The sensitive issue of the title "Architect" and the Buildin
- This topic has 1,242 replies, 62 voices, and was last updated 12 years, 11 months ago by
Anonymous.
- AuthorPosts
- May 23, 2007 at 6:53 pm #815047
Anonymous
InactiveI’ve just seen that nearly 60% have voted in favour of an Irish Architects Registration Board. 😮 FRIENDS : GET YOUR HEADS EXAMINED – YOU’LL REGRET IT! 😮
At least so few have voted that the poll can be taken as a glorious vote of no confidence in the whole thing. :confused:
May 24, 2007 at 4:45 pm #815048Anonymous
InactiveMy first post, so please go easy 🙂
As an Architectural Technician in full-time employment in a non-RIAI architectural firm since 1999, i have been performing the duties of an ‘Architect’ since my first day….
Our firm aims at mainly urban and rural residential projects, and i can say we would consider ourselves ‘specialist’ in this area, in all aspects of the construction process, from brief forming, planning and engineering consultation, design and project mamagement. This is our target market, as there are a myriad of RIAI firms locally that tie up the local commercial, industrial and public projects. My employer is not formally qualified as an architect, but has been working as an architect for over 30 years…..
I have been designing residential developments, urban housing and rural stand alone homes for the past 7 years. My work has been favourable critised by well respected local RIAI architects. My question is this…
How can the registration board deliberate on “the work submitted must be equivalent to that of an Architect in terms of its scale and complexity and quality” when the exact role of an architect in the construction process is so contraversial.??reading the ‘official journal of the european union’ L 255 it states the training of an architect should lead to the acquisition of 11 skills….
on reading this list its clear to me that i am formally trained in 6 of them; i have experiential training in 3 others… i do not have training in only 2 of them….
however, the list describes skills that would be more pertenant to other professions than architects….
ie “understanding of structural design, constructional and engineering problems associated with the building design”
or “adequate knowledge of urban design, planning and the skills involved in th eplanning process”
or “adequate knowledge of physical problems and technologies and of the function of buildings so as to provide them with internal conditions of comfort and protection against teh climate”these definations of the requist skills of an ‘architect’ would be more correctly used to describe an architectural technician, or services engineer, or structural engineer etc….
June 6, 2007 at 10:27 pm #815049Anonymous
Inactivehope its ok to bump this, in hope of any comments on my post…..
June 7, 2007 at 11:37 am #815050Anonymous
InactiveI am currently doing a degree in Interior Architecture in Griffith College, Dublin. Its a BA recognised by HETAC and internationally. What does this mean for me? Can I call myself an Interior Architect? :confused:
August 27, 2009 at 6:02 pm #815051Anonymous
InactiveAn interesting comment on the architectural profession by Paul Finch, the new chair of CABE, in response to a question by Will Alsop: http://www.architectsjournal.co.uk/5207267.article
Do you think the role of the architect should be returned to the position it occupied before project managers were invented? Will Alsop
The role of architects was defined by architects themselves in the 1830s. From the expulsion of the measurers, the splitting off of planners and, more recently, the apparent abandonment of project management on major buildings, the message seems to be that many architects are content for others to carry out activities that are not fundamentally about ‘design’. Neither CABE nor anybody else can disband project management as a separate discipline, tempting though that may be to some.September 8, 2009 at 12:52 pm #815052Anonymous
InactiveI have created my own practice in dublin 8 years ago. I have tryed to register with the RIAI but never could because my qualification is not listed in the EU directive which includes a list of cetain qualifications valable for registration.
I am waiting for the RIAI to set up the registration procedure as per the B.C.A. 2007 (Building Control Act 2007). Last year the RIAI was trying to prevent my practice being listed in the Golden Pages on the ground that I was not M.RIAI. I had to employ my solicitor to solve this conflict. The B.C.A. 2007 stipulates that anyone having applyed for registration can continue practicing as an architect until a decision on the application is reached by the board. The RIAI was acting in breach of the B.C.A. 2007 by trying to prevent my practice and others to be listed in the Golden Pages. My solicitor could never comvince the RIAI to change their way of doing, but the Golden Pages legal team decided that the RIAI’s request to list only RIAI members was not justified because Registration as per the B.C.A. 2007 was not yet in place.
I have a master degree in Arts & Architecture issued by a State University from Paris. I have 14 years of experience working in France, UK, and Ireland. I am wondering what type of politic is following the RIAI by trying to prevent honest and competent architects like me to continue practicing.
I will be able to register as an architect after having past an examination but at the moment my practice is damaged by the economical climat and also by the RIAI which is claiming everywhere that registration started in May 2008, when in fact it is not started at all to this date.
The RIAI is using its position as the registration body to promote the services of its members, when it should in the contrary carry out the registration task without prejudice. When a member of the public call the RIAI to obtain information about my practice, the RIAI tells them that I am not a member and that there is no guarantee that I will be able to register. They recommend my potential client to use the services of a MRIAI architect. I know that I have already lost some potential clients this way and I am wondering if I could take legal action against the RIAI on this ground.
