The sensitive issue of the title "Architect" and the Buildin

Home › Forums › Ireland › The sensitive issue of the title "Architect" and the Buildin

Viewing 20 posts - 801 through 820 (of 1,243 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #815807
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @wearnicehats wrote:

    hidden behind your concern for the public is your real agenda ie fuck the future to look after yourself. You aren’t self trained or established CK. You have an unrecognised degree and a few extensions to your name. Believe me, it’s that attitude that will sink this Bill dead. Sorry for butting in on the “Save CK” thread again but you made the mistake of putting up a post shorter than 2000 words

    Well I am doing my best here wearnicehats… If I cannot call myself qualified or self-trained, then how can I define myself? Since 1987 my studies and professional work were focused on Architecture, isn’t that a proof that I am established professionally?

    Believe me it is already very unpleasant to have spent 8 years in university, and still being requested another 13,500 Euro to pass further examinations… If I studied medicine or accountancy, I would understand… But I studied architecture…

    Excuse me if the RIAI has influenced my behavior in deciding calling myself self-trained… It is true that I am not fully… But aren’t we all self-trained in a way? Very few of the so called self-trained architects did not study. A large majority has degrees in architecture, architectural technology, engineering, surveying, construction and so on…

    I believe that the term self-trained is now used for those who are requested to spend up to 13,500 Euro for registration.

    Definitions of words are changing… Words do not always mean what they should…

    #815808
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @vca wrote:

    The fact that 80% of the complaints received by the RIAI are related to unqualified people claiming to be architects is the figure for 2009.
    http://architecturenow.ie/news/?article=746

    At least make the attempt to quote accurately.
    The relevant quotation is:

    “Last year 80% of complaints received by the RIAI were related to unqualified practitioners.”

    The article doesn’t say that the complaints were related to “unqualified people claiming to be architects”.
    Whether they claimed to be architects is not discussed.
    That’s your interpretation of the comment.

    This betrays a lack of rigorous thinking unworthy of an Architect.
    Unfortunately this is all too common in the kind of MRIAI I run up against.

    Let’s analyse this comment a little more.

    “Last year 80% of complaints received by the RIAI were related to unqualified practitioners.”

    Hmmm – “…were related to unqualified practitioners…” that’s a funny way of putting it.
    The article doesn’t state that the complaints were made against unqualified practitioners.
    “Related to”… were unqualified practitioners making complaints against Member of the Institute?

    I think this piece of reportage needs to be fully backed up by statistics stating who said what about who and why.
    That way we can exclude crank calls and unfounded allegations and get some sort of idea of the state of the profession.

    ONQ.

    #815809
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @wearnicehats wrote:

    hidden behind your concern for the public is your real agenda ie fuck the future to look after yourself. You aren’t self trained or established CK. You have an unrecognised degree and a few extensions to your name. Believe me, it’s that attitude that will sink this Bill dead. Sorry for butting in on the “Save CK” thread again but you made the mistake of putting up a post shorter than 2000 words

    There’s nothing like a well structured argument that goes to the heart of the matter and avoids making a foul mouthed ad hominen attack in order to get attention.

    And what you just posted is nothing like a well structured argument that goes to the heart of the matter and avoids making a foul mouthed ad hominen attack in order to get attention.

    ONQ.

    #815810
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @onq wrote:

    There’s nothing like a well structured argument that goes to the heart of the matter and avoids making a foul mouthed ad hominen attack in order to get attention.

    And what you just posted is nothing like a well structured argument that goes to the heart of the matter and avoids making a foul mouthed ad hominen attack in order to get attention.

    ONQ.

    KAPOW! cut to the quick once again by your rapier wit

    It really wasn’t ad hominem (you really like that little phrase don’t you) as it was a response to CK’s general attitude towards this whole affair and his continuing delusions of grandeur rather than his ethereal self. Anyway, he’s quite happy for graduates to be f**ked over (is that better you sensitive soul?) whilst forgetting that he continues be little more than one himself. Choosing to work on your own rather than a company whilst having undertaken an architecture degree does not make you “self taught”.

    One thing that it does underline to me is the size of the holes in this Bill’s sieve.

    I think that the only real way to resolve all of this is for the RIAI and their opponents to agree an independant review body that will review the current RIAI registration options and types. If this body decides that the current methods are fair then they must stand. If not, then they will be subject to review until agreed to be fair. Once a fair set of registration methods is agreed then these must be applied to everyone, including grandfathers. This will ensure that those people currently eligible for registration but relying upon a favour will not slip through the net. It will also provide mental parity for those who see these OAPs as a bunch of chancers trying to kick in the back door

    #815811
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @wearnicehats wrote:

    KAPOW! cut to the quick once again by your rapier wit

    It really wasn’t ad hominem (you really like that little phrase don’t you) as it was a response to CK’s general attitude towards this whole affair and his continuing delusions of grandeur rather than his ethereal self. Anyway, he’s quite happy for graduates to be f**ked over (is that better you sensitive soul?) whilst forgetting that he continues be little more than one himself. Choosing to work on your own rather than a company whilst having undertaken an architecture degree does not make you “self taught”.

