The sensitive issue of the title "Architect" and the Buildin

Home › Forums › Ireland › The sensitive issue of the title "Architect" and the Buildin

Viewing 20 posts - 401 through 420 (of 1,243 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #815407
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Hi Solo.

    Sorry I got so bored by all the agreement on your other reply to me I fell asleep in the middle of answering it… 😀

    ONQ.

    #815408
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @XArchitect wrote:

    I am a non-registered architect and I’ve just joined Archiseek. (snip)

    Hi XArchitect.

    Lots of crisp thinking in your post.

    I wasn’t aware of the level of unqualified successes who were MRIAIs – CK is going to love this!

    BTW, can you clarify whether you are unqualified as well as unregistered or, if qualified, what your qualification is?

    You don’t have to post the name of the 3rd level institution if you don’t want to, just confirm whether you qualified as a technician or an archtiect – or neither as the case may be 🙂

    You might benefit from a review of comments submitted to the Government by the various representative bodies as well as a detailed review of Dir 85/384/EEC and DIR 2005/36/EC.

    You might review the Competition Authority’s comments to Government, which I understand were concerned that people shouldn’t be forced to become Members of the RIAI in order to be registered.

    I’m not sure how this sits with the level of hoop jumping we have to go through now.

    Back in 1989, S.I. 15 of 1989 wrote DIR 85/394/EEC into Irish Law.

    This was known as the Architect’s Directive, not the Graduate Architect’s Directive and a good read of the references above may prove instructive.

    By the way, has anyone applied to be Registered, but NOT to become a Member of the RIAI yet?

    The RIAI are within their rights setting jumps to go through to become one of the their Members – they’re a private club, after all, and they make the rules about who can join.

    Registration of Architects seems to be a wholly different thing, and there they will have to be seen to be fair and even handed.

    ONQ.

    #815409
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @Solo wrote:

    Hi X,

    Welcome to the thread.

    But I am surprised by your post and a little confused. What exactly was your point. If everything is as you allude beyond the protection of “Title” are you suggesting that there is no problem with the RIAI being the Competent Authority, The Registrar and the single Largest Private Members Club for Architects with the powers to make whatever regulations it sees fit when ever it sees fit.

    It is clear that there is a problem with the RIAI…Xarchitect is telling us that it is not new… I was not aware of the RIAI history, but I know that some of their architects have no academic qualification despite the RIAI claiming that they represent professionally qualified architects. This is just another misleading information that they provide.

    However, it must be said that even in Germany, France and surely other European countries, institutes include self-trained architects who are permitted to practice as such due to their experience. In Germany some architects have only 3 years of studies behind them…

    The problem with RIAI ltd (as called by Xarchitect), is the double standard and discrimination that they implement…

    #815410
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    The debate has matured enough in introduce the text of the substantive below document S.I. 15 of 1989.

    This is the document that wrote DIR 85/384/EEC – otherwise known as the Architect’s Directive – into Irish Law.

    The RIAI is not the first “competent authority” as such – this power was already vested in the Minister – and may still be AFAICS.

    By one view John Gormley and his predecessor Dick Roche – in empowering the RIAI – were merely following a continuing Government process.

    That of Ministers transferring their Ministerial responsibility to what may be termed “competent bodies”.

    This may be particularly attractive to Ministers wanting to avoid fatal “hits” to their political careers.

    They raise up target dummies like the HSE which gets blamed in their place for every disaster.

    ONQ

    ===========================================

    http://www.irishstatutebook.ie/1989/en/si/0015.html

    S.I. No. 15/1989 — The European Communities (Establishment and Provision of Services in Architecture) Regulations, 1989.

    S.I. No. 15/1989 — The European Communities (Establishment and Provision of Services in Architecture) Regulations, 1989. 1989 15

    S.I. No. 15/1989:

    THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES (ESTABLISHMENT AND PROVISION OF SERVICES IN ARCHITECTURE) REGULATIONS, 1989.

    THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES (ESTABLISHMENT AND PROVISION OF SERVICES IN ARCHITECTURE) REGULATIONS, 1989.

    The Minister for the Environment, in exercise of the powers conferred on him by section 3 of the European Communities Act, 1972 (No. 27 of 1972), hereby makes the following Regulations:

    1. These Regulations may be cited as the European Communities (Establishment and Provision of Services in Architecture) Regulations, 1989.

