Government wants to repossess landmark College Green bank

Home › Forums › Ireland › Government wants to repossess landmark College Green bank

Viewing 20 posts - 41 through 60 (of 76 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #816918
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Hey Gunther

    Many thanks for posting the pics of Soanes proposed Bank of Ireland. It makes you wistful thinking what a beautiful assembly of building we would have had around College green had it been started a few years earlier!

    I am always interested to see proposals that never quite got built. There are a number of famous Victorian examples, but this is one of the few Georgian I can think of. I know its off topic but I always wondered given the expansion of Dublin as a trade centre in the late 1700s, was it ever proposed to construct a purpose built City Hall? As opposed to converting the Royal Exchange.

    C

    #816919
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    GrahamH’s remarks about tourists are a bit harsh. Tourists provide much of the money which the local people survive on and so should be encouraged, without this money locals may not even have need for a bank!

    A pedestrianised plaza at College Green, as suggested in another thread, with the Bank of Ireland building as the focal point as some sort of museum/exhibition centre would be the jewel in the crown of the city. The space created would be enjoyed by both locals and tourists and would allow the building to be appreciated by those in the plaza without a screen of buses. Entrances such as that off Westmoreland Street could be reinstated also.

    The renovation costs would be enormous but if cleverly designed to reduce running costs while remain sympathetic to the structure, a museum could possibly be viable. This would be a great addition to Dublin and would be great to see in time for 1916 centenary.

    #816920
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Yes the comments about tourists were a little sweeping (though having worked at the coalface of tourist heritage sites, your eyes get quickly opened to the reality of the game). But the general point is one of reluctance to exclude the populace from the building on a day-to-day basis, rather than any antipathy towards visitors. These buildings were built (or adapted) for patrons’ use while conducting everyday business, exposing one to a fleeting dose of grandiosity – the Georgian equivalent of a swig of L. casei Immunitas for the aesthetically-dependant – as part of daily life. This is a ceremony that has even greater impact in today’s world, and one that should not be erased in a hasty clamour to give a perceived ‘dignity’ to such a building as seen through modern eyes – this is especially true of the Public Office of the GPO. There is little more dignified that a construct serving its intended function.

    gunter, agreed in relation to the dubious (and latterly nonexistent) prestige of banks, but the nature of the occupant is not the core point. What I was trying to say is that the building retains an air of prestige because the Bank of Ireland possesses it for that very reason – it wants to command a public presence, make a civic statement, and generally be pretentious about its operations. As such, and with banking in the hierarchical scheme of things pretty tightly woven into modern society, for good or evil, the building on College Green is lent a very special significance in its current role. It is fit for purpose. Its very (what one imagines to be) uneconomic viability is the very reason that it is viable – its extravagance is what lends it such appeal, what makes its design relevant, and what makes its positioning in the city appropriate as it ever was. Realistically speaking, outside of a predictable and enforced State occupancy, there is no other deserved use for this building.

    The enormous architectural and heritage value of the building as converted into a bank has always considerably underplayed. Indeed, the majority of the building that stands today is the result of the complex’s lengthy, hugely expensive and extremely accomplished modification for banking use. It is more a bank than a parliament house. The conversion is one of Francis Johnston’s finest works, one that is rarely assessed beyond a haze of politics and nostalgia, or without the usual denigrating stance of the project being one of mere tweaking around the edges. The alteration was an immensely challenging prospect, one that involved the assimilation of the work of four previous architects’ work into a coherent whole, coupled with the over-riding demand of preserving the primacy and design intention of Pearce’s masterpiece. In fact, it is as much what Johnston did not do, amongst ever-heightening calls for bells and whistles Regency embellishment to the existing exterior, as much as what he did do, that is to his immense credit as project architect.