    You are missing the point… I do not call myself self-trained because I like it or because it suits my interests… I call myself self-trained because the RIAI and the BCA 2007 do not differentiate someone like me who studied during 8 years in university to someone else who did not go to university at all. The education system in my university was also mainly based on learn how to learn methods rather than learn what we teach you…

    The RIAI and the BCA 2007 consider me as a self-taught… Then I talk as such…

    The problem is that the BCA 2007 is either too simplistic or too elaborated, and this is the worst possible scenario. A good law should cover all particular aspects, all particular cases, or it should ensure that everyone is considered fairly using a more general approach. This is not the case with the BCA 2007.

    Many like me, with qualifications in Architecture are considered as self-taught. Many Self-taught with decades of experience are regarded as incompetent. And in the mean time some individuals registered abroad, with no knowledge of Irish Building Regulations, Irish forms of contracts, Irish planning law, are authorized to practice as architects in the state despite their ignorance.

    I maybe not fully self-trained wearnicehats, but you are missing the point here…

    #815812
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @wearnicehats wrote:

    KAPOW! cut to the quick once again by your rapier wit

    (bows)

    It really wasn’t ad hominem (you really like that little phrase don’t you) as it was a response to CK’s general attitude towards this whole affair and his continuing delusions of grandeur rather than his ethereal self.

    I didn’t invent the phrase – I’ve been in enough online debates to see a person who intersperses ad hominems with argument as lacking a reasoned approach to the substantive issue.

    Anyway, he’s quite happy for graduates to be f**ked over (is that better you sensitive soul?) whilst forgetting that he continues be little more than one himself.

    CK may be bitter as a result of his situation – I cannot say that I blame him – but in general he has not attacked Graduates [happy to be proven wrong on this with a suitable quotation]. He definitely has an axe to grind with the RIAI and teh Minister and I sympathise with his position to some degree.

    Choosing to work on your own rather than a company whilst having undertaken an architecture degree does not make you “self taught”.

    I’m not sure what you’re tryign to say here, and I’m not going to defend CK, but I cannot classify him as being “self-taught”.
    Admittedly I am going on his word alone, but he claims he has had several years of academic training in design focussed on Architecture.
    He also claims to have spent many years workign in design opffice in Britain – in a spooky kind of way, it seems to mirror Corbusier’s own route to competence.
    The fact that there are standards being set in Europe and Ireland that effectively exclude people with CK’s history from the profession should give you pause for thought – who benefits?

    One thing that it does underline to me is the size of the holes in this Bill’s sieve.

    There is no hole. Only persons who can show seven years evidence of establishment in Ireland and who have provided services commensurate with those of an architect are considered by this Bill.
    People working as draughtsmen or technicians who have taken no responsibility for their own work by certifying and/or doing the bulk of a design or building project themselves need not apply.

    I would not support something that denigrates the profession
    I support this Bill and I think any fair minded MRIAI would support it too.
    The numbers are relatively small – assuming the above definition is applied correctly.

    The risk to the public that the RIAI alleges exists; –

    • has not been proven to exist per se though empirical evidence open to public scrutiny or
    • has not been shown to emanate solely from the Grandfathers.

    The RIAI lobbyists appear to have directed the public debate by using a boogy-man to help inform it.
    If David Grant is the exemplar, there should at least be a body of evidence to show that he is typical of unregistered practitioners.
    Evidence shows he is atypical – to use a sole exception to invoke an unfairly restrictive law is not best practice

    For the record those Grandfathers who have lobbied their local T.D.’s have had testimonials placed on the written record in the JOC Meeting of 18th May 2010.
    The elected representatives drew censure from the Chairman because they chose to speak at length about Grandfathers.
    The previous RIAI arguments, those based oninference as opposed to evidence, did not hold sway at the JOC.

    The point of this Bill is not to open the floodgates.
    A limited number of persons will be eligible and their competence will be recognised.
    But the flip side is that as soon as the Grandfathers put their hands up to register, their past work will become open to scrutiny.
    This will focus the Registrar, the Oireachtas and the public on them and will swiftly expose any incompetence or wrongdoing on their part.
    The Public through their elected representatives, should be able to have their say in this process, to make architecture once more the public art it used to be.

