The sensitive issue of the title "Architect" and the Buildin
- This topic has 1,242 replies, 62 voices, and was last updated 12 years, 11 months ago by
Anonymous.
- AuthorPosts
- August 28, 2010 at 11:37 am #815827
Anonymous
Inactive@onq wrote:
You still don’t get it CK.
The references you cited were from third party sites, not the RIAI.
You should know by now to get the most authoritative references, CK.
================================
http://www.riai.ie/about_the_riai
The RIAI is the Regulatory and support body for Architects in Ireland. Support services are also provided for architectural Technicians.Although the RIAI carries out a statutory function as the Registration Body and Competent Authority for Architects in Ireland this is carried out on an entirely self-funding basis. The RIAI does not receive any Government Funding or State Aid for this Statutory Function
Since 1839 the RIAI has been committed to upholding the highest standards in architecture and providing impartial and authorative advice and information in issues affecting architects, the built environment and society.
Our main roles are:
* Promoting architecture
* Supporting architects and architectural technicians
* Regulating architects
* Protecting the consumer================================
See anything there about “representing” architects? No.
And you have to admit that “supporting” could mean anything.
Also note the bit about “regulating” architects – that’s important.
Because you cannot “regulate” and “represent” at the same time.The RIAI is a regulatory body that offers support – it doesn’t represent its members.
Which may come as a big surprise to the usual assortment of golf playing alcoholics here.ONQ.
Ok ONQ,
The RIAI has changed its functions. But, this does not really change my point in post No.: 813
The RIAI represented only professionally qualified architects before it became the architects registration body.
The position of the institute and its members did not change from one day to the other. They did not suddenly abandon their pre-conceived ideas on self-trained architects or those with qualifications not listed in the EU Directive. The RIAI was a club before it became the registration body. It is still a club today.
The RIAI is in charge for protecting the interests of registered architects as per the BCA 2007. However, it would take years before the Technical Assessment can review all potential applicants and this is due to the RIAI laborious procedure for registration. The actual political RIAI lobbying defends registered architects on the ground that the new grand-father clause may devaluate their privilege and damage their interests, this implicates the RIAI to act against the interests of future registered architects who did not have the opportunity yet to register due to the laborious procedure set up by the registration body / regulator which is now lobbying against them.
There was obviously a selection on who shall be on the register first… Of course it was MRIAI first, who else? There was no consideration for established practices who may have to wait 2 years before being able to register, why? Answer: Because it did not concern any members of the RIAI… The discrimination is obvious and I am wondering how the RIAI will defend that in court if the issue is sorted there…
The RIAI is lobbying against the interests of future registered architects who did not have the opportunity to register due to the RIAI incapacity to deal appropriately with the workload within an acceptable time frame, I think that the registration body / registrar lobbying campaign could be in breach of the BCA 2007 and then illegal. However, the RIAI is also a private institute with private members (MRIAI), and I am not sure of the implications on this ground… Who is?
The problem that we are confronting today was very easy to predict. How could an Institute which was representing only qualified architects, be able to act properly when registering self-trained architects? How can an institute which existence was founded on its privileges over self-trained architects suddenly accept these last ones as their equals?
August 28, 2010 at 1:40 pm #815828Anonymous
InactiveCK,
I am not sure you understand the seriousness of the RIAI’s position.
They apparently NEVER represented their members.
They apparently existed SOLELY to promote architecture.
This has huge implications for them in the future in terms of their role.
But I can see that you only want to peddle the same old stuff you like to peddle.
Fine by me – there is a lot in what you say – you’re just missing the bigger picture.
ONQ.
August 28, 2010 at 2:38 pm #815829Anonymous
Inactive@onq wrote:
CK,
I am not sure you understand the seriousness of the RIAI’s position.
They apparently NEVER represented their members.
They apparently existed SOLELY to promote architecture.
This has huge implications for them in the future in terms of their role.
But I can see that you only want to peddle the same old stuff you like to peddle.
Fine by me – there is a lot in what you say – you’re just missing the bigger picture.
ONQ.
I am not peddling, I am analyzing,
I realized that the RIAI is doing some bricolage which appears very unprofessional for a regulator. But my first concern was about the legality and ethic of the RIAI lobbying campaign against the Building Control Amendment Bill 2010.
