CIE’s €100 million Tara Street Station construction
- This topic has 125 replies, 42 voices, and was last updated 15 years, 4 months ago by
Anonymous.
- AuthorPosts
- July 29, 2009 at 2:00 pm #808903
Anonymous
InactiveI suppose it was quite ridiculous to expect something that was mildly different from the current scene to be built. FFS.
July 29, 2009 at 8:54 pm #808904Anonymous
Inactive@aj wrote:
Since when has DCC been concerned with architectural quality? The permit derelection of large swathes of the city while permitting the sort of crap that lines the quays.
The hag of heinretta street comes to mind as a perfect example of DCCs concern for architectual quality.
+1000000!!
Good point. Plus, after years of planning, one arm of government is objecting to what the other is doing. NO joined up thinking. It really says ALOT about why this country is in the state it is!
C
July 29, 2009 at 10:15 pm #808905Anonymous
InactiveCIE are planning on spending €100m on this office spec development scheme – while acres of office space is empty, and An Bord Snip proposes saving €55m by closing 240km of railways around the country? Fuckwits 😡
And despite the scheme being higher than Liberty Hall, they cannot provide toilets for passengers because of the “confined” nature of the site?? FFS.
Somebody please abolish Irish Rail and CIE – this is clearly a public sector body that has got out of control, and is more interested in wasteful distractions as opposed to its core business. Get rid of them.
Finally just a quick reminder as to what custodians CIE are in the city centre with properties under their, eh, “care” – https://archiseek.com/content/showpost.php?p=73702&postcount=10
Note their employees private cars parked up in their depot, while they continue to dump buses onto Parnell and Mountjoy Squares. You just couldn’t make it up – 9 buses are now regularly parked back-to-back on Parnell Square alone. Also note the disgraceful condition of Broadstone Station.
Save Irish railways + public transport: Abolish CIE now.
July 30, 2009 at 2:34 am #808906Anonymous
InactiveThis all has a familiar ring to an upside down L shape down the river except the architecture is -1000 points and the impact was peanuts (I got burned there)
Should liberty hall and this be related? It will be be interesting to see how all this plays out and they end up with 6/7 stories like everyone else that does interesting stuff… unless its all part of the plan;)http://www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/ireland/2009/0730/1224251671423.html
July 30, 2009 at 8:54 am #808907Anonymous
Inactive@hutton wrote:
CIE are planning on spending €100m on this office spec development scheme – while acres of office space is empty, and An Bord Snip proposes saving €55m by closing 240km of railways around the country? Fuckwits 😡
And despite the scheme being higher than Liberty Hall, they cannot provide toilets for passengers because of the “confined” nature of the site?? FFS.
Somebody please abolish Irish Rail and CIE – this is clearly a public sector body that has got out of control, and is more interested in wasteful distractions as opposed to its core business. Get rid of them.
Finally just a quick reminder as to what custodians CIE are in the city centre with properties under their, eh, “care” – https://archiseek.com/content/showpost.php?p=73702&postcount=10
Note their employees private cars parked up in their depot, while they continue to dump buses onto Parnell and Mountjoy Squares. You just couldn’t make it up – 9 buses are now regularly parked back-to-back on Parnell Square alone. Also note the disgraceful condition of Broadstone Station.
Save Irish railways + public transport: Abolish CIE now.
My understnading is that IE will pay nothing for this building.
The developer who builds it will rebuild the 2nd busiest station in the country for free.the toilets issue might not be unrelated to the large congregation of drug addicts and dealers who infest this area.
all the same I think it’s wonderful that you know so much that you can sort everything out just by having a quick think without any need to check annoying facts.
July 30, 2009 at 11:11 am #808908Anonymous
InactiveIt’s a very detailed application but there are still some bits.
DCC normally request landscaping drawings with paving/crossing details.
We had 50 bike spaces for a few apartments go figure…
It would be good it the road was level.
+26.03 that hurts slevinAdditional Information – Softworks Specification
Additional Information – Street Furniture Schedule
Additional Information – Streetscape Masterplan
Additional Information – Landscape ImagesJuly 30, 2009 at 4:16 pm #808909Anonymous
InactiveReally interesting project, really hope this gets the go ahead as it would be an important step in elevating this station into a transport hub
July 30, 2009 at 6:34 pm #808910Anonymous
InactiveCannot understand DCC appealing it on grounds that it is a big slab overlooking the Customs house.
And what in the name of Allah is Liberty Hall, Hawkins Hse and that other lego set on top of the Ulster bank. Compared to that unholy trio this is quite elegant.
July 30, 2009 at 9:00 pm #808911Anonymous
Inactive@marmajam wrote:
Cannot understand DCC appealing it on grounds that it is a big slab overlooking the Customs house.
