The sensitive issue of the title "Architect" and the Buildin

Home › Forums › Ireland › The sensitive issue of the title "Architect" and the Buildin

Viewing 20 posts - 841 through 860 (of 1,243 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #815847
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @wearnicehats wrote:

    I’m amazed that you two find time to do any work.

    Is that the best you can offer to this thread?

    The rest of us are talking about matters of some import.

    The formal regulation of one of the most onerous professions in Europe.

    The continuance of livelihood for competent persons engaged in providing archtiectural services.

    That sort of thing – it demands the attention of people with the integrity to ensure that the debate traverses all reasonable arguments.

    ONQ.

    #815848
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:

    It is a 13,500 Euro problem to me.

    Welcome to CK Outlaw Architects

    La plus ça change…

    Can one be a chancer with 8 years learning and 16 nearly 17 years practice?

    Of course.
    Especially if you fail to disclose – assuming it is true – that in your earliest years you were not practising as an architect but as a draughtsman or technician.

    (waffle snipped)

    It is not my support to the bill that will have an effect on my skills… You are loosing your marks… Stay focus if you want to defend this bill honorably… And stop asking people 100% support… 95% is not that bad…

    Its not enough.

    Post a clear and unambiguous post here CK.

    “I support the Building Control (Amendment) Bill 2010 proposed by John O’Donoghue.”

    Otherwise, everyone will will be free to draw the inference that you are a Chancer.

    ONQ.

    #815849
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @onq wrote:

    La plus ça change…

    I am not a quitter onq… I will help to make things change…

    @onq wrote:

    Of course.
    Especially if you fail to disclose – assuming it is true – that in your earliest years you were not practising as an architect but as a draughtsman or technician…

    I was working in the UK onq… I have worked as a design architect (as per payslips), also a CAD Architect, and as a technician, but I have not seen the difference between the positions.

    @onq wrote:

    Its not enough.

    Post a clear and unambiguous post here CK.

    “I support the Building Control (Amendment) Bill 2010 proposed by John O’Donoghue.”

    Otherwise, everyone will will be free to draw the inference that you are a Chancer.

    ONQ.

    Do you think that you are doing some good this way? What I know about this bill is superficial and incomplete. It is going on the right direction but it lacks consistency.

    Where can we read the latest version?

    #815850
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @onq wrote:

    Is that the best you can offer to this thread?

    The rest of us are talking about matters of some import.

    The formal regulation of one of the most onerous professions in Europe.

    The continuance of livelihood for competent persons engaged in providing archtiectural services.

    That sort of thing – it demands the attention of people with the integrity to ensure that the debate traverses all reasonable arguments.

    ONQ.

    oh I’m sorry – I thought you were just bickering in a going round and round and round in circles sort of way. My mistake – carry on

    #815851
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @wearnicehats wrote:

    oh I’m sorry – I thought you were just bickering in a going round and round and round in circles sort of way. My mistake – carry on

    No. no – that’s the other thread.

    This here’s for SERIOUS discussion only.

    ONQ.

    #815852
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    So Onq?

    You have bothered me during hours asking for my unequivocal support of the bill and you are not even able to tell me where I can read the latest revision…

    What is wrong with you?

    #815853
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:

    I am not a quitter onq… I will help to make things change…

    There’s hope yet.

    I was working in the UK onq… I have worked as a design architect (as per payslips), also a CAD Architect, and as a technician, but I have not seen the difference between the positions.

    Yes, yes, most of us have worked in the UK at some point or other.
    I’ve designed small sections of road in Saudi, and drawn huge amounts of road – as a draughtsmen.
    I was working for the seventh largest engineering form in the world at that time, but that doesn’t make me a civil engineer CK.
    It made the recent AutoCAD 3D Civil course I took much easier ot understand for me than for others, but I cannot claim to be an engineering technician.