    C. P, Curran’s outstanding essay on the conversion of the Parliament House to Bank of Ireland, published in a quarterly Bulletin of the Irish Georgian Society in 1977, remains the leading account on this much-unknown part of the building’s – really the city’s – history. We can directly quote the correspondence of Johnston in due course, but sticking with the decision to build or acquire a new headquarters in the first place, we must look to north of the Liffey to the site of St. Mary’s Abbey, where the Bank of Ireland had established itself in 1783 off East Arran Street. This was still a commercially thriving part of town, though the brick building in which the bank was located was not secure, forcing the institution to look elsewhere as it expanded. The enormous growth in the scale of the bank in the space of two decades, from being located in a modest premises in a secondary part of the city to proposing a bombastic palace on the city’s principal thoroughfare – indeed comprising a city thoroughfare in the case of the Soane proposal – is truly extraordinary, even by Anglo standards.

    Tying in with thebig C’s comments above, suggestions were made during the 1780s that the Royal Exchange should be converted into the National Bank, while James Malton advocated in 1786 that the Exchange be moved into the old Custom House which was shortly to be vacated by the new building downstream in 1791, noting: “where I have heard the Bank is intended to be built, a most ineligible site indeed.” The Bank even petitioned the Lord Lieutenant for the grant of ground occupied by the old Custom House and a second time in 1795 – both efforts to no avail. It was because of this intransigence on the part of the State that negotiations were opened with the Wide Streets Commissioners in 1799 regarding the Westmoreland Street site – what Curran describes as the entire site bounded by Westmorland Street, College Street, D’Olier Street and the river – not just to the Fleet Street boundary. The deal fell through for the simple reason that the Wide Streets Commission did not yet own all the land, the majority of which it had purchased from Trinity College. Much of it has already been cleared and enclosed, but as the Commissioners where short of funds to purchase the remaining lands at that point (the war with France having a huge impact on finances, with the Commission already enormously in debt), the Bank finally pulled out of the agreement in 1802. Architect Thomas Sherrard drew up plans for Westmoreland Street in 1799 to include the Bank, with College Street marked out as ‘Bank Street’ (can you imagine how that street sign would be corrupted today?). This is the same year as the Commission’s architect, Henry Aaron Baker, drew up approved elevations for the rest of Westmoreland Street.

    Presumably the two drawings above (there are seven Soane designs in total) are what Curran refers to in relation to Bank Street, with a building frontage:

    “of 320 feet. For this front Soane prepared two alternative elevations for the new bank, one of 287 feet 6 inches in length and the other of 260 feet; the rest of his building was disposed on the longer sides of the wedge-shaped site about two internal courtyards separated by his central block which consisted of portico, vestibule, hall and a cash office, 90 feet by 60 feet.” “The drawings in some cases are signed and dated and are accompanied by an undated printed sheet tabulating the Bank’s requirements.”

    As early as 1801 the Bank was actively considering the Parliament House site as the most practical solution to its needs (not to mention much slimmed down, given the depression in the Dublin economy). A definite proposal was made in March 1802, with the Bank purchasing ground at Foster Place from the Commissioners in May of the same year. In June an Act of Parliament was passed enabling the disposal of the former Parliament House, and on the 27th of August 1803 the Seal of the Corporation was directed to be put to the deed of conveyance, passing the building into the possession of Bank of Ireland.

    #816921
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Thanks for that very imformative post Graham.

    Was it the Sherrard design or perhaps an early Baker plan which proposed a collonade along Westmorland St?

    Also, in relation to the final proposed site for the Bank, by College Street would that include the large traffic island at the side of Trinity. In other words would the Bank have closely abutted the side of the College?

    #816922
    admin
    Keymaster

    Bank of Ireland to sell art collection
    Saturday, 15 May 2010 07:42
    Bank of Ireland is to sell its art collection and put the proceeds towards its community and charitable investment programme.

    The bank currently owns 2,000 pieces of art, which is one of the largest collections in the country.

    The works, which are valued at €5m, will be sold on the open market.

    A spokeswoman for AIB has said the future of its art collection was under review.

    A spokeswoman for Anglo Irish Bank said any decision on the future of its collection would be made by its board and management in line with the wishes of the Minister for Finance.

    Labour Spokeswoman on Arts Mary Upton said all of the banks’ art collection should be made available to the public.

    The proceeds should be taken off the next preference dividend and the collection kept intact if the government will allow BoI to off set the tax benefits of the donations to their charitable programmes; if you had to paint 2,000 walls to cover up the picture staining it could cost close to €5m making this almost a revenue neutral exercise. Barings still has its art collection and they were in a much worse state than BoI and this way the bank could buy the collection which has been carefully assembled over time back when their business plan bears fruit; scattering the collection to the four winds into a very poor art market makes no sense except for the auctioneer who gets the fee.

