Cork Transport

Home › Forums › Ireland › Cork Transport

Viewing 20 posts - 241 through 260 (of 1,025 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #779293
    a boyle
    Participant

    mr angry rebel yesterday you pointed out that dublin has motorways everywhere. Yet dublin has the worst traffic in the country. At which point will you begin to realise that building roads as a means of solving congestion is completely useless, and that other alternatives namely road management (tolling) buses and train are used.

    I put it to you than most people on the dublin to cork road are there out of nessecity not choice.

    #779294
    Angry Rebel
    Participant

    @a boyle wrote:

    mr angry rebel yesterday you pointed out that dublin has motorways everywhere. Yet dublin has the worst traffic in the country. At which point will you begin to realise that building roads as a means of solving congestion is completely useless, and that other alternatives namely road management (tolling) buses and train are used.

    I put it to you than most people on the dublin to cork road are there out of nessecity not choice.

    Sigh….no I didn’t. That was this post.

    In any case, I don’t agree that Dublin has motorways “everywhere”. It has motorways leading in/out of it on almost all major routes, but they all lead to the M50. That would work quite well if

    • The M50 had 4 lanes each direction
    • There were fully freeflowing junctions at each interchange
    • More people used commuter rail on the n8/M8 corridor
    • More commuter rail options existed on the other main corridors
    • Development had not been allowed to develop all along the M50
    • There was an outer ring road (way way out, so it wouldn’t happen again) so people with no business in Dublin wouldn’t be near or in Dublin (e.g Cork to Belfast traffic and anyone going to Dublin airport from the South/South West
    • There were no tolls slowing traffic (or tolls were levied using freeflow technologies)

    Need I go on? The point I’m trying to make is that motorways are not inherently bad, or solely responsible for causing traffic. It’s no surprise that Dublin traffic is bad when you realise all the bullets above do not exist! Motorways relieve traffic if done correctly, but that means, designed right, in the right place, for the right reason, with the correct supporting infrastructure, such as good pubic transport, sustainable planning and development.

    Unfortunately, that doesn’t always happen in Ireland, but as a result, people like a boyle seize on them as a bad thing! It doesn’t mean you stop using roads as one of tools to address congestion, and suggesting otherwise (a boyle “building roads…is completely useless”) is blinkered in the extreme.

    I’ve said it before…it’s not a case of one or the other, it’s all of the things that we are talking about here over the last n pages. However, saying things like, “replace all motorways with 2+1s and force people onto alternate modes” is just stupid. You have to strike a balance. You need roads and rail for freight, for people who like driving, who aren’t actually going from one major urban centre to another (but to somewhere in between or not near a railway or airport), you need good rail services for moving high volumes of point to point passengers and freight etc etc etc

    #779295
    lawyer
    Participant

    @Micko wrote:

    Anyone know if the Motorway designation will be extended from Watergrasshill to the top of Glanmire.

    The road is of equal quality as the stretch of Motorway presently being built, a centre divider has recently been put up and there is an optional route for L drivers and tractors to take.

    Driving from Fermoy today, just at the start of the Watergrasshill bypass, I notices a roadsign in motorway blue facing me, pointing to Watergrasshill.
    This would seem to suggest that at least part of the road from Watergrasshill back to Cork is going to be a motorway.

    #779296
    Micko
    Participant

    After just getting home and driving home from the match in Dublin, I am even more against Boyle’s point of view with the road network.

    The stretch of road between Cashel and Portlaoise is a disgrace and only a standard motorway/dual carriageway would be sufficient.

    if you were in the traffic that we were in coming into Abbeyleix you’d know about it too. And seemingly this is the same situation every Friday too.

    #779297
    a boyle
    Participant

    @Micko wrote:

    After just getting home and driving home from the match in Dublin, I am even more against Boyle’s point of view with the road network.

    The stretch of road between Cashel and Portlaoise is a disgrace and only a standard motorway/dual carriageway would be sufficient.

    if you were in the traffic that we were in coming into Abbeyleix you’d know about it too. And seemingly this is the same situation every Friday too.

    You have just reinforced my point about wrong investment. No road will ever be able to cope with all the supporters driving up to dublin. It is not surprising that there was traffic problems on the way back.

    What i am saying is that you did not need to be on that road. That a train should have been provided to move the thrity thousand people up to dublin and back home again . That is what trains are good at .

    Yes the road is not of good quality. But you and others are confused as to what we need. We need a 2+1 road which is fully seperated from other roads like a motorway. that is more than enough road space. Alongside that we need a direct train link running on the hour direct (no stops or one max at limerick junction) and then another running on the half hour servicing the other stations.

