel element of it is definately needed and a 5 star hotel slap bang in the middle of the city will obviously be very attractive for tourists and buisness people alike, a top class hotel was needed in the city centre but you’d have to wonder about the viability of the new hotel at the george site,its going to be a lot smaller than its counterpart at the savoy and with a new luxury hotel planned for the old jurys, you’d wonder would a larger retail development at the george have been more appropriate, as it is the first 2 floors are planned as retail space, these larger retail outlets are a sign of things to come and they are really going to put it up to cruises street where oasis have moved out and next are due to follow shortly citing a lack of space as the reason, this probably highlights the inadequacy of cruises street for larger retailers!
BTW great news on that events centre, something the city is really lacking!
August 17, 2005 at 3:02 pm #753297ShaneP
ParticipantWell. I still can’t believe you approve of that heap on Edward St., Dave123.
If it lasts half as long as the Savoy did, i’d be surprised. It’s not only the fact that it looks cheap, which bothers me – the whole project appears to be the product of a lazyminded approach by architects, developer and planners. It is the epitomy of everything that’s wrong with new developments in Limerick today (as described by Ash1 a few weeks ago)
As far back as 1991, a report was published on the success or otherwise of the first urban renewal schemes throughout the country – Murray O’laoire were involved in preparing that report, which included a section on the design of city centre apartment schemes. One of the many observations made was that new developments should have a variety of unit sizes to ensure a good social mix, as is the norm in the rest of Europe, so what do we end up with in Limerick, 14 years later – a block of 33 two bed apartments on Edward St and another one of c.135 two bed apartments on William St. – These lessons should be well learned at this stage as there are enough examples in this country and elsewhere of successful apartment schemes. It’s pretty disheartening to say the least.
On a related point, is anyone aware of an apartment scheme in Ireland which includes a service lift and entrance (which allows for apartments to be renovated or upgraded without inconveniencing other residents or closing off roads and footpaths to accomodate cranes etc.)?
As for Annacotty, it is good to see the place looking a bit more lively these days – the new bars etc have been hopping the couple of times i was out there, and the river makes a great backdrop to the village, long live Annacotty! – I guess Dunnes Stores will have to open a branch or two there soon though, given the rate at which they seem to be proliferating in Limerick. 3 new stores in as many years, can’t help but wonder are they trying to take over the world? There’s plenty of room in my hot press or perhaps under the sink if they’re stuck for sites and there’s easily enough room on the chimney for a spar, centra and vodaphone outlet if they want to make a bit of a shopping centre out of it!
Is the demolition of the Savoy still in progress? Saw it during the first couple of days and it was fairly spectacular – the wrecking ball/ drill cut straight through the building ,the tv screens for the bowling alleys were hanging on by a thread, and you could see straight thru’ a section of the cinemas. Hope there’s a new cinema in town to replace it soon. Don’t think ther’s any risk of oversupply in in the hotel sector though Tuborg – seems a good no.of them are reporting 90% occupancy since all those Ryanair flights started out of Shannon. It was reported in the Post recently that there wasn’t a single room available in the city one weekend and if the convention centre gets built there’ll be capacity for plenty more. It’s the best idea to come about in years, a development that would suit Limerick perfectly. Did quite a bit of research on the subject for my thesis last year so will stick it up here soon – as it’s undergoing major reconstructive surgery at the moment, if any one’s interested.
- AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

