Is it really now time to consider restriction of service??

Home › Forums › Ireland › Is it really now time to consider restriction of service??

Viewing 20 posts - 41 through 60 (of 78 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #816491
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @teak wrote:

    I recently did the very difficult planning on a site for a client who then went to his bank to get funds and the bank manager would only issue those funds if a named Architect chosen by the bank manager was used otherwise no money. it’ a dog eat dog situation at the moment.

    Can you tell us more about this one, WNH ?

    Tayto’s positive exit from our crisis is all right for USA architects — they happen to be au fait with the very style of homes that these nouveaux riches in China see on their TV — but it is not, I think, an area that small Irish firms could plausibly aspire to.
    Are you trying this avenue yourself, Tayto ?

    Maybe a better idea would be for recently laid-off staff from the bigger international firms (MOLA, DW, etc) to form a sort of “virtual company” (personal compatibilities allowing) so as to be able to tender for the big foreign design jobs.

    Closer to home, if architects have a will to master High German (hup-ow-that!) there is something going on over there.

    I wish some dog-idle architect would design a definitive set of nationwide signposts that are
    1. Clear at a range 40m by all people, colourblind or not.
    2. Non-twistable about the upright or about the base.
    3. Suitably placed.
    4. Contiguous through every village, town and city for every sighted visitor with no local knowledge whatever.
    5. Made of durable materials and using durable/renewable finshes. (No aluminium as it’ll be stolen.)

    no I can’t because. if you read the posts, I didn’t write it

    was there any need to include the words “dog-idle”? I’d love to be paid to design a sign – who should I talk to Teak?

    #816492
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    I’d love to be paid to design a sign

    Wouldn’t everyone.

    Who should I talk to Teak?

    No one for the time being.
    Pat Kenny verbally sponsored the idea years back but lately he has just despaired of even raising the subject.
    Maybe with so many young people leaving school with no jobs this will be one of those useful public works type tasks that will be given to them that they do not despair, rebel or turn to crime.

    My suggestion was that some unemployed architect might look at it over the odd idle hours.
    But they clearly cannot be doing this while the house bills mount up.

    As you know, those clowns Rennicks have a stranglehold on the councils’ appropriations for signs.
    I wish someone would pay me to investigate this oh-so-intimate relationship . . . .

    #816493
    Paul Clerkin
    Keymaster

    @Solo wrote:

    I recently did the very difficult planning on a site for a client who then went to his bank to get funds and the bank manager would only issue those funds if a named Architect chosen by the bank manager was used otherwise no money. it’ a dog eat dog situation at the moment.

    This I would bring to the attention of the bank`s regional manager and a journalist

    #816494
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    If you’re waiting to get paid you’ll do nothing.
    Set yourself a task – then just do it.
    It needn’t cost you a lot.

    It takes very little time to write an e-mail to all your local councillors asking why Rennicks have the signs.
    It may be as simple as there being no competition.

    ONQ.

    #816495
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @Paul Clerkin wrote:

    @Solo wrote:

    I recently did the very difficult planning on a site for a client who then went to his bank to get funds and the bank manager would only issue those funds if a named Architect chosen by the bank manager was used otherwise no money. it’ a dog eat dog situation at the moment.

    This I would bring to the attention of the bank`s regional manager and a journalist

    #816496
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @Paul Clerkin wrote:

    @Solo wrote:

    I recently did the very difficult planning on a site for a client who then went to his bank to get funds and the bank manager would only issue those funds if a named Architect chosen by the bank manager was used otherwise no money. it’ a dog eat dog situation at the moment.

    This I would bring to the attention of the bank`s regional manager and a journalist

    The incorporated law society also issue “notes” about whose certs may be acceptable.
    Their current position denies graduates in favour of registered architects.
    They are hewing the BCA 2007 Line.

    If architects are going to be brow beaten like this into Registering then three things need to happen:

    1. A fair registration process – one that is seen to be fair, as opposed to pandering to the RIAI.
    2. A fair assessment and reassessment process – one that regularly assesses MRIAIs as well.
    3. Restriction of the provision of architectural services to Architects and their tied agents.

