well what about the developments popping up in the shannonside ?

Home Forums Ireland well what about the developments popping up in the shannonside ?

Viewing 20 posts - 2,101 through 2,120 (of 2,479 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #755158
    johnglas
    Participant

    Does no-one have a clue what to do about wires on the exterior of buildings? These restorations are very restrained, but it looks as if the wirescape is going to stay. Can wires not be put in the basement areas, or under string-courses or round the back – or just undergrounded and concealed within the structure as they should be?

    #755159
    Tuborg
    Participant

    Looking at the former Council offices it seems they have re-opened at least one original door ope and possibly another that were previously bricked up and replaced with windows? The reason for the “scar” at the rear that CologneMike referred to, seems to be some kind of flimsy concrete extension (see below) I presume the repaired wall will now be covered by salvaged or imitation brickwork as has been done just below the roofline?

    Im still not a fan of that glass box on the roof though, they would have been better off in re-instating the buildings original pitched roof. Unfortunately though, it looks like this practice may become more common as a solicitors firm just up the street have also installed a similar structure on top of their building in the last year or so! On the whole though, its always good to see Georgian buildings in this area being brought back into regular usage.

    Over in the [url=”https://archiseek.com/content/showthread.php?t=6460&page=3%5DOld Illustrations of Limerick[/url] thread, KeepAnEyeOnBob mentioned the ornate street lamps that were used to light up the city centre in the early 20th Century and the possibility of installing replica’s in the Georgian district.

    The City Council have defined the Georgian quarter as the area between The Crescent and Cecil Street and the adjoining streets. The council appear to be treating it as a separate area in its public realm strategy so hopefully a detailed plan for the Georgian district will be drawn up with distinctive paving and lighting. I think I’ve already said that the new paving been laid in the city centre is too ostentatious for the Georgian core.

    #755160
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @Dreamstate wrote:

    Is this the same developer as the block onto Henry Street to the rear of the old County Council Offices?

    Sean Geary and Len Dineen see post

    @Tuborg wrote:

    I presume the repaired wall will now be covered by salvaged or imitation brickwork as has been done just below the roofline?

    I doubt it Tuborg, the plaster work looked to me like as if it were the finished job. Maybe a coat of white paint for the plaster work, as white is the predominant colour of the new buildings within the block.

    Hartstonge Gate ~ River Stone House (Album)

    #755161
    Dreamstate
    Participant

    The City Council Planners and Jim Henson’s characters have a lot in common ….

    The Georgian Centre extends from Bank Place along Patrick & Rutland Street / Arthurs Quay onto O’Connell Street but LCC now say that it never really did !!!! They will only allow buildings of historic importance to be knocked to facilitate development .

    Is Tiger Lillies gone yet ? Quins is due for demolition next ,,, Patrick / Rutland is about to be castrated …..

    As I said before …. Limerick City Council view any development as good development.

    The Limerick planning section seems to be in awe of any developer who once played for Munster , Ireland and any developer who uses a Dublin architect . . . . But then again , the GOBSHITE Councillors seem to rule the roost

    #755162
    Tuborg
    Participant

    @Dreamstate wrote:

    It still amazes me that Arthurs Quay Park ( which is more popular than ever since the railings came down ) is to be built upon without any public backlash. This forum seems to be resigned to the fact.

    Buildings PREVIOUSLY within the Architectural Conservation Area to be demolished to make room for the Opera Centre …..

    ‘ Any development is good development ‘ seems to be Limerick City Councils motto

    Understandably there has been a lot of opposition to the proposed removal of this city centre park but you have to look at the bigger picture here. This part of the city is dying and badly needs to be brought back to life. Penneys and Debenhams gave up the ghost here years ago, just take a look at the yard behind Penneys in the attached aerial shot , its being used partly as a loading area and partly as a surface car park!:rolleyes:

    Aurthurs Quay park was a decent proposal back in the early 90s but it just hasnt worked and its now time for a change. Under the plan, the redeveloped area would be a primarily pedestrian zone with a new public square at the junction of O Connell St and William/Sarsfield St. A promenade would be developed along the waterfront linking Sarsfield Bridge to another public space behind the Hunt museum. This in turn would be linked by a new pedestrian bridge to another public plaza at the potato market.

