Metro North
- This topic has 958 replies, 74 voices, and was last updated 15 years, 1 month ago by
Anonymous.
- AuthorPosts
- March 9, 2009 at 9:35 am #794886
Anonymous
Inactive@PVC King wrote:
PPP returns are based on a return on total capital employed. The project price according to you is €2.5bn therefore an annual return of €200m p.a. would be the very minimum that any of the 3 possible players involved would have considered back in the good old days when a system called credit existed.
Have you a shortlist of the PPP players who would actually do it on your terms
Mickey Mouse?
Donald Duck?
Roger Rabbitt?Of the economic opinion pieces in todays sindo the metro was listed in every economic analysis as the first project to go.
you’re crazy.
March 10, 2009 at 2:41 am #794887Anonymous
Inactivehttp://www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/ireland/2009/0310/1224242572119.html
Following an emergency meeting of industry-wide groups yesterday, Mr Parlon said the construction industry was already in freefall. He said the industry would be bringing forward a plan to fund development projects “off-balance sheet” through utilising the 80 per cent of pension funds currently being invested outside the State.And he said Ireland would ruin its credibility internationally if the Dublin Metro project did not go ahead.
Mr Parlon also said he would very strongly support the Dublin Metro North project, which was a public-private partnership.
“Very little Government money will go into the metro and we have some of the best engineering and financial consortia in the world involved,” he said.
“At a time when we sorely need every euro to be retained in the economy, it makes a huge lot of sense that the pension fund would be invested in infrastructure,” he said.
The proposal was not yet fully refined, but they had engaged with private pension funds and the scheme would likely see a 6-7 per cent guaranteed return on investment. The guarantee would be underwritten by the private sector and would be “off balance sheet” for the Government, and so would not add to the country’s debt.
“In terms of our national or international credibility, if anything is pulled on the metro at the moment, we can throw our hat at trying to attract those kinds of players to invest here in the future.”
I have a very limited financial mind but the Irish pensioners invest internationally and then they spend some of the money in Ireland which guarantees them a return of 6-7 percent? Does that guarantee an 6-7% fare increase every year? is that about right? No Irish bank was offering a guaranteed 6-7% in the boom or guaranteed pension funds what’s changed? I know some people who have lost half there life savings
March 10, 2009 at 4:56 am #794888Anonymous
InactiveOK, let’s have a look at the figures that PVC finds so sacred.
MN will have a capacity of 20,000 passengers per hour per direction. It will operate for 19hrs a day. That amounts to max capacity of 760,000 per week or approx 370 million passengers per year.
Let’s say it carries 200 million a year ( going by LUAS it will be more). In 10 yrs time that will be a fares income of more than 500 million a year.
In fact MN will be a huge earner.
Further, given Ireland’s economic, political, and geographical location location, even at this time it will not be difficult to raise the cash.
Very difficult to take PVC seriouslly when you look at the alternatives he proposes.
Take the idea of a spur from the northern line.
Puttng an airport train down the line after each nth commuter train will push the DART frequency to one every 30 mins in the rush hour. Maybe I’m paranoid but I suspect the rush hour DART commuters might spot that…..
And this for a train that will only have one stop en route to the airport.
Build a LUAS to the airport?
Nonsense.
The route is one of the city’s busiest, with several severe pinch points.
Yet the proposal is to take 2 lanes from other traffic. All for the modest Luas carrying capacity……..March 10, 2009 at 9:57 am #794889Anonymous
Inactive@missarchi wrote:
I have a very limited financial mind but the Irish pensioners invest internationally and then they spend some of the money in Ireland which guarantees them a return of 6-7 percent? Does that guarantee an 6-7% fare increase every year? is that about right? No Irish bank was offering a guaranteed 6-7% in the boom or guaranteed pension funds what’s changed? I know some people who have lost half there life savings[/I]
Well at least you are honest. 🙂 I have no idea what you are trying to say.
Parlon is as blinkered as the public servants who are bitching about a contribution towards their pensions. He is a PR guy and knows as much about construction/viability economics as I do about pig farming. In fact, I think I probably know more about pig farming! Similar mathematical calculations (i.e. old guff) were used to justify the Channel Tunnell and EuroDisney, both of which went down the crapper.