    Instead we’ve seen; –

    1. The MRIAI-only registration process.
    2. Graduates [5 years in academia] and those with ten years in practice, whose certs were previously accepted being unfairly discriminated against, allowing Architectural Technicians [3 years in academia] to continue to use their title and certify freely.
    3. A free-for-all, where the nonsense protection of the Title only, fails miserably to protect the livelihoods of people who have spent up to ten years of more of their lives as students qualifying or as low paid graduates working for MRIAI’s.
    4. Persons in other professions employing architectural graduates and architectural technicians to provide architectural services

    Thsi is a total bastardisation of the profession.
    Something’s got to give.

    ONQ.

    #816497
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Can I just say that a longer time for editing posts would REALLY be appreciated, by me if by nobody else.
    As well as a removal of the glitch that can occur when you’re posting and the preview box comes up.
    You can end up with two posts, thinking that first had gone to preview when it had been posted.

    ONQ.

    #816498
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    double post

    #816499
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @onq wrote:

    Restriction of the provision of architectural services to Architects and their tied agents.

    Persons in other professions employing architectural graduates and architectural technicians to provide architectural services

    Thsi is a total bastardisation of the profession.
    Something’s got to give.

    ONQ.

    well well well, are we now seeing circling of the wagons that the BCA has always threatened??

    im not going to turn this into a yet another techie v arch discussion, but the above post (while selectively quoted, retains ethos) is EXACTLY the kind of thinking that draws a huge wedge in the architectural profession. Like it or not, technicians are architectural professionals, and as such deserve as much chance to provide “architectural services” as architects. If persons in ‘other professions’ (assuming QS, Engs etc here) are engaging architectural graduates and technicians to provide “architectural services” then shouldnt they be allowed to provide the service they had been qualified to do????

    Like it or not, at the formal education level ARCHITECTURE as a profession and an art form is being split into a “design orientated” syllabus and a “technology” orientated syllabus…. two sides of the one profession. Older established architects may not understand, accept or agree with this as they have trained and practised in both aspects…

    On the actual topic….. (putting on my devils advocate mask!!)…

    1. restriction DOES exist in that the practise of nixers is ILLEGAL
    2. restriction on one profession is narrow sighted…. if restriction existing in the architectural profession, will it also exist in the mechanic profession?? cabinet making?? carpet laying ??? etc etc ad nauseum…….. what is so special about the architectural profession that it deserves special legislation to restrict???? if a dodgy mechanic fecks up servicing a car, a person could pay with his/her life…. would that profession deserve to be regulated ahead of a profession that doesnt kill people (only careers)….

    oh and ONQ, what exactly is an Architects “tied agent”?

    #816500
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    –

    #816501
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @henno wrote:

    @onq wrote:

    Restriction of the provision of architectural services to Architects and their tied agents.

    Persons in other professions employing architectural graduates and architectural technicians to provide architectural services

    Thsi is a total bastardisation of the profession.
    Something’s got to give.

    ONQ.

    well well well, are we now seeing circling of the wagons that the BCA has always threatened??

    im not going to turn this into a yet another techie v arch discussion, but the above post (while selectively quoted, retains ethos) is EXACTLY the kind of thinking that draws a huge wedge in the architectural profession. Like it or not, technicians are architectural professionals, and as such deserve as much chance to provide “architectural services” as architects. If persons in ‘other professions’ (assuming QS, Engs etc here) are engaging architectural graduates and technicians to provide “architectural services” then shouldnt they be allowed to provide the service they had been qualified to do????

    The services they have been qualified to do is to provide technician information to architects after three years of a technically focussed course – there is very little design content in their course.
    This doesn’t make them competent to design buildings, just to detail the designs of others – this is the chip on their shoulders they all seem to have.
    The only ones who seem to get beyond thsi are the ones who go on to become architects.

