The sensitive issue of the title "Architect" and the Buildin

Home › Forums › Ireland › The sensitive issue of the title "Architect" and the Buildin

Viewing 20 posts - 1,221 through 1,240 (of 1,243 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #816227
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @Solo wrote:

    Wow CK I know I told you and Onq to spice it up a bit as you were dropping down the rankings but this is much better than I anticipated. It’s great who said handbags at dawn we are way past handbags now.

    One guy swinging a handbag at empty air does not a tournament make…

    If CK had stuck to the handbags instead of charging off course at the King who was sponsoring the tournament he might still be here.

    Still, we’ve seen this kind of behaviour from CK before – his Gallic passion gets the better of him, he can’t seem to find the stop button – never mind the reverse – and off he goes into the distance… a pity, but somehow, inevitable…

    ONQ.

    #816228
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @Solo wrote:

    @onq wrote:

    And while I’m on Paul, what’s gone on with the metrics of this thread.

    Replies: 1191

    Views: 354

    How can there be four times fewer views than replies?

    ONQ.

    Thats cause some people never shut up LOL

    I see the maths is giving you trouble again, Solo.

    Each time I viewed my own posts before editing it seemed to me a view was counted.

    So it follows logically that the number of posts cannot be more than the number of views.

    As for having the last word, we’ll see how many reply cycles you last when you get your teeth into a thing.

    Endless, I should imagine… :rolleyes:

    (Why am I seeing only the test version of :rolleyes: – don’t these avatars appear as graphics, or is everybody seeing this properly and its just my browser settings?)

    ONQ.

    #816229
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Righto, enough waffling about Solo’s inability to count and CK’s departure.

    Here is the list of jobs for architects on offer from Jobrapido – it is a joke, with not one “proper” archtiect listed thereon – it paints a picture of a Title so debased in the public eye as to be meaningless and casts huge questions ove the competence an real intent of those who promoted and passed the Building Control Act 2007 – it is impossible for the intent of the Act – the clarification in the public eye of what the word “Architect” means, when current usage is as debased as it is.

    =====================================================

    From:

    http://www.jobrapido.ie/?j=nvvzk9vvutxa3u6fn&utm_source=jobalert&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=ADWORDS_IE_JOB_SEARCH

    Search also: Naval Architect, Project Architect, Systems Architect, Interior Architect, Solution Architect

    Location
    Systems Verification Test (SVT) Software Engineering – Technical Leader/Architect
    IBM Ireland Limited
    9 Jan 2011 • http://www.ibm.com
    Dublin

    Senior Solutions Architect – Services Strategic Platform
    Dell Inc.
    9 Jan 2011 • http://www.dell.com
    Dublin

    Solution Architect – Financial Services South Dublin
    Computer Futures Solutions Limited
    8 Jan 2011 • http://www.computerfutures.com
    Dublin

    Software architect / Consultant – Dortmund, Germanynew
    MeghenGroup International
    8 Jan 2011 • http://www.meghengroup.com
    DublinUnread

    4 X Senior C# Developers – URGENT – 1 X Architect
    Stelfox Ltd
    8 Jan 2011 • http://www.stelfox.ie
    Dublin

    Architect Open Source (PHP/MySQL)
    Collins Mcnicholas Recruitment And Training Group
    8 Jan 2011 • http://www.loadzajobs.ie
    Londonderry

    Service Architect Tower Lead
    Fujitsu Uk
    7 Jan 2011 • http://www.jobsnation.net
    Ireland

    Customer Solutions Architect
    Fujitsu Uk
    7 Jan 2011 • http://www.jobsnation.net
    Ireland

    Solution Design Architect
    Vodafone
    7 Jan 2011 • http://www.jobsnation.net
    Ireland

    Systems Mgmt Architect (Netcool)
    Fujitsu Uk
    7 Jan 2011 • http://www.jobsnation.net

    =====================================================

    Its a joke.

    All the grief the RIAI have put Graduates and Grandfathers through, preventing them from using the title architect and this is going on.

