The sensitive issue of the title "Architect" and the Buildin
- This topic has 1,242 replies, 62 voices, and was last updated 12 years, 11 months ago by
Anonymous.
- AuthorPosts
- August 19, 2010 at 7:33 pm #815787
Anonymous
Inactive@vca wrote:
The fact that 80% of the complaints received by the RIAI are related to unqualified people claiming to be architects is the figure for 2009.
http://architecturenow.ie/news/?article=746.Hi VCA,
I talk to some MRIAI before, and generaly they have stonger arguments than yours… Also they express themselves with more maturity… Your arguments give me doubts on who you really are… Probably a student willing to become architect…
Your previous link goes directly to an article written by the RIAI… They are representing their members and for this reason are trying to discredit the others… Some of their statements have already been forbidden because of a misleading content. My guess is that the same apply to the pseudo-survey. Would you believe a survey carried out by a company to demonstrate that their services are better than the ones of their competitors? Someone needs to be really naïve to believe such a survey. The RIAI calls me unqualified, but I have a master degree and many others are in my situation… They also call engineers, technicians and surveyors unqualified, despite the 3 to 7 years studies that they followed…
@vca wrote:
Does CK have a reference for accessing the Law Society’s records of their legal procedures broken down by profession and by unqualified person / RIAI member as claimed by CK’s solicitor?
In relation to the validity of my solicitor’s information… This can be verified in court if necessary…
@vca wrote:
The proposed fee for the TAB is a fraction of what a third level education in architecture would cost and equates with about five years of professional institute fees. Why do the unqualified people still want something for nothing?
In addition on what basis does CK consider the proposed examinations / assessments as being inappropriate? They seem entirely appropriate and fair to me.
Do you mean that it is about money? I thought that it was about skills…. The ARAE is the most expensive examination for architects’ registration in the world… It cost €11,500 + €2,000 for seminaries, instead of €3,500 in the Netherlands and around €4,000 in the US… Then yes, you must be right… It is about money.
The ARAE would require a professional running a business to zap during 8 to 10 months from his current practice and get involved with examination subjects which are completely foreign to his workload. How do you find €13,500 and zap from your current source of revenue when you have children and a family depending on you? You must have a big load of savings for doing that… The Dutch examination is much more appropriate and much more practical… The problem being that many MRIAI are out of work at the moment and that some new occupations are necessary to keep them busy and keep their bank accounts positive…
August 19, 2010 at 9:46 pm #815788Anonymous
InactiveCK
It is really quite simple but I am guessing that there may be a language problem and something is getting lost in translation for you.
I provided a source for my claims which you dismiss as pseudo. You also mentioned in a separate post that you would like to see the results of an independent survey despite your later claim that there is allegedly one already carried out by the Law Society.
When I asked you to provide a source for the claims allegedly being made by your solicitor your reply is:
“In relation to the validity of my solicitor’s information… This can be verified in court if necessary…”
What court? You need to do better than that!
August 20, 2010 at 9:37 am #815789Anonymous
Inactive@vca wrote:
CK
It is really quite simple but I am guessing that there may be a language problem and something is getting lost in translation for you.
I provided a source for my claims which you dismiss as pseudo. You also mentioned in a separate post that you would like to see the results of an independent survey despite your later claim that there is allegedly one already carried out by the Law Society.
I though that as an architect you would not be too simplistic VCA… And even as a student you should not be too simplistic if you want to obtain your degrees… All you provided is an article where the RIAI makes an unverified declaration about complaints addressed to them… My question was “Would you believe a survey carried out by a company and demonstrating that this company’ services are better than the ones of its competitors?”…
@vca wrote:
When I asked you to provide a source for the claims allegedly being made by your solicitor your reply is:
“In relation to the validity of my solicitor’s information… This can be verified in court if necessary…”
What court? You need to do better than that!
My solicitor is informing me sometimes. We are also friends and I never paid for her services in relation to all the registration assistance that she gave me. She organized a meeting with a barrister for me when the RIAI was trying to prevent my practice being listed in the Golden Pages. I have no reason to doubt her information about legal actions taken against architects. She obtained this information when one of her colleagues was working on a case against a MRIAI who had no qualification at all, probably someone from the Minster’s list. She also told me that a percentage of MRIAI were not qualified despite the RIAI claiming to represent qualified architects… Why would she lie on this matter? I do not have access to the files, but if there is a court case against the RIAI, I am sure that this will come out…
There is a group named Architects’ Alliance, you must have heard about them… They are preparing themselves for a legal challenge to the Irish court if necessary… Personally, Depending on the result of the proposed amendment to the BCA 2007, I may lodge a complaint to the European Court because I feel that Section 22 of the Act and the ARAE route are discriminating against workers freedom of movements as imposed by the E.C. Treaty.
August 20, 2010 at 9:44 am #815790Anonymous
Inactive@vca wrote:
MRIAI and Proud and my cheeks are burning!
You mean you went and slapped yourself?
(shakes head)
What I do know is that:
1. ONQ was banned from boards.ie. I quote a posting of ONQ’s from askaboutmoney.ie (ONQ is omnipresent).
“BTW, best not to mention my name over on boards.ie. I got banned from there for posting long informative replies to questions……………
This is an ad hominen attack – go for the man, not his arguments – is this your idea of a rebuttal of my reference to your lack of knowledge?
I gave extended, informative replies on Boards that weren’t appreciated by the people running the planning forum there, who had theirown way of doing things.
The really funny thing about the thread you referred to is that I was thanked on it by several people for the extent and excellence of my advice.
BTW, people who lead with ad hominem attacks are usually bottom of the barrel posters – I’ll expect a few straw man arguments next.2. Not every single MRIAI is inherently incompetent as a result of joining that professional institute.
This is a straw man argument – no one alleged that this is the case.
The below comment does not apply to the many competent RIAI Members, but it points out the inequity of a law that AUTOMATICALLY registers all Members of an Institute.
As I posted before several times, I have come up against MRIAI members on many occassions –- carrying our remedial work to buildings they had certified,
- enlightening them as to the role of the Building Control Office in compliance matters,
- fighting and winning appeals against entrances with demonstrably substandard sightlines that should never have gotten permission
– you name it.
I have a theory that these geniuses may have been competent on the day they did their Part III – I’ll give that process the benefit of the doubt.
Since then the wide palette of competence this required has narrowed to whatever special interest or discipline they currently pursue.
Either that or the ones I end up dealing with are just certifying in a negligent manner or certifying fraudulently – you choose.3. Not every single Irish person calling themselves an architect without any formal qualifications is inherently competent to provide professional services commensurate with a registered architect.
This is a straw man argument – no one alleged that this is the case.
Not every person, when challenged spews this amount of waffle to distract people.
But then, there is you, the exception that proves the rule.BTW, the provision of services isn’t regulated.
And, according to John Graby, this is unlikely to change any time soon.
Where then is the protection for members of the public, as opposed to “sanctifying” Architecture?4. There are over 2000 MRIAI’s in Ireland. Using Architect’s Alliance figures there are approximately 200 unregistered people offering ‘architecture-light’ services in Ireland. 80% of complaints received by the RIAI annually actually relate to unregistered people whose clients have nowhere else to turn to.
Don’t believe all you read in the papers, but do try and access current figures from your own Institute.
There are 2,850 MRIAI’s according to John Graby’s last count at the Joint Oireachtas Committee on the Environment of 18th May 2010.
The EU figures confirm that there are around 1,000 persons practising as unregistered architects in Ireland.
This does not appear to encompass the 30,000 or so engineers, many of whom supply architectural services.
Furthermore it does not appear to encompass the 15,000 or so Architectural Technicians, all of whom supply architectural services.
The 20% – 80% figures are not even relevant, since the Disciplinary Committee has been defunct for two years now and the new structures for dealing with complaints about Architects are not in place.Does your 200 total refers to an interview given by Brian Montaut in a recent newspaper interview?
This only relates figures he decided to release for tactical reasons regarding core Membership of one organization.
There are many adherents and supporters of that organization, all of which supply architectural services, and many others who are not affiliated – most are in fear of the current heavy-handed, monolithic, law.
More importantly, that organisation, the Architects Alliance of Ireland, does not purport to represent all the unqualified persons who are acting as architects in Ireland, only some of them – but in general its aims are their aims.For the record, there is nothing “architecture light” about the services I offer, which includes the ability to debate the subject, as opposed to raising straw man arguments and making ad hominem attacks.