    If you have spent most of your time as a desk jockey drawing pretty pictures that could lead somone to suspect that you have almost no site experience either in terms of inspection or adminstering the contract.
    Have you done any conveyancing or court work, expert witness work, arbitration hearings, remedial work, certification of monies, achieved any difficult or large permissions where you were the senior architect and/or which had a demanding urban or conservation brief?
    This isn’t me being clever CK – this is the sort of thing an Architect can be asked to do – more importantly, that a member of the public might expect him to be competent at doing..

    Do you think that you are doing some good this way?

    I think I’m putting it up to you so that you’ll state your unequivocal support the Building Control ( Amendment) Bill 2010, or else withdraw your claim of being a competent architect.

    What I know about this bill is superficial and incomplete. It is going on the right direction but it lacks consistency.

    Where can we read the latest version?

    Are you implying you haven’t read the Bill yet?
    The BCA Bill 2010, the single most important document affecting your life after the BCA 2007?
    Are you telling me that the real reason you won’t commit to supporting it is because YOU DON’T KNOW WHAT’S IN IT???!!!

    (shakes head)

    Well, that’sone admission I wasn’t expecting.
    But really, looking at the kind of brazen waffling you go on with, I should have suspected.

    Here:

    http://www.oireachtas.ie/documents/bills28/bills/2010/4110/B4110D.pdf

    And after you read it I expect to see the posting I requested several times now.

    ONQ.

    #815854
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @onq wrote:

    Are you implying you haven’t read the Bill yet?
    The Bill, the single most important document affecting your life after the BCA 2007?
    Are you telling me that the real reason you won’t commit to supporting it is because YOU DON’T KNOW WHAT’S IN IT???!!!

    Here:

    http://www.oireachtas.ie/documents/bills28/bills/2010/4110/B4110D.pdf

    And after you read it I expect to see the posting I requested several times now.

    ONQ.

    It is a bit short isn’t it?

    #815855
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:

    So Onq?

    You have bothered me during hours asking for my unequivocal support of the bill and you are not even able to tell me where I can read the latest revision…

    What is wrong with you?

    You’re a lazy git CK.

    I should have left you stew, but even you deserve your chance.

    ONQ.

    #815856
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:

    It is a bit short isn’t it?

    Size isn’t everything.
    I’d expect a Frenchman to know that.
    Besides, this is the Bill that has the Registrar so upset.
    It must be fairly powerful stuff to discomfort the normally placid John Graby.

    ONQ.

    PS Try clicking on the link.

    #815857
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @NevilleNeville wrote:

    One of the first things I intend to do should I be fortunate enough to become Registered is sit the Part III Exam as a means of upskilling and proving it, as opposed to trading on the MRIAI suffix.
    Badge engineering is no substitute for knowledge.

    ONQ.

    Interesting thought ONQ considering that the majority of those architects currently on the register had to prepare for and sit the exam and be assessed prior to achieving their MRIAI status where should this amendment go through you will have the luxury of doing the Part III course as an upskilling exercise where the results will have no consequence to your registration should you be granted it through this route.[/QUOTE]

    this has been raised previously – refer to my post #804 – and the loophole will hopefully be shut as part of any long term amendment ie that those who could very easily register but have chosen not to will be excluded from any so-called Grandfather Clause. Just because you can’t be bothered to look for your glasses doesn’t mean you’re blind

    #815858
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @wearnicehats wrote:

    Interesting thought ONQ considering that the majority of those architects currently on the register had to prepare for and sit the exam and be assessed prior to achieving their MRIAI status where should this amendment go through you will have the luxury of doing the Part III course as an upskilling exercise where the results will have no consequence to your registration should you be granted it through this route.

    this has been raised previously – refer to my post #804 – and the loophole will hopefully be shut as part of any long term amendment ie that those who could very easily register but have chosen not to will be excluded from any so-called Grandfather Clause. Just because you can’t be bothered to look for your glasses doesn’t mean you’re blind

    Another genius who cannot post attributes correctly – and again, I have cleared it up by posting the previous poster in bold text.