As for Irish pension funds investing here, have we entirely lost the plot on financial risk assessment? In 2008 the Irish share prices Index (ISEQ) fell by 66%. Internationally, the Dow Jones Industrial Average closed down 34% and Standard & Poor’s 500-stock index finished down 38% – – its worst year since 1937. Year to date in Ireland the figures are considerably worse.
Irish pension funds invest overseas so as to spread their risk. Invest your pension in Ireland and you will see it lose value at a much faster rate. Frankly, there is little left to invest in in Ireland. Of course, any public servant does not have to worry about this,
When the IMF arrives Metro North will be one of the first things to be binned, along with guaranteed index-linked pensions and guaranteed Public Service jobs for life. Looking at the tripe emanating from the Government and worse still from the Opposition, the date the IMF will arrive is not far off. Sadly, I’m beginning to look forward to it, because I’m sick and tired of the head in the sand status of the fools involved in running this country.Metro North is a distraction, a red herring and a waste of discussion time, unless of course you are an architect with no work and plenty of time.
Rs
K.March 10, 2009 at 2:17 pm #794890Anonymous
Inactive@KerryBog2 wrote:
Well at least you are honest. 🙂 I have no idea what you are trying to say.
Parlon is as blinkered as the public servants who are bitching about a contribution towards their pensions. He is a PR guy and knows as much about construction/viability economics as I do about pig farming. In fact, I think I probably know more about pig farming! Similar mathematical calculations (i.e. old guff) were used to justify the Channel Tunnell and EuroDisney, both of which went down the crapper.
As for Irish pension funds investing here, have we entirely lost the plot on financial risk assessment? In 2008 the Irish share prices Index (ISEQ) fell by 66%. Internationally, the Dow Jones Industrial Average closed down 34% and Standard & Poor’s 500-stock index finished down 38% – – its worst year since 1937. Year to date in Ireland the figures are considerably worse.
Irish pension funds invest overseas so as to spread their risk. Invest your pension in Ireland and you will see it lose value at a much faster rate. Frankly, there is little left to invest in in Ireland. Of course, any public servant does not have to worry about this,
When the IMF arrives Metro North will be one of the first things to be binned, along with guaranteed index-linked pensions and guaranteed Public Service jobs for life. Looking at the tripe emanating from the Government and worse still from the Opposition, the date the IMF will arrive is not far off. Sadly, I’m beginning to look forward to it, because I’m sick and tired of the head in the sand status of the fools involved in running this country.Metro North is a distraction, a red herring and a waste of discussion time, unless of course you are an architect with no work and plenty of time.
Rs
K.t h e r e w i l l b e n o IMF in O i r l a n d.
be better off shticking to the GAA and mangling the disciplinary appeals process. simpler to understand ha ha.
March 10, 2009 at 2:48 pm #794891Anonymous
Inactive@marmajam wrote:
be better off shticking to the GAA and mangling the disciplinary appeals process. simpler to understand ha ha.
Not sure that the IMF could do much to help the GAA in Kerry.
K.March 10, 2009 at 8:42 pm #794892admin
Keymaster@marmajam wrote:
t h e r e w i l l b e n o IMF in O i r l a n d.
be better off shticking to the GAA and mangling the disciplinary appeals process. simpler to understand ha ha.
Noel O’Gara at least had a sense of humour; you do not, nor any valid points.
Missarchi you really have outdone yourself quoting Tom Parlon; lets think back over TP’s career. IFA Chief Incitement Officer for the regular farmers mobs who released flocks of sheep into the Dept of Agriculture. The 32 story residential tower in Kilmainham which the market rejected in his stint as a member of the PDs that party born in the 1980’s out of the sheer frustration that Haughey was promising to buy the electorate in the 1986/7 period before Ray McSharry sorted Haughey’s plans into something credible. With this perfect background in controlling his members, designing viable development schemes and joining a party of fiscal recitude what does Tom Parlon suggest?
The proposal was not yet fully refined, but they had engaged with private pension funds and the scheme would likely see a 6-7 per cent guaranteed return on investment. The guarantee would be underwritten by the private sector and would be “off balance sheet” for the Government, and so would not add to the country’s debt
The proposal is not yet developed because investment funds that have some funds left after the rush to the exits can buy investments yielding 8.5% plus; an example might be a 100,000 sq foot Tesco supermarket with 18 years left and no breaks with rent reviews every 5 years yielding 8.5%.