You do the math because “as an MRIAI fool who cannot count” I would probably be wrong in estimating that there is a forty fold likelihood of encountering problems by engaging an unregistered architect.
Hmmm. Okay lazybones, I’ll do the math.
Who, apart from MRIAI’s provides architectural services in Ireland, including making designign buildings, planning applications, master plans, fire certs, etc?- 33,000 Engineers
- 15,000 Technicians
- 1,000 Unregistered Architects
I have omitted the tens of thousands of “draughtsmen” who will “draw up some plans” for €300 for an extension, without having visited the house once and who do this as a sideline, undercutting people practising in the profession.
Assuming all these figures are current and correct and please feel free to rebut if you can;-
The 80% of complaints registered may arise from 49,000 persons practising in Ireland.
Only 1,000 of these claim to be architects.
That’s almost 1/ 50thBut its 1/ 50th of 80%, which is 1.6%, let’s say 2% for arguments sake.
So, maybe 2% from unqualified architects versus 20% arising from MRIAI’s.
You appear to be ten times more likely to get a complaint arising from an MRIAI.
Even if you said only half the engineers act in planning matters the population drops to 32,500 of which 1,000 are unregistered architects.
Even if you only allow that half the technicians do planning work outside a main office [two chances of this] the population drops to 25,000 of which 1,000 are unregistered architects.
So a realistic figure is 1/25th of 80%, which is 3.2% , or about 1/6th of the 20% attributable to MRIAIs.
On the face of it, it looks as though – per capita, and allowing for all the other providers of architectural services, unqualified success is deserved.
You could of course develop the argument still further, suggesting that only the technicians would be referred to the RIAI because the Engineers would be referred to their institute.
You could say that technicians don’t make mistakes in planning and design matters which would raise the errors attributable to unregistered architects.
But all of this conveniently forgets that the 20% figure could be low because people don’t have much faith in the Institute as a body that will censure architects.
To be fair, some complaints could be from disgrunted persons who are peeved at their architect for reasons unrelated to the provision of services – arrogance, poor tempter, etc. – we just don’t know.
This is because we cannot check any of these figures, because John Graby confirmed these are all dealt with on a confidential basis.
This means that the public learn nothing about the persons involved or the process and that’s just the way the professions like it, because some of the more egregious errors would make your hair stand on end.
One thing we do know is that registration does not protect members of the public, because there is no disciplinary body in place to deal with complaints.
Another thing we know is that even if there were such a body, it would be limited to dealing with the alleged 20% of complaints arising from Members of the Institute.
Finally, we also know that some people do not make complaints to the Institute because it is perceived as a generally useless exercise – my own experience confirms this.
For the record, this was the kind of joined up thinking for which I was banned from the Planning forum on boards.
ONQ.August 20, 2010 at 11:01 am #815791Anonymous
InactiveONQ
I think that the award for straw man arguments would have to go to your fellow ’tilting at windmills’ comrade CK. I am not worthy of such an accolade.
As for ad homineum debating styles may I respectfully suggest that you might re-read some of your own posts with a more critical and self-questioning assessment – skills that I hope you posess as a trained and qualified architect.
I suspected that your goal was to silence any opposition of your position by bombast and your response above (along with your other 500+ postings) has convinced me that this is the case.
I believe this to be the reason that you were barred from other online discussion forums and the reason that I am unwilling to engage in any further futile debate with you.
I am going back to my life with my tail between my self-slapped cheeks.
Adieu CK and ONQ
August 20, 2010 at 11:11 am #815792Anonymous
Inactive@vca wrote:
ONQ
I think that the award for straw man arguments would have to go to your fellow ’tilting at windmills’ comrade CK. I am not worthy of such an accolade.
As for ad homineum debating styles may I respectfully suggest that you might re-read some of your own posts with a more critical and self-questioning assessment – skills that I hope you posess as a trained and qualified architect.
I suspected that your goal was to silence any opposition of your position by bombast and your response above (along with your other 500+ postings) has convinced me that this is the case.
I believe this to be the reason that you were barred from other online discussion forums and the reason that I am unwilling to engage in any further futile debate with you.
I am going back to my life with my tail between my self-slapped cheeks.
Adieu CK and ONQ
Thanks for your poor contribution…
August 20, 2010 at 2:35 pm #815793Anonymous
Inactive@vca wrote:
ONQ
I think that the award for straw man arguments would have to go to your fellow ’tilting at windmills’ comrade CK. I am not worthy of such an accolade.Translated as :”I’ve been rumbled, I have no defense, I’d better do some stand up comedy routines instead…”
As for ad homineum debating styles may I respectfully suggest that you might re-read some of your own posts with a more critical and self-questioning assessment – skills that I hope you posess as a trained and qualified architect.
Translated as: “I know, I’ll do two ad hominems at once and diss his posts, that’ll put him on the back foot…”
I suspected that your goal was to silence any opposition of your position by bombast and your response above (along with your other 500+ postings) has convinced me that this is the case.
Translated as: “My bombast failed so I’ll accuse him of doing what I tried to do…”
I believe this to be the reason that you were barred from other online discussion forums and the reason that I am unwilling to engage in any further futile debate with you.
Translated as: “I’ll throw in a scurrilous allegation disguised as an ad hominem and try to salvage my dignity and beat a hasty retreat…”
I am going back to my life with my tail between my self-slapped cheeks.
Translated as: “Okay, forget about the dignity part – I like slapping my butt-cheeks too much – now where are my Lederhosen …”
Adieu CK and ONQ
Translated as: “I’ll be back for more slapping when I have rubbed on some ointment…”
So long, VCA, I hardly knew you…ONQ.
August 23, 2010 at 9:22 pm #815794Anonymous
InactiveMISINFORMATION ABOUT THE REGISTER – AND THE FACTS
THE TECHNICAL ASSESSMENT PROCESS IS NOT INDEPENDENT
Answer: The process is completely separate from the RIAI.
RIAI, as Registration Body, does not have a role in the assessment of those not having architectural qualifications or the decisions
taken. The responsibility is that of the independent Technical Assessment Board which has four non-architects appointed by the
Minister for the Environment, three architects nominated by the RIAI and a Chairperson/Barrister nominated again by the Minister. The
Board has appointed panels of expert architects to provide an opinion on the submissions received but the Board has the right to
accept, reject or to seek further information on any application.
There is also full independent appeals mechanism. This includes an internal independent Statutory Appeals Board, again with a
majority of non-architects and a Chairperson who is required to be a Barrister or retired High Court Judge. Appeals can be made on
procedural or substantive grounds.IT TAKES TOO LONG / IT IS TOO DEMANDING
Answer: It can be done in your spare time in as little as two months. You can also take as long as you need.
The RIAI ran a pilot study in late 2007 and 2008 in order to test procedures. A period of two months was given to prepare submissions and those who participated did not find this particularly difficult but gave the view that four months would be preferable. This was at a
time of an unprecedented level of activity in the construction industry; all those who submitted were working full time, so the applications were prepared in their spare time. The application forms, information papers and standard C.V. templates have been available on the
RIAI website since November 2009.TOO EXPENSIVE
Answer: This is law and is necessary. While there is a cost, there is nothing extra being charged.
Assessment of those not having architectural qualifications, as a once off exercise, is necessarily a complex process with the need for a whole range of checks and balances, audit trails etc. A detailed report on costs has been submitted to the Minister as all costs have to be approved. The cost being proposed, of the order of €6,300 is the actual cost to the RIAI as the Registration Body. RIAI receives no State funding; the process is required to be self-funding. The costs have been investigated and audited by an independent firm of Accountants experienced in forensic work and this has also
been submitted to the Minister for his decision.THIS IS ELITIST AND ARCHITECTS ARE LOOKING AFTER THEMSELVES
Answer: This is completely incorrect. It is the Amendment that seeks to serve special interests.
Far from being elitist, the process is completely inclusive. It already has a grandfather process to accommodate good competent non
qualified persons. The Technical Assessment is completely independent and does not disadvantage anyone in the process. In fact, the
only people worried about this are those who are unwilling to have their work independently assessed. This is not in the public interest.THE BAR HAD BEEN SET TOO HIGH
Answer: Again incorrect. All the process looks for is minimum architectural standards.
