The sensitive issue of the title "Architect" and the Buildin

Home › Forums › Ireland › The sensitive issue of the title "Architect" and the Buildin

Viewing 20 posts - 1,161 through 1,180 (of 1,243 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #816167
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    I have just learned that Lecorbusier was a self-trained architect qualified in arts and decoration. This is probably one of the best kept secret in the history of French education.

    If Lecorbusier was born today, he would probably be discouraged to practice in Ireland and prevented to practice in France, his country of glory.

    Such a waste….

    #816168
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:

    If Lecorbusier was born today, he would probably be discouraged to practice in Ireland and prevented to practice in France, his country of glory.

    But he wasn’t born today, so get over it

    #816169
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @parka wrote:

    @CK wrote:

    If Lecorbusier was born today, he would probably be discouraged to practice in Ireland and prevented to practice in France, his country of glory.

    But he wasn’t born today, so get over it

    Some like him are still alive today: Tadao Ando for example. Some others will be born or arrive on the scene tomorrow…

    The act of preventing self-taught architects to practice does not suit the interests of Architecture. It only suits the interests of those, without as much talent and skills, who are authorized to use the title…

    I cannot get over it… How can someone love architecture and ignore such a discrimination ?

    #816170
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:

    The act of preventing self-taught architects to practice does not suit the interests of Architecture. It only suits the interests of those, without as much talent and skills, who are authorized to use the title…

    Honestly, this is just getting silly! A sentence involving the words clutching and straws comes to mind!

    #816171
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    That Le Corbusier was a gentleman architect is no secret. As was Frank Lloyd Wright, Marcel Breuer, Jean Prouve. The only ‘waste’ is the time you’ve wasted bringing this to our attention. Read a book.

    #816172
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    From “Ove Arup – Master Builder of the Twentieth Century”

    Ref: Chapter 7 – notes to pages 141-151

    Note 6.

    “6. OA, Diary, 15 Nov and 19 Dec 1950.There is a dispute over whether Fry invited le Corbusier to be Partners in the project or whether the invitation was the other way around.Le Corbusier, Perret and Freysinnet were the only ‘unqualified’ architects permitted to practise in France by the Vichy Government during the Nazi occupation: thus affiliation upset other CIAM Members.”

    CIAM = Congrès internationaux d’architecture moderne

    #816173
    Paul Clerkin
    Keymaster

    Hmmmm maybe CK needs to collaborate with the current Irish regieme 😉

    #816174
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    I read “Vers un architecture” in French about 16 years ago… I still go through it sometimes.

    To insinuate that Le Corbusier had any spiritual links with the Nazi ideology is silly…

    Have you compared Nazi architecture to Le Corbusier’ s design? Have you compared Nazi’’ s art to Le Corbusier’ Art work?

    I guess that you guys are just making provocations to start a conversation here…

    Le Corbusier had the choice to immigrate to the US like others, or to stay and obey the occupier’s rules. I think that his creativity was in itself a form of resistance to the invader’s ideology. I am just surprised that he was permitted to practice has his work was in total disagreement with the Hitler’ Neoclassic style. I am not an expert in French history, but I guess that the Vichy government had to compromise for the sake of peace and that the Germans did not really mind about Le Corbusier as he was not Jewish or communist and not working in Germany.

    #816175
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @onq wrote:

    From “Ove Arup – Master Builder of the Twentieth Century”

    Ref: Chapter 7 – notes to pages 141-151

    Note 6.

    “6. OA, Diary, 15 Nov and 19 Dec 1950.There is a dispute over whether Fry invited le Corbusier to be Partners in the project or whether the invitation was the other way around.Le Corbusier, Perret and Freysinnet were the only ‘unqualified’ architects permitted to practise in France by the Vichy Government during the Nazi occupation: thus affiliation upset other CIAM Members.”

    CIAM = Congrès internationaux d’architecture moderne

    To my understanding Freysinnet never worked as an architect. He was working as a structural engineer. I was not aware that there was a restriction for the practice of architecture under the Vichy government… To my knowledge the first restrictions arrived in France much later, in 1977.

    #816176
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Just chipping in with another stark revelation :-

    Walter Gropius could not draw.

    #816177
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    oh god here we go again…..