    Oh, I can hear Graby’s excuse now – “THEY’RE NOT EVEN IN THE BUILDING INDUSTRY – NO ONE COULD MISTAKE THESE FOR REAL ARCHITECTS”.

    That’s not the point John.

    You have disenfranchised people who have traded for years as Architects and prevented Graduates using a title that is rightfull theirs, and prevented their certs being acceptable, at a time when Technicians and Engineers are merrily providing archtiectural services and certifying – as architects or WHATEVER, but certifying and having their certs accepted.

    All this is happening at the same time that the primary title is being undermined by every Tom Dick and Harriet in the software profession.
    Its bad enough architects with five years of a course behind them or ten years or more in practice have to play second fiddle to technicians and engineers when it comes to certifying work, but to see this nonsense from a totally unrelated profession muddying the waters – its not on!

    ONQ.

    #816230
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Righto, enough waffling about Solo’s inability to count and CK’s departure.

    Here is the list of jobs for architects on offer from Jobrapido – it paints a picture of a Title so debased in the public eye as to be meaningless and raises huge questions ove the real intent of those who promoted and passed the Building Control Act 2007.

    It is patently impossible for the intent of the Act – the clarification in the public eye of what the word “Architect” means – become a reality when current usage of the Title Architect is as debased as it is.

    =====================================================

    From:

    http://www.jobrapido.ie/?j=nvvzk9vvutxa3u6fn&utm_source=jobalert&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=ADWORDS_IE_JOB_SEARCH

    Search also: Naval Architect, Project Architect, Systems Architect, Interior Architect, Solution Architect

    Location
    Systems Verification Test (SVT) Software Engineering – Technical Leader/Architect
    IBM Ireland Limited
    9 Jan 2011 • http://www.ibm.com
    Dublin

    Senior Solutions Architect – Services Strategic Platform
    Dell Inc.
    9 Jan 2011 • http://www.dell.com
    Dublin

    Solution Architect – Financial Services South Dublin
    Computer Futures Solutions Limited
    8 Jan 2011 • http://www.computerfutures.com
    Dublin

    Software architect / Consultant – Dortmund, Germany
    MeghenGroup International
    8 Jan 2011 • http://www.meghengroup.com
    DublinUnread

    4 X Senior C# Developers – URGENT – 1 X Architect
    Stelfox Ltd
    8 Jan 2011 • http://www.stelfox.ie
    Dublin

    Architect Open Source (PHP/MySQL)
    Collins Mcnicholas Recruitment And Training Group
    8 Jan 2011 • http://www.loadzajobs.ie
    Londonderry

    Service Architect Tower Lead
    Fujitsu Uk
    7 Jan 2011 • http://www.jobsnation.net
    Ireland

    Customer Solutions Architect
    Fujitsu Uk
    7 Jan 2011 • http://www.jobsnation.net
    Ireland

    Solution Design Architect
    Vodafone
    7 Jan 2011 • http://www.jobsnation.net
    Ireland

    Systems Mgmt Architect (Netcool)
    Fujitsu Uk
    7 Jan 2011 • http://www.jobsnation.net

    =====================================================

    All the grief the RIAI have put Graduates and Grandfathers through, preventing them from using the title architect and this is going on.
    It is a joke, with not one “proper” architect listed on the list above and this is only one out of many websites.
    I could level similar accusations of selective administration at the ARB – they’re for dessert, elsewhere.

    Oh, I can hear John Graby’s excuse now, as he strides across what’s left of the the profession like a colossus –
    “But they’re not even in the building industry – no-one could mistake these people for real architects.”
    Oh really? They mistook David Grant for a real architect for long enough, didn’t they?
    Wasn’t the purpose of the BCA 2007 to bring clarity to the use of the Title?

    Because it hasn’t brought much clarity that I can see.
    Its only prevented Graduates from using the title, but hasn’t regulated the provision of services.

    The Building Control Act 2007 disenfranchised people who have traded for years as Architects and prevented Graduates using a title that is rightfull theirs under EU Law, and prevented their certs being acceptable.

    This is occuring at a time when Technicians and Engineers are merrily providing architectural services and certifying – as themselve or as architects or WHATEVER, but certifying the provision of architectural services AND having their certs accepted!