These emails sent to politicians, CPD lobbying points for MRIAI, it is related to the RIAI previous statute of representing only professionally qualified architects. Now that the RIAI shall represent architects on the register instead, is it legal for the institute to act against the interests of those who have not yet been given a chance to be on the register? Especially when the register is made of 99.9% of the institute’s automatically registered members (MRIAI). Isn’t this lobbying campaign obviously biased towards their members, despite what and who they claim representing?
The fact is that the RIAI is now untouchable… If the politicians do not realize the problem and reject the bill, I am just trying to imagine what the court would make of this lobbying campaign.
If the RIAI pretends now to represent Irish Architecture as well as architectural technicians… The Act never gave this power to the institute, then where do they get it from?… Even if my participation to Irish architecture is limited to small and medium size developments, I consider that I am legitimately producing architecture and the RIAI does not represent me at all… It is clear that they are trying to change and adapt to their new statute, this is a late but welcome move; however they have represented professionally qualified architects for over a century, and this is the reason for the discrimination of self-trained architects today. It will take long before the RIAI attitudes, pre-conceived ideas and state of mind accept the self-trained as equals. It will probably implicate replacing the existing directors with unbiased and more competent individuals… Can the government do that?
August 28, 2010 at 6:12 pm #815830Anonymous
InactiveThe RIAI, it regulates its Members – and not all of them are qualified.
Some of them were on the Minister’s List, but these were subject to an assessment.
The RIAI are currently putting it about that the Building Control Amendment Bill 2010 is a free for all – this is not so.Grandfathers must show; –
“…evidence of establishment comprising
of having had practical experience of providing
services commensurate with those of an architect
in the State for 7 years or more…”.CK, do you support this Bill?
Would you accept the Title “Building Designer” instead?
ONQ.
August 30, 2010 at 10:41 am #815831Anonymous
InactiveYou already know my position on this bill onq,
It is not normal that self-trained architects’ experience gained abroad is totally ignored when professionally qualified architects can gain all their experience abroad if they want to…
We are now living in a global economy where architects are entitled to travel, specially in the EU where a directive exists to facilitate this purpose.
Why is the Building Control Bill not taking that in consideration? What is the problem with established self-trained architects having gained experience in the UK or France, where the quality of architecture and architectural practices has nothing to envy to its Irish equivalents?
I think that requesting all the self-trained architects’ experience to be gained in the State has nationalist and discriminative implications. Why isn’t the same requested to professionally qualified architects?
This bill should have been an opportunity to correct the Act on this matter.
August 30, 2010 at 1:35 pm #815832Anonymous
Inactive@CK wrote:
You already know my position on this bill onq,
You say a lot of things CK.
I want to be very clear on this.
If you are in favour of the Bill, simply post; –
“I support the Building Control (Amendment) Bill 2010 proposed by John O’Donoghue.”Just post that comment above, without any qualification or evasion.
ONQ.
August 30, 2010 at 3:51 pm #815833Anonymous
Inactive@onq wrote:
You say a lot of things CK.
I want to be very clear on this.
If you are in favour of the Bill, simply post; –
“I support the Building Control (Amendment) Bill 2010 proposed by John O’Donoghue.”Just post that comment above, without any qualification or evasion.
ONQ.
I cannot answer this restrictive and biased question. Do you live in a world where everything is black or white onq?
My position is that the amendment bill is positive on the ground that the RIAI looses its power to denigrate registration to hundreds of established practices in Ireland. However, I think that John O’Donoghue has not addressed the issue of those like me who have gained a large part of their experience in other EU countries. Why isn’t this experience considered by the Act? Not considered by the amendment bill?
When registration was implemented in France only 5 years of experience was requested to be listed on the Register. There were no geographical or political restrictions in relation to the requested experience. The same in the Netherlands, self-trained architects may gain all their experience abroad. Why would it be different in Ireland?
I have heard some very protectionist arguments claiming that Ireland would be invaded by Romanians and Polish if the experience can be gained in other E.U. states. These types of declarations are really the fruit of restricted minds unable to understand that the future of Ireland lay in its ability to share skills and knowledge with the rest of the world. I personally think that a flow of immigrants would be welcomed for the Irish economy today, but this is not the point… Those like me who have gained experience abroad probably acquired more skills and knowledge than those who did not, surely they did not acquire less…
August 30, 2010 at 7:00 pm #815834Anonymous
Inactive@CK wrote:
I cannot answer this restrictive and biased question. Do you live in a world where everything is black or white onq?(snip)
CK,
That’s nonsense.