    Like it or not, at the formal education level ARCHITECTURE as a profession and an art form is being split into a “design orientated” syllabus and a “technology” orientated syllabus…. two sides of the one profession. Older established architects may not understand, accept or agree with this as they have trained and practised in both aspects…

    I qualified in 1990 and I understand this very well.
    Technicians are trained to think about components and building physics [tom some degree] not about developing a design to both planning stage and on-site to the completion stage.
    Another year of professional practice studies or M&E 101 makes them better at answering technical questions, it doesn’t make them architects or even architects-lite

    On the actual topic….. (putting on my devils advocate mask!!)…

    1. restriction DOES exist in that the practise of nixers is ILLEGAL

    Nonsense in relation to restriction – services are not restricted.
    Technicians who are operating as architects are already beginning to feel the heat as untrained persons and draughtsmen on the dole and working from home are taking the business from them too.
    Nixers are not illegal as long as you declare them for tax purposes and they do not breach your contract of employment.
    However under the Health and Safety regulations the Designer carries special responsibility and like everyone must be competent to carry out his/her task.
    Technicians are not trained as designers – ergo.

    2. restriction on one profession is narrow sighted….

    One definition of a profession is a group composed of highly trained people providing competent specialised services to the public and the state.
    Its neither narrow minded or short sighted to restrict access to competent persons or to assess those persons – it is good practice.

    if restriction existing in the architectural profession, will it also exist in the mechanic profession??

    The Mechanic is a tradesman, but yes, that trade in particular should be restricted.
    I don’t want an idiot fettling a ton of metal that could kill someone if the brakes failed.
    Building trades are effectively restricted by the Safety Health and Welfare at Work legislation requiring all persons to be competent to carry out their assigned tasks.

    cabinet making??

    Cabinet Making is a craft I think, but restricting it is fine by me, not that many would be competent enough to do attempt cabinet making – the hierarchy in woodworking in terms of growing skill level runs Carpenter, Joiner, Cabinet Maker.

    carpet laying ???

    Neither a trade nor a profession.

    etc etc ad nauseum…….. what is so special about the architectural profession that it deserves special legislation to restrict????

    If someone is at that stage in their life where buildings are merely used to support bodily function the importance of the built environment may be lost, but for the rest of us it is vitally important.
    Even for people with little cerebral appreciation of buildings, they are aware of the support they bring to human activity.

    We spend half our lives awake in homes or workplaces with another quarter in activities in recreational pursuits that are normally supported by buildings in some way, while the last quarter is spent sleeping – again usually in some sort of building.

    Better built environments and buildings offer significantly increased life expectancy and quality of life – this is a given.
    They do this all the time, 24/7/365 – I shouldn’t ahve to explain this – you should know.

    if a dodgy mechanic fecks up servicing a car, a person could pay with his/her life…. would that profession deserve to be regulated ahead of a profession that doesnt kill people (only careers)….

    I have already confirmed that the trade of mechanic should be regulated.
    In case you weren’t aware [ where have you been for the last thirty years] badly designed buildings *do* kill people.
    The quality of design here in Ireland tends to mitigate against such disasters but laypersons shouldn’t go around assuming they know much about buildings any more than they should assume they are competent to carry out operations or prescribe medicine [Pharmacists take note].

    Building Collapses:
    The Hyatt Hotel Walkway collapse is probably the most famous collapse in America not attributed to a terrorist attack
    http://mecholsky.mse.ufl.edu/EMA4913-14/Hyatt%20Walkway%20Collapse%20J%20article.pdf
    In developed countries, where the technical expertise and knowledge is available, unscrupulous developers can put people’s lives at risk:
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sampoong_Department_Store_collapse
    Buildings in many third world countries still do not meet international building code standards.
    http://www.deccanherald.com/content/113471/delhi-building-collapse-death-toll.html
    Deaths in Mombasa as building collapses http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TNeHmxiygFc

    Health Risks:
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sick_building_syndrome
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mold_health_issues

    Fire Risks:
    http://www.stardustsupport.com/cms/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=25&Itemid=37

    At least do some cursory reading up on the subject before commenting.

    oh and ONQ, what exactly is an Architects “tied agent”?

    They provide services to them, not to the public.

    ONQ.

    #816502
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Lawyers operate a particularly Byzantine form of protection, whereby bar associations are limited to geographical locations, and an attorney in one region may be prohibited from practicing in another. what does that sound like?