    All this is happening at the same time that the primary title is being undermined by every Tom Dick and Harriet in the software profession!

    Its bad enough architects with five years of a prescribed course to their name or ten years or more in competent practice have to play second fiddle to technicians and engineers when it comes to certifying work, but to see this nonsense made of the Title by a totally unrelated profession muddying the waters – its just not on!

    Lets see if the Registrar is only good at hitting soft targets or whether he has the teeth to prevent this continuing abuse of the Title Architect.

    ONQ.

    #816231
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    I’m toying with the idea of developing a “rate your architect” website along the lines of http://www.rate-your-solicitor.com/

    What is the view of Members of Archiseek on such a proposal?

    ONQ.

    #816232
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    The ratings would not be limited to Members of the Institute.

    This is not intended to undermine the BCA 2007 or the Registrar or Institute Members.

    Submissions would be going back several years before 2008, when anyone could avail of the title.

    They would be invited since 2008 and would include persons without a formal qualification providing services.

    The would include professionals with other qualifications like engineers and surveyors and teachers and draughspeople.

    Anyone in short who provided any archiectural services any acted “as an architect” whether or not they used that name in business.

    Any thoughts?

    ONQ.

    #816233
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    seems RIAI registration is no protection for consumers… quelle surprise….

    #816234
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @henno wrote:

    seems RIAI registration is no protection for consumers… quelle surprise….

    More a fault of the building control system and the lack of a requirement to have any professional inspect during construction.

    #816235
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Doc, that’s not the whole truth.

    The buck must stop with the certifying architect.
    Where matters are obvious to visual inspection he has to call it.

    Prime Time showed a Condition of a Fire Cert requiring an inner room to be removed.
    According to the programme, it wasn’t removed, and if so, certifying compliance in such a situation is wrong.

    Unbelievable that here I am gathering my bits and piece together to (finally) apply for Registration and this hits the fan.
    Its enough to make you throw your hat at it, when you see this kind of nonsense dragging down the reputation of the profession.

    #816236
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @onq wrote:

    Where matters are obvious to visual inspection he has to call it.

    Prime Time showed a Condition of a Fire Cert requiring an inner room to be removed.
    According to the programme, it wasn’t removed, and if so, certifying compliance in such a situation is wrong.

    Have to agree with you on that one ONQ! An obvious and complete oversight…..see no evil, etc.

    #816237
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Tried to edit the above post but was not allowed to.

    When I say there is something wront with the system, there is something wrong with a system that allows an apartment be sold having had no inspection whatsoever during construction and allowing the use of Form 1A Opinion on Compliance at the end of construction. This is the Opinion on Compliance that an architect can sign having had no involvement in the construction stage of the project (only the design stage) and relies on letters of confirmation from the contrcator and sub-contractors that they have carried out their work/built in compliance with the building regulations.

    This form of Opinion I’m sure will be gone soon! With no regulation/registration of contractors (to ensure they are competant and at least understand the building regulations), it’s obvious now you cannot rely on these written confirmations.

    Opinions on Compliance are documents, the wording of which are agreed with the Law Society, intended soley for the purpose of conveyance. They are not statutory documents. These Opinions are not worth the paper they are written on!

    With regard to the inner bedroom, this was clearly conditioned out by the Fire Safety Certificate. You don’t know whether it was agreed by the architect and developer at the time that this should be renamed a Study or and additional living room and not be called a bedroom and then the developer simply sold on as bedroom?

    I’m sure it will come out in the wash. As they say, there are two sides and then there is the truth!

    #816238
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    I disagree that you cannot rely on contractors certificates.
    Its up to you as the inspecting architect to review their work.
    This assessment informs you as to whether or not you can accept their certs.
    The basic issue is what I’ve christened the Paddy-Last Cert where no inspection occurs.
    This is exacerbated by the Drive -By Inspection, where its cursory and no record photos are taken.
    I’ve set standards for my own work going back fifteen years which required regular in-depth inspections.

    #816239
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @henno wrote:

    lets take a step back from this indepth debate and consider what the long term outcomes of the BCA 2007 may be.