I am desapointed with the RIAI. They are looking at the registration process in a way that facilitate everything for their members, but they do not consider the interests of non members qualified for registration as per the B.C.A. 2007. I thing that there is obvioulsy a conflict of interest there.
September 8, 2009 at 1:52 pm #815053Anonymous
InactiveI think there is a clear conflict of interest here too.
The Competition Authority submitted a recommendation when this legislation was being considered that the RIAI should not be the body responsible for registration.“The Competition Authority is concerned, however, with the impact of the proposed new registration system for architects, as outlined in the Building Control Bill 2005. As currently proposed, the Royal Institute of the Architects of Ireland (RIAI), which represents the vast majority of architects in Ireland, would be given the responsibility for maintaining a register of architects in Ireland, including those who are not RIAI members. This creates the potential for conflicts of interest between the RIAI’s role in representing its members and its statutory roles of protecting consumers and regulating all architects.
The Competition Authority makes a number of recommendations designed to ensure that the proposed registration system is as transparent, independent and accountable as possible. In particular, it proposes the creation of an Architects Council of Ireland – an independent and accountable body to register architects”.
http://www.tca.ie/templates/index.aspx?pageid=930The RIAI describes itself as a “representative body for professionally qualified architects” in Ireland. This single statement on the website sparks any number of areas where there is potential for conflict in its new second role as a registration body.
The UK system of separating out theses functions was devised for good reason:
ARB is the independent statutory regulator of all UK registered architects.
ARB has a dual mandate to protect the consumer and to safeguard the reputation of architects. To achieve this, we:
* keep an up to date Register of all architects
* promote good standards both in the education of architects and in professional practice
* provide consumers with an accessible service in cases of complaint
* investigate and prosecute unregistered individuals in business or practice who unlawfully call themselves an architect.
http://www.arb.org.uk/If you are a RIBA Architect you can chose to disagree with your professional body, relinquish your membership, and retain your right to call yourself an Architect by virtue of your ARB accreditation. Professionals who have suitable qualifications and experience can register without having to become members of the RIBA.
(I wonder will RIAI membership fees be reduced to a suitable ‘recession level’ or even in line with deflation come renewal??)
September 8, 2009 at 2:16 pm #815054Anonymous
InactiveIt seems that the competition Authority had anticipated the problem.
September 8, 2009 at 2:52 pm #815055Anonymous
Inactive@trace wrote:
An interesting comment on the architectural profession by Paul Finch, the new chair of CABE, in response to a question by Will Alsop: http://www.architectsjournal.co.uk/5207267.article
Do you think the role of the architect should be returned to the position it occupied before project managers were invented? Will Alsop
The role of architects was defined by architects themselves in the 1830s. From the expulsion of the measurers, the splitting off of planners and, more recently, the apparent abandonment of project management on major buildings, the message seems to be that many architects are content for others to carry out activities that are not fundamentally about ‘design’. Neither CABE nor anybody else can disband project management as a separate discipline, tempting though that may be to some.your comment re the abandonement of PMs is relevant – happening all over as Clients realise PMs get money for jam as the northies say. The role is now ripe for architects to take back what – let’s face it – they’ve all still been doing due to the fact that most PM’s are failed QSs and are having rings run around them by Contract Managers. The banks have set them free and architect’s should ensure they stay so.
Re an Irish version of the ARB – absolutely essential. The RIBA in the UK offers little but a “free” magazine. the ARB ensures regulation and is one hell of a lot cheaper
September 8, 2009 at 3:07 pm #815056Anonymous
Inactive@wearnicehats wrote:
Re an Irish version of the ARB – absolutely essential. The RIBA in the UK offers little but a “free” magazine. the ARB ensures regulation and is one hell of a lot cheaper
Didn’t the RIAI’s submissions to government on the regulation argue for them taking on the registration role?
Anyway, like any good democracy it’s up to us members to vote in the council we want next time. Don’t think we can vote in a new director though?
Interesting to note that RIAI CPD courses have just become mandatory for members, some of which can be very pricey.September 19, 2009 at 1:20 pm #815057Anonymous
Inactive“RIAI CPD courses have just become mandatory for members, some of which can be very pricey”
Thats a nice way to ensure funds during a recession!An independent Registration body is essential – just like the UK. The current proposal is a joke and will reflect badly on the Profession.
October 9, 2009 at 1:27 pm #815058Anonymous
InactiveThe registration of architects was officially started in May 2008 last year… And I am still waiting for the procedure to be in place to regularize my situation.
The fact is that the RIAI has tried to prevent my practice being listed in the Golden Pages last year, and I am wondering what will happen this year. The RIAI continues to promote and defend its members but as the registration body, the RIAI has done nothing for practicing architects non members of the Institute.
As a practicing architect I know that delays can happen during the design, the construction process, and it is understandable that delays can also happen during procedures such as the registration of professionals. However, I think that the RIAI has no excuse for not changing its structure and politic towards non members. 16 months after May 2008, nothing positive has been done for architectural practices non member of the RIAI.