Who is going to take the development risk on this for 6-7% when estimates for Londons Cross rail which is 6-7 miles underground are coming back at £15bn sterling. It simply doesn’t stack up as a private sector investment.
Tom’s real piece de resistance yesterday however was on RTE; I think the CIF really need to look at Tom’s continued role if they are to recover any shard of credibility.
The supplementary Budget to be introduced by the Government has the potential to make things worse rather than better, according to the Construction Industry Federation.
CIF Director General Tom Parlon said the focus appeared to be on taxes and cuts and, in his view, this was ‘entirely the wrong thing to do’. http://www.rte.ie/news/2009/0309/construction.html
John Drennan’s piece quite chillingly spells out the road ahead; I wish it were different but looking at PMIs on both manufacturing and services in the early 30s now is not the time for white elephant projects.
Cowen must come clean on the ‘ground zero’ of economic collapse
Sunday March 08 2009Ireland first heard about the concept of “ground zero” after the planes crashed into New York’s Twin Towers on 9/11. In the chaos that followed, we learned that ground zero was the furnace of the battle.
It is that final equivocal point before the skies clear, the shootings die down and we learn the identity of the winners and losers of the war.
After last week, amid all the smoke and chaos of the Irish economic collapse — quite aside from the fact that, rather like Britain under Labour in the Seventies, Ireland under Cowen is not working — one other thing was clear: it is well gone past the time that the Government came clean and told us what precisely the ground zero of the Irish economic collapse will be.
The people already suspect that the truth of the matter is that Ireland has no money.
It would (just about) be excessive to say we are bankrupt, but Ireland Inc is — as of now — technically insolvent to the point where only our membership of Europe is sparing us from a fate similar to that of Iceland.
If, however, the Irish people are ever going to face the consequences of this in practice rather than in theory, it is now time to make it official.
In other words, the Government must tell us when we are going to reach “ground zero”, and what it will mean, even if we will not reach that point for some time yet.
The Government also needs to tell us what we are going to have to do to ensure that reaching ground zero will not bankrupt the nation, because it is now abundantly clear that our economy needs extensive surgery.
A nation which is poised to borrow €25bn to keep the show on the road, and secure revenue of little more than €30bn, is probably less than six months away from default.
If that occurs, the only thing that will save us is the sight of Angela Merkel landing with a large bag of German taxpayers’ money. While some feral Dail conspiracy theorists believe that Fianna Fail’s (FF) secret plan is to go bankrupt and let the Germans take the rap for the consequences, we suspect that not even Brian Cowen wants to be remembered as the Redmondite who turned Ireland into a Home Rule-style colony of Germany.
If this is to be avoided, the Exchequer is faced with stark choices.So far Cowen has tried to fool himself, and us, by claiming that a war on PR consultancies would balance the nation’s books. That option is no longer viable.
So also is the aspiration that €4.5bn might do the job, because if the Department of Finance believed in February that we faced a €4.5bn shortfall, the real figure is more likely to be €6bn.
That, of course, fails to take into account the reality that we have to sort out the rest of the €20bn deficit, but options such as carbon taxes, domestic rates, third-level fees, the ending of mortgage interest relief, rental relief, tax credits and water charges can be put off until our next scheduled budget in December.
For now though, the Cabinet needs to gulp hard and admit to itself and us that the economic “ground zero” we face means all the gains of the past 12 years are now the fiscal equivalent of an auction of repossessed cars.
Ireland is going to have to return to a lower tax rate of 25 per cent and a top rate of 44 per cent. It is a measure of the fiscal mess we are in that merely restoring the status quo of 1997 represents a huge gamble, because the €400bn of private debt means many ordinary citizens simply do not have the liquidity to pay these taxes.
This is only the start of it, however, for our current weakened state means that even this revolution in taxation will raise a maximum of €2bn.If we are to become fiscally solvent, the cherished child benefit of the ladies who lunch will have to be taxed.
That and the abolition of the early childhood supplement will bring in another €800m and see FF go down as the party who finally taxed children’s shoes.
In the light of our latest figures, Cowen’s proud status as the boss of “the highest capital programme” in Europe is as dead as the FF election manifesto.