    The act precludes an unregistered person from using the title “Architect” in any form of advertising, or business correspondence, certification etc.

    So what does that mean?

    Does it mean anyone can advertise / claim to offer ‘architectural services’, ‘architectural design’, ‘architectural *blank*??
    what if they name themselves ‘ACME Architecture’ ? etc does it matter??

    I would claim not really.

    I can see the endgame of the BCA being the RIAI claiming a monopoly on as many services as possible currently available on the ‘open’ market. Design Team leaders for public contracts currently have to be RIAI or similar chartered engineers. This will filter down to smaller projects. RIAI will pressurise the Law Society not to accept certification from non-registered purveyors of ‘architectural services’, be they Architectural Technologists or non chartered engineers etc. See AIB requirements for example of whats to come.

    Perhaps we may even see a time when only registered architects could make planning applications, as is being debated on another thread in this forum. Or perhaps local authorities may make this decision themselves??..

    Make no bones about it, the RIAI now have a very very strong position to lobby those close to them about the monopolization of services. As time passes this stranglehold will become even stronger. Like the child that cries the loudest, it gets fed first.

    The competition authority has be shown to be meek when opposing a body of the RIAIs stature. Its conclusions in its report to the BCA bill were largely ignored. It now claims to be legally helpless to AA.

    post from almost exactly 3 years ago……

    unfortunately what i predicted has turned out top be true. 🙁

    #816240
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    They’re still out there, you know.
    The various non-architect disciplines who persist in calling themselves architects on their flyers, ads and – when they have them – websites.

    The curious thing is, that they often leave their flyers in areas where a number of other architects reside or practice . . .
    Are they relying on the old Irish custom of not professionally attacking someone who is a neighbour, who has children at school with one’s own and who boldly parades himself at the local chapel on a Sunday ?

    If so, then it’s time that you architects organize yourselves on a local chapter basis and have their improper use of the word architect prevented legally and ‘professionally’ with no individual neighboring professional fingered as an informer.

    I just don’t get why those many of them who have legit qualifications as architectural technicians/technologists, building draughtsmen and so on don’t simply advertise as such.
    For so many smaller jobs, esp. those related to home modifications/extensions, the latter people would be the preferred choice of most people. Yet they continue to risk public opprobium for the sake of an odd tasty tidbit . . . :crazy:

    #816241
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    That sounds like a 1950s Legion of Mary solution you’re looking for there teak.

    I didn’t pay enough attention to Registration at the time, not that it would have made any difference.

    There is a counter argument that if you can design buildings and you do it for a living, you’re an architect, in common speech. Registration of the title architect, under the administration of the RIAI, imposes pre-conditions that undermine that commonly held understanding. Supposedly this was to be for the benefit of the public, to protect them from some poorly skilled practitioners who haven’t passed as many exams as the RIAI guys, but actually it was for the benefit of the membership of the RIAI, many of whom are probably equally poorly skilled, to judge from much of what has been built in recent years.

    Ironically, registration probably will benefit the public in the long run, by propelling the RIAI down the same protectionist road that the trade guilds went down in the 18th century, into oblivion. The more the Institute attempts to ring fence the architectural profession, the more that ring-fenced profession will be by-passed by the consumers it is professing to protect, many of whom just want a competent design and planning service at a reasonable cost.

    I became an architect to design buildings, I didn’t become an architect to join a closed shop. The guild system ultimately failed because the guilds were closed shops adrift in an sea of technological advance and because innovation was conspicuously happening in the centres of growth not controlled by the guilds. The same will happen to the RIAI. By making the title ‘Architect’ more precious, it is inevitable that the practice of architecture will become more expensive to sustain and that will open the door to other professionals, who can also design and plan buildings, to offer a comparable service at a more attractive rate. We’re living in the android era, the days of the premium brand are over.

    The Registration debate may be over, but in making its Faustian pact with the legislators to become the sole custodians of the coveted title ‘Architect’ the RIAI now finds itself conjoined in a deadly legislative embrace that has been represented as aiming to compel the designers of buildings to be legally responsible for what is actually being built under their guidance, which is a prospect that is both perfectly reasonable, and terrifying.