    The reason why there are so many (yes many) architects of Corbusier’s generation were “unqualified” was because of the lack of schools of architecture. Working as an architect was a completely different thing a century ago, yes that long….. 100 years. Most apprenticed in offices before being elected (invited to join because you did not apply) to institutes (of gentlemen architects) [note to self Groucho Mark’s famous quote….], not too many women around either it appears. Qualification, training, experience are all an often murky past. Ando’s past is of particular interest since it appears to have been kept well hidden, that would be a terrific subject for an investigative biographer. Many supposed untrained unqualified architects are not what they seem often hiding their training or apprenticeship preferring the myth or illusion of the artist being born rather than being taught. This is the biggest fallacy around. Many have alternative artistic training and experience in associated or parallel areas. Practice, Practice, Practice, is the key…… there are no absolutes… leave Corbusier where he lies (in the past). By the way many gentlemen architects could through their means (money) employ talent to execute their ideas taking in turn all the credit, so no different than today. There are only a few architects about whom it can be proven execute their work from the inception (sketch) through details to execution, Aalto, Fehn, Utzon, Murcutt to name a few.

    #816178
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    This train of thought is so utterly ridiculous it drives me, once again up the wall.

    CK:

    This is not 1908.

    Do you think that, if regulation had been in place in 1908, that people like Josef Hoffman or Otto Wagner would be encouraging Corb to sit about and wait for his grandfather?

    I hate to break it to you but all the “self-taught” architects that you constantly refer to have something which you – and 99.9% of the rest of us – do not have. REAL TALENT. You are not a talented architect CK, no matter what you think. I am not talented either. I am competent, however. But that’s my opinion. I expect you think you are competent. Again; your opinion. What to do – Oh I know – take a competency test.

    That said let’s humour you (or me, really) for a while. Hmmm let’s see – If Le Corbusier was alive today…..

    He’d give out to you for spelling his (self assumed) “name” wrong for a start

    But most of all I suspect he’d tell you to go away, do your exams and stop trying to pretend to be something that you clearly are not. You’ve tried this one before CK and it’s laughable. It’s the same as someone saying – I did first year medicine so I’m obviously the same as Magdi Yacoub.

    As the man himself said:

    I prefer drawing to talking. Drawing is faster, and leaves less room for lies.

    #816179
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @wearnicehats wrote:

    Hmmm let’s see – If Le Corbusier was alive today…..

    He’d never get granted a D.A.C. for his ramp design :p

    #816180
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @wearnicehats wrote:

    This train of thought is so utterly ridiculous it drives me, once again up the wall.

    CK:

    This is not 1908.

    Do you think that, if regulation had been in place in 1908, that people like Josef Hoffman or Otto Wagner would be encouraging Corb to sit about and wait for his grandfather?

    I hate to break it to you but all the “self-taught” architects that you constantly refer to have something which you – and 99.9% of the rest of us – do not have. REAL TALENT. You are not a talented architect CK, no matter what you think. I am not talented either. I am competent, however. But that’s my opinion. I expect you think you are competent. Again; your opinion. What to do – Oh I know – take a competency test.

    That said let’s humour you (or me, really) for a while. Hmmm let’s see – If Le Corbusier was alive today…..

    He’d give out to you for spelling his (self assumed) “name” wrong for a start

    But most of all I suspect he’d tell you to go away, do your exams and stop trying to pretend to be something that you clearly are not. You’ve tried this one before CK and it’s laughable. It’s the same as someone saying – I did first year medicine so I’m obviously the same as Magdi Yacoub.

    As the man himself said:

    I prefer drawing to talking. Drawing is faster, and leaves less room for lies.

    Well Wearnicehats,

    I have practiced architecture for the last 17 years and I started to study arts & architecture about 23 years ago… If you pretend that I am not architect… Then what am I?

    There are many self-taught architects who made it to the hall of fame… Many of them do not have the influence that Le Corbusier had, but they are still much more influential than most of the so-called qualified architects…

    I am not a super-star and none of us is… But I never pretended to be one… I am just looking to continue practicing without being bothered, without having any problem to define myself in front of my clients, without having to call a MRIAI to certify my work, without the RIAI to misrepresent my skills in front of potential clients.

    One of my point is that qualification does not guaranty quality and self-education does not mean incompetence. Those guys are proving my point: Le Corbusier, Gustave Eiffel, Mies, FLW, Prouvé, Gray or Scott and much more recently Ianis Xenakis (who died 6 or 8 years ago), Nail Cakirhan, Will Bruder, David Salmela, Harry Gesner, Wendell Burnette and many others…

    If you prefer me to take the example of unknown self-taught architects to prove that many self-trained architects are skilled, I can provide pages of names…

    This is not 1908… But open your eyes… Most of us are self-taught using computers. I learned by myself how to create a website, how to use photoshop and most of the softwares that I am using today….

    Even If I had studied at DIT, I would not have learned about part M of the Building Regulations because when I left university in 1995, there was no building regulations in the Republic of Ireland. I would not have learned about government forms of contracts for public work because they did not exist. I would not have been taught to use Revit for the same reason… And so on…

    We are all self-taught Wearnicehats. The problem is that some who spent time in university want to have privilege on the others… It is common sense that if academic studies are necessary to gain knowledge, apprenticeship and professional experience are much more appropriate… Any one who pretends the contrary must be a scholar or a degree holder misleading an audience to protect his own interests… Don’t forget that I studied too. You may create some doubts in the mind of a fully self-trained architect on this subject, but not in mine.