Even for a Frenchman.A comment may be biased.
But a question cannot be biased.You can give two answers, yes / no.
By definition this cannot be restrictive.
You have no recognised qualification here.
Even in France you were not able to practice.You were to come back after gaining experience.
Instead of gaining this in France, you went abroad.
Having disregarded the rules you want to re-write them.
There is no Europe wide license to practise architecture.Even in adjoining countries accreditation is local, one or other.
French Architects are not automatically accredited in Germany.
To rise to the top of a profession you have to persevere and master one thing.
After you have proved yourself at one thing you can diversify, but only afterwards.You have been dipping your toe into the water in several jurisdictions, each for a short time.
That is not how you reach a standard of excellence, that is how you become a jack of all trades.
So, do you support the Building Control (Amendment) Bill 2010 or is the title “Building Designer” acceptable to you?ONQ.
August 31, 2010 at 11:49 am #815835Anonymous
Inactive@onq wrote:
CK,
That’s nonsense.
Even for a Frenchman.A comment may be biased.
But a question cannot be biased.You can give two answers, yes / no.
By definition this cannot be restrictive.Obviously you are not aware of choice architecture…. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Choice_architecture
@onq wrote:
You have no recognised qualification here.
Even in France you were not able to practice.You were to come back after gaining experience.
Instead of gaining this in France, you went abroad.If I was to come back in France, I would need to pass a kind of technical assessment (portfolio and interview) and my 10 years of experience gained abroad would be fully considered (I have only one year of experience in France anyway). I would need to be living in one of the French departments (main residence) and to pay tax in France for being able to register. My studies would be acknowledge by the Admission Board and they would be a positive addition to my European experience.
@onq wrote:
Having disregarded the rules you want to re-write them.
There is no Europe wide license to practise architecture.When I left France one alternative to the 10 years experience was to be involved in the design of buildings built in a minimum of 3 countries outside France (this has strongly motivated my migration). This option is no more possible. It is not me changing the rules….
@onq wrote:
Even in adjoining countries accreditation is local, one or other.
French Architects are not automatically accredited in Germany.The only restriction to relocate within EU States is linguistic. Experienced registered architects with qualifications listed in the EU Directive can relocate without restriction if they can use one of the country’s language. I thought that you would know that by now…
@onq wrote:
To rise to the top of a profession you have to persevere and master one thing.
After you have proved yourself at one thing you can diversify, but only afterwards.You have been dipping your toe into the water in several jurisdictions, each for a short time.
That is not how you reach a standard of excellence, that is how you become a jack of all trades.This is a lot of non-sense… Irish architects should design only building from Ireland then… In France where we have different climates, architects should work only in their respective areas… You are talking of a new world order where architects cannot travel, Irish buildings design by Irish residents only…
I have been practicing in the UK where I learn about the English Building regulations before they appeared in Ireland. I worked in France where we are using construction techniques to much higher standards. In France 2-storey houses all have concrete floors; only very cheap houses have timber floor joists. French have developed reflective insulation in the building sector using the NASA technology. In Germany there is the passive haus standard which is spreading all over Europe.
It is not by closing on itself that Ireland will get out of trouble… What I learned in the UK and in France you will never learn in Ireland. What I learned in Ireland I would never have learned in France or the UK. Your nationalist theory is retrograde ONQ… I thought that you would be more open minded… I would recommend that you try your skills abroad; you will discover that there is something else out there, something not better, not worse… Something that will widen your skills, your knowledge, your mind… I have worked from Bristol, on a University project in Canada with a leading architect from New York, you will not find that on my website because it is not representative of my practice in Dublin… But these types of experience are rich of learning…
I do not say that one cannot learn staying within his country of origin… I say that those who did choose to discover wider horizons should not be discriminated… We have a chapter of the EU Treaty for this purpose. I which that there was an international treaty in the same direction…
August 31, 2010 at 12:56 pm #815836Anonymous
InactiveCK,
Accreditaion in Germany does not entitle you to practise in France Automatically – you must be ratified – and vice versa.
Otherwise we would have a Europe-wide Register of architects, the very thing we do not have at the moment, even for Graduates with prescribed qualifcations like mine.
You OTOH have picked up a bit here, and a bit there and my point is that you have to master the profession to the required standard in one jurisdiction, not globe-hop accreting bits of it.