    Mind you, given the practices that are current in many MRIAI-run practices, this could land some MRIAIs in a pickle as their “pet Technician” stands up and attemtps to get the credit for the work he has done for the past fifteen years;-

    • running the office
    • meeting and minding clients “on project”
    • allocating staff and resources
    • negotiating fees

    – while the resident MRIAI has been out at the golf club wining and dining clients.

    These duties are the normal province of senior archtiects within a practice, assuming there is one main figurehead or principal, but senior technicians may carry out these duties.
    Thus, persons who have been shouldering the responsibility of chief architect under the principal do not always have the qualification Architect, but they certainly have the experience obtained over the years and some derive the requried level of competence. Yes, I have met chancers masquerading as architects, but the only way to deal with this is to admit them and assess them.
    Otherwise they can exist on the fringes, under an another name, never having to show their work ad never havign their record scrutinised and nost importantly, never having been censured for incompetent work.
    Unless there is a fundanmental sea change in approach like this, such rogue practitioners can continue bullshitting clients and getting competent professionals a bad name by association – indefinitely.

    And that’s just not good enough.

    I think that the only real way to resolve all of this is for the RIAI and their opponents to agree an independant review body that will review the current RIAI registration options and types. If this body decides that the current methods are fair then they must stand. If not, then they will be subject to review until agreed to be fair. Once a fair set of registration methods is agreed then these must be applied to everyone, including grandfathers. This will ensure that those people currently eligible for registration but relying upon a favour will not slip through the net. It will also provide mental parity for those who see these OAPs as a bunch of chancers trying to kick in the back door

    The Grandfathers have little faith in the RIAI administering this in a fair manner.
    The RIAI have lobbied for 20 year for proper recognition of the Title and when it was in their grasp they went a little mad [or parliamentary draughtsmen and the Seeanad – where the RIAI apparently hold sway, allegedly went overboard] and decided to shaft everybody except their own members by not recognising; –

    • persons with 7 years providing services commensurate with those of an architect, or
    • Graduates whose right to use the title was enshrined in two EU Directives – DIR 85/384/EEC and DIR 2005/36/EC

    John Graby may be a nice guy, but he carries a big legal stick and he is backed by a Minister not known for turning.

    On mature reflection – great phrase I’ve wanted to use for a while 🙂 – I would modify my position in my ideal world.
    Publish a list in all the newspapers of all the architects to be registered and invite critical comment from the Public.
    Any applicant with a complaint made against them would be put on hold until the complaints could be investigated.

    But the ham fisted way this Act has been implemented means that there is no Professional Conduct Committee to assess any such complaints.

    In relation to the current Bill, nothing is stopping the Registrar from conducting an advertising campaing inviting comment from the public about prospective Grandfather applicants for registration.
    To be fair to Grandfathers, there should be no exclusions – comment should be accepted about MRIAI’s as well, including recent “converts”.
    Comment should also be invited about people not using the title and not registered either – the famed “weekend draughtspersons”. or technicians, or architectural technologists.
    [two chances of someone shopping somebody who worked for buttons and who was paid in cash, but one could at least try].
    Such complaints should be made public and the persons or practices so named held to account.
    That should give a fair picture of the profession and how it relates to the public.

    The RIAI might be in for a shock when they see the sheer number of people proving architectural services including seeking statutory approvals.
    They might finally realise why so many architects are out of work at the moment.
    To many amateur suppliers with below-cost fee structures in a small pond.

    There is nothing stop the RIAI using some of their annual fee income to promote architecture by doing some research on unqualified architects.
    If, as has been alleged, there are only 200 or so Grandfathers, that’s not an army.
    That’s 200 e-mails to the local authorities in their area requesting confirmation that they have not been involved in schemes which requried enforcement action, or details where they have been so involved.

    Its time for the RIAI to stop lobbying by inference and actually produce some hard figures to back up their claims of protecting the public.
    Let them at least show there is a defined threat that their policies are competent to deal with.
    Either that or stop complaining about the loss of standing of the MRIAI qualification.

    Since completed enforcement actions are already open to public scrutiny, they can be published.
    But unresolved actions should not be published due to possible defamation claims that may arise.
    And again, to be fair to Grandfathers and to all others, the files should include all the MRIAI jobs too.

    ONQ.

    #815813
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    “The Grandfathers have little faith in the RIAI administering this in a fair manner”

    Where is there any evidence of unfairness?

    I have yet to see any evidence that the Architects Alliance / Grandfathers’ have the ability to administer another system as proposed in their Bill any better than the system currently operating under the Building Control Act (BCA) 2007 and regardless of the lack of empirical evidence a system is needed. The current BCA system may not be perfect but at least it is a standard against which amendments may be made.