    Obviously we will need more detailed information to make a proper judgement on the project but overall I think the proposals are positive enough!

    Proposed Aurthurs Quay Redevelopment

    #755163
    vkid
    Participant

    I don’t know, they’ve made some mistakes but there has been some great progress as well. No point being negative about everything. There are a lot of positives. I really like the way Henry St is developing for example. Looking from the sinking church at one end to Arthurs Quay Park at the other, it is really taking form. The new Pedestrian areas also look great. There are plenty other positives to point out.

    Restoring all the Georgian stock would be ideal, but if you actually want people to use them, sacrifices have to be made imo. In a city of Limericks size it may not always be practical to restore every Georgian building to its original state… so personally I’m open to compromise to a degree. The overall aim is regenerate and breath new life into the city,and to make that happen, buildings may have to adapt.

    This might not be a popular notion but to be honest I kind of like whats done to that Solicitors office near the crescent. The building looks great and the rooftop addition is pretty discrete from street level(and not bad at that). The sash windows look very tidy, and it all looks so clean and fresh. I also kind of like the youth centre building opposite the Glen Tavern…another georgian with a bit stuck on, but it works. If the facades of the Opera Centre are suitably restored/preserved and integrated well, I imagine I will quite like those too!

    I’ll wait and see what the finished article is like at the old Council offices but I am happy to see these buildings back in use. I’m not saying rip the place apart and knock everything but I do think in a city like Limerick the ideal restoration of all Georgian stock is not realistic and a certain amount of sacrifice in these projects is to be expected..

    Speaking of the Opera Centre, did i see somewhere a decision on the new plans is due this month??

    #755164
    justnotbothered
    Participant

    @Dreamstate wrote:

    The City Council Planners and Jim Henson’s characters have a lot in common ….

    The Georgian Centre extends from Bank Place along Patrick & Rutland Street / Arthurs Quay onto O’Connell Street but LCC now say that it never really did !!!! They will only allow buildings of historic importance to be knocked to facilitate development .

    Is Tiger Lillies gone yet ? Quins is due for demolition next ,,, Patrick / Rutland is about to be castrated …..

    As I said before …. Limerick City Council view any development as good development.

    The Limerick planning section seems to be in awe of any developer who once played for Munster , Ireland and any developer who uses a Dublin architect . . . . But then again , the GOBSHITE Councillors seem to rule the roost

    You overrate the Councillors importance in planning in Limerick. The real issue is the planning office doesn’t have the energy or ability to decide what type of city it wants Limerick to be. The Councillors can object to or endorse a project, but most of the development in Limerick is not happening on council or State land.

    Limerick City Hall is populated by some of the worst Civil Servants in Ireland, from housing right through to planning. These people are both unanswerable to anybody and uninterested in the city. The council have been relegated to a rubberstamp committee rather than a driving force in Limerick.

    #755165
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Hartstonge Gate ~ River Stone House

    23-27 Henry Street / Savin’s Lane / Rear Buildings 76-83 O’Connell Street

    Apartments and offices complex

    Development Cooperation Directorate of the Department of Foreign Affairs (Irish Aid) relocation.

    #755166
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Hartstonge Gate ~ River Stone House

    Georgian houses form a C-Shape boundary (Harstonge, O’Connell and Mallow Streets) around this re-developed block. This high density development shows in my opinion that the Opera Centre can also be developed without having to sacrifice any Georgian buildings on Ellen Street. On the other hand, will this type of high density re-development happen to similar Georgian blocks between O’Connell and Catherine Streets?

    View A:

    Henry Street / corner Harstonge Street. ( Nice hanging street cable. :rolleyes: )

    View B:

    Entrance to new L-Shaped lane. Henry Street / rear mews of Mallow Street.

    Great potential for these old mews if properly restored (Restaurant, Café, Gallery).

    View C:

    I presume this is the entrance to the new foreign aid offices?

    View D:

    Left and right side perspectives of the new lane from within the core of the block.

    View E:

    Here buildings to the rear of the former Limerick County Council offices.

