The sensitive issue of the title "Architect" and the Buildin

Home › Forums › Ireland › The sensitive issue of the title "Architect" and the Buildin

Viewing 3 posts - 1,241 through 1,243 (of 1,243 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #816247
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @teak wrote:

    I was not aware that the new regs prevented arch techs from doing design work.
    .

    Yes it does.
    The complier of the building regulation compliant drawings and documents can only be an architect or surveyor in accordance to BCA 2007 or an engineer in accordance with Engineers of ireland act 1969.
    So that leaves the situation where the professional specifically trained and targeted at legislative and regulatory compliance is prevented from providing the technical service they exist for.

    @teak wrote:

    My point was simply that the lone term architect ought simply be used according to the existing law.
    And that other related professions might compete for design and non-design work as architectural technicians / technologists, building draughtsmen, etc.
    But you say that this is now forbidden.

    For the purposes of building regulation compliance, its nonsensical that technicians cannot provide technical design. In a lot of cases it will still be the technician in the office who is required to provide this technical information, yet it must be another person who is required to put their name to a certificate where they are stating that they

    prepared exercising reasonable skill, care and diligence

    the design documents. Does that make sense?

    @teak wrote:

    Can it be that the RIAI membership has a distinctly different view on all this to that of the RIAI executive ?
    This would explain the lack of challenge to these unofficial operators working under the noses of the official architects.

    A professional body out of step with its rank and file — there’s nothing new in that.

    well judging by the internal revolt as expressed in the EGM and the vote of for a revised amendment and revised policy from the executive, plus the emergence of the Breg forum and the conversation around this, its quite obvious theres a schism between the membership and the executive.

    #816248
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    There has been an incredible amount of work going on behind the scenes between the RIAI and its members, the government and, just as importantly, the insurance industry to bring about modifications and tweaks to the proposals in order to overcome the very basic concerns over the certification process. I don’t know of any architect who disagrees with the principle of the new regs. It is the fundamental flaws in the wording of the certification that is causing the problem – moreso over the very simple problem of whether or not even established practices are going to be able to get PI Insurance

    As with everything in this country we took an established regulation in the UK and, while trying to put our own tweak on it, made a balls of it. The Building regulation process in the UK works and, given half a chance it should work here too.

    Sounds more like a case of dodging the can.
    An incredible amount of work going on behind the scenes . . . :lolno:
    I love it !

    I am no fan of the RIAI but I don’t think they’re out of step. They do contact anyone advertising themselves as an architect when they’re not and warn them of what they’re doing wrong i.e calling themselves what they’re not.

    WearNiceHats — No one has been bearded on this yet, according to RIAI.
    Let alone prosecuted.
    Despite the ubiquitous flyers, business cards and thumbtack ads on noticeboards.
    It seems that even within the profession – both membership and RIAI exec – that there are some very mixed feelings on this whole question.
    And I do get the impression that there’s an even greater than usual desire by the sort of people who become architects to avoid the battle – with its incumbent need for cohesion and mutual support – for their own livelihood and their own professional self-respect.

    #816249
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    I recognise that we’re having two separate conversations on this thread, but, given that the profession is in full civil-war mode at the moment, a little bit more confusion won’t do much harm.

    On the Building Regs issue, The RIAI opposition group [the one headed up by the seven past presidents] have circulated their list of approved candidates for the upcoming RIAI council election, presumably with the intention of staging a palace coup.

    In the interests of fulfilling my duties as a sometimes paid up member of the RIAI, I’ve examined the two lists; the official, 31 candidate list, circulated with the official RIAI ballot, and the 10 candidate, opposition group’s approved list.

    Unfortunately, I haven’t a clue who most of the people are, not being overly engaged in institute politics as a rule, but what I can say is that the handful of candidates that I have encountered, and whose records on a range of issues I respect, are all candidates who are not on the opposition group’s approved list, names like; Eddie Conroy, also a past president and a advocate for restraint, Ali Grehan, [the city architect] and Fionula Rogerson, who was a rare thing during the building boom, a thoughtful architect.

    It could be argued that the architectural profession disgraced itself as much as any of the other ‘stake-holders’ in the building bubble, it rode the tiger shamelessly and we are tainted by that and will continue to be until there is a proper self examination and some measure of atonement offered. The profession might like to think of itself as above all of that, as I suspect it does on most matters, but invariably there was a little RIAI crest on the foot of each of the increasingly outlandish planning applications lodged during the bubble and I recall very little talk of restraint as the RIAI jetted off, en-mass, each year to Barcelona, or Trieste, or New York or Chicago for its ever more self-gratifying annual conference.

    Phil Hogan, judging from the tone of his article in the Irish Times last week, is unmoved by any of the internal pantomime convulsing the RIAI and is more convinced than ever that the architectural profession has a responsibility for the buildings that it conceives, a responsibility that he is not going to let the profession weasel its way out of. The pleas of the RIAI opposition group that ‘we’re not ready for S.I 180’ sound hopelessly feeble against this determined drive to finally begin to properly regulate the activity of building in this country.

    Interesting times ahead I think. I certainly won’t be making any rash commitments with my direct debit mandate until we see if there’s a good old-fashioned split.

Viewing 3 posts - 1,241 through 1,243 (of 1,243 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.