    Reply Originally posted in Post # 839 to this thread; –

    https://archiseek.com/content/showpost.php?p=110228&postcount=839

    I am unlikely to take the route offered by the Bill, which caters for persons without a formal qualification who have provided services commensurate with those of an architect for seven years or more in Ireland.
    I am formally qualified and hold a prescribed qualification and I have in excess of twenty years post-graduate experience as an architect.
    I intend to apply via the Option C route which requires a significant submission of information and a self-assessment matrix.
    This submission covers information you might be asked a part of the Part III assessment exam.

    I posted this response in bold text so your cannot miss it this time.

    You don’t seem to see that taking this exam is the only way to prove current competence.

    Its not an easy exam to pass by all accounts, so your description of it as a “loophole” seems to be utterly clueless.

    ONQ.

    #815859
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @onq wrote:

    Size isn’t everything.
    I’d expect a Frenchman to know that.
    Besides, this is the Bill that has the Registrar so upset.
    It must be fairly powerful stuff to discomfort the normally placid John Graby.

    ONQ.

    PS Try clicking on the link.

    What happens to Section 22? why wasn’t it ammended?

    Section 22 starts as such:

    “22.—(1) The following person may apply to the Technical
    Assessment Board for a decision that he or she is eligible to be
    registered in the register pursuant to this section, namely, a person
    who has been performing duties commensurate with those of an
    architect for a period of 10 or more years in the State (but no period
    of such performance that occurs on or after the commencement of
    this section shall be reckoned for the purposes of this subsection).”

    It should be amended too… as such:

    “22.—(1) The following person may apply to the Technical
    Assessment Board for a decision that he or she is eligible to be
    registered in the register pursuant to this section, namely, a person
    who do not fall within any of paragraphs (a) to (g) and (i) and (j) of section 14(2)”

    It sounds like if the guy who wrote it did not believe much in its chance to succeed…

    #815860
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @onq wrote:

    this has been raised previously – refer to my post #804 – and the loophole will hopefully be shut as part of any long term amendment ie that those who could very easily register but have chosen not to will be excluded from any so-called Grandfather Clause. Just because you can’t be bothered to look for your glasses doesn’t mean you’re blind

    I am unlikely to take the route offered by the Bill, which caters for persons without a formal qualification who have provided services commensurate with those of an architect for seven years or more in Ireland.
    I am formally qualified and hold a prescribed qualification and I have in excess of twenty years post-graduate experience as an architect.
    I intend to apply via the Option C route which requires a significant submission of information and a self-assessment matrix.
    This submission covers information you might be asked a part of the Part III assessment exam.

    I posted it in bold text so your wouldn’t miss it this time.

    Originally posted in Post #

    ONQ.[/QUOTE]

    I didn’t miss it the first time. Don’t recall referring to you personally in either post (I don’t do ad hominem remember), just those who will chance their arm.

    #815861
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:

    What happens to Section 22? why wasn’t it ammended?

    Section 22 starts as such:

    “22.—(1) The following person may apply to the Technical
    Assessment Board for a decision that he or she is eligible to be
    registered in the register pursuant to this section, namely, a person
    who has been performing duties commensurate with those of an
    architect for a period of 10 or more years in the State (but no period
    of such performance that occurs on or after the commencement of
    this section shall be reckoned for the purposes of this subsection).”

    It should be amended too… as such:

    “22.—(1) The following person may apply to the Technical
    Assessment Board for a decision that he or she is eligible to be
    registered in the register pursuant to this section, namely, a person
    who do not fall within any of paragraphs (a) to (g) and (i) and (j) of section 14(2)”

    Well done CK.
    As far as I am aware, you are the first person to point that out.
    There are probably more follow-on matters to be clarified or amended in the text.
    All such i-dotting and t-crossing exercises are best left to the Parliamentary Draughtspersons.
    The important thing is that this omission is not material – it does not negate the conferral of rights in the proposed Secion (j).