The basic point was that if you haven’t achieved a recognised qualification or gained experience in the way a statutory assessor of that experience requires it, then you must seek to change the terms of reference – i.e. the Law.Unless you want to see the Bill and its main proposer disappear off the radar, you and people like you should be repeating this simple mantra at every opportunity:
“I support the Building Control (Amendment) Bill 2010 proposed by John O’Donoghue.”Because if you don’t show appreciation to people who are trying to help you, you will lose their support.
In short, if you act like a cochon don’t be surprised if you get gutted like one.
And no, I’m not just referring to you when I say that.The posted called VCA has already denigrated this Bill suggesting that it allows anyone to become Registered as an architect.
The defence against this allegation is the requirement to show evidence of establishment comprising of providing servies commensurate with those of an architect in the state for 7 years or more.
If you cannot produce evidence that shows you have acted competently for 7 years – in Ireland – as an architect – then you have no business seeking to become registered here and you may try your luck in another EU country.Up until now no other country has had so open a policy as Ireland.
This leaves a credibility gap for some people who were practising as architects.
The Registrar is making every effort to ensure that Registered Architects are competent
While some people think his efforts are too strict, no reasonable person thinks a no-show is acceptable.
You have to show your work and by it provide evidence that you have provided services commensurate with those of an architect.You may have felt that benefitting from such an open policy in the Tiger Years far outweighed the fact that you were not getting accredited in France.
Now, the economic downturn should surely give you pause for thought and more importantly might suggest that your home country might be a better place to seek to continue your practice.If you decide to stay here you can choose to call yourself a Building Designer and continue on your way.
That is, until the provision of architectural services becomes regulated – in the next five years or so.
Failing this you are obliged to become registered to continue to practice as an architect.
The only means for you to do this is (i) the ARAE, which is costly in time and money.
Or there is (ii) the PRAE which isn’t in place yet and you say you don’t want to do it.The fact is that there is nothing preventing you studying for an exam in current knowledge and there is nothing suggesting anyone of working age should be exempt from knowing how to build to current standards.
One of the first things I intend to do should I be fortunate enough to become Registered is sit the Part III Exam as a means of upskilling and proving it, as opposed to trading on the MRIAI suffix.
Badge engineering is no substitute for knowledge.ONQ.
August 31, 2010 at 1:29 pm #815837Anonymous
Inactive@onq wrote:
CK,
Accreditaion in Germany does not entitle you to practise in France Automatically – you must be ratified – and vice versa.
Who said the contrary? This procedure take 3 months in Ireland as per the BCA 2007, but applicants can start practicing on the first day…
@onq wrote:
You OTOH have picked up a bit here, and a bit there and my point is that you have to master the profession to the required standard in one jurisdiction, not globe-hop accreting bits of it.
Are you asking for international business to stop in architecture? Everybody staying in his country and working from there?
@onq wrote:
The basic point was that if you haven’t achieved a recognised qualification or gained experience in the way a statutory assessor of that experience requires it, then you must seek to change the terms of reference – i.e. the Law.
I would comply with the BCA 2007 and pass the ARAE if I could afford it and if I was confident in the assessors’ good faith. However, I do not have this type of saving, I am already in negative equities and the RIAI has proved many times that they are not acting in good faith towards self-taught architects, this is scarring me…
@onq wrote:
Unless you want to see the Bill and its main proposer disappear off the radar, I suggest you and people like you repeat this simple mantra at every opportunity:
“I support the Building Control (Amendment) Bill 2010 proposed by John O’Donoghue.”.You arleady know my position on this bill… Don’t try to force my opinion. I do not have to vote on it, others do… If I had to vote for or against, I think that I already said that I would vote for… Then What is your problem?
@onq wrote:
Because if you don’t show appreciation to people who are trying to help you, you will lose their support.
In short, if you act like a cochon don’t be surprised if you get gutted like one.
And no, I’m not just referring to you when I say that.
ONQ.Look onq, if this bill is designed just to help me and others in my situation then let’s just skip it. If it exists to make the registration procedure more coherent, if it exists to prevent the discrimination of a minority, if it exists to prevent a monopoly, to prevent consumers to be misled, then let’s improve it the best that we can…
August 31, 2010 at 1:53 pm #815838Anonymous
Inactive@CK wrote:
Who said the contrary? This procedure take 3 months in Ireland as per the BCA 2007, but applicants can start practicing on the first day…
So apply and practice away.