    Even though that is not actually the case, the RIAI is now tearing itself apart along this fault line, which is frankly not what I want for my €450 a year.

    The vista of seven past presidents of the RIAI shaking their walking sticks at the current incumbent is unedifying to put it mildly, and needs to stop.

    S.I. 80 of 2013 does not demand that the architect for a given project himself self-certifies the work, it provides for an ‘Assigned Certifier’ to verify the compliance of building work with the Building Regulations, which, as with the practice that has emerged to deal with BER certification, will doubtless end up with the creation of a new pool of professions to fulfil this certification role, practitioners [many of whom will be architects] with the appropriate training and P.I. insurance who will take on this new responsibility for a fee.

    The past-presidents group propose an independent inspectorate that will be, effectively, exactly the same thing, but with a half-assed Local Authority inspectorate layer above that to carry out spot checks on random, or suspect, developments. That would only have the effect of deflecting responsibility off into some grey area between the two where everyone involved can sleep soundly in the knowledge that no one will ever be effectively pinned down for any involvement they may have had in any new revelation of dodgy buildings practice.

    The RIAI has no choice now, registration is a done deal, now it needs to get its act together and embrace the notion of actual accountability, in partnership with anyone else who wants a piece of that action, or retreat deeper into its protective shell and get ready for irrelevance.

    #816242
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @teak wrote:

    They’re still out there, you know.
    The various non-architect disciplines who persist in calling themselves architects on their flyers, ads and – when they have them – websites.

    The curious thing is, that they often leave their flyers in areas where a number of other architects reside or practice . . .
    Are they relying on the old Irish custom of not professionally attacking someone who is a neighbour, who has children at school with one’s own and who boldly parades himself at the local chapel on a Sunday ?

    If so, then it’s time that you architects organize yourselves on a local chapter basis and have their improper use of the word architect prevented legally and ‘professionally’ with no individual neighboring professional fingered as an informer.

    I just don’t get why those many of them who have legit qualifications as architectural technicians/technologists, building draughtsmen and so on don’t simply advertise as such.
    For so many smaller jobs, esp. those related to home modifications/extensions, the latter people would be the preferred choice of most people. Yet they continue to risk public opprobium for the sake of an odd tasty tidbit . . . :crazy:

    well you see this is the problem… architects seem to think architecture stops at the drawing board.

    Why would a technologist only be deemed capable to provide technical design for “a smaller job”, “home modification/ extension”, “an odd tasty tidbit”?? Why should an architect actually be considered capable of providing technical design for the same scale of project? I hear of fourth year architects in college crying out for technical education because they feel the standard they are taught is not good enough.
    The problem currently is that the existing practitioner be they technician / draughsman etc are precluded now from providing technical design to anything other than the smallest ‘exempt status’ extensions. What are the RIAI afraid of? surely if their skills are so obviously ahead of non registered designers then the market will take care of removing the rabble… oh wait a minute….

    The one professional perfectly positioned to provide the service required in SI 80, the architectural technician, has been excluded from the legislation because RIAI exists to serve its member and not for the betterment of architecture. The RIAI council has 24 architects and but one technician member, yet its purports to represent architects and technicians equally??

    SI 80 has architects actually terrified now because they have been asked to put up or shut up, and they have chosen to shut up.

    #816243
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    I don’t see much evidence of them shutting up, the opposite seems to be the case.

    The last thing that architects need to be doing right now is going on the radio and sounding muddled about what exactly their issue is with new Building Regulations. For the man in the street, the new Building Regulations are intended, whether effectively or not, to stop a repeat of the dodgy building practices that have put people out of their apartments and on the street with him.

    Joan O’Connor, a member of the past presidents group that has set itself up in opposition to the RIAI Council’s handling of the proposed legislation, spent five minutes dumping on the current Building Regulation proposals on Morning Ireland before seemingly conceding that the proposed new measures in S.I. 80 would bring about a small improvement in consumer protection.

    Everyone in the argument is desperate to get out the message that their real concern is for the consumer, but nobody wants to be holding the certificate when a crack appears in the consumer’s wall.