    Just because there are too many people on the road at the moment does not mean you should build a motorway. This is for two reasons :
    1. car drivers currently have no choice but to drive, since the train stops at so many places that taking it is a waste of time. The bus is even worse because it is held up in every single town. (serious consideration needs to be given to providing a dedicated route through even town and village for buses , it would saves hours.)
    2. car owners actually have an incentive to drive as much as possible . The huge amount of vrt , road tax , and high insurance are a once off payment. This has the effect of an all you can eat restaurant. You have no incentive to stop using your car once you have got it because you spent so bloody much on it in the first place.

    In NO other part of our lives do we run things so badly.



    Putting a motorway between cashel and portaoise is completely pointless for another reason. Cork and Dublin can’t and won’t cope . Firstly both cities have commuter belts , one streches to fermoy/michtlestown , the other to portloaise. So on both dual carriage ways into both cities there is already a good amount of traffic taking up a good amount of space. NOW it has been pointed out that this is not a great thing ,but it is however enevitable, and has happened in all cities.
    What that means is that there is only some much space left over for more cars, those going the whole way between the two cities.

    NOW it have been argued that this is result of poor planning . But i would say it is just the way thing pan out when you start building motorways.

    EVEN if we could reverse it , this is what we would need to do. 2 lane motorway between cashel and portloaise, then 4 lane motorway between portloaise and dublin (for the limerick boys), then the m50 would need at least 6 lanes at certain points. NOW even if we could afford to build such a ring road , the plain fact is that it is pointless because there simple ISN’T the space to let so many cars into the city and there never will.
    This is at both ends cork and dublin, as both cities are some thousand years old.

    Because of this we have pretty much built as much capacity as our cities can cope with. (that means number of lanes, we could and should build bypasses)

    Inside each city we need to focus on freeing up space by booting commuters out of their cars and onto buses that actually work. This will allow more space for those who actually need to use a car, like people doing their groceries, bying furniture, vans , delivery trucks.

    #779298
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Rerouting these trains to Drumcoundra via the Phoenix Park Tunnel on match days would be a great help to make the option attractive with free surface parking offered on any derelict lands in the main rail stations at point of origin

    #779299
    a boyle
    Participant

    does that mean you can see some logic to my argument

    #779300
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    I see the logic that no road building decisions can be predicated on match day flows but still strongly assert that a DC is warranted between the two major population centres in the state

    #779301
    Micko
    Participant

    I think you are wrong.

    There was no traffic at all from Dublin down to Portlaoise due to the quality of the roads.

    If you had 2+1 you would have madness everywhere, especially where the road would reconverge into 1 lane. It would be complete madness on a day like yesterday. Just imagine the backlog caused by 2 lanes of slow traffic merging into 1 every 2 to 3 miles. Crazy. if their was all dual carriage way to Cork, there would be no heavy traffic whatsoever. none at all.

    The cost of 2+1 isn’t that much cheaper.

    BTW, there is only so much capacity on the Cork to Dublin line, with only a limited number of trains. You would need 10 times the amount of trains to make a dent in yesterdays traffic.

    How do you
    1. Deal with all the trains when they wouldn’t be in usage for 99% of the year and justify their cost and
    2. Deal with the fact that their is only one line going into Dublin from kildare onwards. no way could it handle the train traffic.

    Boyle, do you even Drive ? your arguements are bizarre.

    #779302
    a boyle
    Participant

    micko forget abou yesterday. no road well ever be able to cope.

    Regarding the use of trains . well current our trains are not being used very well.

    in terms of capacity , there is (almost) no limit. Trains can run up to frequencies for 90 seconds. now that is a bit over kill for dublin to cork, but there is no problem on capacity on the line.

    At the end stations , well dublin has space (some) at heuston , but more importantly dublin has a complete spare station at broadstone. Cork is not so busy , so i don’t see why a train arriving could not pull in before continuing on towards cobh where an additional side track could be provided ,if needed.

    Regarding the number of trains , I am confused as to what your point is. 15000 odd people use the road every day so provide a service for ten thousand say or fifteen.

    For things like match days would it not be better to spend some million on a few spare trains than a spare road. the road is subtantially more expensive.

    If you are right about a 2+1 being a disaster , when cars a pilling back into the one lane , then you have only confirmed what i have being saying all along . building a dual carriage way to cork and limerick is only forcing four lanes in at naas. Then those four lanes have to share the m50 with all the other people who live in the vicinity of the m50 . so you need to upgrade the m50 to a 6 lane or maybe even an 8 lane motorway.
    But then you get back to the most important point which is that dublin does not have the space inside it to cope with ANY more cars. the same applies to cork

    Why accomodate cars in abbeyleix if they are only going to sit in a traffic jam in cork and dublin. If you really want a dual carriage way to cork then you have to do two things : stop other traffic getting to the m50 and corks ring road , and building a dualcarriage way the WHOLE way through cork and dublin .