Are you asking for international business to stop in architecture? Everybody staying in his country and working from there?
Nope, just that if you intend to avail of registration in a country without attaining a formal qualification, you’d better abide by the rules.
I would comply with the BCA 2007 and pass the ARAE if I could afford it and if I was confident in the assessors’ good faith. However, I do not have this type of saving, I am already in negative equities and the RIAI has proved many times that they are not acting in good faith towards self-taught architects, this is scarring me…
An architectural qualification/registration is like buying a house – an investment.
House values may fall as well as rise, but it’ll always be a house and – one ne way or another – it’ll have to be paid for.
At the moment you seem to be only haggling over the price and trying to hedge your bets, but the sheer extent of your waffling suggests something else.
Your inability to recognise the value of the Building Control (Amendment) Bill 2010 and your unwillingness to support it and thank the proposer of said Bill seems to mark you out as an Idiot.
But it could be you know exactly what the implication of signing up for this Bill are, and your unwillingness to support it seems to mark you out as a Chancer.
Chancer or Idiot – your choice – in both cases you are not looking like a credible, competent, professional architect able to prove himself.You arleady know my position on this bill… Don’t try to force my opinion. I do not have to vote on it, others do… If I had to vote for or against, I think that I already said that I would vote for… Then What is your problem?
I’m not asking you to vote for it CK.
I’m asking you to state publicly that you support it
As a mark of gratititude you should also state that you are grateful to John O’Donoghue T.D. for proposing it.Look onq, if this bill is designed just to help me and others in my situation then let’s just skip it. If it exists to make the registration procedure more coherent, if it exists to prevent the discrimination of a minority, if it exists to prevent a monopoly, to prevent consumers to be misled, then let’s improve it the best that we can…
No, CK, its too important to just “skip it”.
This Bill represents the minimum acceptable wording – it cannot be lessened to suit you.
You don’t get to dictate the terms of the Bill or lower the hurdle even more, you get to say yes or no.
You are obliged to show evidence of your competence if you want to continue to work in Ireland as an architect.Let’s take that first step on the road.
I want to see a post from you clearly stating, without qualification or evasion; –“I support the Building Control (Amendment) Bill 2010 proposed by John O’Donoghue.”
That way – assuming you are a man of your word – members of the public can be assured that you are willing to show your work.
They will see you are claiming to have provided services communsurate with those of an architect for 7 years in Ireland.
This is the minimum you need to do to preserve any shred of credibility in Ireland while working as an architect.Otherwise the choice is far more bleak – Idiot or Chancer.
ONQ.
August 31, 2010 at 2:13 pm #815839Anonymous
Inactive@onq wrote:
So apply and practice away.
Do you listen only to yourself during a conversation? Or do you take attention to the other part’s argument as well?
@onq wrote:
Nope, just that if you intend to avail of registration in a country without attaining a formal qualification, you’d better abide by the rules.
If you think so… Then why aren’t you?
@onq wrote:
An architectural qualification/registration is like buying a house – an investment.
House values may fall as well as rise, but it’ll always be a house and – one ne way or another – it’ll have to be paid for.
At the moment you seem to be only haggling over the price and trying to hedge your bets, but the estent of your waffling suggests something else.I thought that it was about skills and knowledge onq… So much about the consumers interets in your version of regsitration…
If everybody was as honnest as you are about it, we would not have this conversation today, because the public would know what is registration all about…
@onq wrote:Your inability to recognise the value of the Building Control (Amendment) Bill 2010 and your unwillingness to support it and thank the proposer of said Bill seems to mark you out as an Idiot.
But it could be you know exactly what the implication of signing up for this Bill are, and your unwillingness to support it seems to mark you out as a Chancer.
Chancer or Idiot – your choice – in both cases you are not looking like a credible, competent, professional architect able to prove himself..Cochon, chancer, idiot,… You are good at throwing insults… Now will that help the bill? Maybe you should try to understand my point instead of acting like a bully.
@onq wrote:
I’m not asking you to vote for it CK.
