Dublin Metropolis – Artist’s Impression

Home Forums Ireland Dublin Metropolis – Artist’s Impression

Viewing 20 posts - 21 through 40 (of 76 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #741142
    Morlan
    Participant

    Originally posted by Diaspora

    The Ballast House on Aston Quay and Appollo House spring to mind.

    Yes, well I actually did that whilst laughing to myself! A Pub/Lounge with 16 floors?!?! :p

    Thanks for your views.

    #741143
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    The one aspect of the photomontage that I did like was the way the loop line went between the buildings on either side. There is something about the way a raised railway seems to slice between two buildings that I think looks really good.

    #741144
    helloinsane
    Participant

    Originally posted by Morlan

    No your right! I get slightly frustrated with the above image because I know that I’ll never live to see a high rise Dublin 😮

    I guess all I can do is dream – the above is a product of that. 🙂

    There are plenty of other cities with high rise, and most of it is crappy. I can see one shinig example out the window right now.

    While I would argue that Dublin could benefit from increased density of development, high rise for the sake of it is most emphatically not the answer. Following that route it may well end up looking exactly like your montage.

    #741145
    Gar
    Participant

    Most of the new RTE dramas etc., or programmes that try to portray Dublin as a modern and happening city always seem to show those ‘pointy hat’ buildings on George’s Quay. Pity there’s feck all else to show. Watch the start of that new BowWow programme on RTE if you get the chance.

    Maybe the new station on Tara street will add something new worth looking at on the Dublin ‘skyline’. I think they’re due to start building there this Autumn.

    #741146
    dc3
    Participant

    Interesting try but we need to know what is in the buildings – rest home for developers, demented engineers etc?

    The lack of Georgian pastiche suggests no private sector involvement.

    #741147
    Rory W
    Participant

    .

    #741148
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    The picture on the first page definitely deserves more discussion

    #741149
    helloinsane
    Participant

    It’s still a horrendously prescient view, sadly.

    #741150
    shaun
    Participant

    Where’s it taken from.The top-floor of liberty hall, right…..It’s an awful sight….Dublin is not a high-rise town.

    #741151
    GrahamH
    Participant

    On a cloudy day the view is remarkably depressing – although watching the city’s weather rolling in from the west is facinating.

    The idea of Dublin anything near Morlans great picture is frightening – reminicent of the initial Spencer Dock proposal. Some very tall landmark buildings away from the immediate city centre is what the city needs I think, adding defintion to the skyline whilst not impinging on the human scale of the city. I don’t like the idea of Tara St where it is, further adding to the cluster of mid-rise in this area – creeping along the quay to O’ Cll Bridge.

    #741152
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Thats what I thought was best about the image i.e. Tara St was at the centre of Dublin.

    It is obvious that this area will never have the types of building that it has in the picture BUT within a kilometere or so to the east there will be a few mid rise landmark buildings.

    What was most interesting about the image was seeing how different cladding systems reacted to being dramatically increased in scale. Buildings such as Kennedy’s bar and the Ballast house looked terrible while others had some potential to a grow.

    As a conservationist I have a problem with buildings of the scale in the image being errected within the existing city core, on the sustainability side I feel that a number of midrise builings in the port end of the docklands are highly preferable to existing settlement patterns.

    #741153
    GrahamH
    Participant

    The worst by a long shot is the Ulster Bank, 5 storeys is bad enough – 30 is just scary! And as for Aviation House!
    It’s funny to see the almost reticent bow facade of AIB/IFSC suddenly morph into the intimidating headquarters of a faceless multinational 😀

    Sorry Diaspora – I was referring to the Tara St Station development rather than the street earlier – I don’t think such a height should be permitted in what essentially is the city centre, especially in this already congested area in height terms.
    The idea of a main street though cutting through a bend in the river is indeed an attractive one though – as are embankment promenades, river boats and snow-capped mountains as a backdrop :p

    #741154
    Morlan
    Participant

    I strongly agree with Graham and Diaspora in that all high-rises should be built away from the mid-rise city centre core. The docklands area has great potential to become a high-rise zone, although, the last time I was in Dublin, I was disappointed to see several 5 story apartment buildings going in beside the old gas works.