The bar is simply that of equivalence with an architect and this is defined as:• Whether the applicant has performed the duties commensurate with that of an architect.
• Whether the work submitted in equivalent to the work of an architect, having regard to the scale complexity and quality.
• Whether or not the work submitted was realised by the applicant and if not totally responsible what responsibility could be
established.
• Whether the applicant can comply with the competencies specified in Article 46 of the Professional Qualifications Directive.
What is required is compliance with the average level of the work of an architect not award winning architects but simply the general
average and no more than that. Articles 46 sets out the basic requirements for the formation of an architect across the EU.
Assessment criteria are not absolute in that the Technical Assessment Board comes to a reasoned judgment; for example not
necessarily all the competences set out in Article 46 have to be covered in full.IT PUTS PEOPLE OUT OF BUSINESS
Answer: This will not prevent anyone working, whether they are registered or not.
The Act does prevent those not on the Register from using the title architect but it does not limit or control in any way the functions of those providing services in the field of architecture. Quite a number of firms that might have described themselves as engineers and architects have changed titles to titles such as engineers and building design professionals or building and planning design consultants
etc.
The Technical Assessment process is completely independent and any competent professional, who is willing to have that competence independently assessed has nothing to fear.August 23, 2010 at 9:32 pm #815795admin
Keymaster@vca wrote:
TOO EXPENSIVE
Answer: This is law and is necessary. While there is a cost, there is nothing extra being charged.
Assessment of those not having architectural qualifications, as a once off exercise, is necessarily a complex process with the need for a whole range of checks and balances, audit trails etc. A detailed report on costs has been submitted to the Minister as all costs have to be approved. The cost being proposed, of the order of €6,300 is the actual cost to the RIAI as the Registration Body. RIAI receives no State funding; the process is required to be self-funding. The costs have been investigated and audited by an independent firm of Accountants experienced in forensic work and this has also
been submitted to the Minister for his decision.I take issue with this; I recently qualified in another built environment profession. The examination process cost £275; I worked very hard for 2 years to get through this and with a lot of experience I was lucky enough to pass first time; to prove it is not a doddle all fellow candidates had relevant professional undergraduate or masters conversion course degrees; the failure rate is still 40%.
€6,300 is an unfair restraint on trade in my book; the RIAI should be performing this function not a private body.
August 23, 2010 at 9:45 pm #815796Anonymous
Inactive@vca wrote:
MISINFORMATION ABOUT THE REGISTER – AND THE FACTS
THE TECHNICAL ASSESSMENT PROCESS IS NOT INDEPENDENT
Answer: The process is completely separate from the RIAI.
RIAI, as Registration Body, does not have a role in the assessment of those not having architectural qualifications or the decisions
taken. The responsibility is that of the independent Technical Assessment Board which has four non-architects appointed by the
Minister for the Environment, three architects nominated by the RIAI and a Chairperson/Barrister nominated again by the Minister. The
Board has appointed panels of expert architects to provide an opinion on the submissions received but the Board has the right to
accept, reject or to seek further information on any application.
There is also full independent appeals mechanism. This includes an internal independent Statutory Appeals Board, again with a
majority of non-architects and a Chairperson who is required to be a Barrister or retired High Court Judge. Appeals can be made on
procedural or substantive grounds.IT TAKES TOO LONG / IT IS TOO DEMANDING
Answer: It can be done in your spare time in as little as two months. You can also take as long as you need.
The RIAI ran a pilot study in late 2007 and 2008 in order to test procedures. A period of two months was given to prepare submissions and those who participated did not find this particularly difficult but gave the view that four months would be preferable. This was at a
time of an unprecedented level of activity in the construction industry; all those who submitted were working full time, so the applications were prepared in their spare time. The application forms, information papers and standard C.V. templates have been available on the
RIAI website since November 2009.TOO EXPENSIVE
Answer: This is law and is necessary. While there is a cost, there is nothing extra being charged.
Assessment of those not having architectural qualifications, as a once off exercise, is necessarily a complex process with the need for a whole range of checks and balances, audit trails etc. A detailed report on costs has been submitted to the Minister as all costs have to be approved. The cost being proposed, of the order of €6,300 is the actual cost to the RIAI as the Registration Body. RIAI receives no State funding; the process is required to be self-funding. The costs have been investigated and audited by an independent firm of Accountants experienced in forensic work and this has also
been submitted to the Minister for his decision.THIS IS ELITIST AND ARCHITECTS ARE LOOKING AFTER THEMSELVES
Answer: This is completely incorrect. It is the Amendment that seeks to serve special interests.
Far from being elitist, the process is completely inclusive. It already has a grandfather process to accommodate good competent non
qualified persons. The Technical Assessment is completely independent and does not disadvantage anyone in the process. In fact, the
only people worried about this are those who are unwilling to have their work independently assessed. This is not in the public interest.THE BAR HAD BEEN SET TOO HIGH
Answer: Again incorrect. All the process looks for is minimum architectural standards.
The bar is simply that of equivalence with an architect and this is defined as:• Whether the applicant has performed the duties commensurate with that of an architect.
• Whether the work submitted in equivalent to the work of an architect, having regard to the scale complexity and quality.
• Whether or not the work submitted was realised by the applicant and if not totally responsible what responsibility could be
established.
• Whether the applicant can comply with the competencies specified in Article 46 of the Professional Qualifications Directive.
What is required is compliance with the average level of the work of an architect not award winning architects but simply the general
average and no more than that. Articles 46 sets out the basic requirements for the formation of an architect across the EU.
Assessment criteria are not absolute in that the Technical Assessment Board comes to a reasoned judgment; for example not
necessarily all the competences set out in Article 46 have to be covered in full.IT PUTS PEOPLE OUT OF BUSINESS
Answer: This will not prevent anyone working, whether they are registered or not.
The Act does prevent those not on the Register from using the title architect but it does not limit or control in any way the functions of those providing services in the field of architecture. Quite a number of firms that might have described themselves as engineers and architects have changed titles to titles such as engineers and building design professionals or building and planning design consultants
etc.
The Technical Assessment process is completely independent and any competent professional, who is willing to have that competence independently assessed has nothing to fear.VCA, you sound like RIAI propaganda, however, The RIAI lobbying leaflet fails to address many issues:
1) The leaflet completely ignores the long and very expensive registration route (E13,500) through the ARAE. This is to my knowledge the most onerous registration procedure in Europe, the US, Canada, Australia, China, and so on. There is maybe one or two dictatures in the world that have more expensive routes to register, but this is not even confirmed yet.
2) The actual qualitative standards to assess applicants without formal qualifications are set by the RIAI itself. The RIAI represents professionally qualified architects and it is against the interests of its members to let those without formal qualification infiltrating the club. Many MRIAI would fail the ARAE, why does the Institute wants us to be more competent than its present members?
3) The leaflet claims that those who cannot use the title architect will be able to continue practicing. However, anyone from the profession who is honest on this subject will admit that practicing as an architect without being able to use the title is unpractical and inappropriate. In the relation title versus function/profession, we are stripped from many of our rights, many of our abilities to practice. This phenomenon will increase in the future with new policies and legislations to come within planning and construction law. The practitioners who are now unable to use the title “Architect†are regarded as unwanted competition. They are subject to pressures to abandon their businesses and profession. What is their future during the difficult times to come? They have no institute where to seek advice, no code of conduct to guide their actions. These practitioners must be considered.
4) The leaflet denigrates that the MRIAI are privileged by the Act even when members of the RIAI have paid the lowest fees for registration.The Registration Body was already informing the public about the necessity for an architect to be registered when the registration was in place for RIAI members only, and not for other applicants. There are many indications to suggest that the RIAI is using its position as the registration body to promote its members. In November 2008, the RIAI tried to prevent practitioners without formal qualification to be listed in the Golden Pages, when the registration procedure was not yet in place. Following protests against this discrimination, it was agreed by the Golden Pages Legal team that the registration procedure not being fully in place, the advertising listing in the Golden Pages would continue as before the legislation. What will happen to those who cannot register when prevented from listing their practice in the Golden Pages? How can they continue to practice when being deprived from such rights? Following a complaint lodged by Architects’ Alliance, a RIAI advertising campaign promoting the new Register of architects has been deemed misleading after the broadcasting watchdog found that it implied that “unqualified” architects could not be trusted. Architects’ Alliance also made a successful complaint to the National Consumer Agency regarding misleading RIAI information published online. During these difficult economical times, when many members of the RIAI are unemployed, the Registration Body has launched a repression against unwanted competitors. The Building
Control Act 2007 has become a powerful instrument against those who do not have the required profile.In 1997, the Strategic Review Committee (of the Construction Industry) identified the need for a grandfather clause in relation to any legislation that would regulate the profession of architects. This was not recommended by David Keane fellow member of the RIAI and barrister. Many countries in Europe and in other parts of the world have implemented registration without discriminating established practices. Prior to making registration compulsory, many countries have automatically registered experienced practitioners, whatever their background and whatever their academic qualification. Our researches within European States on this subject (see the following of this post), revealed that four out of five countries have protected existing businesses by providing automatic registration to established practices. The fifth country, which did not provide an automatic registration of experienced practitioners within its legislation, provided instead an affordable and a very practical examination.