    Now be a good lad and post the requested comment

    ONQ.

    #815862
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @onq wrote:

    Well done CK.
    As far as I am aware, you are the first person to point that out.
    There are probably more follow-on matters to be clarified or amended in the text.
    All such i-dotting and t-crossing exercises are best left to the Parliamentary Draughtspersons.
    The important thing is that this omission is not material – it does not negate the conferral of rights in the proposed Secion (j).

    Now be a good lad and post the requested comment

    ONQ.

    Now do you really believe in this bill having a chance?

    #815863
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @wearnicehats wrote:

    I didn’t miss it the first time. Don’t recall referring to you personally in either post (I don’t do ad hominem remember), just those who will chance their arm.

    It contained a reference to me and you still don’t see this exam, taken regularly by all MRIAI’s as the only logical means of proving that the Members are competent to current standard.
    People don’t sit Professional Practice Exams in order to “chance their arm”!
    Therefore there should be no bridling of this Exam.

    ONQ.

    #815864
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:

    Now do you really believe in this bill having a chance?

    That’s up to people like you CK.
    Its not my Bill, its John O’Donoghue’s Bill.

    But re the follow-on wordings, it doesn’t seem to cause a particular problem.
    Most inconsistencies will be caught and addressed by the parliamentary draughtspersons.

    And, let’s fact it, this is a minor inconsistency – even if it was missed it would act to prevent you from requesting to sit the ARAE. :rolleyes:
    There seems to be no reason for you to be requesting to sit an exam costing €13,500 which by your own admission you will refuse to take, especially if you have an opportunity to register by another means – so what’s your point?

    Post a clear and unambiguous post here CK.
    “I support the Building Control (Amendment) Bill 2010 proposed by John O’Donoghue.”
    Otherwise, everyone will will be free to draw the inference that you are a Chancer.

    I’ll check back later on to see if you’ve shown any more signs of intelligent life.

    ONQ.

    #815865
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @onq wrote:

    And, let’s fact it, this is a minor inconsistency – even if it was missed it would act to prevent you from requesting to sit the ARAE. :rolleyes:
    There seems to be no reason for you to be requesting to sit an exam costing €13,500

    ONQ.

    That is maybe the problem… The RIAI is loosing big money if this bill passes… They have enough influence as to be the main body behind the draft of Part III BCA2007… I don’t think that a declaration from me on this forum would weight much…

    #815866
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:

    That is maybe the problem… The RIAI is loosing big money if this bill passes… They have enough influence as to be the main body behind the draft of Part III BCA2007… I don’t think that a declaration from me on this forum would weight much…

    CK,



    If the Bill goes through the RIAI and the ARAE company are out tens of thousands of Euros in training costs alone, by the Registrar’s admission.
    If the Bill goes through the projected revenue stream from processing Grandfathers dries up.
    Even on Brian montauts reduced figure of circa 200 persons this is

    200 x 13500 = €2,700,000

    That’s Two Point Seven Million Euro!!!



    The other main point,

    the… v-e-r-y… s-i-m-p-l-e… p-o-i-n-t …

    – is that this Bill is the only chance for someone like you to become registered

    – for a reasonable cost

    – and you are reluctant to support it!



    Anyone reading this thread from either John O’Donoghue’s office or No. 8 Merrion Square would be scratching their heads in wonderment.
    You have repeatedly failed to post a very simple unequivocal statement supporting the Bill.
    “Why doesn’t this guy support John O’Donoghue’s Bill?” they’d ask.
    I cannot understand your position.

    Post a clear and unambiguous post here CK.
    “I support the Building Control (Amendment) Bill 2010 proposed by John O’Donoghue.”
    Otherwise, everyone will will be free to draw the inference that you are a Chancer.



    ONQ.

Viewing 20 posts - 841 through 860 (of 1,243 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.