So far approximately €6bn of the €8bn we propose to spend this year has been allocated. The rest is dead meat — and, yes, that includes vanity projects like Metro North and the Western rail corridor.
The Government is going to have to take €1.5bn out of the social welfare and the public sector pay €20bn spending pots.
At least the public sector has given the Government its chance, for we cannot think of any better example of the truth of the old saying about how those whom the gods wish to destroy they first make mad, than the decision of the Irish Association of Higher Civil Servants to support a one-day strike in defence of the pay and conditions of the fine mandarins who turned this country into Albania.
The only appropriate response to this threat is a decision by the Government to rescind every pay increase sanctioned by the flawed benchmarking system.
It would of course be excessive to reverse the 20 of them in one go, but a Bertie-style “a lot done, more to do” cut in public sector pay of five per cent for all salaries above the €60,000 mark would represent a good start.
That would raise €500m immediately, but if we are to remain solvent the Government will have to follow the fine precedent set by Ernest Blythe and raise €1bn by cutting social welfare rates by five per cent .
Sadly, the Taoiseach’s tasks do not end there. If we were still living in the soap opera era of Bertie, all eyes would be focused on the leadership implications of Brian Lenihan’s decision to singe his leader’s beard with his admission last week that we need a national government in all but name. This means poor Cowen will now have to suffer the cruellest cut of all.
Saying sorry, particularly for aristocrats, may be the hardest thing, but if the Taoiseach “gets real” and apologises for the sins of the past and extends his drowning hand to the Opposition, he would at least be on the high moral ground.
Everyone in the country except FF, Labour and Fine Gael (FG) realises that we need a new politics of mature generosity. Of course, the Opposition is understandably worried about the consequences of its own ambitions of saving Private Cowen.
In fact, FG and Labour need not worry, for no matter what happens the public will use the first chance they get to run the current lot out of power for a generation.
Their main concern should be the consequences Gilmore and Kenny will have to deal with should their political selfishness create a situation where, if they finally get into office, there will be no country left for them to run.
With 30% of dublin architects and surveyors on the dole or McDonalds (sorry – anyway their fit outs are getting better) what needs to happen is that credit flows in the system again; the perception of the banks is linked to the perception of the government. What McSharry & Co did with the support of Dukes in 1987/88 created a boom that lasted from 1988 – 2007 minus 1991-93; building uncosted vanity projects to stimulate demand giving the central euroean governments the excuse they have been waiting a decade for to kill the corporate tax advantage would be quite Parlonesque.
March 10, 2009 at 9:50 pm #794893Anonymous
InactiveThere are so many inaccuracies above I don’t know where to begin. Firstly, the comparison to Crossrail is ludicrous. Crossrail involves 20 km of tunnels twice the diameter proposed for Metro North, along with the total rebuilding of almost every station on the route, along with large scale electrification works. It is an entirely different scale to what is planned in Dublin.
Metro North is a much more modest project – it will use the same type of rolling stock as the Luas, narrower than the DART to allow smaller, cheaper tunnelling. The bored tunnels will run from the city to Griffith avenue, and under the airport, about 7km. The rest of the line will either be cut and cover, or on the surface with over and underbridges. The tender price of 4.5billion is an all inclusive price, including the interest payments.
Metro North will link:
Dublin’s most important office district (Around Stephen’s Green and Leeson Street)
Dublins 2 main shopping areas
The densest residential area in the state (around Parnell street)
The national childrens hospital, and the Mater.
The countries biggest sports stadium (Croke Park)
DCU – 15,000 students a day – the vast majority who commute on public transport
Ballymun, a historically deprived area, very dense, and very high public transport use.
The airport – with 23 million passengers a year, is one of the busier in Europe
Swords – the largest town in the state with no rail link, and poor public transport access to the city.
And finishing with a park and ride on the second biggest motorway in the state – which carries 90,000 people a day at that point.And we know who is prepared to take the risk to build it – the tenders from the qualified bidding groups – who all include finance providers, are in: http://www.rpa.ie/en/news/Pages/MetroNorthTenderBidsRecieved.aspx
All that remains to be seen is can we afford it and should we build it.
