Luas, Metro and DART – Drawings and Photomontages
- This topic has 216 replies, 34 voices, and was last updated 12 years, 5 months ago by
Anonymous.
- AuthorPosts
- December 10, 2010 at 7:55 am #813264
admin
KeymasterI am saying the “gaps” will mostly remain and added to that (for most current DART users… including me)
Evidence?
will be a lengthy interchange time, both ways.
150m down an escalator……
December 11, 2010 at 6:04 pm #813265Anonymous
InactiveWhat evidence… don’t be silly … the proposal is to reroute the DART from the North to Heuston via Docklands Underground and the gaps will remain.
In this forum I am inviting architectural “fixes” for the DART Underground as proposed.
CIEs proposal was based on the “Loop line” being the biggest bottle-neck but as a DART user I known that is not the case. The lack of four-tracking is by far the worst bottle-neck.December 11, 2010 at 6:29 pm #813266admin
KeymasterThe only section of the network where all trains currently travel is between the Royal and Grand Canal’s; by diverting all northbound DARTS via the interconnector tunnel 30-40% of traffic is removed from this constrained environment and given access to the key commercial and civic zones in the City. You are the first person in this forum to ever complain at having the ability to have a direct service to Stephens Green instead of Tara Street, Christchurch instead of Connolly.
4 tracking the northern line is a worthy medium term objective, however getting a luas line to the airport would be a greater priority along with some other public transport projects such as Metro West either built as Dart spurs or Luas feeding into Luas North.
December 12, 2010 at 5:34 am #813267Anonymous
Inactive@PVC King wrote:
You are the first person in this forum to ever complain at having the ability to have a direct service to Stephens Green instead of Tara Street, Christchurch instead of Connolly.
When I am wrong, I say sorry. When you are wrong you come up with a direct lie. I never complained about a service to St Stephen’s Green and that is not the center of the city.
December 12, 2010 at 8:46 am #813268admin
KeymasterSo you support the service then?
In employment density and retail intensity terms Stephens Green is the centre of the City; distances may for the pruposes of maps be measured from the GPO but that reflects historic and out of date development patterns as against where people travel to most.
December 12, 2010 at 10:31 pm #813269Anonymous
Inactive@PVC King wrote:
So you support the service then?
So what’s wrong with “sorry”????
I bet more people travel to Blanchardstown S.C. and surrounds than to St Stephen’s Green. If so, by your argument electrification to Coolmine and Clonsilla should take priority over DU. Now isn’t that a good idea?? after the four-tracking north of course.
Of course the whole system should be “joined up”, and platform destination choice should be the standard goal.
December 13, 2010 at 8:01 am #813270admin
KeymasterI think you will find electrificiation to Maynooth is on the cards within or a couple of years after the interconnector completes. Electrification to Maynooth won’t be too far behind nor will electrification to Balbriggan and staggering station calls between Connolly/Spencer Dock and Howth Junction something along the lines of
Dart
IC
Clontarf Rd
Killester
Raheny
Howth JunctionNorthern Line
Connolly
Clontarf Rd
Harmonstown
Kilbarrick
Howth JunctionWould speed up Dart, slow down Northern Commuter and allow passengers from Dart and Northern Commuter to interchange at Clontarf Road to whichever routing they wanted.
December 13, 2010 at 12:59 pm #813271Anonymous
Inactive@PVC King wrote:
…… a couple of years after the interconnector completes.
It will be 4 years at least if DU ever starts and with any luck your “a couple of years after” will mean I will not need the lousy gapped service.
Anything less than 4-tracking is a bad compromise that would severely curtail the trains entering and leaving the DU and compromise the DU RO as it stands. I think they are forecasting a DU train every 3 minutes (would have to check that).
December 13, 2010 at 7:54 pm #813272admin
KeymasterAs the country moves from the ripping itself apart in the media phase to the time to rebuild under a new administration phase; money will be tight and and only must have projects built; I more than anyone would love to see the exchequer position swapping places with the Singapore Finance ministry (not that they would ever end up with any fiscal deficit beyond a single year) but that is not going to happen any time soon.
3 minute headways with Darts speeded up and outer commuters slowed down would be a very very dramatic improvement on current services which are auwful. Blind confidence in the future is inviting a very bad end and being seen to plan for new projects at this time would be just that, the bond hawks certainly have not gone away; careful and meticulous planning has the potential to deliver progress; Dublin Underground is the key piece of investment in the Irish transport system as the economy returns to better times through carefully targeted investments. Straining the public finances to fund new projects or Metro North will send out all the wrong signals from an economy that needs to be seen as beyond perfect for at least the next 5 years.
I am however confident better times are ahead once a stable government emerges who have the will to get it right; no more Tuam motorways……
December 14, 2010 at 1:04 am #813273Anonymous
InactiveHave you ever tried to walk across the N17 of Sawdoctor fame at rush hours? I can only presume you know nothing about the N17 otherwise you would not quote Tuam as a bad example.
Continuous 3 minute headways on DU without big “gaps” will never happen without 4 tracking of feeder lines, for the reasons I have already quoted.