    The operation of closed professions, which include architects, civil engineers, hairdressers, opticians, real estate agents, speech therapists and bakers, has been described by IOBE

    http://www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/world/2011/0121/1224288006860.html

    #816503
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Interesting article, but again, its apples and oranges.

    I’m not talking about restricting access to the profession from other countries affecting the free movement of goods and services.
    I’m talking about the provision of professional services by people without a prescribed qualification or even a technicians qualification.

    Greece seems to be operating a “guild” system where similarly qualified persons from other countries cannot get a look in.
    Mind you I noted the reference to graduates with interest, they still have it good.
    €530/mth seems a lot more when you’re on the dole.

    ONQ.

    #816504
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    ONce again, recruitment sites assail my inbox.

    Once again, I am depressed from reading their offerings.

    http://www.jobrapido.ie/?w=architect&l=&p=19

    Not one “real” architect amongst them – the Title has become an Adjective.

    ONQ.

    #816505
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @onq wrote:

    The services they have been qualified to do is to provide technician information to architects after three years of a technically focussed course – .

    my apologies onq… i am probably confusing you when i refer to the professional technician, i am doing so because it has become the vernacular… many persons in the built environment do not understand the difference between a technician and a technologist. It is the ‘technologist’ that i am referring to, and i suppose i should have clarified that in my previous post.
    The technologist also holds a level 8 qualification in the field or architecture.

    The Architectural Technologist a level of technical professionalism above the “architects technician” stage…..

    Technologists are qualified to receive the architects design and to analyse, synthesise and evaluate those design factors to produce a communication to the contractor to deliver the project. After the design stage, the technologist is most qualified to deliver this project due to their indepth knowledge of building science, associated specialities, legal requirements and project goals. The architect is to be considered part of the design team to input their specific skills in the design field. In many cases a technologist is the design team leader.

    @onq wrote:

    Technicians are trained to think about components and building physics [tom some degree] not about developing a design to both planning stage and on-site to the completion stage.

    I would challange you on this. I think you need to do some investigating into architectural technology courses. Technicians are SPECIFICALLY educated to develop a design through planning through to before site workings to on-site supervision to completion stage. Who do you think is more qualified to check the compliance with fire regulations on site??? the architect or the person who design the method of compliance??

    I graduated from your old alma mater in 1999. I can confirm to you that both Contract administration and law were part of my syllabus.

    I specifically took issue with you stating that “architectural services” should be restricted to architects. I never challenged your point that technicians are not formally educated in design studies (although some AT courses DO provide a contextualisation design program). I agree and accept that point. However, if you had asserted that “architectural design services” should be restricted then obviously i would have a different opinion to my previous post. Can you please clarify if thats what you actually meant?

    As a member of CIAT and striving towards MCIAT status, i can assure you that should a restriction of “architectural services” be purported by whomever, technicians and technologists will be considered inclusive in who is qualified to offer these services.

    @onq wrote:

    Building Collapses:
    The Hyatt Hotel Walkway collapse is probably the most famous collapse in America not attributed to a terrorist attack
    http://mecholsky.mse.ufl.edu/EMA4913-14/Hyatt%20Walkway%20Collapse%20J%20article.pdf
    In developed countries, where the technical expertise and knowledge is available, unscrupulous developers can put people’s lives at risk:
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sampoong_Department_Store_collapse
    Buildings in many third world countries still do not meet international building code standards.
    http://www.deccanherald.com/content/113471/delhi-building-collapse-death-toll.html
    Deaths in Mombasa as building collapses http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TNeHmxiygFc

    Health Risks:
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sick_building_syndrome
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mold_health_issues

    Fire Risks:
    http://www.stardustsupport.com/cms/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=25&Itemid=37

    At least do some cursory reading up on the subject before commenting.

    ONQ.

    thanks for reinforcing my point that professional building scientists are required as part of the provision of architectural services to the public.

    #816506
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Henno,

    There is a huge amount to what you have said and I agree with a lot of it, but equally I am aghast with the apparent underming of the standing of the profession by what looks like a glorified technican class.