    #816181
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Will someone tell Paul that there is a mismatch between threads up here…

    #816182
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    As far as I’m concerned, there should be no non-architects proving architectural services direct to the public.
    Surveyors, engineers and draughtspeople should be barred based on their lack of design competence and training.
    Part I or Part II architects providing services through these non-design based offices should also be structly controlled.
    You only have to look some of the results in the Irish countryside today to see what people with neither design ability nor training have produced.

    I agree onq… But the term “Architect” should not define a title as it is per the current legislation. It shall define a profession. The access to the profession shall be opened to self-taught after a certain number of years in practice.

    For the record:
    Architectural technicians are a grey area, because their course introduce them to design of small buildings in third year.

    What about architectural technologists?

    I think only people who are trained or have shown they are competent to design should be allowed design and all such should be registered.
    I think only such persons as have been assessed as being capable and competent should be providing services direct to the public.

    Someone who has practiced for ten years or more is competent. You say that market assessment is not enough, but in the contrary it is much more valuable than any academic assessments. Someone who has practiced during 10 years proved that he has the skills to do so, as well as the skills to adapt to a fast changing working environment. Academic training is only a simulation… It does not reflect the real world…

    #816183
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    copy of previous post deleted

    #816184
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:

    Will someone tell Paul that there is a mismatch between threads up here…

    It looks like Paul merged the threads – not a problem really unless you’re into thread multiplication for multiplications sake.

    ONQ.

    #816185
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:

    What about architectural technologists?

    I remember your original post regarding technicians on the boards, but now you want to join the CIAT, make your mind up, do you want to be an Architect or a Technician, trust me it’s not really hard decision.

    http://boards.ie/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=2055500559

    @CK wrote:

    Don’t forget that I studied too. You may create some doubts in the mind of a fully self-trained architect on this subject, but not in mine.

    Revit, Part M, forms of contract etc., yes we can all learn them, but it means nothing if you don’t hold the appropriate qualifications

    #816186
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:

    What about architectural technologists?

    Allow me to direct you to the answer I gave on boards.ie, an answer Mellor agreed with.

    http://boards.ie/vbulletin/showpost.php?p=67993725&postcount=52

    ====================================================

    Quote:
    Originally Posted by Dafydd Thomas View Post
    I just started architecture today in DIT and many of the architectural technologists I met were devastated (to say the least) that they didn’t get architecture. I think if people fully understood the work of an architectural technologist there would be equal respect assigned to the profession as to architecture. Although I’d imagine the workload and pay wouldn’t. I can’t say I understand what they do, other than that it’s a more “computer-based” profession.

    As its a qualification deriving from a Technician background I imagine [rank speculation follows] that they are highly competent technically and have also competences in both how to run an office and how to administer a building contract.

    I think an architect may be held in court to have greater liability than an architectural technologist [but I may be wrong on this].

    In Ireland, the title Architectural Technologist is recognised by not protected by the Building Control Act 2007, whereas the title Architect is protected by said Act.

    I think the architect will have a broader based approach to, and appreciation of, design – which is not limited to buildings but may include landscape, furniture and urban design.
    The architect may have a more free-ranging process in which to arrive at a final design.
    That’s what you would expect from someone who successfully completed a full time five year design course with 4-6 major design projects per year and four design critiques per project – 16-24 in all per annum, excluding the Final Year Thesis.

    — De.Lite.Touch

    ============================

    And yes, before you ask the obvious question *I* was posting as De.Lite.Touch…

    I think only people who are trained or have shown they are competent to design should be allowed design and all such should be registered.
    I think only such persons as have been assessed as being capable and competent should be providing services direct to the public.

    Someone who has practiced for ten years or more is competent. You say that market assessment is not enough, but in the contrary it is much more valuable than any academic assessments. Someone who has practiced during 10 years proved that he has the skills to do so, as well as the skills to adapt to a fast changing working environment. Academic training is only a simulation… It does not reflect the real world…

    I think that solely relying on their duration in practice as evidence of competence is a convenient argument by people who want to advance the theory of market “accreditation”.

    I discredited this nonsense from Montaut a good while ago by a simple reference to prostitution.
    If the market is going to be taken as evidence of academic excellence then all prostitutes should be awarded Professorships.

    It seems blatantly obvious that the work produced during this ten year period must be assessed – and that it must be assessed qualitatively, not just quantitatively – in order for competence to be shown both in terms of design as well as professional practice.

    ONQ.

Viewing 20 posts - 1,161 through 1,180 (of 1,243 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.