    The pilot Technical Assessment Scheme resulted in several amendments to that system proving that there is flexibility in the system and with those operating it.

    The pilot Technical Assessment Scheme resulted in a 50% success rate. Where is the celebration and acknowledgement of the wonderful achievement of those candidates who were successful?

    To quote one member of the pilot Technical Assessment:
    “My advice to candidates would be to firstly appreciate the huge importance of being accepted
    as member of a professional representative body such as the RIAI”

    More importantly where is the clamour from those who were unsuccessful in the pilot Technical Assessment Scheme alleging unfairness?

    The proposed Bill sounds like a Chancers’ Charter and nothing else. Where have these Grandfathers been for the last 30-40 years? Any self-taught practitioners offering a professional service to their clients have absolutely nothing to fear from the Technical Assessment Scheme and all of the architectural profession will be strengthened by their embracing it.

    It also irritates me intensely that almost every reference on this thread to “self-taught” people is coupled with allusions to Le Corbusier whilst every MRIAI is portrayed as a golf playing alcoholic incapable of telling you what the letters d.p.c. stand for.

    Have a great weekend!

    #815814
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @vca wrote:

    “The Grandfathers have little faith in the RIAI administering this in a fair manner”

    Where is there any evidence of unfairness?

    Go back few posts earlier, or do you prefer that I re-post the same?

    @vca wrote:

    “
    The pilot Technical Assessment Scheme resulted in a 50% success rate. Where is the celebration and acknowledgement of the wonderful achievement of those candidates who were successful?

    It must be specified that this is the rate after appeals procedure (total cost 9,500 Euro)

    @vca wrote:

    “
    To quote one member of the pilot Technical Assessment:
    “My advice to candidates would be to firstly appreciate the huge importance of being accepted as member of a professional representative body such as the RIAI”

    What if you do not seek membership of the RIAI?

    @vca wrote:

    “
    More importantly where is the clamour from those who were unsuccessful in the pilot Technical Assessment Scheme alleging unfairness? ”

    It is not about glamour… How many have been successful? How many passed it? It is about a fair system. Why should recognized and established professionals be judged by younger and less experienced judges. Judges who are claiming loudly that they are against the registration of self-trained architects because it undermines their own studies and career.

    #815815
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @vca wrote:

    “The Grandfathers have little faith in the RIAI administering this in a fair manner”

    Where is there any evidence of unfairness?

    In my own cause, restoring the right of graduates to use the Title Archtiect, I can point to the misleading statement to the JOC attributed to the EU Commission suggesting that the Graduate standard was not the minimum standard throughout the EU.

    This was somewhat ironic, since I understand that our own Jim Horan MRIAI Head of teh School of Architecture in Bolton Street, wrote the revised description of the full time course content leading to the graduate qualification for inclusion in the Mutual Recognition of Qualifications Directive.

    In relation to Grandfathers, the simple fact that they were not automatically registered despite decades providing competent services should scream at any right-thinking [as opposed to ass-covering] MRIAI that this is not a level playing field.

    I have yet to see any evidence that the Architects Alliance / Grandfathers’ have the ability to administer another system as proposed in their Bill any better than the system currently operating under the Building Control Act (BCA) 2007

    Unlike the RIAI, the Grandfathers/AAoI have no ambition that I know of to administer any system.
    The preoccupation with power and administration of the profession appears to emanate solely from No. 8 Merrion Square.
    But even the suggestion of the Grandfathers administering another system will send Montaut et al into ecstasy at being thought of as on a level with the RIAI.

    …and regardless of the lack of empirical evidence a system is needed.

    The imposition of a system on the basis of innuendo and inference is what the American Military have donr in the Middle East and elsewhere.
    Its called War by Propaganda and its vulnerable to counter propaganda and the truth.
    Exposing the truth is seldom pretty, often a two-edged sword, but its the only way to frame and write good law in an equitable manner.

    The current BCA system may not be perfect but at least it is a standard against which amendments may be made.

    It is NOT a standard.
    It is the automatic, draconian imposition of one private organization’s certificate allowing it to take precedence over all other evidence of competence.
    As such it is grossly unfair and defamatory.

    The pilot Technical Assessment Scheme resulted in several amendments to that system proving that there is flexibility in the system and with those operating it.

    Credit where its due for trying a pilot scheme first.

    The pilot Technical Assessment Scheme resulted in a 50% success rate. Where is the celebration and acknowledgement of the wonderful achievement of those candidates who were successful?

    75% Failure Rate the first time around.
    You call failing 14 out of 18 first time around candidates a success?
    I understand that he initial four passing grades were joined by an additional five only when they appealed the results and the standard was relaxed.

