The sensitive issue of the title "Architect" and the Buildin

Home › Forums › Ireland › The sensitive issue of the title "Architect" and the Buildin

Viewing 20 posts - 1,201 through 1,220 (of 1,243 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #816207
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:

    Are you really that naive onq? Paul obviously receives donations from RIAI members…

    Research Paul’s history and you’ll see he is not affiliated to the RIAI in any way – but of course you went to the trouble of researching his history before making your unfounded allegations, didn’t you? No? Quelle surprise…

    By the way Paul, I would like to be removed from the members’ list of these biased forums… How can I manage that?

    I’m sure many people would echo that sentiment, unfortunately you are part of the legend that is Archiseek, just as you are inextricably linked with Brian “Monty” Montaut and Gary Solan and me for all time – believe me, I know how embarrassing this will turn out to be for all of us…..

    It seems that you are able to remove any information that you like from the threads… I do not feel comfortable to be part of such a scam. Then please remove all my data or I will lodge a complaint to a relevant authority.

    You cannot force a host to remove posts you freely made thus disturbing the integrity of the record.
    Someone may want to use your online ramblings on archiseek as proof you have diminished mental capabilities….

    You cannot manipulate a discussion in a way that change the outcome. out.

    You haven’t shown any manipulation on Paul’s part – its you who are trying to manipulate the discussion by removing your old posts.

    This is outrageous, especially if members cannot opt

    You’re overdoing the wronged, indignant “pauvre” Frenchman CK – it won’t wash this time.

    I will contact you privately on this subject…

    BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA!!!!11111!!!!1111

    Very French Foreign Legion CK – I expect Paul will run off and block up his chimney now…

    HAPPY NEW YEAR…

    Sure its only starting CK – has John Graby called around to your door yet?

    Happy New Year yourself, CK!

    ONQ.

    #816208
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:

    Someone who has practiced for ten years or more is competent. You say that market assessment is not enough, but in the contrary it is much more valuable than any academic assessments. Someone who has practiced during 10 years proved that he has the skills to do so, as well as the skills to adapt to a fast changing working environment. Academic training is only a simulation… It does not reflect the real world…

    I didn’t respond to this nonsense assertion earlier but I do so now.

    Someone who has practised “as an architect” for 10 years may be competent, but if all he has done is provided services to an architect as a technician, he is unlikely to have gained the experience necessary to claim membership of the architectural profession.

    But it is totally incorrect to state as fact that merely because someone tries to do something for ten years he becomes competent at it by virtue of persistence.

    That puts repetition on a par with “market tested” as a means to obtaining professional qualifications – it cannot stand any logical assessment.

    Many people have natural limits to their talent they will never breach, many talented people without gaining proper experience will neve rreach their potential.

    So to suggest mere repetition of a set of tasks without proper tuition or qualitative eassessment over a quantitative time limit empowers a perons with a qualitative professional ability fare above that of draughtsman or technician is a nonsense of the highest order.

    Some people who have not had formal academic training in a prescribed course may have both the necessary raw talent and be lucky to gain the appropriate training, expertise and experience to provide services commensurate with those of an architect – they are few and far between in my experience.

    I know from personal experience of one who appears to have done so, having reviewed that person’s claimed work and tested that person’s mettle, judgement and ability against my own – that’s one person CK – not a multitide.

    As for the rest of the Alliance, there may be one or two others, but I cannot say whether or not for certain because I have little or no experience of them directly and almost none of their work.

    But to suggest that someone can become an architect merely because they may have stuck at it the attempt for ten years without formal academic training – I would say there is two chances of that being correct, CK.

    A solicitor may be happy to accept their technical opinion on built work or their certificate for payment based on their past competence at signing certificates and their integrity and honesty, but a solicitor isn’t competent to judge that person’s ability as an architect and designer.

    To get public acceptance practically trained architects need to be prepared to submit their work for qualitative assessment – anyone who doesn’t want to stand up and show their work for review by competent professionals cannot expect accreditation as an architect based solely on their word and unsupported assertions.

    ONQ.

    #816213
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    I am sorry onq,

    the poll was removed from this thread why?

    removing some information, specially this poll is misleading the readers of this thread. I have privately contacted Paul and I am waiting for his explanation.

    He may have created this discussion board, but this does not give him the right to influence the content by removing information.

    With regard to Paul being independent from the RIAI, this does not mean that he does not share similar interests, but this is not the problem here.

    This discussion forum pretends to give freedom of speech to supporters and opponents of the actual legislation but it also manipulates the information as to please the RIAI.

    I was interested to participate to this thread as long as the conversation was hosted by a neutral organization. Obviously this is not the case anymore. I believe that Paul is acting unlawfully by manipulating the information as to favor the views of the RIAI. I would like him to remove my data from this forum for this reason.

    He has the technical ability to do so. He cannot oblige me to stay as a member and in the same time, use his position to manipulate information on this thread as to undermine my point of view. I think that a court in Northern Ireland or in the ROI would acknowledge that this is not acceptable.