As to whether we should build it or not – I am clearly in favour. 4.5billion is a small sum for an investment that will last 100 years or more, judging by other metro lines around the world. We will never get a chance to build it so cheaply as we can now.As to can we afford it – it’s a trickier question. The government is going dambusters through the growth and stability pact, and we certainly can’t afford to borrow any more this year, or likely several years after that. But money isn’t due until it’s built, and that will be at least 5 years from now. If we haven’t recovered by then, the price of the metro will be total peanuts compared to what the country will be spending on the banks, and will actually result in a tangible benefit.
And lets not forget that every developed nation is taking on enormous amounts of debt right now – this inevitably points to a decade of high inflation to come, where the value of the metro to Dublin will stay the same, but the difficulty of paying it back will be reducing every year.
March 10, 2009 at 10:06 pm #794894Anonymous
Inactive@Fergal wrote:
And we know who is prepared to take the risk to build it – the tenders from the qualified bidding groups – who all include finance providers, are in: http://www.rpa.ie/en/news/Pages/MetroNorthTenderBidsRecieved.aspx
In each one of those syndicates there are companies/financiers that currently are having difficulty keeping their heads above water. Have you been reading the papers?
K.March 10, 2009 at 10:38 pm #794895Anonymous
InactiveActually, none of HSBC, BAM, Macquarie Bank, or Barclays have so far received a penny of a government bailout, although Barclays were sailing pretty close to the wind, and most would be noted for their prudent financial management. They all are in a position to lend, and have lots of experience in this kind of project.
March 11, 2009 at 12:52 am #794896Anonymous
Inactive@marmajam wrote:
OK, let’s have a look at the figures that PVC finds so sacred.
MN will have a capacity of 20,000 passengers per hour per direction. It will operate for 19hrs a day. That amounts to max capacity of 760,000 per week or approx 370 million passengers per year.
Let’s say it carries 200 million a year ( going by LUAS it will be more). In 10 yrs time that will be a fares income of more than 500 million a year.
Ok I was waiting for you to say something interesting or intelligent given the knowing and belligerent tone of your posts but the above proves that you are just a clown. 200 million a year? You are predicting that almost every man, woman and child in Dublin will take a “trip” on metro north once every single working day of the year?
“Going by Luas it will be more”? The two Luas lines together – which have been a phenomenal success – carry about 30 million a year and you basing your predictions on a SINGLE line carrying 7 times the number of passengers as the two Luas lines together?
Even the RPA are only projecting 35 million passenger trips a year last I read. Also last I read the capital costs were projected to be around the 3.7 billion not 2.5 billion which I believe was the figure the RPA bandied about for an O’Connell St. to Airport metro (not Stephen’s Green to Swords) with no connection with any other rail line except the red Luas, no station/connection at Drumcondra or other “trimmings” (like disabled access!).
To be honest, I would have just about supported this project until last year even though by my calculations the government subvention was going to cost in the range of 4 and 11 euro per passenger journey for the 35 years. Even assuming the winning consortium can secure finance at 8% and the passenger numbers are 50% higher than what the RPA are suggesting, the subvention per passenger journey works out at about 6 euro. This is massive when you look at Luas never mind IR or Dublin Bus (it will cost the government as much in subvention to carry a single metro north passenger as it currently costs to carry 20 passengers on Dublin Bus). However, my support was based on the idea that at the time we had a 20 year record of completely underestimating our infrastructure needs and that the government coffers were awash with money and if they were going to waste billions that I’d prefer they do it doing something which provides a tangible benefit instead of countless projects and expenditure which deliver nothing at all.
I no longer support metro north. The population of the country is falling for the first time in 2 decades; of the remainder we are looking at 80s levels of unemployment by the end of the year. We need to look for cheap and clever solutions and to be honest I don’t actually feel that ferrying people too and from the airport should be the top priority; I fly in and out of it regularly and while I’d much prefer to take a 25 minute metro to Stephen’s Green, in the context of air travel the extra 20 minutes spent on a bus is relatively insignificant.
Believe it or not metro is not the only solution for urban mass transport; I’ve been spending time in Zürich (which has the best public transport system I’ve experienced) and they had a referendum on building a metro system about 20 years ago and voted against it because the metro proposals simply did not deliver in terms of cost. Instead they greatly increased the tram system and built interconnectors to leverage the existing heavy rail lines. Of course the Swiss have the operational side down to a tee while we sit at the opposite end of the spectrum.
