CIE’s €100 million Tara Street Station construction

Home › Forums › Ireland › CIE’s €100 million Tara Street Station construction

Viewing 20 posts - 61 through 80 (of 126 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #808943
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    heh butty bridge…. very clever denny

    #808944
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @jimg wrote:

    Give it 20 or 30 years and when Victorian becomes as fashionable as Georgian is now, it’ll be the pride of the city – a Victorian wonder admired for it’s engineering ambition and robust execution; we all admire Roman aqueducts, no?

    I’m being half facetious but it either stays as it is or it goes completely. The latter isn’t going to happen this half century at least. The only thing that could be worse than it would be a “modern” looking replacement.

    I disagree. I think the Victorians did a lot of wonderful things, but this is a complete abject failure. It ruins the view of one of the architectural set pieces of Dublin and its bulky blackness lacks any elegance whatsoever. I don’t think we should be so in awe of the past that we have no confidence that our age could improve upon this monstrosity.

    #808945
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @rumpelstiltskin wrote:

    I disagree. I think the Victorians did a lot of wonderful things, but this is a complete abject failure. It ruins the view of one of the architectural set pieces of Dublin and its bulky blackness lacks any elegance whatsoever. I don’t think we should be so in awe of the past that we have no confidence that our age could improve upon this monstrosity.

    I completely agree. It is an inelegant, clunky eyesore whose only saving grace is the view OF the Custom House as you cross it. This by no means excuses it. Arriving east of the bridge by car or on foot you really see just how criminal obscuring the Custom House is. The photoshopped image above – with Liberty Hall reduced and the loopline removed – looks so much better. Although it does seem to leave out the Lafayette Building (is this its actual title?)

    This is a feeling I get so often looking at Dublin ‘vistas’. We have the right raw ingredients BUT WE ALWAYS GET IT WRONG. Well not always, but often.

    Rage.

    #808946
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    I’d love to see a photoshop with only the bridge gone.

    #808947
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    I agree, the Loopline is an insult on one of the most beautiful buildings of it’s kind in the world (customs house). It needs to be replaced by a very thin, streamlined, minimalist bridge that opens up the customs house to O’Connell St and extends the centre of town out to the docklands. Psychologically it has this effect of dividing the city in half.

    #808948
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    It’s an insult as it now stands, but anything can be adapted to harmonise with anything else if the will is there (as well as the skill)
    anything.
    a sculptural perspective needs to be taken on the 2 edifices.

    #808949
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Even if it was replaced by a more streamlined bridge, you’d still have something blocking the Customs House.. unless you brought it down to street level and then back up again (which is silly).

    #808950
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    why don’t we raise the Custom House instead…

    #808951
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @alonso wrote:

    why don’t we raise the Custom House instead…

    Damn straight alonso, these people just can’t look at the bigger picture. We all know the solution to this is to put the Custom House on stilts.

    #808952
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @missarchi wrote:

    remind’s me of the white house and some british tv show…

    I would accept that if I could be sure that there would be a cluster of buildings 20 storeys plus built down in the docks. I would accept a fully low-rise city centre in return for buildings of truly high scale being built in the docklands.

    #808953
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @Cathal Dunne wrote:

    I would accept that if I could be sure that there would be a cluster of buildings 20 storeys plus built down in the docks. I would accept a fully low-rise city centre in return for buildings of truly high scale being built in the docklands.

    +1 vote for this, I think a low-rise city centre is really what you want, it makes for a more open atmosphere, easier to find your way around.

    #808954
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @Yixian wrote:

    +1 vote for this, I think a low-rise city centre is really what you want, it makes for a more open atmosphere, easier to find your way around.

    What………

    I can find my way around Manhatten easily. That is really stupid what you just said.
    To translate that.
    Lets keep the city centre low rise (cus its easier to get around) Lets build high rise (cus its not easy to get around)

    Dublin city centre can still be a low rise city with 6/9 story buildings. I would be happy if they maintained this height within the canals. It height has nothing to do with making an atmosphere or getting around. The issue with the city centre it’s has architectural merit and much of the old buildings are protected structures. The city is generally 4/5 story’s. Tall buildings would not suit. That is the reason why, not this “oh its not easy to get around”

    #808955
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Well, in my person opinion I like the ambience of a low-rise city centre, it just feels more accessible. Manhattan is a bad example because of the way it’s streets are divided so uniformly, but old cities like Dublin don’t have that luxury and I value being able to see the tops of the few tall landmarks in the city centre to orient myself.

    I don’t live in Dublin so this advantage would disappear the more you get to know it – but I maintain that prefer it the height it is. Dot it with a few high rises sure, or better yet simply large monuments and statues.

    Building the high rise either side of the centre of town would look nice, particularly from down the river.

    And yeah 6/9 story is fine, I just mean not HK or NY scale in the very centre.

    #808956
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @Cathal Dunne wrote:

    I would accept that if I could be sure that there would be a cluster of buildings 20 storeys plus built down in the docks. I would accept a fully low-rise city centre in return for buildings of truly high scale being built in the docklands.

    I totally agree with you on this… keep city centre a low rise and classical looking area and build the docks to the sky!

    #808957
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @OisinT wrote:

    I totally agree with you on this… keep city centre a low rise and classical looking area and build the docks to the sky!

    I thought that was the original concept behind the docks, that it was a blank canvas. The ordinary criteria for building in the City could be relaxed and plot ratios and heights could increase. All the time preserving whats left of the historical core. Many reasonable people agree with this policy.

    However, the anti-skyscraper brigade started to object to taller buildings in the docklands because the could be seen in the distance from historic areas!!….and ABP took these spurious arguements seriously! Matters were not helped when a certain DDDA planning officer imposed uniform 6 storey parapet heights in the IFSC. Of course because such a conservative short sighted decision was taken….nobody batted an eyelid!

    #808958
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    I think that is where the north wall was supposed to come in… a cluster…

    #808959
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    I happen to think the sight of skyscrapers seen in the distance behind classical areas look very nice.

    It is a real shame that there was so much resistance to high rises before the recession, and now it appears to be too late. When any old city in Canada has a raft of vast scrapers and Dublin has next to none, it makes the city look inherently less like the economic hub it is becoming.

    Someone please reassure me that Dublin will catch up 🙁

    #808960
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    There is a plan on DCC’s website for this whole area- Georges Quay Plan- Go to Planning the Framework Development Plans- Its a DRAFT at the minute

    #808961
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @Yixian wrote:

    I happen to think the sight of skyscrapers seen in the distance behind classical areas look very nice.

    It is a real shame that there was so much resistance to high rises before the recession, and now it appears to be too late. When any old city in Canada has a raft of vast scrapers and Dublin has next to none, it makes the city look inherently less like the economic hub it is becoming.

    Someone please reassure me that Dublin will catch up 🙁

    there wasn’t resistence to highrise in the right place eg the docks

    #808962
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @lostexpectation wrote:

    there wasn’t resistence to highrise in the right place eg the docks

    Good point, I guess the recession hit just a little too early.

Viewing 20 posts - 61 through 80 (of 126 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.