    #755167
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Hartstonge Gate ~ River Stone House

    View F:

    Restored boundary walls of the Hartstonge Street buildings.

    View D / G:

    Underground parking entrance/exit – Archway Hartstonge Street.
    I wonder how long will the brick-work of this relative low overhead archway survive.

    #755168
    Tuborg
    Participant

    Great pics as usual CologneMike, I had meant to take a look around that place myself but never got around to it! I suppose the first thing to say is that its certainly good to see the site developed after lying derelict for as long as I can remember.

    Unfortunately though I find myself distinctly underwhelmed by the finished product. The Henry Street frontage is incredibly bland and Id nearly go as far as to say ugly! I mean whats the story with all those windows?, it just look really messy! I dont think this particular patchwork of materials on the front facade works either.

    The City Council may feel that this development reflects their ambitions for a more intensive usage of the core areas of Georgian blocks. But in my opinion it comes pretty close to over-development, maybe others might think it actually is? Them apartments squeezed in between the office block and the old council hq surely cant provide a quality living environment either. What have you got to look at, only the backsides of the surrounding buildings. Its all a bit claustrophobic, I dont think I’d like to live there anyway!

    #755169
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Just an FYI but the Greenpark racecourse housing development has been refused permission.

    http://www.limerickcity.ie/WebApps/PlanningApps/PlanningApplication.aspx?FileNo=07453

    They revised their application because the planning office thought the original was a Georgian pastiche. We’ll probably end up with the usual collection of Barratt boxes instead, in what should be a medium density urban village development close to the city and accessible by public transport.

    #755170
    Tuborg
    Participant

    @vkid wrote:

    Speaking of the Opera Centre, did i see somewhere a decision on the new plans is due this month??

    A decision is due by next Thursday, provided the planning department don’t look for further clarification on the plans. Although the word is that they are now satisfied with the information they received a few weeks back.

    Unfortunately we don’t know what that information is. It would be great if the developers came around to the idea of retaining the buildings on Ellen Street, although that’s probably being optimistic. Either way we should know the score next week.

    Incidentally I came across a large group of Italian tourists yesterday, making their way from the Hunt Museum towards O Connell Street. As they passed the forlorn, boarded up buildings on Rutland/Patrick St, many of them starting gesturing and pointing at them, the group then stopped to take some photos. They seemed to be particularly interested in the building with the tree growing out of it:eek:; I don’t think they could quite believe what they were seeing! Its certainly makes for an impressive sight, literally on the doorstep of one of the city’s main tourist attractions. What an embarrassment!:o

    #755171
    Dreamstate
    Participant

    Well , As far as I’m aware the Opera centre doesn’t propose to have any doors in from Patrick / Rutland Street so they might as well stay boarded up. Entry to units from the ‘Mall’ only will completely sterilise the streetscape….just like Stephens Green SC in Dublin did to South King Street as previously stated :confused:

    #755172
    vkid
    Participant

    Heard that was changed in the new plans and there is to be another entrance on Patricks St.. Was talking to someone who had seen the plans and was overall more excited by the new design than what went before. It is only one opinion..havent seen them myself.

    #755173
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @vkid wrote:

    Heard that was changed in the new plans and there is to be another entrance on Patricks St.. Was talking to someone who had seen the plans and was overall more excited by the new design than what went before. It is only one opinion..havent seen them myself.

    The new plans as submitted recently (not the further information) do include a significant opening onto Patrick’s street just at the turn above the mid-west institute offices.

    The further information does not propose to retain the buildings on Ellen st. they were giving reasons or excuses for their demolition. Once of which was to do with increasing the amount of sunlight onto the south facing areas of the development. It’s a shopping mall in Ireland in a city and they’re looking to catch some rays apparently.

    My suspicion (but I read The Prince too often) is that they are looking to draw a foul with the Ellen st changes as we’d say in GAA circles so as to delay the start of the project (while having an reasonable excuse for their banks) until they think they can get the best value for their construction Euro and be hitting completion just as the economy picks up.

    #755174
    vkid
    Participant

    TO be honest thats the one thing I notice any time I’m on Ellen Street is how dark it is. Any apartments oi’ve been inon the street are extremely dark. Would do no harm in my book to open it up a bit…Its a horrible street at the moment, dark dingy and made up mostly of sex shops, head shops and the odd antique store thrown into the mix..