    I am not asking Paul to change his way of doing. If this is the type of forum that he is willing to run, he can do so, but not with me.

    Paul I will give you a few days to remove my membership of archiseek (which was first named archeire when I registered) and all other personal data. If you refuse to do so, I will consider that you are using this forum and manipulating information for misleading the public and acting my personal interests.

    #816214
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @Paul Clerkin wrote:

    What the fuck are you on about now

    Hi Paul,

    Keep your “fuck” out of this…

    The poll was removed from the thread “The sensitive issue of the title architect…”

    I believe that you or someone working with you is manipulating the information by removing data from the thread.

    You said first that you were not responsible from the thread being removed from the first page of the google search engine; however, the removing of the poll from the thread can only be your action or the action of someone working with you.

    Otherwise how can you explain it?

    I was interested to participate to this thread only if the organisation hosting the discussion was acting in a neutral way. I believe that this is not the case anymore. I think that my request is only normal and fair.

    I will give you a few days to remove my membership of archiseek (which was first named archeire when I registered) and all other personal data. If you refuse to do so, I will consider that you are using this forum and manipulating information for misleading the public and acting against my personal interests.

    Regards

    #816215
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @Paul Clerkin wrote:

    You, Sir, are a nut.
    I do not interfere with threads or take donations to change them.

    If the number do not co-incide that is merely an unfortunate site effect of the import of the old boards into the new boards or more probably the merging of the many many threads that you start on the same subject when you become bogged down arguing in circles. If the poll is gone, it is because of the forums merge.

    Alternatively crack units of the MRIAI Ninja Taskforce may actually be hacking into your computer from their mountain lair in Wicklow

    Paul you are taking us for for a ride here… I am not that ignorant regarding database…

    Maybe you are trying to do too much by running the main site and a discussion forum in the same time. If you decided to remove this thread all together, it would be understandable, but you cannot only remove parts of it. Or if you decide to do so then I ask you to remove the data that I created too.

    #816210
    Paul Clerkin
    Keymaster

    CK has been removed from the site for his patently untrue allegations against me and the site and his paranoid rambling and inability to see sense.

    Hate doing this but he’s his own worst enemy – and doing untold damage to his own cause – more so that a dropped poll or a thread disappearing down the google rankings.

    Over the almost 15 years of this website, I have banned only a handfull of people – usually for repeated libel/slander, and do so for the health of the site.

    Inline with standard procedure on forums, I shall not be removing his posts to preserve the integrity of the previous discussion.

    Once again this site is free of any interference from any architectural organisations be those professional like the RIAI, or historical and conservation minded. I do not edit or remove posts without saying I have and for the usual reasons of libel or copyright infringement (sometimes I am asked to remove photos). I do not have an agenda other than getting the public to interact more with the built environment and to encourage discussion.

    I receive no payment for doing this – other than what the site generates (not a lot). Indeed it is fair to say that the site has cost me a lot over the years, as it is a massive time commitment and stops me from doing nixers/projects for personal clients.

    Hopefully ck-gate is now at an end.

    #816212
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Happy New Year Paul

    It looks like you have made a good start by getting rid of CK!

    I look forward to following the forums without his paranoia.

    #816211
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @vca wrote:

    Happy New Year Paul

    It looks like you have made a good start by getting rid of CK!

    I look forward to following the forums without his paranoia.

    Alright . .Enough’s enough, Talk about kicking a man when he’s down.
    While Paul had every right to banish CK, he may be banned from taking part in the forums but he can still read them.
    Give em a break.

    #816209
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    CK, I know you are reading this, so please take this in.

    You were previously informed that the relocation of the forum to different software / temporary addresses was what knocked Archiseek off the bookmark you had.
    Problems can occur even when websites are running normally, but a changeover is not classed as normal running in any web-master’s book.
    Even this week there was a connectivity problem which Paul addressed in order to allow us to participate over the holiday period.
    Paul is diligent and incredibly restrained as a web-master in comparison to most discussion forums I have participated in.

    As for your comments about Archiseek being influenced by the RIAI – this is patent nonsense.
    The posters here seem to include several MRIAI’s, some Alliance Members and Graduates.
    There are also many non-architects like PVC King who also contribute to the debate.
    The RIAI /John Graby have issued comments in RL, but so far not online AFAIK.

    I think you owe Paul an apology for making unfounded comments here.
    And another for posting his private correspondence to Archiseek.

    ONQ.

    #816216
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    <>

    Zut alors!

    Ze forum eet is a traverstie of its former gloree.

    Ze clones have all gone on skiing trips and we now see zat zere are only 30 regulaires.

    Sacre bleu!

    <>

    Or is it with his departure all the RIAI monitors have been told to stand down and had their overtime payments stopped?

    Damn! This paranoia is catching!

    ONQ.

    #816217
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    I am really starting to miss my daily dose of CK. He was beginning to cheer me up in an otherwise pretty cheerless world!

    #816218
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Shall we start a campaign to get him back on . .I’m sure he would of calmed down by now.