    2. These Regulations shall come into operation on the 25th day of January, 1989.

    3. (1) In these Regulations

    “Directive” means Directive No. 85/384/EEC adopted by the Council of the European Communities on 10 June, 1985 and published in the Official Journal of the European Communities Volume No. L 223/15 dated 21st August, 1985 as amended by Directive No. 85/614/EEC adopted by the Council of the European Communities on 20 December, 1985 and published in the Official Journal of the European Communities Volume No. L376/1 of 31st December, 1985 and by Directive No. 86/17/EEC adopted by the Council of the European Communities on 27 January, 1986 and published in the Official Journal of the European Communities Volume No. L 27/71 of 1st February, 1986.

    (2) In these Regulations, words and phrases shall have the same meaning as in the Directives referred to in sub-article (1).

    4. These Regulations shall apply as respects nationals of Member States of the European Communities who possess diplomas, certificates and other evidence of formal qualifications in architecture awarded in a Member State.

    5. The Minister for the Environment is hereby designated to be the competent authority for the following purposes of that Directive—

    ( a ) to communicate, in accordance with paragraph 1 of Article 7 of the Directive, the list of diplomas, certificates and other evidence of formal qualifications in architecture awarded in Ireland and which meet the criteria laid down in Articles 3 and 4 of the Directive together with the establishments and authorities awarding them and any amendments to the list;

    ( b ) to receive information from another Member State under paragraph 4 of Article 17 or under paragraph 2 of Article 18 of the Directive and, insofar as the information relates to matters that are regulated, to verify the accuracy of the facts as provided for in Article 17 and 18 of the Directive and within three months to inform the Member State from which the information was sent of any consequential action taken;

    ( c ) to ensure the confidentiality of information received or issued under Articles 17 and 18;

    ( d ) to issue certificates under paragraph 2 of Article 23 of the Directive.

    6. The following bodies are hereby designated to be the competent authorities for the purposes of—

    ( a ) issuing certificates under paragraph 3 (third indent) of article 22 of the Directive;

    ( b ) confirming the authenticity of formal qualifications under Article 27 of the Directive;

    ( c ) issuing diplomas, certificates and other evidence of formal qualifications pursuant to Article 28 of the Directive.

    National University of Ireland.

    College of Technology, Bolton Street, Dublin.

    Royal Institute of the Architects of Ireland.

    GIVEN under the official Seal of the Minister for the Environment this 24th

    day of January 1989.

    PADRAIG FLYNN,

    Minister for the Environment.

    EXPLANATORY NOTE.

    The purpose of these Regulations is to give effect to implement Directives Nos. 85/384/EEC, 85/614/EEC and 86/117/EEC relating to the mutual recognition of specified architectural qualifications awarded in the Members States to nationals of the Member States and measures to facilitate the exercise of the right of persons holding such qualifications to establish themselves and to provide services anywhere in the Community.

    The National University of Ireland, the College of Technology, Bolton Street, Dublin and the Royal Institute of the Architects of Ireland are the competent authorities as regards the issuing of formal qualifications which are in compliance with the requirements of the Directive and the provision of any information relating to these qualifications.

    #815411
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    I am not sure about your point posting the above onq…

    Some of my concerns these days are related to the RIAI discrediting my practice and others. I have potential clients who are calling the RIAI and then decide not to use my services.

    Obviously the RIAI is discouraging them to use my practice, and they are abusing their position when doing so, as they did with the misleading advertising that was forbidden by the Broadcasting authorities.

    #815412
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:

    I am not sure about your point posting the above onq…
    (snip)

    Read 85/384/EEC from cover to cover, then 2005./36/EC – all should become clear.

    ONQ.

    #815413
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @onq wrote:

    Read 85/384/EEC from cover to cover, then 2005./36/EC – all should become clear.

    ONQ.

    I did read 2005./36/EC, I did read between the lines of 85/384/EEC and it looks like an old version of it, in the field of architecture only…

    These directives are related to the recognition of qualifications from one E.U. state to another… What is happening within the state is regulated by the state… In Ireland the BCA 2007…

    #815414
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:

    I did read 2005./36/EC, I did read between the lines of 85/384/EEC and it looks like an old version of it, in the field of architecture only…

    These directives are related to the recognition of qualifications from one E.U. state to another… What is happening within the state is regulated by the state… In Ireland the BCA 2007…

    CK,

    DIR 85/384/EEC was the first Directive to formally recognise my degree as entitling me to practise as an architect throughout the EEC and Ireland was in the EEC.