In Ireland, the Building Control Act 2007 offers automatic registration to practitioners with some academic qualifications as detailed in the Directive 2005/36/EC, but to no one else. There is no practical examination, but only unaffordable and inappropriate procedures of assessment for practitioners without formal qualification. As per the Act, established practitioners without formal qualification are requested to gain all of their experience within the State, when those with qualifications listed in the Directive 2005/36/EC can gain all of their experience abroad if they want to, or within the State if they prefer. What is the logic behind this double standard? Why are the skills of some competent professionals ignored because gained in practice rather than in university?
When the policy of statutory registration for architects was debated, The Competition
Authority argued strenuously that the registration body should be completely independent of professional representation. This was precisely to avoid conflicts of interest arising between the RIAI’s dual roles as regulator and representative body. Unfortunately, The Competition Authority recommendation on this matter was not adequately considered. The Royal Institute of the Architects of Ireland was appointed as the Registration body, despite the obvious conflict between its new role and the interests of its existing members. The RIAI is discriminating outsiders. Inappropriate and unfair procedures were implemented.The system is such, that today a foreign architect registered in another EU country, may establish his practice as an architect in the Republic of Ireland without any experience, without any knowledge of the State regulations and legislations. However, Irish citizens and/or Irish residents with many years of experience practicing architecture in the State, are prevented to use the title “Architectâ€.
Many countries have protected the title “Architect†or the profession before the Irish Building Control Act 2007. Within the Republic of Ireland, the legislation and its implementation has discriminated established practitioners who do not have the relevant academic qualification. For the purpose of comparing the Irish system to other countries, we have compiled information on how registration was implemented in France, United Kingdom, Italy, Belgium, and The Netherlands. We were unable to access the relevant legislations in Spain where access to the legislation was denied to us without any valuable reason and in Germany because of linguistic issues.
a) The implementation of architects’ registration in France
In France the legislation regulating the practice of architecture is dated from the 3rd of
January 1977. The name of the legislation is: “Loi n°77-2 du 3 janvier 1977 sur l’architecture â€.
The legislation regulates the practice of architecture rather than the title “Architectâ€.
Article 37 of the legislation permitted established self-trained practitioners with five years of experience in the field of architecture gained prior to the publication of the law to be automatically listed on the French Register of Architects. The article also details the composition of a committee in charge of assessing practitioners who did not comply with the requirement of five years experienceb) The implementation of architects’ registration in The United Kingdom
In the United Kingdom, the legislation regulating the title of “Architect†is dated from 1931.
The name of the legislation is: “Architects (Registration) Act 1931â€.
Section 6 of the Act permitted self-trained architects in practice for 2 years prior to the start of the legislation to be automatically listed on the register on the condition that their application was made within 2 years from the commencement of the Actc) The implementation of architects’ registration in The Netherlands
In The Netherlands, the legislation regulating the title of “Architect†is dated from the 7th of
July 1987. The Name of the Legislation is:â€Wet op de architectentitel van 7 juli 1987â€. The legislation does not directly provide automatic registration for self-trained practitioners, but some articles include a minister exemption to the examination. Self-trained practitioners without ministerial exemption and with seven years of experience can pass a register examination. The first part of the examination includes the presentation of three projects. The second part of the examination is an essay, a thesis on a given subject.d) The implementation of architects’ registration in Italy
In Italy, the legislation regulating the practice of architecture is dated from the 24th of June
1923. The name of the legislation is: “legge 24 june 1923 No. 1395â€.
Article 9 of the legislation permitted self-taught practitioners with 10 years of experience within 6 month of the publication of the law, to be automatically listed on the Register. Article
9 also permitted those with alternative qualification in architectural design and 5 years of experience within 6 month of the publication of the law, to be automatically listed on the
Register.e) The implementation of architects’ registration in Belgium
In Belgium, the legislation regulating the practice of architecture is dated from the 20th of
February 1939. The name of the legislation is: “Loi du 20 fevrier 1939â€.
Article 7 of the legislation permitted self-taught practitioners born before the 1st of January 1907 (32 years and 2 months old) to be automatically listed on the Register. Those born between the 1st of January 1907 and the 31st of December 1916 (23 years and 2 months old) were subject to an examination prior to be listed on the Register.Many of us are passionate in their work, passionate in architecture. Our only failing is not to be in possession of a formal qualification listed in the Directive 2005/36/EC.
The Building Control Act 2007 and its implementation are threatening our rights to practice. If the Act is not amended, we are prevented to use the title “Architectâ€, prevented to certify our works. Our practices will become dependent on certificates issued by other professionals who may charge unaffordable fees to deliver the service. It is more likely that the Registration Body will support new policies in the future, restricting further more our rights to practice. An ammendement of the BCA 2007 is necessary for the sake of architecture, the sake of design, the sake of our practices…August 23, 2010 at 10:10 pm #815797Anonymous
InactiveBUILDING CONTROL (AMENDMENT) BILL 2010
WHAT IS WRONG WITH THE PROPOSED AMENDMENT?
IT IS UNNECESSARYThe Building Control Act 2007 already has independent, statutory “practical experience assessment procedures†to enable those who do not have architectural qualifications, but experience to apply for Registration. What is required under this process/grandfather clause is the submission of:
1. Information on four projects prepared by the applicant over a 10 year period.
2. A C.V. showing ten years of work in the field of architecture.
3. Details of the work carried out over a 10 year period commensurate with those of an architect.
4. Information on projects for each year of the period and declarations as to the authorship of the projects and all documentation necessary to support the information.
Any reasonably competent provider of architectural services should be able to provide such information – and have no reason to avoid the process.
IT UNDERMINES CONSUMER PROTECTIONThe proposed amendment is based purely on self-declaration and quantitative, rather than qualtitative assessment. It specifically excludes any type of independent assessment of the competence of the applicant leaving it open to question.
This means ‘architects’ would be registered without reaching a required minimum standard in the interest of consumer protection. What the amendment tries to do is to serve, at the expense of the consumer, those who are unwilling to have their knowledge, skill and competences assessed by an independent Government appointed Statutory Board.IT DAMAGES THE REPUTATION OF IRISH ARCHITECTS AND ARCHITECTURE
The proposed amendment specifically excludes compliance with the basic minimum EU standards for the education of architects. Those admitted to the Register through the proposed amendment could have the right to register in EU States, which would be
contested by those States, and would cause the qualifications of every Irish architect to be questioned.
In the present economic circumstances many architectural practices and individual architects have to seek work abroad. The proposed amendment damages the internationally validated status of the Register and Irish architects with qualifications.IT DISADVANTAGES YOUNGER ARCHITECTURAL GRADUATES
The Building control Act 2007 requires, as in many of EU Member States, both a formal qualification and a professional practice qualification. The Professional Practice qualification usually takes from two to three years after graduation to complete and includes two years practical experience, a lecture course and a written and oral examination. A 35 year old architect with a qualification, would still
have to take the professional practice cycle or be exempted, in contrast with the unqualified 35 year old who can simply apply without any requirement to take a professional practice examination.
IT COULD COST THE STATE MOREThe amendment is so loosely constructed as to provide the possibility for virtually anybody working in the areas of building services, engineering etc. to apply, and given the complete absence of any objective assessment of competence to register as an architect.
Such persons, employed in local authorities, semi-states or Government could then apply for payment at the grade of architect with substantial additional costs to the State.