    There is no doubt great anger being directed at the banks at present due to their lending policies but tokinistic gestures such as this are just as short sighted as the lending policies that put them into this position in the first place. Sorting out the BoI balance sheet will hinge on their capital raising which will be billions in scale and in that regard €5m less the costs of repainting the affected walls denuded of their art will be a pittance.

    #816923
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    When they say ‘art collection’ . . . .

    . . . I don’t know if I’d panic too much about some of this stuff getting dispersed to the four corners .

    #816924
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    ‘Art’ escaping from the wax museum ‘plus’. Another fine Tourism Dublin enterprise.

    #816925
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Yes, the developments in Foster Place of late are so outrageous they beggar belief. One could not manifestly convey the gombeen mindset that permeates such large swathes of Irish small business thinking any better if one tried – and by association, Irish planning, or rather the apparent complete lack thereof.

    An integral element of the composition and setting of the nation’s pre-eminent classical building, and one of the city’s finest historic enclaves, is comandeered by paddywhackery of the worst order, and not so much as a whimper from the planning authority! Indeed it even receives national attention over a preposterous media stunt involving the Minister for Tourism who (only too rightly) failed to attend its opening on multiple occasions, and still nothing! Every last scrap of the above muck, along with associated trashy blue lights which have been erected by the same private enterprise on all of the publically owned trees of Foster Place, demands immediate removal.

    Could somebody please give us some hope that there are people in charge in this city. The recent addition of even more licenced taxi spaces on the street by the public authority merely adds insult to injury, while the insertion of a parking meter into the west portico of the bank is truly the icing on the cake.

    #816926
    admin
    Keymaster

    That W sign over the door case is truely shocking and the bloke on the right looks like he is urinating; the WAX letters are clearly a trip hazard on a public footpath.

    Someone should complain….

    #816927
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Dublin Tourism get €900,000 per annum from DCC, some of which they are now spending on other illegal advertising at their own listed premises – see shopfront race to bottom thread, snap by smithfield resi.

    Hence DCC is collecting rates from compliant owners to effectively subsidise cheapening illegal developments dumbing-down and degrading the city centre.

    The Dublin Tourism website itself is also a good laugh; first option available in the left hand side is for visitors to go “Beyond Dublin”. Clearly DT have a real commitment to this city if the first thing they can do is direct business away from the capital :rolleyes:
    … not that tourists will really want to stick about if the treatment of our most important buildings is of the standard seen now in Foster Place or DT’s own HQ at Andrew Street.

    By the way DCC have themselves gone to great effort to erect brown directional signs for tourists promoting the Foster Place Disgrace – as can be seen at Beckett Bridge, Suffolk Street and elsewhere.

    Great to see what the taxes grabbed from other private businesses are being spent on.

    When the last intelligent person leaves Dublin, can they please turn out the lights 😡

    #816928
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @PVC King wrote:

    That W sign over the door case is truely shocking and the bloke on the right looks like he is urinating; the WAX letters are clearly a trip hazard on a public footpath.

    Someone should complain….

    I have heard that the matter was 6 months ago raised with senior executive DCC officials responsible for this area – yet nothing was done

    How much are DCC senior execs paid p.a. again – €150,000 – €210,000 + expenses if I am not mistaken.

    It is hard for me to understand why people are being paid telephone-figure salaries for jobs that they simply are not doing 😡

    #816929
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    They’re probably as browned off writing letters as you are,. What we need is a small hit-squad to drive around in a big van with a set of ladders and just seize and impound all the illegal signage where ever its found and then charge the bastards for storing it, or donate it to IMMA to turn into an ‘installation’ as a commentary on urban degradation.

    What’s wrong with that?

    #816930
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    DCC is collecting rates from compliant owners to effectively subsidise cheapening illegal developments dumbing-down and degrading the city centre.

    Interesting way to put it…

    By the way – I think John Tierney is still on the board of Dublin Tourism.