    #816219
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    The call on this one is Paul’s IMO – its his website and his reputation that seems to have been impugned, as well as the RIAI’s.
    CK can get quite “thick” when he’s arguing his corner and he was advised several times by me to back off and apologise.
    It seems that he chose not to do so as evidenced by the lack of any apology printed here, so he’s made his bed.

    There is also the question of whether he has anything meaningful left to contribute to the ongoing debate.
    CK has been around the houses on the substantive argument here many times with many people.
    I’m not sure what usefulness his contributions would bring especially if he’s defaming people.

    However one was never quite sure where he was going to fire a letter off to next.
    I am going to miss that passionate unpredictability of his around this forum.
    Apelles, that’s one spooky looking avatar πŸ™‚

    ONQ.

    #816220
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @onq wrote:

    Apelles, that’s one spooky looking avatar πŸ™‚

    ONQ.

    Ditto ONQ . .ditto.

    #816221
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @onq wrote:

    And while I’m on Paul, what’s gone on with the metrics of this thread.

    Replies: 1191

    Views: 354

    How can there be four times fewer views than replies?

    ONQ.

    Thats cause some people never shut up LOL

    #816222
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:

    @onq wrote:

    @apelles wrote:

    That must be the amount of views since the changeover, it obviously wasn’t updated properly.

    That was my thought too, but then I noticed most other threads seemed to have updated okay.
    A mystery – or CK’s paranoia is having an effect!
    Agggghhk!
    πŸ˜‰
    ONQ.

    Are you really that naive onq? Paul obviously receives donations from RIAI members…
    By the way Paul, I would like to be removed from the members’ list of these biased forums… How can I manage that?
    It seems that you are able to remove any information that you like from the threads… I do not feel comfortable to be part of such a scam. Then please remove all my data or I will lodge a complaint to a relevant authority.
    You cannot manipulate a discussion in a way that change the outcome. This is outrageous, especially if members cannot opt out.
    I will contact you privately on this subject…
    HAPPY NEW YEAR…

    Wow CK making friends again I see.

    #816223
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:

    @Paul Clerkin wrote:

    You, Sir, are a nut.
    I do not interfere with threads or take donations to change them.
    If the number do not co-incide that is merely an unfortunate site effect of the import of the old boards into the new boards or more probably the merging of the many many threads that you start on the same subject when you become bogged down arguing in circles. If the poll is gone, it is because of the forums merge.
    Alternatively crack units of the MRIAI Ninja Taskforce may actually be hacking into your computer from their mountain lair in Wicklow

    Paul you are taking us for for a ride here… I am not that ignorant regarding database…
    Maybe you are trying to do too much by running the main site and a discussion forum in the same time. If you decided to remove this thread all together, it would be understandable, but you cannot only remove parts of it. Or if you decide to do so then I ask you to remove the data that I created too.

    Wow CK I know I told you and Onq to spice it up a bit as you were dropping down the rankings but this is much better than I anticipated. It’s great who said handbags at dawn we are way past handbags now.

    #816224
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @Paul Clerkin wrote:

    CK has been removed from the site for his patently untrue allegations against me and the site and his paranoid rambling and inability to see sense.
    Hate doing this but he’s his own worst enemy – and doing untold damage to his own cause – more so that a dropped poll or a thread disappearing down the google rankings.
    Over the almost 15 years of this website, I have banned only a handfull of people – usually for repeated libel/slander, and do so for the health of the site.
    Inline with standard procedure on forums, I shall not be removing his posts to preserve the integrity of the previous discussion.
    Once again this site is free of any interference from any architectural organisations be those professional like the RIAI, or historical and conservation minded. I do not edit or remove posts without saying I have and for the usual reasons of libel or copyright infringement (sometimes I am asked to remove photos). I do not have an agenda other than getting the public to interact more with the built environment and to encourage discussion.
    I receive no payment for doing this – other than what the site generates (not a lot). Indeed it is fair to say that the site has cost me a lot over the years, as it is a massive time commitment and stops me from doing nixers/projects for personal clients.
    Hopefully ck-gate is now at an end.

    Just when it was getting interesting again. Ck is a bit of a loose cannon and if you ever met him actually a nice person and quite interesting to talk to but he does seem to loose the plot every now and again. I know from experience.

    #816225
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @apelles wrote:

    @onq wrote:

    Apelles, that’s one spooky looking avatar πŸ™‚

    ONQ.

    Ditto ONQ . .ditto.

    I suppose we can expect Paul Clerkin’s avatar looking like Gandalf the Grey sometime soon…

    ONQ.

    #816226
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @Solo wrote:

    @Paul Clerkin wrote:

    Just when it was getting interesting again. Ck is a bit of a loose cannon and if you ever met him actually a nice person and quite interesting to talk to but he does seem to loose the plot every now and again. I know from experience.

    I think you mis-spelt “Scud missile”.

    Plus you and I have met CK in other circumstances, and in neither case was he blowing his top.

    (although rumour has it he had to be held back during the presentation to the JOC, but then, didn’t we all to some degree… LOL!)

    ONQ.

Viewing 20 posts - 1,201 through 1,220 (of 1,243 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.