In the current climate, Metro North represents hubristic trophyism. There isn’t a chance it will be built. I still support the interconnector but support very little that the RPA is proposing. The red line extension makes sense. But the Lucan Luas and Metro West are simply daft; the convoluted proposed BX is similarly stupid (60% more expensive than a straightforward direct link according to RPA estimates while being slower and more disruptive).
March 11, 2009 at 9:44 am #794897Anonymous
InactiveBut the Irish Independent has learned that the capital projects which are safe include all the major inter-urban motorway projects such as the Limerick-Nenagh upgrade, the Galway to Ballinasloe motorway and the Dublin to Waterford motorway. Two public-private partnerships, the Limerick to Cork motorway and the Galway to Tuam motorway, have also been approved in recent months.
THE credit crunch and financial meltdown is playing havoc with the Government’s plans to deliver billions of euro of Public Private Partnership (PPP) projects.
As banks withdraw from lending, construction projects ranging from the €700m Thornton Hall prison to the Abbey Theatre face immense difficulty in securing private funding. Not one single PPP project was funded last year, following a glut of schemes in 2007.
The implosion of Depfa bank, which was one of the major funders of the Irish PPP sector, forced a number of schemes to seek new financing. Last week, Transport Minister Noel Dempsey announced ambitious plans for new roads worth almost €1.4bn. Three of these will come under the PPP scheme.
Dempsey is adamant that the Metro North project will continue. It is understood that sovereign wealth funds have expressed an interest in financing Irish infrastructure. Several of the funds — primarily from the Gulf states such as Dubai, Abu Dhabi and Kuwait, have met with officials from the department of finance.
Dempsey is believed to be keen on taking a future Irish PPP project — such as Metro West — on an investor roadshow to the Gulf states to gauge interest.
March 11, 2009 at 10:03 am #794898Anonymous
InactiveI am appalled by the pro-cyclical economics on display: the down turn is a reason to build, not to stop. MN is, or almost is, a shovel ready project, if it can be financed it should go ahead.
Do you think the famine piers made strict economic sense, or the WPA projects?
Our entire stimulus package, so called, boiled down to 100m for home insulation; crazy. Local governments are canceling sensible urban renewal projects for the sake of funding, somehow the book keeping is easier if you pay people dole instead?
Obviously if the MN involves too much direct government borrowing it can’t go ahead, we are having trouble selling bonds, but if it is predominately financed through the PPP mechanism, it should absolutely go ahead, not for public transport reasons, though I think they justify the project, but for economic reasons.
March 11, 2009 at 12:07 pm #794899Anonymous
InactiveIt’s a bit too late to be appalled by pro-cyclical fiscal policies, notjim. Any chance the country had of allieviating the cyclical downturn fiscally was blown by the government spending policies since 2001. Because government spending expanded at such a rate during this 6 or so years, it will be impossible to even maintain current levels of expenditure never mind continue the exponential trajectory of spending. There are two sides to a Keynesian approach – government contraction during booms and expansion during busts. I find it almost amusing the number of “half” Keynesians that have suddenly appeared in the country; i.e. they never complained about the government spending like crazy during a boom but are now demanding – referencing Keynes – that the government spend like crazy during a bust.
I also think that many people have a very twisted understanding of what Keynes argued for. He would NEVER have advocated borrowing money to pay people to dig holes and fill them in again or to build useless piers in inaccessible places. He argued for an expansion of government spending during a business cycle trough in order to even out the lack of demand in general in the economy. The government spending is still expected to be efficient in terms of stimulating the economy. Paying people to build roads through bogs which will never or rarely be used (or the modern equivalent – building motorways in sparsely populated areas) would obviously be a popular plan with the likes of Tom Parlon and who he represents but it would hardly benefit anyone outside of the people immediately employed.
This isn’t theoretical – look at Japan since the 1990s for what happens if you blindly embrace the idea of government stimulus spending for the sake of it. In 10 years they borrowed the equivalent of their entire GDP and spent it on “infrastructure” like the famous bridge which is rarely used. None of this spending did anything to stimulate the economy and it remained in a slump despite this huge amount of spending except now they have a tower of government debt to deal with as well as a falling economy.
