Government wants to repossess landmark College Green bank
- This topic has 75 replies, 27 voices, and was last updated 15 years, 6 months ago by
Anonymous.
- AuthorPosts
- April 20, 2010 at 10:20 pm #816898
Anonymous
InactiveThe banks probably lease them to themselves anyway.
Take all the banks and rent them to the banks!
All this stuff is like a big blanket the details will never come out because it will disclose to much and the state will be liable. I will never forgive the banks for harassing me to invest in the twilight years. It’s musical chairs…April 20, 2010 at 11:01 pm #816899Anonymous
InactiveAh yes because we have lots of ideas for appropriate uses just crying out for a public owned beautiful historic building; like we have a million things we want to exhibit.
BoI maintaining the building and supporting a by now historically established use which permits public access is one of the few things in the favour!
Ring should go and shove a Custom’s House up his arse.
April 21, 2010 at 1:30 am #816900Anonymous
InactiveApril 21, 2010 at 2:02 am #816901Anonymous
Inactive@kinsella wrote:
Seconded.
and then what?
April 21, 2010 at 2:40 am #816902Anonymous
Inactive@Paul Clerkin wrote:
We bailed out BoI, let’s have their HQ
“It’s the only place you can get people into the one area and have a focal point on ceremonial occasions. When Ireland came back from the World Cup in 1990 people gathered there…….
College Green could continue to host ceremonial occasions regardless of who occupies the Bank. However, as the location for the World Cup homecoming after Italia 90, the place was totally inadequate. I was there that night and it was pure luck that nobody was crushed to death by the crowds. The Phoenix park would have been a far more suitable location and sure enough, thats where the Irish team were welcomed home four years later when they returned from USA 94. Ironically College Green would have been the ideal location this time around given the small crowd that turned up at the park.
It was the wrong place for the Clinton visit too, as only those in the crowd with a direct view of the stage could catch a glimpse of the man. If Obama is ever granted the freedom to graze his sheep in Stephens Green I would guess that he won’t be presented with the keys to the city on the steps of The Bank of Ireland.
For what its worth, I’m also in favour of Cllr Ring’s call to have the building handed over to the state as long as it remains open to the public. I disagree with Senator Norris’ proposal to house the Seanad there. Although I think the good senator was just throwing the idea out there to gauge peoples opinion and always knew privately that such a move was a non runner.
April 21, 2010 at 10:14 am #816903Anonymous
Inactive@Global Citizen: remains open as what? Banking is the established historic use, it remains a fine bank and, as I said, the way the BoI maintains a slightly pompous and ceremonial atmosphere in the main banking hall is one of the things that does them credit. Why fall in with this silly and senseless populism?
Exhibition center: ha, what is all this stuff that is crying out to be exhibited. What is this perceived lack of fine historic buildings ready for re-use. Look around!
Cap salaries, make bankers sit in stocks in College Green, put people in prison, whatever, just don’t mess up one of the few examples of an historic building being well maintained in a public and historically established use.
April 21, 2010 at 10:23 am #816904admin
KeymasterThe venue clearly is not large enough for important national events such as a Bill O visit or a once in a generation decent soccer team return but has its uses for more niche events. The BoI has always been very good at supporting the arts in providing the interior of the space etc. Also to say that BoI is nationalised is somewhat untrue; the National Pensions Reserve Fund was in a position to buy preference shares yielding a mammoth dividend at a very low price; these if held will when the bank raises capital through disposals and a rights issue be worth considerably more than was paid for them. The UK Government is now in profit on RBS and Lloyds but Northern Rock like INBS and Anglo are unfortunately case studies that every finance student will be examined on hopefully for generations to come as an important lesson well learned.
All that can be expected of BoI is that they enter the 21st century on City Centre car-parking i.e. close the one at their College Green branch and turn the space into a public venue for suitable events and continue to manage the building in the sensitive manner that they have to date other than the rushed wheelchair access application which had as much forward thinking planning as the Anglo balance sheet.