IT IS INCONSISTENT WITH THE REST OF LEGISLATION
The proposed amendment introduces a far lower level for registration as an architect by practical experience than is provided for in the section of the Act dealing with building surveyors and quantity surveyors which still include qualitative assessment, interview and
verification.August 24, 2010 at 11:27 am #815798Anonymous
InactiveTHE BUILDING CONTROL (AMENDMENT) BILL 2010
THE PROPOSED AMENDMENT IS NECESSARY
Thousands of practicing professionals are discriminated by the Building Control Act 2007. The Act proposes no alternative to established practitioners who are unable to register. The practitioners who are now unable to use the title “Architect†are regarded as unwanted competition. They are subject to pressures to abandon their businesses and profession. What is their future during the difficult times to come? They have no institute where to seek advice, no code of conduct to guide their actions.
THE BUILDING CONTROL ACT 2007 PROTECTS REGISTERED PROFESSIONALS RATHER THAN CONSUMERS
Registration should be implemented to protect the public, without discriminating established practitioners.
If Part 3 of the Building Control Act 2007 was drafted to protect the public from unqualified individuals, then the Act should ensure that these individuals are subject to a code of practice and that they are monitored by a regulator. But the Act does not provide for such clause. Some practices are left unconsidered to provide architectural services without the support of an Institute, without the assistance of the regulator. The BUILDING CONTROL (AMENDMENT) BILL 2010 will ensure that all practicing professionals are monitored and subject to a code of conduct.
IT DOES NOT DAMAGE THE REPUTATION OF IRISH ARCHITECTS AND ARCHITECTURE
The UK, France, Belgium, Italy like the large majority of all other European States have permitted established practitioners to register without damaging the reputation of their architects and architecture. Why would it be different in Ireland?
IT DOES NOT DISADVANTAGE YOUNGER ARCHITECTURAL GRADUATES
The BUILDING CONTROL (AMENDMENT) BILL 2010 does not disadvantage those who had the opportunity to graduate, but it insures that the others who could not afford university have the opportunity to continue practicing in all legality within the State. It is Membership of the Institute that will give graduates the right to practice abroad. The BUILDING CONTROL (AMENDMENT) BILL 2010 only requests that established practitioners can continue practicing as architects in the State, it does not seek membership of the Institute for these professionals.
IT IS A REMEDY AGAINST UNFAIR EXAMINATIONS
a) The Technical Assessment is elitist, biased and expensive
Registration through the so called Technical Assessment Board, as per Sections 21 and 22 of the Building Control Act, cost €6,500. The appeal cost €4,000. The assessment is for practitioners without formal qualification, as per Section 14.2.(h) of the Act. The applicant must be able to demonstrate 10 years of experience performing duties commensurate with those of an architect within the State prior to May 2008. It is difficult for applicants to comply with the requirements of the Technical Assessment as described in the Act. The RIAI is not facilitating applicants’ task, in the contrary. The Registration body requests that any proof of experience submitted to the Technical Assessment Board shall be verified by a registered professional involved in each project presented by the applicant. Why shall projects which did not involve a registered professional be omitted? Some documents created over a decade ago need to be provided with the verification of individuals who may have migrated or may be dead today. Many of Architects’ Alliance members have practiced on their own account without the assistance of a registered professional. Why should their skills and experience be ignored? Another issue is related to the interpretation of “duties commensurate with those of an architectâ€. An applicant with experience on small residential projects only, would not be successful for registration through the Technical Assessment. However, from a small extension to a skyscraper, isn’t it quality that the public is looking for? Isn’t the architect responsible for quality on small and large projects? Some architects are involved with large developments, some others with small developments. It is very rare that an architect is involved with both. Each established practitioner specializes in a field of architecture. Non registered architects are more frequently specializing in small developments because the government and the RIAI have erected barriers to prevent them doing otherwise. Applicants are judged on how they were managing and supervising their projects. The RIAI procedure is used as a model for quality. However, RIAI standards were never requested by law. Many self-taught architects were complying with the legislation, producing quality services, following their own procedure. Not being members of the Institute, many of us were denied the access and the use of important documents, such as RAI forms of contracts, forms of certifications and so on. How could we have followed those standards? Only those working with members of the RIAI as colleagues were able to do so. Section 14.2.(h) from Part 3 of the Building Control Act 2007, is a route for experienced professionals without academic qualification to register as architects. However, the Registration Body has closed this door setting up a very inappropriate examination.
b) The ARAE is inappropriate, biased and unaffordable
Many were not in a financial position to pay the requested fees in relation to the register examination for self-trained architects this year (ARAE). The examination is very inappropriate and elitist. The skills required during most of the examination are not reflecting the skills of experienced professionals, but those of newly qualified students in architecture. We have compared the ARAE (Republic of Ireland examination) with its Dutch equivalent. The total fees and cost all included are as follow: Dutch Register Examination: €3,065 – ARAE (Republic of Ireland examination): €13,500 There is no justification for such difference in the fees as stated above. The ARAE (Republic of Ireland examination) is over 4 times the cost of its Dutch equivalent. This is a break down of the ARAE cost:
Application cost: €2,250 – Examination cost: €9,250 – Attendance to UCD lectures: €2,000
Within the ARAE brochure, the lecture fees are not included in the examination fees. They are presented separately and cost €1,350 for those who seek membership of the RIAI. However, self-trained architects cannot seek membership prior to have been successful to the ARAE or successful to the Technical Assessment. The fees for UCD lectures requested to self-trained architects were €2,000 in 2008. It must be noted that it is not compulsory to follow the lectures for the examination, but that failure to do so would dramatically jeopardize any chance of success. The Dutch Examination for self-trained architects includes 2 parts. The first part is an interview for the presentation of 3 projects which the applicant has fully or mainly designed. The second part is a thesis on a given subject that the applicant can prepare within his office. The examination reflects the skills required within an architectural practice. In comparison, only 1 of the 3 parts forming the Register Examination in the Republic of Ireland can be pursued in an office. Most of the examination is carried out within university classrooms and other amphitheatres. The skills and knowledge required are proper to students in architecture but they are not the skills and knowledge of an experienced architect. The applicant is not assessed within his working environment. Legal information, Building Standards, Technical Guidance Documents and others that must be part of the architect’s office are not permitted during the examination. Part 1 of the ARAE has the purpose of assessing the applicants’ eligibility for the examination. It requests that all projects presented by the applicant shall be verified by a registered professional. The Building Control Act does not make such request; it is the ARAE procedure as set up by the RIAI that is demanding such verification. Section 14.2.(f) from Part 3 of the Building Control Act 2007, is a route for experienced professionals without academic qualification to register as architects. However, the Registration Body has closed this door setting up the ARAE, which is a very inappropriate examination.
The BUILDING CONTROL (AMENDMENT) BILL 2010 is a fair remedy to the above examinations. A remedy that match other European states implementation of registration.
IT WILL GIVE MORE COHERENCE TO THE REGISTRATION OF ARCHITECTS.
The Building Control Act 2007 is used by the RIAI as a tool to discriminate some competent professionals. Many practitioners were misrepresented and compared to incompetent practitioners. Irish citizens and/or Irish residents with many years of experience practicing architecture in the State are prevented to use the title “Architectâ€. However, some foreigners without working experience in the State, without knowledge of the Irish planning system and/or Irish Building Regulations can use the title in the Republic of Ireland without any difficulty, in all legality. Why are the knowledge and skills of competent local practitioners denigrated for the profit of incompetent foreigners?
August 24, 2010 at 1:44 pm #815799Anonymous
InactiveWith so much misinformation being published on this thread please find below the official response given by the RIAI to prospective Technical Assessment Board candidates’ questions.
There are lots more details at:http://www.riai.ie/admissions/technical_assessment/
The questions shown here include those posed at their briefing and questions subsequently received by the RIAI. This document will be updated as new questions are addressed through further briefings and follow-up queries.
Question / Answer
1. Do you have to demonstrate all competencies
listed?Each of the 11 competencies listed in Article 46 must be
demonstrated, but the indicators listed to clarify each of
the indicators do not all have to be addressed. A ‘critical
mass’ of the relevant indicators is required to
demonstrate each competency.
2. What if some of the work used is outside the
State?