    So three quarters failed at first, and 50% is the outcome of people who were pepped and allowed Appeal – that’s a very high standard for an assessment even after “adjustment”
    This shows the unworkability of a totally new system without redacted successful submissions, specimen exam papers, specimen answers, or graduates and past exam papers to advise.

    To quote one member of the pilot Technical Assessment:
    “My advice to candidates would be to firstly appreciate the huge importance of being accepted as member of a professional representative body such as the RIAI”

    .
    “The aim of the RIAI is not to represent its Members, its aim is to promote Architecture. Many members are surprised when they discover this.”

    10 CPD Points for answering who said that – if in doubt consult a competent authority near you.

    Every MRIAI should know what they pay their fee for – hint: its not personal representation.

    More importantly where is the clamour from those who were unsuccessful in the pilot Technical Assessment Scheme alleging unfairness?

    Dunno – too scared to say anything?
    Too embarrassed to admit they weren’t still architects?
    Like they’re going to come right out and splash that all over the newspapers.

    Did you offer them a counselling service after they failed, after you destroyed their cherished ambitions, their careers and their self image?
    Maybe they all committed suicide having contemplated “the huge importance of being accepted as member of a professional representative body such as the RIAI” – after they failed.

    But why are you asking me?
    You’re supposed to be one of the Competent Ones.
    Don’t you believe in your own legend now you’re Automatically Registered?

    OTOH…

    Perhaps they want to lobby for a change in the law.
    I know here they can get some competent advice.
    Its not CPD rated, but it may be more effective.

    The proposed Bill sounds like a Chancers’ Charter and nothing else.

    Oh Yipeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!!!!!!!!!
    A Genuine VCA Ad Hominem Attack!
    Quelle Surprise!

    Where have these Grandfathers been for the last 30-40 years?

    Ehrm, what part of “working competently in Ireland” did you not glean from the JOC Meeting on 18th May 2010?

    Any self-taught practitioners offering a professional service to their clients have absolutely nothing to fear from the Technical Assessment Scheme and all of the architectural profession will be strengthened by their embracing it.

    Allow me to re-phrase that:

    “The RIAI have nothing to fear from self-taught practitioners offering a professional service to their clients who may benefit from the provisions of the Building Control Amendment Bill 2010 if it becomes law and all of the architectural profession will be strengthened by the RIAI embracing this Bill.”

    It also irritates me intensely that almost every reference on this thread to “self-taught” people is coupled with allusions to Le Corbusier …

    The truth hurts, ehhh?

    What would you do if I added Michael Scott [blessed be his name, blessed be his holy works] to the mix?
    Did you know he actively resisted becoming a Member of the Institute – said he had no time for people with letters after their name.
    John Graby is fond of telling everyone that Scott became a Member of the Institute – he never says he sat a special exam after pressure from the RIAI.

    … whilst every MRIAI is portrayed as a golf playing alcoholic incapable of telling you what the letters d.p.c. stand for.

    Hey, I said “wining and dining” – you interpreted it in those other, glowing terms not me.

    Was this a confession from you by other means, perhaps?

    Have a great weekend!

    Most people start their weekend on a Friday.
    I suppose golf playing alcoholics need to get an early start.
    Watch out for those wee holes in the middle of the greens won’t you?.

    ONQ.

    PS The acronym “d.p.c.” stands for “Damp Proof Course” – do I get my CPD points?

    #815816
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @onq wrote:

    .

    ONQ.

    PS The acronym “d.p.c.” stands for “Damp Proof Course” – do I get my CPD points?

    DPC means DUMP for PROFFESSIONAL CANVASSING

    Do I get my CPD points too?

    #815817
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    I do not think that the RIAI Lobbying campaign is illegal because the RIAI as a double statute. It is the registration body for architects in Ireland but it is also a professional body representing its members, those using the letters MRIAI after their names.

    This is one of the problems that we are confronted to, the RIAI has this double statute and it creates a conflict of interests within the registration procedure. The registration body has no reason to be opposed to a grand-father clause. On the other hand, the RIAI was an institute representing only professionally qualified architects; it is this part of the institute that is lobbying against the grand-father clause today, against those who do not hold a professional qualification.

    The Competition Authority had anticipated the problem, but the government at the time did not listen to the warnings.

    If the RIAI lobbying campaign is legal, it is surely against the ethic and incompatible with the statute of the architects registration body of Ireland. The RIAI is involved in a conflict between self-trained architects and qualified architects, but it is in charge for registering members of the two groups. It is evident that by supporting one side, the RIAI his discriminating the other. It must be recalled that over 99% of architects listed on the register also use the letters MRIAI after their names, because the registration body has done everything possible to privilege RIAI members. I am not aware of any country where such conflict of interests exists. The registration body should either be run by the State or it should be independent from any professional representation. It is sure that more conflicts will rise in the future because of the RIAI double statute and double standards. Those who wish to register as architects without seeking membership of the professional body are not represented by the RIAI, but they still pay the same annual registration fees than RIAI Members who pay no additional fees for their privileges.