April 21, 2010 at 10:34 am #816905Anonymous
InactiveContinued use as a bank is a safe option, but conversion into a proper city museum certainly has merit.
There has long been vague talk of building a ‘museum of the city’, with sites such as that useless patch of grass on Winetavern Street [which currently affords a panoramic view of the Civic Office bunkers] being a particularly good option, if only the country wasn’t broke.
In the circumstances, the old Parliament House wouldn’t be a bad option. As well as it’s own inherent architectural and historical attributes, the building has numerous little wasted areas and courtyards that aerial views suggest are either totally unused or are in use just as surface car parks, these could make stunning exhibition spaces [if glazed over] which in conjunction with the existing historic interiors might make a world class museum.
As PVC said, getting the car parking out of the forecourt would be a positive, either way, as would having the whole building open 7 days.
I certainly can’t see the building ever returning to parliament house use.
April 21, 2010 at 10:48 am #816906admin
KeymasterI do not dispute that it would make a great museum; it is after all the original parlimentary experience the Country had. My concern for this building is one that I share with the GPO; there is a large banking hall that is ideal for a museum but what do you do with the warren of offices and vaults that makes up the rest of the building excluding the College Street facing entrance hall which is by a distance my favourate entrance hall in Dublin. I think it is an issue that could benefit from some operational research when the public finance or IFI funding positions merit it. i.e. potentially have BoI grant a long license to either the state or a charitable foundation for designated parts of the building; my guess is that they would be loathe to as the building is one of the rare examples of a building of European heritage importance that has commercial consent; which makes this particular worth a significant sum which they are unlikely to want to see evaporate in the absence of full value being paid; from an operational position I have no doubt that the rental value of the banking hall and offices would not come close to the annual maintenance and additional heating/cooling costs that come with such grand proportions and age. We need another era of Farmleigh style government finances to get triffling matters such as money out of the way!!!
April 21, 2010 at 11:43 am #816907Anonymous
Inactive@PVC King wrote:
the rushed wheelchair access application which had as much forward thinking planning as the Anglo balance sheet.
ha ha! Brilliant. 😀
April 21, 2010 at 10:12 pm #816908Anonymous
Inactive@notjim wrote:
@Global Citizen: remains open as what? Banking is the established historic use, it remains a fine bank and, as I said, the way the BoI maintains a slightly pompous and ceremonial atmosphere in the main banking hall is one of the things that does them credit. Why fall in with this silly and senseless populism?
Exhibition center: ha, what is all this stuff that is crying out to be exhibited. What is this perceived lack of fine historic buildings ready for re-use. Look around!
Cap salaries, make bankers sit in stocks in College Green, put people in prison, whatever, just don’t mess up one of the few examples of an historic building being well maintained in a public and historically established use.
Snap!
The essential character of the Bank of Ireland (note, Bank of Ireland, not ‘former Parliament House’ – it has been the former for more than double the time of the latter) as it stands today is one of prestige and stately public declaration. This is not just a result of the remarkable grandeur of the building’s design, the genius of its detailing, or its obvious venerability. For this character is also, indeed if not largely, derived from its function as a ceremonial (if no longer operational) headquarters. This is significant.
It is wrong to suggest, as is often stated, that the Bank of Ireland has no claim over this former public building as reinvented as a financial centre. Yes, the ideal use for it following the Union, as much as to ease the pain as to avoid further embellishment of the whole tawdry spectacle, would have been as a public gallery, as it temporarily became immediately post-1801. Nonetheless, the Bank’s decision to acquire the building as its headquarters lent considerable prestige and a vote of confidence to the city’s most important architectural work – what could have become a neglected embarrassment in the heart of the city. Bearing in mind that the Bank had its own plans for a magnificent headquarters, to be built to the designs of John Soane in a location and style that would make it the most prominent public building in the capital, it is not unreasonable to suggest that the former Parliament House as much reflected the Bank’s own sense of itself and its architectural pretensions, as it proved a convenient and economical solution to its headquarters dilemma in rapidly changing times. The Bank’s further commitment to the site over the following two centuries, including the substantial and highly accomplished adaptions carried out directly for it, further emphasises the institution’s inherent connection to the site as it stands today.