    #816931
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    What we need is a small hit-squad to drive around in a big van with a set of ladders and just seize and impound all the illegal signage where ever its found and then charge the bastards for storing it, or donate it to IMMA to turn into an ‘installation’ as a commentary on urban degradation.

    What’s wrong with that?

    I’m working on it..(really)

    As it stands at the moment, removal could be construed as illegal. I’m working on a way to get a volunteer group authorised. There is precedent, apparantly IPA used to remove ‘other’ postering.

    If you are wondering what the legal position is Wicklow CC have an excellent policy document. linkage

    Anyone interested in forming a ‘hit-squad’ once I have this sorted from a legal standpoint, drop me a PM..

    #816932
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @gunter wrote:

    They’re probably as browned off writing letters as you are,. What we need is a small hit-squad to drive around in a big van with a set of ladders and just seize and impound all the illegal signage where ever its found and then charge the bastards for storing it, or donate it to IMMA to turn into an ‘installation’ as a commentary on urban degradation.

    What’s wrong with that?

    While you’re at it could you get a few more erm ‘hardcore’ elements to join this proposed possee armed with chainsaws and angle grinders as well to take out the trees and pole clutter around town

    #816933
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @tommyt wrote:

    While you’re at it could you get a few more erm ‘hardcore’ elements to join this proposed possee armed with chainsaws and angle grinders as well to take out the trees and pole clutter around town

    You mean; invite the chair of the poles+trees sub-committee onto the direct-action task force?

    Tommy, Tommy, you’re jumping the gun there, that can only be done if you put down a special motion at the annual congress, or if you give due notice of the intention to convene an egm, assuming that there is a quorum of affilliated members to approve such action and, as you know, either way the motion can be defeated by a simple majority if the membership decide that such action is beyond the remit approved by the special orders that sanctioned the direct action in the first place, and provided that the covenants that restrict the usage of the van can be set aside under the provisions of the collateral terms inserted into the draft new modus operandi which, as you know is still a policy document, having failed to pass congress last year with the required two-thirds majority.

    Obviously, either way, the whole thing is still subject to approval by the legal sub-committee and any ammendments proposed by them will have to be submitted for a full vote of the governing body, because, as you know, it’ll be our wrists that’ll be slapped if something goes horribly wrong.

    That’s the way to get things done around here.

    #816934
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    OMG, that “advertising” of the wax Museum is simply shocking.

    I beileve that several years ago, this building housed a Museum of Irish Banking….how appropriate, but its a pity some of the bankers didn’t spend more time there studying some of the bubbles of the past!!:))

    I remember there was a proposal to transform the Foster Place frontage into the entrance to a Milan style Galleria leading to Fleet St. Obviously, that would entail alot of remodeling! I am assuming that the interiors are quite good?

    Overall, for such a nice location and building, I can’t help wondering is there a more appropriate use then a Wax Museum?

    C

    #816935
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    You could try and Arts Centre provided good quality entertainment coupled with a trip of the House of Lords…

    #816936
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @hutton wrote:

    By the way DCC have themselves gone to great effort to erect brown directional signs for tourists promoting the Foster Place Disgrace – as can be seen at Beckett Bridge, Suffolk Street and elsewhere.

    These signs are everywhere. I must have counted about 30 so far…just for the “National” Wax Museum +. There are four on College Green alone. One of the more interesting ones is on the new Beckett Bridge. It was literally erected within days of the bridge opening. I must say finding the NWM+ is my main priority when crossing the Beckett Bridge.

    How does the process for these work. Anyone? I presume a licence and fee is required. Do DCC make and install the signage or as seems more likely does a free for all ensue.

    The whole thing makes a mockery of the soon to be installed “wayfinding” signage on College Green and elsewhere. There is a vague promise to remove brown finger signage as wayfinding comes on-stream. Lets not hold our breath. I am waiting for the pic of a new wayfinder sign with a brown finger sign attached. 😡

    #816937
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @StephenC wrote:

    The whole thing makes a mockery of the soon to be installed “wayfinding” signage on College Green and elsewhere. .

    Any more details on these new signs Stephen?

Viewing 20 posts - 41 through 60 (of 76 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.