    #779303
    a boyle
    Participant

    yes i do drive , a lot, and have driven all over europe and america.

    If you want to see how to do things right skip back on this thread and look at a map of germany and compare it to the map of france. then go and drive in both countries , and then come back and tell me which has worse traffic.

    #779304
    Angry Rebel
    Participant

    You keep harping on about Cork and Dublin not being able to take the traffic. That’s a good point, but it’s not a reason to not build DC/motorway between the two biggest population centres in the state. DC all the way could save drivers probably 3/4 hour, an hour or more at peak times. If that means spending 5 minutes more in traffic in Newlands Cross (not Naas, don’t know why you keep mentioning that) then you’re still 40 minutes quicker.

    Now don’t start whinging about trains, everyone on this thread thinks more and better trains is a better idea, but they are not a magic bullet (in fact most Iarnroid Eireann services are a far cry from bullets…!) As for 2+1 roads, forget it. Insisting those are suitable for 1 of the busiest routes in the country is just retarded, and strips all your comments of any credibilty, including any good points that you do make.

    #779305
    mickeydocs
    Participant

    @a boyle wrote:

    yes i do drive , a lot, and have driven all over europe and america.

    If you want to see how to do things right skip back on this thread and look at a map of germany and compare it to the map of france. then go and drive in both countries , and then come back and tell me which has worse traffic.

    The last time I checked the routd au soleil didn’t pass through Germany.
    The French make very significant investments in public transport, Paris has a greater population of 12 million people and most of her traffic problems occur during Summer months when very large portions of Northern Europe and the British Isles decide to drive through France en route to holiday destinations.

    As a student I spent a year and a half in Paris and was very impressed by how cheap, comprehensive and efficient the public transport network is. My only issue with the public transport was the fact that workers had a tendency to go on lightening strikes. I once spent half an hour stuck in a metro in the bowels of Paris on a very hot Summer’s day.

    #779306
    Pug
    Participant

    smashing points in the last few pages folks, keep it going. I’ve travelled a bit so Irelands transport is a bit of a pet hate of mine. All govt officials in dept of transport should be sent to germany for a week.

    1. Irish rail is a joke – pandering to unions, poor customer service, slow trains (its almost as quick to drive from Cork to Dublin, how sad is that), no direct rail links to other towns like waterford, wexford,galway. Martin Cullen should just resign in shame for that alone.
    2. I agree that the rubbish other forms of transport make over reliance on the roads, which are only now beiong made into what they should be. I know we only have the money in the country over last few years but its ridiculous.
    3. Cork needs a fleet of the smaller IMP-like buses at more frequent times that run until at LEAST 2.30 am. Last bus at 11.30pm is beyond all stupidity.

    My overall point is that Irelands politicos have no will to improve this. Even though the local powerless councillors tuck away a nice €86k a year to do sweet FA. Its very frustrating. The kinsale flyover was finished allegedly a few months ahead and the response from 2 local politicians, one a councillor and 1 a european MP for gods sake is to congratulate the builders. the flyover is 10 YEARS LATE. Thats the low benchmarking right there. And now the NRA pulled the funding for the sarsfield and bandon roundabout so where will the traffic move from?? Yep, the badly laned kinsale roundabout. Idiotic isnt the word.

    small point but i flew in to the new terminal last week. I’m told its aer aranns fault ( i hold my hand up there if I am wrong) in that they wont pay for the more expensive parking in front of the new terminal but the plane was parked at the old terminal and we had to walk all the way up to the new one and climb 3 flights of stairs to get in. Escalator anyone? Think of that in the winter in the wind and rain. Welcome to Ireland in the 21st century.

    #779307
    a boyle
    Participant

    @Angry Rebel wrote:

    You keep harping on about Cork and Dublin not being able to take the traffic. That’s a good point, but it’s not a reason to not build DC/motorway between the two biggest population centres in the state. DC all the way could save drivers probably 3/4 hour, an hour or more at peak times.

    You and the others are still not actually listening to what i am saying. It is pointless to build 2 dual carriage ways from limerick and cork and then join them together into one three lane dual carriage way. And then it is further pointless to bring all that traffic to the three lane m50 in order to join it up with all the other traffic.

    Yes we want bypasses

    Yes we want those bypasses to have slip roads on and off them , so that you don’t have to stop everywhere.