Therefore the Bank of Ireland on College Green in its current incarnation exhibits significant meaning and legibility, as the building’s design directly correlates to its use as a ceremonial headquarters: it is precisely what its occupant wants it to be. By contrast, its conversion to an exhibition space dilutes this prestige – in fact it arguably turns it on its head, as it then becomes about finding an arbitary use for yet another grand old building, rather than the building dictating a use that is commensurate to its status in the city. In many ways, this is why converted former public buildings in other European cities often fail to impart that spark of prestige they once bestowed on the visitor or passer-by. They just become another Acme mothballed grand shell, given the tokenistic treatment of restoration and ‘readable and reversible intervention’ to accommodate the masses clambering over their great steps, fingering their columns and wandering aimlessly about their great halls. Critically in all of this, they become objects for those least interested and least connected to their local value – the tourist – while the citizen for whom the building was once built gets pushed to the sidelines. In effect, what is being proposed for Dublin’s two flagship public buildings – the General Post Office and the Bank of Ireland – is to take them out of the hands of the citizenry, for whom they were built and for whom they provide essential services, and put into the hands of the marketeers of Fáilte Ireland and troops of intensely apathetic Spanish teenagers. As a rule of thumb, the Bank of Ireland should remain as is unless for operational reasons it becomes no longer relevant or viable, or a suitable alternative use ties in with the bank reassessing its options.
There is one solitary alternative use, and one use only, that comes in any way close to appropriately interpreting the intensely tangled collection of baggage that comes with the Bank of Ireland, and that is, as suggested, a City of Dublin Museum. The story of the capital that brought the building into being – there are few better compliments.
April 21, 2010 at 11:33 pm #816909Anonymous
Inactive@notjim wrote:
@Global Citizen: remains open as what? Banking is the established historic use, it remains a fine bank and, as I said, the way the BoI maintains a slightly pompous and ceremonial atmosphere in the main banking hall is one of the things that does them credit. Why fall in with this silly and senseless populism?
Exhibition center: ha, what is all this stuff that is crying out to be exhibited. What is this perceived lack of fine historic buildings ready for re-use. Look around!
Cap salaries, make bankers sit in stocks in College Green, put people in prison, whatever, just don’t mess up one of the few examples of an historic building being well maintained in a public and historically established use.
Nowhere in my post did I mention exhibition centres or a hint at returning the bank to the state as a means of getting some form of vengeance over its current custodians.
I would simply like to see it become more accessable so that it may be appreciated in greater numbers. Of course the dignity of the building must be maintained to accommodate this. The suggestion that it could be used to house a City of Dublin Museum has the most merit as the building itself played a large part in the history of the city and country as a whole.
The fact that the building remains a bank is in my opinion, the very reason why it is overlooked by so many. People simply see it as another branch of BOI and therefore pass it by as they have no business going in there unless they have a transaction to make.
True, it has been home to the bank for a lot longer than than those it was built to house and the Bank of Ireland have been worthy residents. But it was (is) the first purpose built parliament building in the world and I believe it deserves greater celebration.
Its a shame that thousands walk past it 7 days a week and never see inside the door.April 21, 2010 at 11:46 pm #816910Anonymous
InactiveI see its current use as the only economically viable use. The government could not afford to maintain it as a public museum, especially considering the abundance of museums nearby.
As someone who regularly walks though the building for pleasure, rather than business I think it is a sincere pity that the bank has closed the House of Lords entrance, further dulling Westmoreland Street and closing the beautiful entrance rotunda to the public and simply encouraging homeless or some commie or animal rights looney to set up their stall in the doorway.