    The RIAI was given to much power… Killing choice and competition… The RIAI cannot be policed by the Competition Authority because it is a regualtor… It cannot be policed by the Ombudsman because it is also a private company… The Building Control Act 2007 has transformed the RIAI into an untouchable force that only the government and the courts can challenge…

    #815818
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    CK,

    Your first paragraph is unclear.

    “I do not think that the RIAI Lobbying campaign is illegal because the RIAI as a double statute. It is the registration body for architects in Ireland but it is also a professional body representing its members, those using the letters MRIAI after their names.”

    The RIAI is a private body with a statutory appointment.
    It is questionable in terms of good governance to do this.
    It does not appear to be illegal, merely not good practice.
    The RIAI allege this is accepted in Europe – its still not good.



    Your fourth paragraph appears to open up a wider debate:

    “If the RIAI lobbying campaign is legal, it is surely against the ethic and incompatible with the statute of the architects registration body of Ireland.”

    Again, it is a little unclear, but the gist of seems to be that engaing in political lobbying to support its own aims is at odds with the terms of reference of a statutory registration body.

    Others would appear to share a similar view.

    I understand that the head of the Assessment Board, a Barrister, has refused even to meet the Architect’s Alliance because she was [correctly, IMO] concerned that it could be seen to compromise the Assessment Board’s impartiality.



    I realise that the Registrar has taken a pro-active stance, in keeping with his interpretation of the ideals of the RIAI to promote architecture.
    This is fine up to a point, the possible consensus and agreement that discussions with the AAoI or any other interest groups might engender outweighing any allegations of collusion or behind-the-scenes negotiations that the simple minded might proffer.

    However the road the Registrar set foot on when he decided to offer CPD points for MRIAI’s to do a course in political lobbying must have everyone who was mentioned in a Flood Tribunal module chortling with glee. The highest competent authority in the land on Architecture – a profession sprinkled with Green and Labour T.D.’s – is opening the Pandora’s Box that they must agree has led to so many corrupt and inappropriate planning decisions during the Tiger years.



    RIAI President Paul Keogh must be spinning on his pedestal so soon after delivering his firebrand inaugural speech
    In it, he declaimed against the poor planning decisions, such as those that have resulted in ghost estates scattered in unlikely places throughout Ireland.
    After all, wasn’t it political lobbying of Councillors in remote rural locations that promoted the “build them and they will come” mentality that overturned sound planning practice throughout Ireland?

    Mind you, its not as if the RIAI are strangers when it comes to political lobbying themselves, although it may be more concentrated in the lofty reaches of the Seanad than the Dáil.

    • It was political lobbying that got the Building Control Act 2007 passed into law, to the great benefit of the RIAI.
    • It was political lobbying that brought some balance to this situation with the publication of John O’Donoghue’s Building Control Amendment Bill 2010.
    • It will be the recent call to Members of the RIAI to do CPD-rated courses in political lobbying that will expose the newly minted office of Registrar to ridicule in the press.

    Those who have benefited by political lobbying cannot complain when they are hoisted by their own petard.



    Contrary to what you might think I don’t see any of this as a good thing.
    John Graby is the Registrar and must rightly busy himself with calling for consensus, promoting architecture and ensuring registration proceeds in an orderly fashion for the benefit of the public.

    But, as Registrar, he needs to stand back from the slippery slope of being seen to promote political lobbying.
    Let the Registrar’s views be made known by a few well-placed phone calls to key figures in the profession, the Dáil and the Seanad, rather than via the public domain.
    But if after mature reflection its decided to mobilse the rank and file of the RIAI Membership, let RIAI President Paul Keogh take the lead, or one of the other Directors of RIAI Limited.

    This is because its a very short step from lobbying for what the Registrar might see is a good cause, and lobbying for planning advantage for a client.
    The latter is best kept at huge distance from any building professionals, whose job is to design and help present a development on behalf of their clients.
    It seems wholly inappropriate for the Registrar to engage in political lobbying at the end of a decade-long planning tribunal which has yet its issue its report



    Let the Political Lobbyist or the Client do the political lobbying – that should not be the architect’s role.
    The current CPD rated course for MRIAI’s seems ill-advised and likely to lower the standing of our profession.

    ONQ.

    #815819
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @onq wrote:

    CK,

    Your first paragraph is unclear.