    But no it is not a good idea to have two lanes of traffic between the edges of the two cities, on the WHOLE.

    If you built a 2+one road WITH slip roads on and off you would have a much higher capacity than a normal 2+1 road . given that earlier it was quoted that a dual carriagway can cope with 20000 and a 2+1 6500 then a conservative number for a two+1 with slip roads on and off is 9000. Now this bring BIG savings . If you have been to america you will have noticed that on many of the motorways they use much smaller slip roads which are designed for 30mph /50kph. This is the kind of thing that could be put in place .

    WHY is my idea so good ? 1 every bridge is halved , 2 each road is halved. 3 the slip roads do not have to be half as elaborate.

    WHY Half the project ? becase then you could build a completely new 2+1 with slip roads somewhere else. With respect to cork a very good place to do this would be to build a road starting near mallow and heading due east ,clipping clonmel, and passing in between kilkenny and waterford berfore curling up to the south of wicklow.

    This is much better because you provide that nice freeflow driving for more people to more places.

    The new motorway/dual carriage way section just anounced is costing 450 million , and the minute it is finished you will save half an hour only to waste it again gettting into dublin . WE are not getting value for money .

    #779308
    jungle
    Participant

    @Pug wrote:

    small point but i flew in to the new terminal last week. I’m told its aer aranns fault ( i hold my hand up there if I am wrong) in that they wont pay for the more expensive parking in front of the new terminal but the plane was parked at the old terminal and we had to walk all the way up to the new one and climb 3 flights of stairs to get in. Escalator anyone? Think of that in the winter in the wind and rain. Welcome to Ireland in the 21st century.

    I agree with almost all of the rest of your posts, but I’ll just try to answer this one.

    Some of the stands (1-5) in Cork Airport are not capable of accommodating a 737-800 (Ryanair) or A320 (Aer Lingus. These aircraft will consequently end up occupying most of the stands in front of the new terminal. This is especially true in summer when there are charter airlines bringing in even more similarly large aircraft, Because Aer Arann aircraft are able to fit on these stands, they are likely to be put there so that they don’t occupy a stand that could be needed by a larger aircraft.

    #779309
    Pug
    Participant

    @jungle wrote:

    Because Aer Arann aircraft are able to fit on these stands, they are likely to be put there so that they don’t occupy a stand that could be needed by a larger aircraft.

    absolutely fair point and i take it “on board” if you pardon the pun. Why then wasnt a travelator within a corridor, i.e. not out in the wind and or some sort of shuttle bus type vehicle built in to the budget to cater for this? This sort of stuff is what makes me wonder who plans these things.

    #779310
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Thats a complete joke we have a company receiving up to €500 subsidy per passenger from the government who deliberately provide a yellow pack service on other routes

    #779311
    jungle
    Participant

    @Pug wrote:

    absolutely fair point and i take it “on board” if you pardon the pun. Why then wasnt a travelator within a corridor, i.e. not out in the wind and or some sort of shuttle bus type vehicle built in to the budget to cater for this? This sort of stuff is what makes me wonder who plans these things.

    The bus situation in Cork is crazy. In Edinburgh and Rotterdam I have been bussed to the terminal from less than 50m away, With the old terminal in Cork, you could walk from stand 16 to the terminal, which must have been a distance of several hundred metres. Having all those pedestrians wandering around is not condusive to smooth airfield operations anyway. The new terminal is at least a little more central to the stands, but a bus system should definitely be put in place.

    #779312
    Pug
    Participant

    Scary stats from the City itself re roads and transport in general.

    1) It is considered that a target of 5% of all trips to
    work, school and college by cycling is achievable
    by 2010. Cork Cycle Strategy, City Plan 2004.

    2) From the draft Bishopstown/Wilton Area Action Plan
    There is a growing dependence on the usage of the private car in the Plan area. The
    Cork Area Strategic Plan (CASP) predicts that without intervention traffic will double in the city within 20 years, peak hour travel speeds to be 8kph (currently 19kph for me) , and travel to work times will increase by 5 times (for me that will mean a 7 mile journey to be just over 3 hours). . Annual growth in traffic volumes are already above that predicted in 2002 by CASP

    Results from the 2002 Census showed continued decline in travel by green modes of
    transport. Almost half of people in the south-west area travel to work and school /
    college by car, resulting in increased problems of congestion, rat-running, parking.
    More students and schoolchildren are now being transported by private car than ever
    before while there have also been significant increases in car ownership levels.

    While in city-wide terms the area is relatively well served by public transport at present only 8% of the people in the plan area use public transport to get to work, school or college.

Viewing 20 posts - 241 through 260 (of 1,025 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.