Why? I would have thought that the Registration Body has also a duty of care toward non members of the institute…
October 9, 2009 at 3:26 pm #815059Anonymous
Inactive@CK wrote:
The registration of architects was officially started in May 2008 last year… And I am still waiting for the procedure to be in place to regularize my situation.
The fact is that the RIAI has tried to prevent my practice being listed in the Golden Pages last year, and I am wondering what will happen this year. The RIAI continues to promote and defend its members but as the registration body, the RIAI has done nothing for practicing architects non members of the Institute.
As a practicing architect I know that delays can happen during the design, the construction process, and it is understandable that delays can also happen during procedures such as the registration of professionals. However, I think that the RIAI has no excuse for not changing its structure and politic towards non members. 16 months after May 2008, nothing positive has been done for architectural practices non member of the RIAI.
Why? I would have thought that the Registration Body has also a duty of care toward non members of the institute…
it is not in the RIAIs members interest to accept registration of new architects due to an ever shrinking market.
The RIAIs primary raison d’etre is to serve its members to the best of its ability….
two plus two equals four…
October 9, 2009 at 4:06 pm #815060Anonymous
Inactivethere are many ways to become a member of the RIAI – many more ways, incidentally, than in many other countries
Either take one of those routes and follow the procedures in place or don’t. It’s really quite simple and all the crying in the world isn’t going to help
October 9, 2009 at 4:42 pm #815061Anonymous
Inactive@henno wrote:
it is not in the RIAIs members interest to accept registration of new architects due to an ever shrinking market.
The RIAIs primary raison d’etre is to serve its members to the best of its ability….
two plus two equals four…
I am afraid that 2+2 equal 3 in this particular situation. If I believe the Building Control Act 2007, the RIAI is supposed to deal with registration without discrimination. But it seems that they are not able or willing to do so…
As the Registration Body, the RIAI should be developing a department to deal with non members. A department to inform, advise, and prepare the ground for post-registration matters. I want to register but I am not willing to become MRIAI.
The RIAI is not fulfilling its function as the Registration Body.
October 9, 2009 at 4:58 pm #815062Anonymous
Inactive@wearnicehats wrote:
there are many ways to become a member of the RIAI – many more ways, incidentally, than in many other countries
Either take one of those routes and follow the procedures in place or don’t. It’s really quite simple and all the crying in the world isn’t going to help
wearnicehats, I think that you do not realy know what you are talking about…
In the UK for example, experience and knowledge lead to registration. The RIAI has a very academic approach to registration. I have 5 years qualification not listed in the EU directive, and on this ground they have refused my candidature as a MRIAI.
They would like me to apply for registration through a route where I would need to work for a MRIAI architect to register as a full member. I have my own practice since 2001, I have children and I am not willing to go back to work for another architect. For this reason I want to register as per the Building Control Act 2007 (BCA 2007) without applying for RIAI membership. It is my legal right to do so…
The RIAI is the Registration Body and it should help with registration as per the BCA 2007, but instead it is only considering MRIAI applications and this is in breach with the BCA 2007.
I am not crying, I am just defending my rights…
October 10, 2009 at 8:18 am #815063Anonymous
Inactive@CK wrote:
wearnicehats, I think that you do not realy know what you are talking about…
In the UK for example, experience and knowledge lead to registration. The RIAI has a very academic approach to registration. I have 5 years qualification not listed in the EU directive, and on this ground they have refused my candidature as a MRIAI.
They would like me to apply for registration through a route where I would need to work for a MRIAI architect to register as a full member. I have my own practice since 2001, I have children and I am not willing to go back to work for another architect. For this reason I want to register as per the Building Control Act 2007 (BCA 2007) without applying for RIAI membership. It is my legal right to do so…
The RIAI is the Registration Body and it should help with registration as per the BCA 2007, but instead it is only considering MRIAI applications and this is in breach with the BCA 2007.
I am not crying, I am just defending my rights…
can you really register with the ARB in the UK without doing an exam?
is working for a MRIAI architect part of the D2 Route?
October 12, 2009 at 8:48 am #815064Anonymous
Inactive@wearnicehats wrote:
can you really register with the ARB in the UK without doing an exam?
is working for a MRIAI architect part of the D2 Route?
An examination is necessary to register with the ARB in the UK. However, anyone with the knowledge, skills and experience of an architect would be successful.
To become MRIAI, an examination is requested, including work experience within a MRIAI practice.
October 12, 2009 at 11:47 am #815065Anonymous
Inactive@CK wrote:
An examination is necessary to register with the ARB in the UK. However, anyone with the knowledge, skills and experience of an architect would be successful.
To become MRIAI, an examination is requested, including work experience within a MRIAI practice.
how do you currently sign payment and/or compliance certs
October 12, 2009 at 11:57 am #815066Anonymous
Inactive@wearnicehats wrote:
how do you currently sign payment and/or compliance certs
Sorry wearnicehats, my solicitor advised me on this matter, but is is a sensible issue that I do not want to discuss in public or with someone that I do not realy know. There are many guys making illegal certifications out there, and I do not want to help anyone this way…
- AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