Anyway, no matter where you sit along this economic ideological spectrum, the government will effectively have X amount to spend on a stimulus package attempting to counter the bust. It is even more vital than during a boom that this X is spent carefully on projects that delivery as much as possible. It is still important to evaluate the projects in terms of costs and benefits. There is no point in spending the money paying people to dig and fill holes in bogs. Metro North does not measure up for me when you look at the figures; we are looking at a subvention of 6 times that given to Dublin bus for a system which will carry a 5th of the passengers.
Also, I dunno why people feel that there is something financially magical about PPP whereby “free” money is being created. It is government borrowing just as clearly as selling bonds is. There is simply no difference (except in terms of accounting) in terms of government finance between paying a PPP consortium 200 million a year for 20 years and paying a 200 million on bond coupons. Sorry there is one difference; for these sorts of figures the government could raise 2.5 billion by issuing bonds while only 1.6 billion would be raised by PPP.
March 11, 2009 at 1:22 pm #794900Anonymous
InactiveIt is not true that Metro North will require a subsidy 5 times that of Dublin Bus. Metro North will probably require a fairly small operating subsidy. It is the capital cost that is expensive – the key difference is that this is only paid once. When the last payment is in for Metro North, say, in 2040, that is the infrastructure paid for forever, unlike Dublin Bus, which wil require the subsidy for as long as it operates. The subsidy for Dublin Bus will only increase over time, as it rises with inflation, while the capital cost of Metro North is a fixed amount, which will decline year over year. In 30 years, 4.5 billion is likely to be equivalent to about 800 million today.
And another issue is that the subsidy to Dublin bus is tiny – it is half the amount spent yearly on the rural school bus scheme for example, and is the main reason Dublin bus can’t run a proper 24 hour service, have reasonable fares, or serve people travelling to destinations that do not start or end in the city centre.
March 11, 2009 at 2:39 pm #794901Anonymous
InactiveWhat Keynes actually said.
“If the Treasury were to fill old bottles with banknotes, bury them at suitable depths in disused coalmines which are then filled up to the surface with town rubbish, and leave it to private enterprise on well-tried principles of laissez-faire to dig the notes up again (the right to do so being obtained, of course, by tendering for leases of the note-bearing territory), there need be no more unemployment and, with the help of the repercussions, the real income of the community, and its capital wealth also, would probably become a good deal greater than it actually is. It would, indeed, be more sensible to build houses and the like; but if there are political and practical difficulties in the way of this, the above would be better than nothing.”
March 11, 2009 at 9:31 pm #794902admin
KeymasterIf it were as simple as following Keynes none of us would work but simple follow an investment strategy with our initial pocket money acting perfectly in five year cycles until we ended up like JP McManus rich!
I do however find his observation of the treasury printing banknotes to bury interesting as that is the one bullet not available to the government; the current issue as opposed to crisis is that International bond markets question Irelands ability to keep creating liquidity by borrowing to plug the government deficit which only results from letting current spending run way out of line during the boom and then the boomier years. What the market is saying the more money the Irish government prints the higher risk premium they will apply to all existing money owed by the government.
How projects like a motorway to Waterford, Western Rail Corridor or Metro can survive in this context is beyond me. But a 2-3 year phase of fiscal responsibility will deliver a sound public purse when things recover in 2012.
Fergal R you are right on crossrail it is 13 miles of new tunnels if the distance from beyond Paddington and the Shenfield branches are included; it is however highly unlikely that the Shenfield branch will happen on time due to the costs escalating due to the fall in sterling and the fact that most tech is made in either the Eurozone or Japan which has levered costs in an upward direction dramatically due to currency movements.
It is also as you point out a more complex project which incidently started last month to tie in the new line with old stations such as Tottenham Court Road. The build costs in Euro terms are now c€21bn due to the depreciation in sterling or over €1.5bn per mile of tunnel.
Where I do fundamentally disagree with you is the passenger generation capacity; Swords is not metro material it has a population of 30,000? How many of them work locally or no longer work?
Ballymun is not highly dense enough, it might have been had they infilled around the towers but a lets give de population a back garden model was chosen.
DCU has how many students? Most of them live in Finglas, Ballygall, Old Ballymun and Whitehall/Sanrty. I’d say it probably has the highest cycely comutting rate of any uni in the country.