April 22, 2010 at 12:03 am #816911Anonymous
InactiveYes lauder, fully agreed on that point. The first time I saw the barrier across the corridor, I thought an event was on, the second time okay, an unfortunate coincidence – the third and it became apparent the entire entrance from Westmoreland Street is now permanently sealed off. What on earth is going on? This was once the grandest and most exhilarating processional route in the city, now shamefully closed off to public view. It’s not even as if they’re cutting down on door staff – indeed there seems to be more security personnel than ever now huddled in the lobby outside the Lords chamber. Also agreed on the increasing numbers of exhibitionists taking possession of the Lords entrance. It’s bad enough as it is as a blank frontage without having the entrance sealed off to boot.
On a wider level, Bank of Ireland needs to draw up a management plan for the building. Not only is the majority of the interior in serious need of redecoration, a rationalisation of corporate furniture, signage and mechanical services is also sorely in order. It’s surprising no work was carried out during the boom years. I’d imagine public perception is that Bank of Ireland threw lavish sums at the building during that time, when the opposite is in fact the case – it could even be described as grotty in large part. Indeed, not a cent of major capital funds has been spent on it since the second exterior cleaning of the early 1990s.
April 22, 2010 at 12:50 am #816912Anonymous
InactiveThe ‘prestigious’ nature of the existing bank use completely passes me by. I detest banks and have always done so, long before the onset of the recent unpleasantness.
@GrahamH wrote:
. . . . . . to accommodate the masses clambering over their great steps, fingering their columns and wandering aimlessly about their great halls. Critically in all of this, they become objects for those least interested and least connected to their local value – the tourist – while the citizen for whom the building was once built gets pushed to the sidelines.
That’s a little bit harsh there Graham. Tourists are very unfairly derided IMO.
OK, maybe the loud-mouth, bloated, perpetually dissatisfied American types that descend from air-conditioned coaches on Nassau Street in chequered trousers could reasonably be gassed en-masse [no offence intended], but the great bulk of the contemporary hoards of European city-breakers are in a different league and they bring with them, in their volume and feed-back, a direct critical analysis of the city, what it has to offer, and the quality of it’s public realm. I see nothing wrong in judging ourselves by the criteria; ‘what does the tourist get from this?’
@GrahamH wrote:
There is one solitary alternative use, and one use only, that comes in any way close to appropriately interpreting the intensely tangled collection of baggage that comes with the Bank of Ireland, and that is, as suggested, a City of Dublin Museum. The story of the capital that brought the building into being – there are few better compliments.
Nobody stamps their authority on a suggestion like Graham, so this could be a runner.
I note PVC’s observations on the labyrinthine nature of the building, but in the context of museum use, that would not necessarily be a negative.
This is the best floor plan I can find. The ‘bank’ interventions, post 1801, were much less comprehensive than originally intended. I’ve marked out Johnston’s cash office in blue and the site of the original House of Commons chamber in yellow. The areas outlined in green are courtyards and open space.
April 22, 2010 at 9:39 am #816913Anonymous
InactiveInteresting thread. Its a huge pity that this building is cut off from the city by a wall of yellow and blue buses and speeding cars. Have to agree that this building needs to be opened up for civic use. What an addition a new museum or some other similarly prestigious function would be to Dame Street and to College Green.
Has anyone any pictures of the interior? Or pictures of the John Soane proposal for the Westin site?
April 22, 2010 at 11:12 am #816914Anonymous
InactiveApparently Dublin Bus have ‘re-designed’ their whole network, according to the radio this morning, so we’ll wait and see if reduces or increases the volume of the yellow and blue wall.

a plundered view of Johnson’s Cash-Office ceiling.
And Below, two versions of Soane’s design for the pre-Act-of-Union Bank of Ireland headquarters for the trianglular site bounded by D’Olier St./College St./Westmoreland St.


All very Washington D.C. meets the Winter Palace
April 22, 2010 at 1:09 pm #816915Anonymous
InactiveCheers Gunter.
April 22, 2010 at 2:07 pm #816916Anonymous
InactiveIt’s very true the building itself is a warren of small spaces, most of which are very pretty in their own right, the rear courtyard could be fabulous, its a fantastic intimate space that could easily be incorporated into the ‘vibe’ of Foster Place.
April 22, 2010 at 11:02 pm #816917Anonymous
Inactive - AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