    “I do not think that the RIAI Lobbying campaign is illegal because the RIAI as a double statute. It is the registration body for architects in Ireland but it is also a professional body representing its members, those using the letters MRIAI after their names.”

    The RIAI is a private body with a statutory appointment.
    It is questionable in terms of good governance to do this.
    It does not appear to be illegal, merely not good practice.
    The RIAI allege this is accepted in Europe – its still not good.


    .

    My point is about the double statute of the RIAI. It used to represent only professionally qualified architects before it became the architects registration body.

    The position of the institute and its members did not change from one day to the other. They did not suddenly abandon their pre-conceived ideas on self-trained architects or those with qualifications not listed in the EU Directive. The RIAI was a club before it became the registration body. It is still a club today.

    The RIAI lobbying campaign is not illegal because they have this double statute. If the RIAI only statute was defined in the BCA 2007, the RIAI could be sued for discriminating self-trained architect in relation to the political lobbying that they carried out this month. It is clear that the registration body / regulator is over passing its duty to defend registered architects by influencing the mode of selection for registration before all pretenders were able to register.

    I am trying to explain that the RIAI is in charge for protecting the interests of registered architects as per the BCA 2007. However, it would take years before the Technical Assessment can review all potential applicants and this is due to the RIAI laborious procedure for registration. The RIAI lobbying defends registered architects on the ground that the new grand-father clause may devaluate their privilege and damage their interests, this implicates the RIAI to act against the interests of future registered architects who did not have the opportunity yet to register due to the laborious procedure set up by the registration body / regulator which is now lobbying against them.

    Because the RIAI is lobbying against the interests of future registered architects who did not have the opportunity to register due to the RIAI incapacity to deal appropriately with the workload within an acceptable time frame, I think that the registration body / registrar lobbying campaign could be in breach of the BCA 2007 and then illegal. However, the RIAI is also a private institute with private members (MRIAI) and this Institute is defending the interests of its members when lobbying against the amendment for a grand-father clause, there is nothing illegal here.

    This political lobbying campaign has under-lined the conflict between the RIAI as the registration body / regulator, and the private side of the RIAI representing only professionally qualified architects.

    The problem that we are confronting today was very easy to predict. How could an Institute representing only qualified architects be able to act properly when registering self-trained architects? How can an institute which existence was founded on its privileges over self-trained architects suddenly accept these last ones as their equals?

    Any other independent body would have been able to use the BCA 2007 and create fair registration procedures for self-trained architects. I did read in what was called at the time the “RIAI Journal”, that the Irish registration procedure was influenced by the Dutch precedent. However, comparing the Dutch examination and the ARAE, we can easily understand the matter of the problem. The ARAE is 3½ time more onerous. When the Dutch examination is practical and would allow established professionals to continue running their practices while passing the exam, the ARAE in the contrary, is based on a very strict time table with examinations in university classrooms spread over 10 months.

    #815820
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:

    My point is about the double statute of the RIAI. It used to represent only professionally qualified architects before it became the architects registration body.

    (snip)

    The RIAI lobbying campaign is not illegal because they have this double statute.

    (snip)

    I am trying to explain that the RIAI is in charge for protecting the interests of registered architects as per the BCA 2007.

    (snip)

    However, the RIAI is also a private institute with private members (MRIAI) and this Institute is defending the interests of its members when lobbying against the amendment for a grand-father clause, there is nothing illegal here.

    This political lobbying campaign has under-lined the conflict between the RIAI as the registration body / regulator, and the private side of the RIAI representing only professionally qualified architects.

    The problem that we are confronting today was very easy to predict. How could an Institute representing only qualified architects be able to act properly when registering self-trained architects?

    (snip)

    CK,

    I am not arguing all your other points because in general I tend to agree.

    I want you to focus on two things, highlighted in bold the snippets above.

    1. Your use of the word “statute”.

    Double statute is not the same as double standard.
    Also the Registrar is empowered by an Act not a Statutory Instrument.
    You may be trying to say that he serves two masters or is compromised by vested interests.
    Don’t let your obvious passion for all things architectural lead you to mangle the language so badly the message gets lost.

    2. Your assertion that the RIAI represents its Members.

    This is an incorrect assumption and you’re missing the point of what I said to VCA in a recent post; –

    “The aim of the RIAI is not to represent its Members, its aim is to promote Architecture. Many members are surprised when they discover this.”

    Le but du RIAI n’est pas de représenter ses membres, son but est de favoriser l’architecture. Beaucoup de membres sont étonnés quand ils découvrent ceci.

    Vous devez comprendre ce fait immédiatement!

    Do you get it now CK?

    ONQ.

    #815821
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Onq,

    You should understand double statute as double function. The RIAI needs to follow a line of conduct as the Registration Body, however as the private institute formed of members, the line of conduct is different and not always parallel.