Hospitals don’t get undergrounds they get light rail or planned bus stops elsewhere; for example Northwick Park Hospital in London that is a university bounded by two tube lines had the metropolitan line stop located to serve the town of Kenton wheras the hospital remians good mile away on foot; they didn’t even bother building a proper pedestrian link.
That leaves The Airport which once had 23p.a.x. which is contracting rapidly, O’C St and Stephens Green which is no longer the centre of the office district, lets be honest 100m from the Green and you hit Whitefriar St / Wexford Street. The office district has headed East towards Baggot St / Mount Street / Grand Canal / South Docks and South towards Ballsbridge.
I can only conclude that public money has no place in this project as it doesn’t offer enough transport capicty for what it costs to build; it doesn’t even connect with the Dart system.
In terms of private money you mention Barclays who have yet to outline the scale of their sub-prime exposure if you believe the shareprice. Maquarie relied heavily on the carry trade of money borrowed in yen at cheap interest rates and then deposited in Aussie banks at much higher rates. The carry trade is dead becuase Japan is in deficit for the first time in decades. Unless they get a significant risk premium why would they invest in a project with major development risks; look at the RPA’s first experience with a new type of infrastructure. How far overspent was Luas in the end in percentage terms?
This leaves Noel Dempsey’s road show in the Gulf; I like Noel Dempsey and I really hope he pulls this one off as maybe the Gulf states can take a different view on investing i.e. no payback for 30 – 50 years to counteract a declining earnings base as natural resources decline.
Sadly it must be the only deliverable option on the table due to the absence of funding and the government’s inability to do unviable schemes financially.
March 11, 2009 at 9:45 pm #794903Anonymous
InactiveThe point is this: MN is a pretty good proposal, Dublin sorely needs better public transport and this proposal does all sorts of useful things. It is not perfect, but we need always be mindful that it is always easy to attack a detailed proposal, we compare the flaws to a counter proposal which lacks details and therefore flaws of its own.
To these benefits must now be added in negative the cost of not building it, a huge potential waste in terms of the lost work hours of the unemployed, the lost use of the otherwise retired work machines, the lost skills to be gains, the huge social cost of unemployment.
This still leaves the cost and here none of us really know what is in the tenders, the advantage of a PPP is that our total debt is still low, what is a problem is not out total borrowing but our ability to sell bonds: in a PPP is an alternative route to raising finance.
March 12, 2009 at 5:44 am #794904Anonymous
Inactivehaving parsed the arguments here dispassionately it is clear that the anti MN camp falls into 2 categories.
(1) we are now a sort of upmarket Greenland. We should squirrel away any money we have and find a rock to hide under. Until the Chinese come.
(2) freeloading bogmen worried that their handouts will be chopped want everything In Diblin axed just in case.PVC Queen is likely in the 2nd category as she knows nothing about Dublin. Thinks sending non stopping trains to the airport via nth line, and leaving DARTs at a 30 min frequency is THE answer. ho ho.
MN will go ahead early next year. That is certain.
March 12, 2009 at 8:16 am #794905Anonymous
Inactive@marmajam wrote:
having parsed the arguments here dispassionately it is clear that the anti MN camp falls into 2 categories.
(1) we are now a sort of upmarket Greenland. We should squirrel away any money we have and find a rock to hide under. Until the Chinese come.
(2) freeloading bogmen worried that their handouts will be chopped want everything In Diblin axed just in case.PVC Queen is likely in the 2nd category as she knows nothing about Dublin. Thinks sending non stopping trains to the airport via nth line, and leaving DARTs at a 30 min frequency is THE answer. ho ho.
MN will go ahead early next year. That is certain.
Tool.
Responding to proper arguments – Metro North definitely has a lot of major benefits and potential but I still think there’s a fundamental question about value for money. We could deliver so much more in the form of a massive, citywide integrated transport system for the same price as this.
Luas cost approximately €31million per km. We could quite feasibly build 4-5 times more length of track for the same cost as MN. And lets not talk about there being no room or capability to implement Luas citywide – If we give the city a top to bottom, radical overhaul in terms of traffic management and public transport we could get it to work.
One of the big arguments in favour of Metro North seems to be the fact that its ready to go. That still doesn’t make it anything more than a foolish vanity project, dreamt up by the leaders of a nation drunk on the wealth of an unprecedented boom.
- AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