    It isn’t unreasonable that the architect for a given project is obliged to provide a certificate that his design complies with the Building Regulations and that the work has actually been executed in accordance with his specifications. Or failing that, that there is someone else employed on the job, eating into his fee percentage, that is prepared to fulfil this role.

    If the responsibility for certification was instead passed on to the local authority, or a new Building Control Authority, as the RIAI opposition group appear to be arguing for, in this country that would be a compo charter. Can you imagine how this would pan out? Who wouldn’t take a pot at the local council if you thought you get the house redecorated. There’d be night classes in cultivating mildew.

    The current version of S.I 80, as I understand it, introduces the concept of the ‘assigned certifier’ who need not be the architect, but, like the architect, is engaged by the client to deliver the project. Presumably the ‘assigned certifier’ will be obliged to carry a level of insurance appropriate to the value of the works he is certifying. No assigned certifier, who wants to stay in business, is going to hand out certs until the works he is supposed to be overseeing demonstrably comply with all statutory requirements.

    This sounds like a workable arrangement to me and a helluva lot more sensible than attempting to resuscitate some version of the old Bye-Law inspectorate, who were mostly humourless zombies even back in the day.

    The Paul Kelly resignation letter [gleefully circulated this evening by the RIAI opposition group] concedes that the assigned certifier will have the power to withhold certification. That alone ought to be sufficient to quickly bestow on him the status of the most respected guy at the table.

    I think the hysteria being whipped up about S.I. 80 is ill judged and reflects very poorly on the profession. Whatever the actual motivation, it sounds like we’re trying to avoid our share of responsibility and, if that isn’t the case, somebody needs to put up a spokesperson who can get that message across with a bit more credibility than we’ve heard to date.

    #816244
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    It was the placement of the adverts (noticeboards, flyers through letterboxes, etc) that made me say that they were seeking the house modification jobs, not simply the nature of their skills.
    I was not aware that the new regs prevented arch techs from doing design work.

    My point was simply that the lone term architect ought simply be used according to the existing law.
    And that other related professions might compete for design and non-design work as architectural technicians / technologists, building draughtsmen, etc.
    But you say that this is now forbidden.

    Can it be that the RIAI membership has a distinctly different view on all this to that of the RIAI executive ?
    This would explain the lack of challenge to these unofficial operators working under the noses of the official architects.

    A professional body out of step with its rank and file — there’s nothing new in that.

    #816245
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    There has been an incredible amount of work going on behind the scenes between the RIAI and its members, the government and, just as importantly, the insurance industry to bring about modifications and tweaks to the proposals in order to overcome the very basic concerns over the certification process. I don’t know of any architect who disagrees with the principle of the new regs. It is the fundamental flaws in the wording of the certification that is causing the problem – moreso over the very simple problem of whether or not even established practices are going to be able to get PI Insurance

    As with everything in this country we took an established regulation in the UK and, while trying to put our own tweak on it, made a balls of it. The Building regulation process in the UK works and, given half a chance it should work here too.

    #816246
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @teak wrote:

    It was the placement of the adverts (noticeboards, flyers through letterboxes, etc) that made me say that they were seeking the house modification jobs, not simply the nature of their skills.
    I was not aware that the new regs prevented arch techs from doing design work.

    My point was simply that the lone term architect ought simply be used according to the existing law.
    And that other related professions might compete for design and non-design work as architectural technicians / technologists, building draughtsmen, etc.
    But you say that this is now forbidden.

    Can it be that the RIAI membership has a distinctly different view on all this to that of the RIAI executive ?
    This would explain the lack of challenge to these unofficial operators working under the noses of the official architects.

    A professional body out of step with its rank and file — there’s nothing new in that.

    I am no fan of the RIAI but I don’t think they’re out of step. They do contact anyone advertising themselves as an architect when they’re not and warn them of what they’re doing wrong i.e calling themselves what they’re not.

    The UK equivalent – the ARB – prosecutes people for this on a daily basis.

Viewing 20 posts - 1,221 through 1,240 (of 1,243 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.