I’m asking you to state publicly that you support it
As a mark of gratititude you should also state that you are grateful to John O’Donoghue T.D. for proposing it.Look onq, as I already said, if this bill is designed just to help me and others in my situation then let’s just skip it. If it exists to make the registration procedure more coherent, if it exists to prevent the discrimination of a minority, if it exists to prevent a monopoly, to prevent consumers to be misled, then let’s improve it the best that we can… Bully…
@onq wrote:
No, CK, its too important to just “skip it” because you have something to prove if you want to continue to work in Ireland as an architect.
Let’s take that first step on the road.
I want to see a post from you clearly stating, without qualification or evasion; –
“I support the Building Control (Amendment) Bill 2010 proposed by John O’Donoghue.”
That way – assuming yo uare a man of your word – members of the public can be certain you are willing to show your work, and are claiming to have provided services communsurate with those of an architect for 7 years in Ireland.
This is the minimum you need to do to preserve any shred of credibility in Ireland.
ONQ.
You bully…
August 31, 2010 at 2:19 pm #815840Anonymous
InactiveOne of the first things I intend to do should I be fortunate enough to become Registered is sit the Part III Exam as a means of upskilling and proving it, as opposed to trading on the MRIAI suffix.
Badge engineering is no substitute for knowledge.ONQ.[/QUOTE]
Interesting thought ONQ considering that the majority of those architects currently on the register had to prepare for and sit the exam and be assessed prior to achieving their MRIAI status where should this amendment go through you will have the luxury of doing the Part III course as an upskilling exercise where the results will have no consequence to your registration should you be granted it through this route.
August 31, 2010 at 2:29 pm #815841Anonymous
Inactive@CK wrote:
Do you listen only to yourself during a conversation? Or do you take attention to the other part’s argument as well?
Your’e the one dodging the question here not me.
If you think so… Then why aren’t you?
What makes you think I am not?
I thought that it was about skills and knowledge onq… So much about the consumers interets in your version of regsitration…
Its about both CK, and so far you haven’t demonstrated much of either.
If everybody was as honnest as you are about it, we would not have this conversation today, because the public would know what is registration all about…
You’re right CK.
Cochon, chancer, idiot,… You are good at throwing insults… Now will that help the bill? Maybe you should try to understand my point instead of acting like a bully.
I am focussed on getting an admission out of you CK.
I am not being distracted by your attempts to hide behind deception or evasion any more CK.
You have been asked a straight question and have dodged the answer on several occassions CK.
That’s not how I expect a competent Architect to behave CK.(snip repetitive nonsense)
Bully…
You bully…
Sad and pathetic.
You are the one telling entire countries that their law is not good enough because it doesn’t suit you, and yet you call ME a bully?!
*Bwahahahahahahahahahahhh!*
Unless you and others in a similar position are seen to support the Building Control (Amendment) Bill 2010, they will be branded as Chancers.
Post here the following message:
“I support the Building Control (Amendment) Bill 2010 proposed by John O’Donoghue.”
or lose what little credibility you retain.
I don’t care if you hope to build on it or not, or wish to “improve” it.
If you don’t get this Bill passed into law you will have nothing on which to build.
Do you get it now CK?
One last chance.
ONQ.
August 31, 2010 at 2:37 pm #815842Anonymous
InactiveI’m amazed that you two find time to do any work.
August 31, 2010 at 2:45 pm #815843Anonymous
Inactive@onq wrote:
Your’e the one dodging the question here not me.
Your’e the one dodging the answer…:)
@onq wrote:
What makes you think I am not?
What are you doing?
@onq wrote:
Its about both CK, and so far you haven’t demonstrated much of either.
Question of opinion I suppose…
@onq wrote:
You’re right CK.
Thanks for that…
@onq wrote:
I am focussed on getting an admission out of you CK.
I am not being distracted by your attempts to hide behind deception or evasion any more CK.
You have been asked a straight question and have dodged the answer on several occassions CK.
That’s not how I expect a competent Architect to behave CK.How do you assess competency… It is one of the problem here, isn’t it?
@onq wrote:
Sad and pathetic.
I know… I know…
@onq wrote:
You are the one telling entire countries that their law is not good enough because it doesn’t suit you, and yet you call ME a bully?!
*Bwahahahahahahahahahahhh!*
I have practiced architecture in 3 different countries during the last 17 years… There is no Law on Earth that will stop me to continue this way…
@onq wrote:
Unless you and others in a similar position are seen to support the Building Control (Amendment) Bill 2010, they will be branded as Chancers.
why are you talking for us as if you were not part of the group? sometimes you sound as if you were doing us a favour… Well don’t…
@onq wrote:
Post here the following message:
“I support the Building Control (Amendment) Bill 2010 proposed by John O’Donoghue.”
or lose what little credibility you retain.