    #755175
    Tuborg
    Participant

    Are they actually serious about the sunlight? If this is considered a justifiable reason to demolish these buildings then the planners really will have lost the plot! Im still convinced that the retention of these buildings is essential in reducing the impact of the new development on the general Ellen Street area. The old bonded warehouse (Quins pub) in particular is a very interesting and attractive building and under no circumstances should it be demolished. I think it would be ideal for a new restaurant/ cafe beside one of the main entrances to the new shopping centre.

    In fairness a major reason why Ellen Street seems so dark and gloomy is simply because it has been left to degenerate so badly. If these buildings were refurbished and integrated into the new complex, I think the street would look and feel very different. The replacement structure that they are proposing along Ellen Street is of highly dubious design in my opinion anyway!

    #755176
    Tuborg
    Participant

    @Dan Sullivan wrote:

    My suspicion (but I read The Prince too often) is that they are looking to draw a foul with the Ellen st changes as we’d say in GAA circles so as to delay the start of the project (while having an reasonable excuse for their banks) until they think they can get the best value for their construction Euro and be hitting completion just as the economy picks up.

    Well they might have another “excuse” now if this story drags on. Limerick City Council, the developers and Trinity Rooms have been at each others throats quite a bit lately, Trinity Rooms are already worried about the impact on their business during the construction of the opera centre.

    Land dispute could delay Opera Centre


    The area outside the Trinity Rooms which is subject to a planning oral hearing

    By David Hurley

    A ROW over a tiny plot of land, which will be the subject of a contentious public hearing next month, could further delay the construction of the multi-million euro Opera Shopping Centre.
    Management at one of Limerick’s most popular nightclubs are seeking to halt proceedings initiated by Limerick City Council to acquire a footpath at Bank Place near the Granary, which they argue, is located outside one of the main entrances to the complex.

    An Bord Pleanala has confirmed a full oral hearing, which will cost thousands of euro, will be held at the Castletroy Park Hotel on September 3 next after the Trinity Rooms formally objected to the CPO proceedings.

    The tiny piece of land, which is less than 100 square metres in size has no registered owner but according to a spokesperson for Limerick City Council it is in “the charge” of the local authority.

    A number of other plots of land and properties at adjacent streets have already been acquired by Limerick City Council in order to pave the way for the construction of the Opera Centre, which could cost up to €250 million.

    In a detailed submission to an Bord Pleanala Managing Director of the Trinity Rooms, Pat Barry, states: “The proposed CPO will put the day to day running of my business and its 103 employees at risk and cause hardship to my employees, suppliers and customers as the main access point via Bank Place will no longer have a public right of way.”

    Limerick Leader

    #755177
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Plan for old Limerick racecourse denied (Limerick Leader)

    By Petula Martyn

    PLANNING permission for a housing development at Greenpark Racecourse has been refused by Limerick City Council, despite An Taisce’s approval of the original application.

    The proposed development at the former home of Limerick horse racing and adjacent to the future home of Limerick greyhound racing, consisted of 222 housing units including 90 houses, 78 duplex apartments, a retirement village and a creche.

    Planning permission was refused because the development was of “insufficient design quality in respect of design of individual buildings”, and on the grounds that the applicant, Limerick Racecourse Company, failed to provide sufficient open space.

    An Taisce, the heritage conservation body, favoured the original application which they said complemented Georgian Limerick but which the local authority considered pastiche.

    “We thought the original submission in terms of design was in keeping with Georgian Limerick,” Daniel Sullivan of An Taisce told the Limerick Leader. “The development was in a crescent shape and made it more appealing.”

    In an unusual move by An Taisce, its Limerick members sent a submission to the council informing the local authority that it liked the original application.

    “It begs the question; if you were applying to build Georgian Limerick today, would it be refused?” Mr Sullivan asked.

    Dan, it seems like the local authority has turned the tables on you on this one. Dismissing An Taisce’s approval as pastiche. Ouch, that hurts! 😀

Viewing 20 posts - 2,101 through 2,120 (of 2,479 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.