    I am not sure of your information about:

    @onq wrote:

    “The aim of the RIAI is not to represent its Members, its aim is to promote Architecture. Many members are surprised when they discover this.”

    ONQ.

    However, prior to registration who financed the RIAI? Wasn’t it the members (MRIAI) as well as government grants? You say that the RIAI’s aim is to promote architecture and not its members. This is bull excrements… One of the RIAI manifesto is: “RIAI | Promoting and Supporting Professionally Qualified Irish Architects“

    This is clear enough, isn’t it? You may argue that representing is not only promoting and supporting, but following this RIAI manifesto, it is evident that self-trained architects are not part of the promotion, not receiving any support. It has even been proved that in the contrary they are denigrated and discriminated by the institute…

    I am saying that the RIAI was supporting and promoting only some qualified architects (MRIAI), that the building control Act imposed on the institute that established self-trained should be considered for registration, that the RIAI has used strong lobbying methods to ensure that the Act would not include a grand-father clause, and that examinations organized and supervised by MRIAI would be compulsory.

    The institute which was officially and still is unofficially opposed to self-taught architects being registered is now setting the standards through the ARAE and the Technical Assessment…

    My earlier point was that the double statute / double function, which consists in one hand of registration and regulation and on the other hand of supporting and promoting MRIAI, is in direct conflict during the transition period of registration. Period which is characterized by the RIAI automatically registering its members when making things very difficult and unaffordable for the others…

    The RIAI actual lobbying against the Building Control Ammendment Bill 2010 is just a continuation of this process. Is it legal or illegal, I am not the right person to answer this question. Is it ethical? surely not…

    #815822
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    F.Y.I. Onq

    The Royal Institute of Architects of Ireland (RIAI) is the representative body for professionally qualified architects in Ireland.

    http://www.intute.ac.uk/cgi-bin/fullrecord.pl?handle=artifact2249

    RIAI Representing Professionally Qualified Irish Architects

    http://www.conservationletterfrack.ie/html/links1.html

    I can find more exemple if you need… Do you get it now ONQ?

    #815823
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:

    F.Y.I. Onq

    The Royal Institute of Architects of Ireland (RIAI) is the representative body for professionally qualified architects in Ireland.
    http://www.intute.ac.uk/cgi-bin/fullrecord.pl?handle=artifact2249

    RIAI Representing Professionally Qualified Irish Architects
    http://www.conservationletterfrack.ie/html/links1.html

    I can find more exemple if you need… Do you get it now ONQ?

    You still don’t get it CK.

    The references you cited were from third party sites, not the RIAI.

    You should know by now to get the most authoritative references, CK.

    ================================

    http://www.riai.ie/about_the_riai

    The RIAI is the Regulatory and support body for Architects in Ireland. Support services are also provided for architectural Technicians.

    Although the RIAI carries out a statutory function as the Registration Body and Competent Authority for Architects in Ireland this is carried out on an entirely self-funding basis. The RIAI does not receive any Government Funding or State Aid for this Statutory Function

    Since 1839 the RIAI has been committed to upholding the highest standards in architecture and providing impartial and authorative advice and information in issues affecting architects, the built environment and society.

    Our main roles are:

    * Promoting architecture
    * Supporting architects and architectural technicians
    * Regulating architects
    * Protecting the consumer

    ================================

    See anything there about “representing” architects? No.
    And you have to admit that “supporting” could mean anything.
    Also note the bit about “regulating” architects – that’s important.
    Because you cannot “regulate” and “represent” at the same time.

    The RIAI is a regulatory body that offers support – it doesn’t represent its members.
    Which may come as a big surprise to the usual assortment of golf playing alcoholics here.

    ONQ.

    #815824
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    The “competent authority” RIAI cannot spell the word “authorative” properly.
    At the risk of being called a spell-lamer, its a-u-t-h-o-r-i-t-a-t-i-v-e
    Also one doesn’t give information “in issues” but “on issues”.

    Their Advertisement writer must have written this page.
    How would that go again if the shoe were on the other foot?
    “Would you trust someone who couldn’t spell to design your building?”

    ONQ

    #815825
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @onq wrote:

    “Would you trust someone who couldn’t spell to design your building?”

    You’re really scrapping the barrel now! :p

    #815826
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @DOC wrote:

    You’re really scrapping the barrel now! :p

    I’m sorry, but only Qualified Barrel scrapers can scrape barrels in Ireland.

    All the old duffers who have been scraping barrels for thirty years can leave.

    Those who want to stay have to pass the new Barrel Scrapers Exam Course.

    ONQ.

Viewing 20 posts - 801 through 820 (of 1,243 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.