    S.I. 15 of 1989 wrote this recognition into Irish Law and conferred the ability to issue evidence of formal qualifications to Bolton Street, UCD and the RIAI.

    But a part of DIR 85/384/EEC, acquired rights to practise were also first recognised.
    2005/36/EC also recognises these rights, which is relevant to your position.

    Geez – its like leading the stubbornest, thirsties nag to the water trough.
    No matter how you encourage him and he’s dying of thirst.

    What don’t you understand about this?

    ONQ.

    #815415
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @onq wrote:

    CK,

    DIR 85/384/EEC was the first Directive to formally recognise my degree as entitling me to practise as an architect throughout the EEC and Ireland was in the EEC.

    S.I. 15 of 1989 wrote this recognition into Irish Law and conferred the ability to issue evidence of formal qualifications to Bolton Street, UCD and the RIAI.

    But a part of DIR 85/384/EEC, acquired rights to practise were also first recognised.
    2005/36/EC also recognises these rights, which is relevant to your position.

    Geez – its like leading the stubbornest, thirsties nag to the water trough.
    No matter how you encourage him and he’s dying of thirst.

    What don’t you understand about this?

    ONQ.

    The EU directive did not change anything for me… It is the BCA 2007 doing the damage and also its zealous implementation…

    #815416
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:

    The EU directive did not change anything for me… It is the BCA 2007 doing the damage and also its zealous implementation…

    I’m beginning to think you have a serious comprehension problem CK.

    Read the sections on acquired rights.

    ONQ.

    #815417
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @onq wrote:

    I’m beginning to think you have a serious conprehension problem CK.

    Read the sections on acquired rights.

    ONQ.


    DIRECTIVE 2005/36/EC OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL of 7 September 2005 on the recognition of professional qualifications …

    Article 49
    Acquired rights specific to architects

    1. Each Member State shall accept evidence of formal qualifications
    as an architect listed in Annex VI, point 6, awarded by
    the other Member States, and attesting a course of training
    which began no later than the reference academic year referred
    to in that Annex, even if they do not satisfy the minimum
    requirements laid down in Article 46, and shall, for the
    purposes of access to and pursuit of the professional activities
    of an architect, give such evidence the same effect on its territory
    as evidence of formal qualifications as an architect which
    it itself issues.
    Under these circumstances, certificates issued by the competent
    authorities of the Federal Republic of Germany attesting that
    evidence of formal qualifications issued on or after 8 May
    1945 by the competent authorities of the German Democratic
    Republic is equivalent to such evidence listed in that Annex,
    shall be recognised.

    2. Without prejudice to paragraph 1, every Member State
    shall recognise the following evidence of formal qualifications
    and shall, for the purposes of access to and pursuit of the
    professional activities of an architect performed, give them the
    same effect on its territory as evidence of formal qualifications
    which it itself issues: certificates issued to nationals of Member
    States by the Member States which have enacted rules
    governing the access to and pursuit of the activities of an architect
    as of the following dates:
    (a) 1 January 1995 for Austria, Finland and Sweden;
    (b) 1 May 2004 for the Czech Republic, Estonia, Cyprus,
    Latvia, Lithuania, Hungary, Malta, Poland, Slovenia and
    Slovakia;
    (c) 5 August 1987 for the other Member States.
    The certificates referred to in paragraph 1 shall certify that the
    holder was authorised, no later than the respective date, to use
    the professional title of architect, and that he has been effectively
    engaged, in the context of those rules, in the activities in
    question for at least three consecutive years during the five
    years preceding the award of the certificate.



    I got through that before… There is maybe something for your qualification there. But nothing related to mine… Did you obtain your degrees before 1987?

    #815418
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Does all this diatribe mean that Senator George Mitchell can no longer be called the ‘architect’ of the Good Friday Agreement unless he’s on the register?:o

    #815419
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @sidecarbob wrote:

    Does all this diatribe mean that Senator George Mitchell can no longer be called the ‘architect’ of the Good Friday Agreement unless he’s on the register?:o

    Don’t tell Graby.

    ONQ.