    I was in Birmingham recently, which is similar to Dublin with its predominantly mid-rise architecture. It has some impressive 15+ story buildings – the Hyatt Hotel for example – but they all look totally out of place! Not something I would want to see in Dublin.

    I have added some new pictures to the first page. These include Central & Ulster Bank, Lib hall and O’Connell House.
    It shows how these building could have turned out, mostly terrible.

    #741155
    Sean Carney
    Participant

    Dublin a Metroplis, who the hell came up with that?. A Metroplis?. I can’t get my head around that one, DUBLIN IS A SMALL CITY, understand. Tokyo, Paris, London, Cairo, Sao Paulo, Mexico Ciy, Beijing, Shangai, Manilla, Jakarta, New York etc etc are metropolises not Dublin, ah ah what a joke, the people who say this have never been outside of Dublin or they are just plain ignorant or stupid, or got delusions of grandure.
    Ive heard O,Connell street is the widest street in the world, give me a break, far from it.
    What next, the only city with trams, the only city with an airport, the only city with a tunnell, I could go on but I won’t.
    Wake up and educate yourself about the world and broaden them narrow little minds of yours.
    Thank You.

    #741156
    helloinsane
    Participant

    Location: Cardiff

    Thank You.

    #741157
    Morlan
    Participant

    Originally posted by Sean Carney

    Grow up and chill out. If you’ve nothing positive to say then don’t bother posting :rolleyes:

    #741158
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Originally posted by Sean Carney
    Dublin a Metroplis, who the hell came up with that?. A Metroplis?. I can’t get my head around that one, DUBLIN IS A SMALL CITY, understand. Tokyo, Paris, London, Cairo, Sao Paulo, Mexico Ciy, Beijing, Shangai, Manilla, Jakarta, New York etc etc are metropolises not Dublin, ah ah what a joke, the people who say this have never been outside of Dublin or they are just plain ignorant or stupid, or got delusions of grandure.

    Sean, I think most people who use this discussion forum on a regular basis realise that Dublin is not a Metropolis. Morlans images from the beginning of this thread (if you actually looked at it?) were merely pointing out what Dublin could look like in Morlans future utopian plan for the city.


    Ive heard O,Connell street is the widest street in the world, give me a break, far from it.
    What next, the only city with trams, the only city with an airport, the only city with a tunnell, I could go on but I won’t.

    Where did you hear that? That has never been said here nor have I heard it anywhere else!


    Wake up and educate yourself about the world and broaden them narrow little minds of yours.
    Thank You.

    Thanks for enlightening me 😀

    #741159
    kefu
    Participant

    If anything, the Metropolis – meaning mother city – title of this thread was meant to be ironic. Oh and here you go by the way smart boy, the actual dictionary definition:-
    me·trop·o·lis ( P ) Pronunciation Key (m-trp-ls) n.
    A major city, especially the chief city of a country or region: Chicago, the metropolis of the Midwest.
    A city or an urban area regarded as the center of a specific activity: a great cultural metropolis.
    Ecclesiastical. The chief see of a metropolitan bishop.
    The mother city or country of an overseas colony, especially in ancient Greece.
    So aside from being a would-be smart-ass, you’re wrong as well.

    #741160
    Devin
    Participant

    Hadn’t seen this thread first time round.

    Dublin looks like Croydon in that first picture.

    #741161
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    One of the forums better threads,

    I found the extra images of the Central Bank very interesting, I know people knock pastiche but 23 storeys of the Central Bank close to the Point Depot would do it for me!!!!!!

Viewing 20 posts - 21 through 40 (of 76 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.