Is it really now time to consider restriction of service??

Home › Forums › Ireland › Is it really now time to consider restriction of service??

Viewing 18 posts - 61 through 78 (of 78 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #816511
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    It seems to depend on whether he’s originally from Ireland and also whether or not he qualified here AND whenter he did his Part III here or not.

    If you have a London Part III and ARB accreditation you have some fun ahead of you.

    If you have an Irish Part II and no Part III you have even mroe fun ahead of you with the Registration Process – feel free to confer on this.

    AFAIK – AND DESPITE ALL APPEARANCES TO THE CONTRARY I’M NOT THE EXPERT ON THIS :lolno: – Irish-qualified Architects practising in Ireland need to be Registered here.

    An Irish Architect needs to be accerdited here to work here – I think there was an article in Hot Press last year about someone in a similar plight – and yer man was qualified out the wazoo – James MacAree I think his name was.

    Yep, here’s the reference – you’ll need a subscription to view it.

    http://hotpress.com/archive/6768196.html

    “A bizarre new law places huge obstacles in front of Irish architects who have qualified in the UK and who wish to practice in Ireland – even though non-Irish citizens face nothing like the same level of difficulty.”

    I didn’t read the original article, but I corresponded with James and advised him in relation to his position.

    I understand that the country you qualified in must accredit you through the competent authority, which in Irelands case is the RIAI.

    You might look at this and revert with a comment as to how it affects you/ the person in question if its not your goodself.

    ONQ.

    #816512
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    sorry – probably wasn’t clear as usual. the person in question ain’t Irish and ain’t me. The question here is whether, by virtue of the qualification and the origin of the design, if you like, in terms of the titleblocks, is this legal? ie what stops uk based fully eu qualified architects working here “from home”

    #816513
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Okay wearnicehats

    I don’t know what you mean by “eu qualified” – issues arise in terms of where the primary degree was obtained, the nationality and country of origin of the person and where the person is practising.
    The legalities of lodging planning applications and practising in one country while based in another seem to be another agenda altogether.
    That is to say, Registration is one thing, practising another.

    I’m assuming the person is EU but not Irish or English and got their primary qualification in the EU country, whatever about being accredited through the ARB.
    My gut feeling on this is that if your work is on site here, you are effectively working here regardless of your place of abode or work.
    Therefore you need to be Registered/Licensed to do so – so there is an accreditation process through the RIAI required.

    Couple of clarifications on this.
    The RIAI are currently the Competent Authority in relation to Architecture in Ireland.
    I feel this should have been limited to “the competent body in relation to Registration of Architects in Ireland”, but that’s the way it is for now.
    The person to whom this question needs to be addressed with full information is he admissions Director of the RIAI who will clarify the correct approach for you.

    The reason I take this view point is the degree of jumping through hoops for the Registration Process that James MacAree had to undertake to get recognised here.
    Common sense seemed in short supply when this framework was being drafted, but there is a feeling that equally, if we have to jump through hoops, so should everyone else.
    I’d be VERY interested in finding our where and how this concludes wearnicehats so please consider posting and update when you know how it terms – or is turning – out for your friend.

    In the meantime, here is a link you could pass on and some extracts which may be relevant to your friend’s position –

    =======================================

    http://www.riai.ie/admissions/architects/


    Registration: Route D1

    To qualify for this route you must:

    * be a national of an EU/EEA Member State
    * have a recognised qualification in Architecture from an EU/EEA Member State and
    * meet the requirements of Directive 2005/36/EC on the Recognition of Professional Qualifications

    Download the ROUTE D1 application package

    =======================================

    Registration: Route D2

    To qualify for this route you must be:

    * A national of an EU Member State, Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway or Switzerland and
    * have a Qualification in Architecture from an EU/EAA Member State other than Ireland which does not meet the requirements of Chapter III Article 46 of Directive 2005/36/EC on the Recognition of Professional Qualifications

    This route relates to the ‘General System’ under Title III Chapter I of Directive 2005/36/EC. If successful you may be required to undertake compensation measures to meet the criteria set out in the Building Control Act 2007.

    Please contact the Admissions Director

    =======================================

    Registration: Route D3
    To qualify for this route you must be:

    * A national of an EU or EEA Member State, and
    * Legally established as an architect in a Member State

    This route relates to those seeking to register for the purpose of providing architectural services in the Irish State on a temporary and occasional basis.

    Download the Route D3 Package

    =======================================

    So as you can see its all hugely bound up in red tape and assessment criteria, despite your person having an “eu qualification”.

    ONQ.

    #816514
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    bloody hell – pictionary must be fun with you. It’s a purely hypothetical situation but, for argument’s sake let’s say the person is english, went to a nice school in england followed by RIBA parts 1 and 2 at university (despite middling grades) in england. RIBA Part 3 taken and passed at said university in england. Spending some time in Dublin, decides to do a bit of work for someone as a favour – no fee, no tax issues. Does it all through on paperwork through a company registered in london. Legal?