It is OK to use work outside the State to demonstrate
some of the competencies in Article 46 if appropriate,
but work outside the State cannot be used to
demonstrate the 10-year requirement. (Building Control
Act, Section 22(1).3. What about work done in the State when
employed abroad?Work carried out in the State while based/employed
abroad cannot be used to demonstrate the 10-year
requirement. The principle underlying the process set
out in the Act is that persons who were based/employed
in other jurisdictions could have availed of the
opportunity to Register there. The Technical
Assessment process is designed specifically to
accommodate persons based in this State where no
such route was available. Work done in the State while
based/employed abroad may be used to demonstrate
competencies in Article 46.4. Are projects to be presented restricted to project
work where a building is the outcome? What
about, for example, analysis of structures carried
out as an expert witness for court cases?This type of work (i.e. where a building is not the
outcome) can be included, but other projects will be
necessary to cover the remaining competencies
5. What about construction qualifications (not in
architecture), can they be listed to demonstrate
competencies?Yes. Learning in a variety of fields, including the
humanities, could be used to demonstrate elements of
some competencies.6. Is there a deadline for submission?
No
7. Can projects completed or carried out after 1 May
2008 be included?Answer pending legal advice
8. In the information on projects section, what do
you do with experience beyond the 10-year
minimum?You are free to include it. The 10 years is a minimum
and all experience before 1 May 2008 is relevant.9. Verification – what is the limit on what a client can
verify?
Clients can verify up to the level of their own expertise.
So a client can judge certain issues they will have
witnessed but not, for example, technical aspects in
general.10. Are design team members suitable as verifiers?
Yes, up to the level of their involvement and expertise.
11. What about work completed after 1 May 2008?
(argues that work past 1 May 2008 should be
included for demonstrating competencies)
Answer pending legal advice12. Can we take that as fact now?
Answer pending legal advice.
13. Would that include CPD courses post 1 May
2008?Answer pending legal advice
14. If there has been one employer overseeing all the
work, is one verifier /verification acceptable?Yes, but the verification must explicitly cover all relevant
claims made.15. Can we include supporting documents to expand
on the references in the competencies index?The range of supporting documentation that may be
submitted is wide and is set out in the Guidance for
Applicants.16. More than one source of verification is
recommended, but if there was one employer for
the whole period, is that adequate?Yes, as long as the verification explicitly lists all claims
being verified.17. In some cases the Index uses terms that are of a
higher order than those required in the
competences in Article 46.The points were first drafted pre-1985 for the Architects
Directive and then replicated in the Qualifications
Directive. Since that time there has been substantial
development and refinement of the theory and
terminology relating to evaluation of learning. It is this
terminology that was used in development of the
indicators. In addition, where evaluation is to be based
on practical experience rather than academic
examination ‘ability’, which can be demonstrated by
performance, is a more appropriate measure of a
competence.18. What if you can demonstrate 90% of the
competences but not 10%?Under the terms of the Act all 11 competencies listed in
Article 46 must be demonstrated. However, within each
of those 11 competencies there is room for judgement
that the critical mass has been reached without fully
demonstrating all elements. The Assessors will be
trained in this area and the Board has an oversight role
to ensure the requirements are being applied
appropriately19. Why are there no grades applied i.e. 70% or 80% ?
This is a ‘demonstrated/not demonstrated’ test based on
the overall judgement of three Assessors in the first
instance. It is the competencies for Article 46 that must
be demonstrated in full, not all of the 63 indicators used
to explain and clarify them.20. With regard to employer reference, what can be
done when the employment was some time ago
and the employer can’t be found?Use everything you can that is relevant and helpful and
do your best to get appropriate verifications. You can
only get what is possible/available.21. What about an employer 35 years ago?
As at 20 above. Ideally the focus would be on more
recent work as that is the work most likely to
demonstrate your highest skill level.22. What about including all elements of the entire
schedule of works, should these be included?Only include what is relevant to your demonstration of
the criteria and can be verified.23. If I’m self employed do I need references for
absolutely everything?
Only for the elements you are seeking to demonstrate.
24. Information on projects – If, for instance, I don’t
have the full cost of a project, for example a
housing estate project I participated in but was
not in overall control of, do I have to find out the
full information?No. Just provide sufficient information for the Assessors
to form a reasonably accurate picture of the scale and
type of project.25. Are the competences “weighted†(either the parts
of Article 46 or the 63 indicators)?No
26. Does the application fee cover the cost of an
appeal?
No27. If an application fails to demonstrate the 10years
does the assessment stop (and is a refund
made)?No. Under the system as set out in the Act all criteria
are assessed at once. Only the expert Assessors can
really make a judgement on whether or not the work
was at the required level for the required period of time.
The Act does not provide for stages in the assessment
or for any purely administrative assessment of the 10-
year criterion.28. If you have concentrated entirely on residential
work, will that be a problem?Possibly. ‘Scale and complexity’ are covered in the
criteria and there may be a difficulty in demonstrating
them with a limited portfolio. It will be a matter of
judgment.29. Will there be a priority system for applicants i.e. if
my business is at risk can I be assessed sooner
than others?No. Applications will be processed in the order in which
they are received.30. How do I demonstrate an ‘awareness’ of
something?
The project analysis section provides for this by allowing
for reflection.31. Could I write a paragraph into the index against
an element to demonstrate the necessary
awareness?Unfortunately not. Based on legal advice, the Index can
only reference documents contained in the Submission.
It cannot contain any additional information.
32. How do I show I know about different types of
contracts I have not actually used?Use the project analysis section.
33. Can an applicant address in the interview certain
issues not addressed properly in the written
submission?The assessors will have a set of issues to cover in the
interview, but applicants will also be given the
opportunity to raise issues.34. How can I demonstrate how strongly I feel about
architecture and my role as an architect?If it can’t be covered in the written submission, it should
be possible to convey your commitment in the interview.35. What about the 10 years – how can I be sure
when they started from the assessors perspective?The early years probably won’t be as good as the later
years. Progress is to be expected so the assessors
won’t be looking for an identical level for the entire
period.36. In what circumstances would the Board made a
decision to re-interview a candidate? Surely not
at all, logically?The decision to re-interview lies with the Board. There
will probably be circumstances when the Board
considers a second interview appropriate, either to
clarify matters and satisfy itself with regard to an opinion
of the assessors, or as a general measure of assurance
that they are satisfied with the standard being applied.
37. If we fail, can we do the assessment again?No. The option is to appeal, pursue the Register
Admission Examination (or any other route that might
apply in an individual case) or consider a change of title.38. I am self employed for almost 9 years. How do I
prove authorship?Verifications by a combination of clients and other
professionals such as structural engineers or similar.39. Can I get one person to provide a general
verification? i.e. that I worked as an architect for
10 years.No. While a single verification may be acceptable in
some circumstances, it must explicitly list all of the
relevant projects and items being claimed for the
purposes of demonstrating the criteria.40. Can I use letters of appointment?
They are valid evidence but cannot be used in isolation.
41. Do I have to demonstrate 10 years of
independent practice?No, it is 10 years working as an architect at the required
level. You can have been an employee for that entire
time.42. In the Information on Projects section I assume
several projects per year should be submitted to
demonstrate 10 year duties. Is there a restriction
on this and do each year’s projects have to be
broad ranging or is this considered over 10 year
period?There is no restriction on the number of projects per
year in the Information on Projects section. Nor does
every year have to include a broad range of projects.
The objective is to show that over the 10 or more year
period, taken as a whole, you have conducted a broad
range of architectural duties.43. I have amassed over 600 projects in 21 years. Is
there a guideline as to how many projects per
year should be put into the Information on
Projects section?See Query 42. An applicant who has an extensive body
of work can be selective about the projects included,
bearing in mind the purpose of the exercise. If you
choose to be selective, you must ensure that the
projects included show the range of work done, duties
performed and competencies required, as well as
demonstrating the ten year requirement and being
capable of verification.44. The Information on Projects section is in A4
portrait format. Can one fold larger drawings to
A4 size, or do you want this section to be A4
sheets exclusively?
The Information on Projects section should not contain
any folded drawings. One thumbnail size drawing and/or
photo per project is all that is required or permitted. The
purpose of the illustration is simply to help the
Assessors form a basic mental image of the project.45. For the purpose of demonstrating competencies
can the planning stage of a project be used for
example to demonstrate appropriate planning
knowledge even if the project never proceeded
beyond this?Yes.