    #815420
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:


    DIRECTIVE 2005/36/EC OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL of 7 September 2005 on the recognition of professional qualifications …

    Article 49
    Acquired rights specific to architects

    1. Each Member State shall accept evidence of formal qualifications
    as an architect listed in Annex VI, point 6, awarded by
    the other Member States, and attesting a course of training
    which began no later than the reference academic year referred
    to in that Annex, even if they do not satisfy the minimum
    requirements laid down in Article 46, and shall, for the
    purposes of access to and pursuit of the professional activities
    of an architect, give such evidence the same effect on its territory
    as evidence of formal qualifications as an architect which
    it itself issues.
    Under these circumstances, certificates issued by the competent
    authorities of the Federal Republic of Germany attesting that
    evidence of formal qualifications issued on or after 8 May
    1945 by the competent authorities of the German Democratic
    Republic is equivalent to such evidence listed in that Annex,
    shall be recognised.

    2. Without prejudice to paragraph 1, every Member State
    shall recognise the following evidence of formal qualifications
    and shall, for the purposes of access to and pursuit of the
    professional activities of an architect performed, give them the
    same effect on its territory as evidence of formal qualifications
    which it itself issues: certificates issued to nationals of Member
    States by the Member States which have enacted rules
    governing the access to and pursuit of the activities of an architect
    as of the following dates:
    (a) 1 January 1995 for Austria, Finland and Sweden;
    (b) 1 May 2004 for the Czech Republic, Estonia, Cyprus,
    Latvia, Lithuania, Hungary, Malta, Poland, Slovenia and
    Slovakia;
    (c) 5 August 1987 for the other Member States.
    The certificates referred to in paragraph 1 shall certify that the
    holder was authorised, no later than the respective date, to use
    the professional title of architect, and that he has been effectively
    engaged, in the context of those rules, in the activities in
    question for at least three consecutive years during the five
    years preceding the award of the certificate.



    I got through that before… There is maybe something for your qualification there. But nothing related to mine… Did you obtain your degrees before 1987?

    CK, you’re right – the problem is with me – my apologies.

    I’m confusing the 1994 ILS recommendation to Members with the Directive.

    In it the ILS included people with 10 years practising as architects as persons from whom certificates could be accepted and that hasn’t changed.

    ONQ.

    #815421
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @wearnicehats wrote:

    to quote billy connolly – fuck off, he hinted

    with regard to the rest of your post – taken from what alma matters (sic) – It’s an old article I know but who am I to doubt the head honcho

    http://www.ucd.ie/arcel/architecture/postgraduate/certarch_ucd.htm

    Thanks wearnicehats – it will be interesting to see how all this pans out.

    ONQ.

    #815422
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @Solo wrote:

    Hi ONQ,

    I still work in the UK where building control applications are made similar to our old bye-law applications. These work very well over there. They brought in self certification as an experiment and not long after went back to the L.A. certifying as well as the Architect and other design professionals.

    (nods)
    I can relate to that
    I have carried out remedial works to houses designed and certified by others in Ireland.
    We requested the LA to come on board in the person of the Building Control Officer, who was taking a very pro-active stance on the matter.
    He ended up writing a building defects sheet to which we responded proposing remedies.
    He would then write back confirming acceptance or otherwise.
    Usually he accepted, because we would agree it all one site.

    My point is that the system works very well and it has been my experience having worked both systems that some of the old Bye Law inspectors were excellent and others a nightmare. I cannot say I have had the same difficulties in the UK. On any job of consequence the builders just up their game as they know the ropes. It is on smaller more domestic scale or self builders where the problems occur.

    I agree (sighs) about the variations with the BCO’s and I have to say I was quite lucky with the ones I dealt with.
    I presume you made that last comment that in relation to the UK?

    Your suggestion is one I have discussed with the Department of the Environment and the Green Party who are presently seeking input from construction professionals on the good and bad points of our present regulation. In particular they are attempting to address the difficulties that are being created by Local Authorities taking guidance documents as cast in stone commandments I refer to the installation of water treatment plants in single dwellings in particular.

    Well, the good and bad of it is still the same – Building Control Officers jobs get advertised every three years IIRC and they get appointed – after that, its their call, and at least one MRIAI got a come-uppance when he failed to realise that, despite me telling him AND quoting the relevant part of the BCA 1990 to him.

    Your suggestion of a single body to whom we make a single application with Fire, Part M and Ber documents all included is simple, workable and more likely than not efficient so it will never see the light of day sorry. For our present Minister your suggestions would need to have a greener more out there feel and be expensive, impractical and of course half baked. If you can lower you standards to come up with such a suggestion I think I might be able to interest our present Minister to adopt it

    Nope, that’s my problem I give excellent advice – I’ve just seen a big job go west because I gave the client contact some very good advice which caused him to think twice, then put it on hold, because of drainage problems it wasn’t in his gift to resolve.