    How does it work, for instance, if an non-irish firm wins a competiton here (pause for laughter) – must they tie in with a local firm?

    I’m not aware of any legislation that stops someone based overseas lodging a planning application here, for instance. Is there any?

    #816515
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Not yet, but wait until next year …

    For now, you must be registered to practise as an architect here.
    It doesn’t matter whether its lodging an application or certifying a building.
    I think its the same in England were if the situation were reversed you’d need a temporary license.

    I’ll try and post a copy of James MacAree’s Hot Press article later on.

    ONQ.

    #816516
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    http://www.flickr.com/photos/61060971@N03/5561213391/sizes/l/in/photostream/

    The amount of hassle I had posting this on Facebook I just went to Flickr instead.

    ONQ.

    #816517
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    James Mac Arees Hot Press Report in detail seems to suggest that his plight may have little enough to do with your friend’s situation Missarchi.

    The issue is which route would be required for him to proceed and for a definitive on his right to practice here, he has to contact the RIAI.

    I think you’ve zeroed in on a poorly defined area – although the RIAI may have fully considered it in their prognositcations.

    Are you practicing “here” by supplying a service or drawings/documents seeking permission or for construction.

    I think that if you are engaged here and the site is here and the LA is here, you are working “here“.

    If you are using the Title “Architect” then you need to be Registered in Ireland to do this.

    I think the ARB have some kind of “temporary” Registration facility – not sure of that.

    If your friend practices here – as an architect – unregistered – he may be in breach.

    Call the RIAI and have a chat.

    :angel:

    Or contact the AAOI.

    :problem:

    ONQ.

    #816518
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Surprise this even got any press coverage…
    The coverage of Irish architecture/design in the press is very skewed.
    So much so you may as well be vegetarian.
    I would like to see the RIAI take on all international media outlets for using the word architect for banking systems IT and jail them all for a year ect…
    ( but I don’t see it happening )

    Promoting and Supporting Professionally Qualified Irish Architects in Ireland.

    from????

    Promoting and Supporting Irish Architecture.

    I’m well aware Irish architects have gone underground for good reason but this does not mean you always are supporting the best design or outcome.
    Professionally Qualified Irish Architects in Ireland can still specify ********* granite over connemara.
    Professionally Qualified Irish Architects in Ireland can still outsource work.
    Professionally Qualified Irish Architects still have a minimum wage?
    Other developed countries have standards of wages that must be paid for different stages of your career does Ireland?
    There is not one Irish indigenous architect/designer building product that I have seen on the market.
    There is no funding for Irish indigenous architecture just modernity. (discrimination?)
    The RIAI does not have an Indigenous Irish architecture award.
    More work can be done…
    In the end Scarpa did not even accept the paper…

    #816519
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Missarchi,

    Its hard to understand what you are posting about now, but I’ll make an attempt to reply to your comments
    The Indo, the Times and the Sunday Business Post have all commented upon the subject of Registration.
    This above issue got hot press coverage because one person stood up to the RIAI who beign unfair.

    My read on this is that it arose partly through the relative inexperience of those adminstering a myriad of new regulations.
    Trying to do the right thing, they got caught up in the myriad definitions and requirements they themselves lobbied for.

    I don’t see this as suggesting any vindictive streak on their part.
    Bureaucrats will tend to say “no” rather than “yes”.

    There is NO objective coverage in the press per se.
    There are the views of the Registrar and the Architect’s Alliance.
    Montaut and Graby have been the ones exchanging views in the press.

    I have stayed out of this because it ignores several issues, some of which I have posted about here.
    I am more inclusive than Graby in terms of allowing competent people to practise as architects if they can show this.
    I am far less forgiving than Graby because I think that only architects should provide architectural services to the public.
    I include Architectural Technologists in this only so long as the law says they are to be held equally liable to architects – otherwise – no!

    Draftsmen – no! These guys are the bane of all building professionals trying to make a living at the moment!
    Technicians of any sort – No! Not unless they submit their work AS ARCHITECTS and show they are competent at this level
    Engineers – NO!!! Bugger this nonsense – I don’t design structures or services for a living – although I have done both – stay off my turf.
    Surveyors – NO!!!!! They survey things, they’re not even trained as designers FFS!!!

    If its about designing buildings for humans it should be done by architects, simple as that!

    ===========================

    Re your other points.

    No Irish architects are underground.
    Unqualified successes are still using the title architect.
    Graduates are still practising from Mammy’s back room and calling themselves architects

    Specifying Granite?
    Outsourcing Work?
    Minimum Wage?

    As for your last comments about recommened rates, indigenous products, architects and Scarpa?
    Are you drunk in charge of a keyboard?
    What are you on about?

    ONQ.

    #816520
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Architects know a lot about very little.

    Drunk? no that comes naturally…
    But it might invoke a response.