The 4 tracking section east of Pearse is ideal for a temporary (2yrs) station while Pearse is outfitted with DU underneath, but the DU as proposed is looking more and more unlikely, and if it goes ahead a lot of current DART users will be alienated.
December 15, 2010 at 7:03 am #813274admin
KeymasterThe N17 of Sawdoctor fame was actually Kilburn High Road at rush hour in practice; if you remember the pretext of the song was a ‘wish that I was on that N17’. A commuter town of c3,000 people can not justify a motorway in post Lenihan Bros Ireland.
So after the Tuam motorway is built what is actually going to pay for 4 tracking? The Central Bank of Ireland is not the Fed it can’t print money when it feels like it. In any event you have not come up with any technical basis as to why playing around with the timetable will prevent 3 min headways; the Northern line in London runs 90 second headways as do the Jubilee and Central lines at peak.
December 15, 2010 at 10:18 pm #813275Anonymous
Inactive@PVC King wrote:
The N17 of Sawdoctor fame was actually Kilburn High Road at rush hour in practice; if you remember the pretext of the song was a ‘wish that I was on that N17’.
The words of the song mention turning left for Shannon … very difficult to do from Kilburn. (say sorry)
Do you ever look anything up???December 15, 2010 at 10:23 pm #813276admin
KeymasterWell I didn’t see much future
When I left the Christian brothers school
So i waved it goodbye with a wistful smile
And I left the girls of Tuam
Sometimes when I’m reminiscing
I see the prefabs and my old friends
And I know that they’ll be changed or gone
By the time I get home again.(Chorus)
And I wish I was on the n17
Stone walls and the grass is green
And I wish I was on the n17
Stone walls and the grass is green
Travelling with just my thoughts and dreamsWell the ould fella left me to shannon
Was the last time I traveled that road
And as we turned left at claregalway
I could feel a lump in my throat
As I pictured the thousands of times
That I traveled that well worn track
And I know that things will be different
If I ever decide to go back.(Chorus)
And I wish I was on the n17
Stone walls and the grass is green
And I wish I was on the n17
Stone walls and the grass is green
Travelling with just my thoughts and dreamsNow as I tumble down highways
Or on filthy overcrowded trains
There’s no one to talk to in transit
So I sit there and daydream in vain
Behind all those muddled up problems
Of living on a foreign soil
I can still see the twists and the turns on the road
From the square to the town of the tribes
(Chorus)
And I wish I was on the n17
Stone walls and the grass is green
Yes I wish I was on the n17
Stone walls and the grass is green
Travelling with just my thoughts and dreamsNot go and troll some other website
December 15, 2010 at 10:26 pm #813277Anonymous
Inactive(Chorus)
And I wish I was on the n17
Stone walls and the grass is greenHehehehe hardly Kilburn
For your info the N17 is the number of the road from Tuam to Galway …. say sorryDecember 15, 2010 at 10:27 pm #813278admin
KeymasterSome of us graduated from Kilburn to places you can only dream of… now F**k off
December 15, 2010 at 10:27 pm #813279admin
KeymasterSome of us graduated from Kilburn to places you can only dream of… now F**k off
December 15, 2010 at 10:29 pm #813280Anonymous
Inactive@PVC King wrote:
Some of us graduated from Kilburn to places you can only dream of… now F**k off
You never graduated from prep school
December 15, 2010 at 10:35 pm #813281admin
KeymasterWe don’t do the 11 plus in Ireland so you are right it is a gap in my CV, University and professional association are enough, but its the many years of experience of sorting out gobshites that my clients pay me for; those that can’t measure thats worth loads; those that don’t understand the bigger picture, kerching…….
December 16, 2010 at 12:11 am #813282Anonymous
InactiveMetro North manager says project has broad support
THERE WAS a broad public and political consensus behind Metro North and a new government was unlikely to halt it, the project manager claimed yesterday.
He said the agency had met Opposition transport spokesmen and “Labour and Fine Gael were broadly supportive” of the project.
About €135 million has already been spent on enabling works and planning for Metro North and the Railway Procurement Agency said yesterday that €45 million had been provided for it in the Budget. This brings the total spend on Metro North to almost €200 million before the project has received Government approval.
Both Fine Gael and Labour refused to give an absolute commitment to the project yesterday, claiming such a move would be “irresponsible” before assuming office and seeing the full costs.
Contracts for significant enabling works would be awarded early next year. “Until we sign the public-private partnership we can’t say the project will go the full way . . . but it is a note of confidence that the Government said it will support enabling works over the next year or so.”
http://www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/ireland/2010/1215/1224285580700.html
December 16, 2010 at 12:29 am #813283Anonymous
InactiveThese have been out for a while but I though’t I’d post them here
DART Underground 3D animationsPearse Station
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p9s8znCf2eAStephens Green Station
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B25XCQ9i0x4Christchurch Station
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oCy8ekqUC-IInchicore Station
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jv0hnXmSdmsHeuston Station
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YD58BF6oHm8DART Underground: A New Travel Experience
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o8hMdzKhPGERPA Metro 3D animations
Metro North
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HgwYT_4Pr9kMetro West
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5prJe0l7M64 - AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