46. Should all Portfolio projects have been completed
or can one be selected to planning stage to
demonstrate particular knowledge?It is not necessary for all projects in the Portfolio to have
been completed. But be sure to include other Projects to
cover the remaining stages.47. In the Competencies Index is it acceptable to
respond to a Competency (e.g. e1, f7, g1, ,j1, j3,
k3, k5, k8) by indicating in the submission
reference – “See Project Portfolio�The reference must be to specific reference number/s,
e.g., P.1.2; P.1.4; P.4.6; etc., not simply “See Project
Portfolioâ€. Otherwise the volume of material in a
submission will render it unlikely that an Assessor will
be able to identify the relevant evidence.48. With regard to verifications (pg 4) does “Equal or
Higher than a Registered Architect†refer to only
See Query 9.The criterion for persons other than
“colleagues in a professional category’’ is that they beAugust 24, 2010 at 3:20 pm #815800Anonymous
InactiveVCA all I posted was true, not misleading… Why should the Dutch pay €3.500 to pass an exam, the US and Canada pay €4,000 and Ireland €13,500? Do you or the RIAI have a valid explanation for that? I know that you and your institute want to protect the interests of graduates, but this is not supposed to be the goal of the Building Control Act 2007…
In 1997, the Strategic Review Committee (of the Construction Industry) identified the need for a grandfather clause in relation to any legislation that would regulate the profession of architects. This was not recommended by David Keane fellow member of the RIAI and barrister.
Manipulations such as misleading radio broadcasting and other publishing have and are being used widely by the Institute. Groups such as Architects’ Alliance have exposed some of these wrong doing and that is why the RIAI has to answer questions to politicians today. What is said on the RIAI website does not reflect what is really happening. Someone would need to be very naive or to be a member of the Institute to Trust the RIAI website. One of the main problems is that nobody really monitors the RIAI implementation of the registration procedure.
– Fees for registration were never agreed by the minister despite what the RIAI claims.
– During the Technical Assessment some information are requested that do not meet Irish legislation for design, construction, planning or any other architectural services. Why ? Why are we supposed to produce written communication with clients and contractors if Irish law accepts verbal communication instead? Why are those using RIAI standard forms privileged?
– The RIAI is changing the rules during the procedure because of pressures by some groups such as Architects’ Alliance who have proved and denunciated some of the Institute unfair actions against self-taught architects.
– So far applicants for the Technical Assessment were judged on RIAI standard practice rather than Article 46 of the EU directive as it is indicated on the RIAI website. Why are the rules changing? Are they really changing or are they just part of the propaganda to discredit the proposed amendment?
– The RIAI has created the ARAE not to have any direct responsibility with this unaffordable and impossible examination, which represents a cost nearly 4 times above the Dutch equivalent and which requires examinations spread on 10 months. The examination is designed for newly qualified students rather than experienced practitioners, why? Many members of the RIAI of our age would fail the exam. Why are we supposed to be successful?
– Members of the Institutes were during a long time the only ones able to register as architects. They are paying the lowest fees for accessing the register. Why?
– Why are experienced established self-trained architects judged on subjective rules by graduates who have opposite interests? Why are we judged by our competitors who are unwilling to see us practicing? Those same competitors who declared on this forum that it is against their interests that we continue practicing?
Other issues are related to the Act itself:
– Why is there no Grand-father clause included in the Act, when most of the other European States have done so in their respective legislations?
– Why was the RIAI appointed as the Registration body despite all the warnings from The Competition Authority?
– Why is self-trained architects foreign experience not recognized by the Building Control Act 2007, when graduates’ foreign experience is? Why are self-trained architects discriminated for having worked in another European Country when the E.C. Treaty imposes freedom of movement for workers in the European Community?
– Why does the Act prevent experienced and mature professionals to continue practicing as architects in the State when it permits foreign registered architects to practice in Ireland without any knowledge of the planning system, building regulations, or any other Irish legislation? Is this protecting Irish consumers?
The RIAI is rich from Government grants, member’s fees and so on…
We are struggling to make a living and fighting an ogre who has decided to eliminate unwanted competition; eliminate our practices…
Our only weapons are our passion for architecture, our skills and our determination. We cannot overcome the RIAI propaganda which is managed by private companies that are unaffordable to us, but we will fight to the end… It will take more than a battle to win this war on registration. Education is a progressive discovering of our own ignorance.
Enjoy what you don’t know VCA…
August 24, 2010 at 7:56 pm #815801Anonymous
Inactive@vca wrote:
With so much misinformation being published on this thread please find below the official response given by the RIAI to prospective Technical Assessment Board candidates’ questions.
how do you explain the hypocrisy when trying to marry the above post with this:
@vca wrote:
MISINFORMATION ABOUT THE REGISTER – AND THE FACTS
THE TECHNICAL ASSESSMENT PROCESS IS NOT INDEPENDENT
Answer: The process is completely separate from the RIAI.
August 25, 2010 at 1:05 pm #815802Anonymous
Inactive@vca wrote:
MISINFORMATION ABOUT THE REGISTER – AND THE FACTS
(snip).
The Act does prevent those not on the Register from using the title architect but it does not limit or control in any way the functions of those providing services in the field of architecture.
The above heading and the statement below it show a basic inconsistency.
Anyone who is an architect knows that the essence of the role is your imprimatur as an architect.
You certify monies, swear declarations, issue opinions of compliance – as an architect
Anything less just doesn’t cut the mustard.I understand that for AIB Bank you must also be an MRIAI, merely being Registered isn’t good enough for them.
This is an unwarranted discrimination in terms of legal standing that the Registrar might look into when he gets a minute.As for you VCA, I have a few words of advice;-
Thank you posting that comprehensive set of responses regardless, but there is a problem.
Posting the party line without analysis or critical comment is not the same as acting as an Architect.
Its called “parroting” – Architects should never “parrot” – it lowers the standing of the profession in any public forum.
An Architect is someone who can analyse the weaknesses of a strategy and foresee inequality or inconsistency in a course of action.Allow me to show you what I mean by this.
========================================
Whether its wrapped in a concern for the public good or not, any strategy restricting the person’s rights must have due regards to the rights of the individual.
These concerns are not minimised or mitigated when the person is a professional.For the avoidance of doubt; –
- I support registration.
- I support protection of the Title.
- I would be happy to support regulation of the profession
- I don’t support the several disenfranchisements in this inequitable Act, both in terms of how it was written and how it was implemented in Irish law.
Many of my concerns rests with the framing of the Act.
The Registrar is trying to be fair to unregistered architects by not being heavy handed.
At the same time he is rightfully concerned with promoting the profession albeit as he sees fit.
But the sad fact is that the Registrar is bound to act within the terms of this unfair and inequitable Act.The newness of the process is the main problem for applicants to address:
The simple fact that the Technical Assessment is a new process and this frightens people.
This isn’t helped by the fact that three months after the Joint Oireachtas Committee in May 2010. there is still no redacted example of a successful submission for prospective applicants to review.Several factors intrude; –
- the lack of preparation
- the lack of past exam papers
- the lack of past pupils of the course to interview
- the lack of even a redacted example
All this weighs heavily against successful completion of the process for many.
Added to the newness of it all, the draconian imposition of a once-only chance to pass the course and the inequity of the process seems clear.
Any right minded member of the Institute should be embarrassed at what is being done to a minority of long-standing practitioners in the name of promoting architecture in Ireland.The TA tries to approximate the evaluation of a five year full time course PLUS two years of professional practice and codify this in an assessment lasting a year or so.
This full time course occurs is in an environment where there are thousands of past pupils to talk to and decades of past exam papers to review.
In the five year full time course students are allowed repeat certain subjects within limits and to repeat studio years within limits.A course which attempts to telescope the five years full time course into one should at least allow for one repeat.
In addition, if the Registrar intends the course to be seen to show fairness in an quasi-academic situation where the norms of past exam papers or prior qualified individuals with a knowledge of the course is not available for “grinds” or preparation, then appropriate preparation documentation should be available and this at least suggests worked redacted examples of successful applications.
FWIW
ONQ.
August 25, 2010 at 1:27 pm #815803Anonymous
Inactive@vca wrote:
With so much misinformation being published on this thread please find below the official response given by the RIAI to prospective Technical Assessment Board candidates’ questions.