    My last project in the UK I had to not only show all of this at planning but also write a mobility report, produce a noise report showing how not only our building might impact the existing area but how the area might impact the residents/occupants of our building. I also had to write a waste management report stating how all construction related waste would be dealt with and then how the finished building would continue to deal with waste issues. The final report dealt with energy usage and how using better construction methods, materials and employing new technologies the building’s carbon footprint could be reduced.

    Bejaypers!
    I cannot even begin to compete unless its one of those jobs that need an EIS, which is around 20-25 grand’s worth of information you end up co-ordinating but only doing a fraction of yourself.

    This made the planning application and building regulation a rather expensive process for my client but it really highlights to all what needs to be done and having done this it make the construction less problematic as everyone has a clear idea of what is to be achieved and how it can be achieved.

    I can believe it, but that’s the best way to sell all this additional regulation to a client – as a means of making the building programme safer and hopefully better co-ordinated and quicker.

    I know I said in a previous post that I would stop agreeing with you as it makes the thread boring but what can I say sorry.

    (taps fingers)
    Buggah!

    ONQ.

    #815423
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    An Association named Architects’ Alliance was formed last year to fight against the inequitable aspect of the BCA 2007 and its zealous implementaion by the RIAI.

    http://www.architectsalliance.ie

    At least some people are reacting… Too many just take the beating and keep on smiling…

    #815424
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    In France the building control system is between the UK and the Irish system… All projects except dwelling and domestic extensions with a floor area below 180 square metres need to be signed by an architect prior to the start of the construction…

    The architect is supposed to prepare the construction design and all specifications. He is also supposed to supervise the construction…

    The building control authorities request an architect’ stamp and signature with the notice for commencement of works, the design and specifications do not need to be submitted…

    The fact is that many people want to build their own dwellings and that they are not interested with the architect designing the dwelling for them. French architects in the country do not let their clients many choices with regard to construction technologies. Generally they have one method of construction and they stick to it whatever the clients… It makes things much easier for them and minimizes the risks.

    Many of these French architects working in the country side are paid sometime between 1,000 to 3,000 just to sign a notice of commencement of work in relation to a project that they did not design on a site where they never been and will probably never go…

    This registered architect’ signature has a value related to the legislation. For the client it is only a cost, for the building and the project it is nothing but an administrative obligation… In relation to the design and quality of the architecture it is shameful…

    I think that this example of bribery, which is very common within the French system, reflects quiet well what registration is about… There are very similar issues within the Irish system with the opinions for compliance, that the RIAI is trying to monopolize… Or with some public sector projects, on which the government would not consider the design of a non registered architect during a competition, even if the design is better than others…

    Registration is a method to control competition, denigrating the know-how, experience and skills of those who are not registered. Registration is a step toward the French system, where architects are necessary not to design, create and control, but just to sign an administrative form…

    #815425
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:

    An Association named Architects’ Alliance was formed last year to fight against the inequitable aspect of the BCA 2007 and its zealous implementaion by the RIAI.

    http://www.architectsalliance.ie

    At least some people are reacting… Too many just take the beating and keep on smiling…

    Are you sure this isn’t a case of “too little, too late?”

    I was speaking with the DIT recently and from what I could glean there is a move throughout Europe to require the Registration of Architects.

    It would be interesting if some readers here could confirm this process.

    Perhaps we’ll just wait for the Architect’s Alliance to get up to speed on this.

    That should take them another two years, but which time it’ll all be fait accompli – again.

    BTW CK they require to see a portfolio of your work too – but you prolly know that from reading their website .

    This may explain the fact that you’re not jumping up and down about YET ANOTHER group who just won’t accept your word for how brilliant you are!

    LOL!

    ONQ.

    #815426
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @CK wrote:

    I(snip)

    I think that this example of bribery, which is very common within the French system, reflects quiet well what registration is about… There are very similar issues within the Irish system with the opinions for compliance, that the RIAI is trying to monopolize… Or with some public sector projects, on which the government would not consider the design of a non registered architect during a competition, even if the design is better than others…(snip)

    So, CK, in one rambling paragraph you’ve managed to alienate your Country of Origin as well as the Registration Body and the Public Sector in Ireland.

    You should join the Architect’s Alliance – they’re looking for Agitators aren’t they? No?

    Oh wait.. Architects, they’re looking for Architects…

    Sorry.

    ONQ.

Viewing 20 posts - 401 through 420 (of 1,243 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.