    I’ll think on this a bit before replying if you don’t mind, because I think you’re heading for a lowest common denominator – minus the design training and adding bits of the engineering and mechanical and electrical engineering professions.

    ONQ.

    #816507
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    What about frank? was he allwright?

    #816508
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @onq wrote:

    Henno,

    There is a huge amount to what you have said and I agree with a lot of it, but equally I am aghast with the apparent underming of the standing of the profession by what looks like a glorified technican class.

    I’ll think on this a bit before replying if you don’t mind, because I think you’re heading for a lowest common denominator – minus the design training and adding bits of the engineering and mechanical and electrical engineering professions.

    ONQ.

    hi ONQ,

    without seeming to be brown-nosing here, buy you know that i also agree with a lot of your opinions when it comes to issues such as the BCA etc.

    However i must strongly argue that your view of “the profession” seems to be very narrowly focused.

    Yes, on the majority of smaller scale projects the architect should be competent enough to be be able to do most of the duties od the technician, in that the architects construction and regulatory knowledge should be adequate enough to be able to makes on going technological decisions.

    However, as the scale of projects grow, the gulf between this “adequate technological knowledge” and the “artistic prowess” of the architect is widened to such a degree that one of both of these competencies will be affected. as i hav esaid vefore, there is a conscious and deliberate divergence of these competencies at the educational stage of the architectural profession. The ‘architect’ is as firmly focused on the ‘design and concept’ of archietcture as the technician / technologist is on the ‘analysis and synthesis’ of architecture.

    #816509
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Looking back on this I see you’re using quotation marks for two phrases in your comments, which I cannot seem to find

    “adequate technological knowledge”

    “artistic prowess”

    You might clarify the reference Henno when you get a minute.

    I agree with your assessment that there is a form of streaming going on in the profession.
    During my education the technician was there to amplify the technical productivity of and office.
    I consider this separate and equal streaming to be totally improper and a disaster on the cards for architects.

    I have come across designs apparently certified or approved for certification by the technician job runner – who had no clue.
    Technicians don’t design my methods of compliance for Part B or anything else – I design my own, vetting and approving all matters arising.
    This included shelling our hundreds of pounds for overpriced British Standards for reference – which I then have to let the Fire Office read because his office doesn’t have a current copy!!!

    Surfacing this week from completing a Business Development Course and reading your follow up, it comes as something of the shock to read your comment above which suggests that architects are now so grossly incompetent technically, technicians must do their work.
    That is a disgraceful state of affairs, only benefiting lazy prima donnas with aspirations to Star Status – by God this profession needs a good kick in the behind to get it back on track – I can see that things have slipped disastrously under the tutelage of the RIAI.

    And I was talking with a colleague only yesterday about the Regulation of the Building Industry.

    Not just Regulation of the Title(s) used by the designers/professionals but their services

    Not just Regulation of the Provision of Architectural Services, but all Services

    Not just Regulation of the Professions as a group but also including:

    • Architectural Technicians
    • so-called CAD Technicians
    • CAD Draughtsmen

    and the like.

    But most importantly Regulation of those who claim to be Main Contractors and their better less experienced cousins, the phalanx of Self Builders – its way past time we put the whole Building Industry on a professional footing.

    Suffice to say that the Building Control Amendment Bill 2010 was only an essay – a tidying up exercise.
    I suspect it will be amended in due course to reflect public concern that Grandfathers must show their work.
    But the great work, that lies ahead – will be the imposition of a formal structure on the way we design and build.
    This work will address the current situation where the person with responsibility for the built work has no qualification.

    Architects and Design Consultants are responsible for the design of the building or elements of the building.
    Half formed creatures like BER consultants and Passive House consultants are not designers at all and should be tied agents.
    But allowing the current state of affairs to continue, where people with absolutely no experience can call themselves main contractors?

    That is a total joke and it reflects the nod-and-a-wink Gombeenism that has led this country to the brink of destruction via the building industry.

    ONQ.

    #816510
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    One thing I’m curious about.

    An architect , fully EU directive qualified and ARB registered in London, does work in Dublin using his London address on title blocks etc.

    Doing anything wrong?

Viewing 20 posts - 41 through 60 (of 78 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.