    Anyway on the wage issue what is the minimum you can pay a:

    a) a pre-grad of architecture
    b) grad of archi
    c) 3 year grad
    d) registered
    e) 10 years rego

    #816521
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    There is no legally applicable rate AFAIK, so its the Minimum Wage.

    ONQ.

    #816522
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    What job will an architect do in 2025?

    So what is the incentive to go through all that pain?
    Clearly it seems there is no award wage or structure is that because there is no architects union?
    You must have serious doubts about the profession now? and who it serves?

    riba or riai?

    What have Brad Pitt, Justin Bieber and Mattel’s new Barbie doll got to do with this?

    http://www.abc.net.au/rn/bydesign/stories/2011/3171139.htm

    #816523
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @missarchi wrote:

    What job will an architect do in 2025?

    So what is the incentive to go through all that pain?
    Clearly it seems there is no award wage or structure is that because there is no architects union?
    You must have serious doubts about the profession now? and who it serves?

    riba or riai?

    What have Brad Pitt, Justin Bieber and Mattel’s new Barbie doll got to do with this?

    http://www.abc.net.au/rn/bydesign/stories/2011/3171139.htm

    They got the design of the Architect Barbie so wrong

    I understand where you’re coming from regarding wages etc.
    Looking at the RIAI website jobs are being advertised without pay and there’s free advice clinics coming up, the future doesn’t look good at all.

    #816524
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Architects are competent to comment on all matters in relation to buildings.
    Contrary to your assertion Missarchi, they know a lot about a lot of things.

    The outlook looks bleak for those students leaving the courses this year.
    Design ability doesn’t put money in the account or food on the table.

    Its time the schools started thinking about the numbers emerging.
    Its clear they’re run to a profit-taking agenda, not sustainability.

    A little bit of professionalism managing all markets is needed.
    The bullshit idea that a chaotic market regulates itself?

    That’s like saying criminals will run to confess crimes.
    Just a load of utter bollox promulgated by the Yanks.

    As for the incentive – you wouldn’t understand.
    Its a career, its a vocation, its a profession.

    You either are an architect, or you aren’t.

    ONQ.

    #816525
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    http://www.facebook.com/#!/group.php?gid=110216182335329

    UK based organisation – Architects Against low Pay. Some interested stuff

    #816526
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    http://www.bdonline.co.uk/news/riba-pledges-to-kick-out-wage-abuse-firms/5015962.article

    All good and well, but Angela spoke a few months ago about how upbeat Irish architects were about the downturn

    #816527
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @onq wrote:

    You either are an architect, or you aren’t.ONQ.

    from the bdonline post by an architect?

    It is important that young would-be architects have the opportunity to escape the profession while they are still young enough to restart in a decent career. Many of these young people are intelligent, hardworking and competent, and deserve a reasonably secure and hopeful future.

    Read more: http://www.bdonline.co.uk/5015962.article#ixzz1IJmCpaER
    BDonline.co.uk

    Under Creative Commons License: Attribution

    onq do you support architects as the people or movement or the idea that an architects design is always superior?
    do you serve your clients more than you serve architects?
    Who comes first your client or your design ideals?

    Onq can you show me how the pay structure for architects factors in the cycles of recessions?

    #816528
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @missarchi wrote:

    @onq wrote:

    You either are an architect, or you aren’t.ONQ.

    from the bdonline post by an architect?

    It is important that young would-be architects have the opportunity to escape the profession while they are still young enough to restart in a decent career. Many of these young people are intelligent, hardworking and competent, and deserve a reasonably secure and hopeful future.

    Read more: http://www.bdonline.co.uk/5015962.article#ixzz1IJmCpaER
    BDonline.co.uk

    Nonsense – no one is trapped in a profession – they can walk away and re-train at any time.

    (heads off to bdonline to see what this is all about)

    LOL! That was posted by Alex Ford on 1 April 2011 @ 11:27 am

    Note the date.

    Under Creative Commons License: Attribution

    onq do you support architects as the people or movement or the idea that an architects design is always superior?

    I take each on their merits.

    do you serve your clients more than you serve architects?

    There is no “serve architects” – is this a ten year old writing these questions?

    Who comes first your client or your design ideals?

    Same question?

    Okay – there is no “first”.
    For me design is a battle between –

    • what I want
    • what the client wants
    • what the planners want
    • what the statutory approvals require
    • what the building regulations require
    • what the building itself seems to want

    [/quote]

    Onq can you show me how the pay structure for architects factors in the cycles of recessions?

    No I can’t – I answered this before didn’t I – why do you ask?
    More importantly, why do you keep asking me?

    I’m not a pundit on the economy or a representative of the Competent Authority here, the RIAI.

    The RIAI’s response is to offer architects on the unemployment the “opportunity” to gain experience working for free in architects offices.

    Indentured servitude.

    ONQ.

Viewing 18 posts - 61 through 78 (of 78 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.