There are lots more details at:http://www.riai.ie/admissions/technical_assessment/
Question / Answer
7. Can projects completed or carried out after 1 May
2008 be included?Answer pending legal advice
11. What about work completed after 1 May 2008?(argues that work past 1 May 2008 should be
included for demonstrating competencies)
Answer pending legal advice12. Can we take that as fact now?
Answer pending legal advice.
13. Would that include CPD courses post 1 May
2008?Answer pending legal advice
Am I the only one surprised to read that 2 years and 4 months after Registration became mandatory [in May 2008, its now August 2010] there are at least three pertinent issues on which competent legal advice is still unavailable.
ONQ.
August 25, 2010 at 3:05 pm #815804Anonymous
Inactive@vca wrote:
BUILDING CONTROL (AMENDMENT) BILL 2010
WHAT IS WRONG WITH THE PROPOSED AMENDMENT?
Lets look at this issue the way an architect might review a design brief
- Gather empirical evidence.
- Develop a reasoned analysis.
- Compose concise critical comment.
IT IS UNNECESSARY
The Bill is hardly unnecessary.
It wouldn’t have been proposed or gotten as far as it has if it was.
Our elected representatives get a lot of bad press – especially in the middle of a recession – but by their nature theyare quick studies.
Lobbyists have no magic wand to enforce unanimous recommendations from a Joint Oireachtas Committee [JOC] but that’s what happened on May 18th 2010.http://debates.oireachtas.ie/DDebate.aspx?F=ENJ20100518.xml&Node=H4#H4
What surprised me at the JOC meeting in May 2010 was that not one Member of the Committee spoke against the presentation by the Architect’s Alliance.
Several showed by their comments to the Committee that they had positive experience of practically trained architects and their work.The bureaucracy in the RIAI and the EU may make common cause, but the fact remains that many successful entrepreneurs do not have third level education and many talented designers do not have the benefits of a university course.
Trammelling talent is only one aspect of over-learning in any discipline and the RIAI has not even attempted to address this issue.
Putting people who have provided competent services in RIAI-designed boxes doesn’t seem like huge a step forward.How many world renowned defined their own route to competence?
Its the nature of talent to engage in self-directed study.
This should be cherished not brainwashed out.
To suit bureaucrats ticking little boxes.
IT UNDERMINES CONSUMER PROTECTION
This is an unfounded assumption.
There is no vast pool of claims arising from practically trained archtiects.
There is no blight on the designed face of Irish architecture solely emanating from them.
Some empirical evidence needs to be assembled [not another poll] to show the degree and nature of complaints arising.
You have to do some work to quantify the severity of the risk the public faces before you can assert this Bill undermines the consumer.One obvious rebuttal is that by bringing practically trained architects under the auspices of the Registrar they become subject to scrutiny and censure.
If they simply change their name to “building designer” they are not restricted from practising in any way and the Registrar cannot refer them to the Professional Conduct Committee.
Its simple logic to infer that any reasonable means of bringing practically trained architects into the fold is a Good Thing.
Conversely, defaming persons who have practised competently for decades by excluding them from automatic registration is a Bad Thing.This Bill seeks to redress this balance.
It also requires the applicant to show proof that they have been in practice providing services commensurate with those of an architect for 7 years, so not just anyone can waltz into the profession.IT DAMAGES THE REPUTATION OF IRISH ARCHITECTS AND ARCHITECTURE
The RIAI suggested at the JOC Meeting in May 2010 that the Commission had given an impression that the Graduate Standard had been erroneously included in the Directives.
“The impression given by the Commission is that the initial listing was erroneous and that the higher level should be applied in all states.”
This was not the case, despite this comment being made by the RIAI’s expert on the Directives.
Misleading and inaccurate statements like that damage the standing of the Registrar even where they are genuine mistakes.
It might be wishful thinking on the part of the RIAI, but its still incorrect.IT DISADVANTAGES YOUNGER ARCHITECTURAL GRADUATES
The damned Building Control Act 2007 prevents Graduates using the title, in defiance of the Directives
DIR 85/384/EEC and DIR 2005/36/EC
This denial of the use of the title to persons who are entitled to use it attacks the very foundation of the profession.
The only beneficiaries of the Act are those holding the RIAI certificate of MRIAI.
The damage this ham-fisted Irish Law has done to the legal assumptions necessary for mutual recognition of professional qualifications is incalculable.I’ll be looking at the Graduate position again and addressing this matter to DG Markt in due course.
IT COULD COST THE STATE MOREThe only people worried at this point is the RIAI, and the ARAE training body, both of which have spent thousands preparing for Registration.
John Graby has hinted that if the Government puts the Bill through they may send them a Bill for all the preparatory work they’ve done.Let’s just briefly review thsi last point in some sort of context.
(i) a private body is set up as the sole provider of an assessment arising of the requirements of an Act – it has no competition
(ii) despite this supposedly being a private body, it appears to have some sort of “inside line” on the what is needed and spends money training assessors
(iii) when the government has what appears to be a franchise pointed out to them, a statutory office holder, a supposedly independent Registrar, suggests reimbursement would be in order.Can you spell
VESTED – INTEREST
When you look at this dispassionately, this stinks.
It exposes the problems of self-regulation and co-regulation – croneyism.
Such problems appear to be systemic for anything other than independent regulation.
IT IS INCONSISTENT WITH THE REST OF LEGISLATIONThis last bit would be hysterically funny if you were to consider the disenfranchisement of Graduates by the BCA 2007.
The inconsistency of the Act with both Irish Statutes and two EU Directives is embarrassing.
Unless of course you were a Graduate of 20 years standing, which I am.
Then you might feel that this above comment was taking the piss.
Which I do, and for the reasons set out below.Grandfather Clauses are entirely consistent with good legal practice.
They recognise the years of competent work which stand as a testament to practically trained persons using the Title.
There is no empirical proof yet offered to show that the designs of practically trained Irish architects suffer more building failures than those of MRIAI’s.To be fair to MRIAI’s, most of the Members I know do excellent work.
There will always be a sunny Friday afternoon or a miserable Monday morning.
But the point is this is even-handed in the likely distribution of failures and faults.
To those MRIAI’s who like to trot out David Grant – just remember, he was a Scottish git.The RIAI refer to the 80% – 20% split between claims that arise from Non-Members and Member respectively.
However the anonymous nature of this reference makes it utterly meaningless – we’d be better off knowing what action was taken.
Until the RIAI open their books and providing some detail on the complaints and results we won’t know the extent of even their own statistics.There is also a body of public opinion that holds to the view that reporting an architect to the institute does not good, that its an old boys club, a closed shop.
This strongly suggests that the total numbers of referrals may be artificially restricted and suggests a possible interpretation of the figures might skew them as well.
I cannot comment in any detail, but I know that for the public to have confidence in a system, it must not only work, it must be seen to work and that is not the case at the moment.“Confidentiality” is old-school and cannot sit with the current Zeitgeist of “Openness and Transparency” – someone should gently nudge the Registrar about this.
My clear understanding of the primary role of the RIAI is not the protection of its members, nor even their representation, but the promotion of Architect.
I fail therefore to see where the need for confidentiality arises in the matter of releasing statistics that do not actually name the individuals involved.The RIAI need to come allow relevant analysis of their records of complaints if their own record of protecting the public good is to be accepted.
========================
ONQ.
August 25, 2010 at 3:20 pm #815805Anonymous
InactiveA grand-father clause would delay the privileges of the graduates by 25 to 35 years… But Irish consumers would benefit without delay… There would be no loss for schools of architecture, no loss for actual or future students in architecture.
It is only those graduates who are practicing today that are creating the problem… They are refusing to compete with established self-trained architects. They want to have privileges that we do not have. They do not really care about consumers…
August 25, 2010 at 3:42 pm #815806Anonymous
Inactive@CK wrote:
A grand-father clause would delay the privileges of the graduates by 25 to 35 years… But Irish consumers would benefit without delay… There would be no loss for schools of architecture, no loss for actual or future students in architecture.
It is only those graduates who are practicing today that are creating the problem… They are refusing to compete with established self-trained architects. They want to have privileges that we do not have. They do not really care about consumers…
hidden behind your concern for the public is your real agenda ie fuck the future to look after yourself. You aren’t self trained or established CK. You have an unrecognised degree and a few extensions to your name. Believe me, it’s that attitude that will sink this Bill dead. Sorry for butting in on the “Save CK” thread again but you made the mistake of putting up a post shorter than 2000 words
- AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