I don’t care if you hope to build on it or not, or wish to “improve” it.
If you don’t get this Bill passed into law you will have nothing on which to build.
Do you get it now CK?
One last chance.
ONQ.
What is the matter with you? Do you read my posts sometimes?
August 31, 2010 at 2:58 pm #815844Anonymous
Inactive@CK wrote:
Your’e the one dodging the answer…:)
(endless dodging snipped)
How do you assess competency… It is one of the problem here, isn’t it?
CK, I helped develop office, staff from draughtsmen to junior architects.
Its only a problem for people without any experience in assessing competence.I have practiced architecture in 3 different countries during the last 17 years… There is no Law on Earth that will stop me to continue this way…
There is no law in Ireland that will allow you to continue in this way.
why are you talking for us as if you were not part of the group? sometimes you sound as if you were doing us a favour… Well don’t…
The days of me doing favours for ungrateful people are over CK.
I’m now seeking to determine whether or not they are people who act with integrity or else are Chancers.What is the matter with you? Do you read my posts sometimes?
Post a clear and unambiguous post here CK.
“I support the Building Control (Amendment) Bill 2010 proposed by John O’Donoghue.”
Otherwise, everyone will will be free to draw the inference that you are a Chancer.
ONQ.
August 31, 2010 at 3:09 pm #815845Anonymous
Inactive@NevilleNeville wrote:
One of the first things I intend to do should I be fortunate enough to become Registered is sit the Part III Exam as a means of upskilling and proving it, as opposed to trading on the MRIAI suffix.
Badge engineering is no substitute for knowledge.ONQ.
Interesting thought ONQ considering that the majority of those architects currently on the register had to prepare for and sit the exam and be assessed prior to achieving their MRIAI status where should this amendment go through you will have the luxury of doing the Part III course as an upskilling exercise where the results will have no consequence to your registration should you be granted it through this route.
My previous post to which you responded is highlighted in bold text above for clarity.
#1.
I am unlikely to take the route offered by the Bill, which caters for persons without a formal qualification who have provided services commensurate with those of an architect for seven years or more in Ireland.
I am formally qualified and hold a prescribed qualification and I have in excess of twenty years post-graduate experience as an architect.
I intend to apply via the Option C route which requires a significant submission of information and a self-assessment matrix.
This submission covers information you might be asked a part of the Part III assessment exam.Why would I consider taking this route and then doing the exam?
Because circumstances prevent me taking the Part III exam.
Because its good to be able to point back to an exam.#2.
CPD is an important part of professional life.
While the majority of MRIAI’s may have sat a Part III Exam, it wasn’t last year’s Part III exam, ergo it may be out of date in relation to several issues, i.e.; Health and Safety, Conservation, etc..
Taking the Part III again was mooted to me as a useful form of upskilling for architects WITH THE PART III ALREADY, because it measures their ability against current standards, not the standards of thirty years ago.
I happen to support this suggestion as a means of ensuring that members of the public are adequately catered for by persons already within the RIAI who became registered because of their membership who have not sat the exam.I trust all that is clear as crystal.
ONQ.
August 31, 2010 at 3:15 pm #815846Anonymous
Inactive@onq wrote:
CK, I helped develop office, staff from draughtsmen to junior architects.
Its only a problem for people without any experience in assessing competence.It is a 13,500 Euro problem to me.
@onq wrote:
There is no law in Ireland that will allow you to continue in this way.
Welcome to CK Outlaw Architects
@onq wrote:
The days of me doing favours for ungrateful people are over CK.
I’m now seeking to determine whether or not they are people who act with integrity or else are Chancers.Can one be a chancer with 8 years learning and 16 nearly 17 years practice?
@onq wrote:
Post a clear and unambiguous post here CK.
“I support the Building Control (Amendment) Bill 2010 proposed by John O’Donoghue.”
Otherwise, everyone will will be free to draw the inference that you are a Chancer.
ONQ.
Keep on track onq… You and me have better things to do… This becomes childish…
It is not my support to the bill that will have an effect on my skills… You are loosing your marks… Stay focus if you want to defend this bill honorably… And stop asking people 100% support… 95% is not that bad…
- AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