And what in the name of Allah is Liberty Hall, Hawkins Hse and that other lego set on top of the Ulster bank. Compared to that unholy trio this is quite elegant.
lol i agree how can a strcuture with a glazed exterior be a slab? i think they meant ‘bulky’ :rolleyes:
July 30, 2009 at 9:09 pm #808912Anonymous
InactiveWell on the right of those pictures you can see a rectilinear portion of the building which could be described as a slab. I still think it looks pretty good though.
July 31, 2009 at 12:56 am #808913Anonymous
Inactive@marmajam wrote:
My understnading is that IE will pay nothing for this building.
The developer who builds it will rebuild the 2nd busiest station in the country for free.the toilets issue might not be unrelated to the large congregation of drug addicts and dealers who infest this area.
all the same I think it’s wonderful that you know so much that you can sort everything out just by having a quick think without any need to check annoying facts.
Okay; show me your developer who’s:
A) Got the €100m to put down on the table now and build this
B) Is going to build this while vast chunks of office space in the city are lying idle
One or or two other “annoying facts” to add for your conundrum –
1) You can’t suggest a developer with a four letter name that begins with “N”, ends with “A” and has “AM” in the middle
2) Also barred regrettably are any out-of-control semi-state bodies whose core businesses are in other areas.
As gunter might say, best of luck with that 🙂
July 31, 2009 at 3:39 am #808914Anonymous
Inactive@hutton wrote:
Okay; show me your developer who’s:
A) Got the €100m to put down on the table now and build this
B) Is going to build this while vast chunks of office space in the city are lying idle
🙂
Eh Treasury holdings? Currently developing Montevetro which is bigger then this, about to unveil Aqua Vetro and developing a Hadid designed office block on the Northside.:rolleyes:
July 31, 2009 at 6:00 pm #808915Anonymous
Inactive@marmajam wrote:
I refer my learned friend to the reply I gave before.
(all the same I think it’s wonderful that you know so much that you can sort everything out just by having a quick think without any need to check annoying facts)
😀
@darkman, quote referred to wrote:
Eh Treasury holdings? Currently developing Montevetro which is bigger then this, about to unveil Aqua Vetro and developing a Hadid designed office block on the Northside.:rolleyes:
Really mamajam? Just a quick glance at the Hadid vs Foster thread throws up this, including I note a-not-so-optimistic comment by your “learned friend”…
@Yixian wrote:
Are any of these projects actually going ahead?
@darkman wrote:
They said a planning application for North Wall Quay would be lodged before the end of the year. Fingers crossed but im not overly hopeful.
@Rory W wrote:
About as much chance as satan’s snowball collection
marmajam, your debate have relied on silly speculative conjecture rather than providing facts. To suggest such as “fact” is irritating, but I’m still happy to watch you fumble with some more rope 🙂
August 1, 2009 at 2:36 am #808916Anonymous
InactiveIt’s lovely
But makes the pimple that is the Loop line bridge now look like a Cyst.
Those pillars are disgusting and the advertisements agrrrrrrrragh its so ugh.
August 1, 2009 at 2:38 am #808917Anonymous
Inactive@marmajam wrote:
Cannot understand DCC appealing it on grounds that it is a big slab overlooking the Customs house.
And what in the name of Allah is Liberty Hall, Hawkins Hse and that other lego set on top of the Ulster bank. Compared to that unholy trio this is quite elegant.
I agree the Tara street development actually brings balance to the Tara street side. All the building’s on that side are over 6 stories. The buildings behind Custom house opposite liberty hall is 10 storys. The Tara street building doesn’t look tall at all.
August 1, 2009 at 2:39 am #808918Anonymous
InactiveThis is good news
August 1, 2009 at 9:22 am #808919Anonymous
Inactive@dave123 wrote:
It’s lovely
The simple curved form (the ”grain of rise” I believe they’re calling it !) facing the Custom House, is perhaps borderline elegant, if of questionable massing and orientation at this location, but the jumble of competing, scaleless, forms on the Tara Street side would make the dismal streetscape here even more forelorn, imo.
If ABP had any inclinations to grant this, they should just give them permission for the curved block, and condition out the rest.
If this means IE end up with a ten storey building and no stairs, . . . . well they’ll learn the next time won’t they 😉
August 1, 2009 at 1:57 pm #808920Anonymous
Inactive@hutton wrote:
CIE are planning on spending €100m on this office spec development scheme – while acres of office space is empty, and An Bord Snip proposes saving €55m by closing 240km of railways around the country? Fuckwits 😡
Somebody please abolish Irish Rail and CIE – this is clearly a public sector body that has got out of control, and is more interested in wasteful distractions as opposed to its core business. Get rid of then.
Save Irish railways + public transport: Abolish CIE now.
Who’s CIE?
IE will not spend a penny on this building but will get a very necessary upgrade of the 2nd busiest station in the country done for free.
That’s their job. Well done by them.
You’re paranoid.
August 1, 2009 at 3:21 pm #808921Anonymous
Inactive@marmajam wrote:
Who’s CIE?
IE will not spend a penny on this building but will get a very necessary upgrade of the 2nd busiest station in the country done for free.
That’s their job. Well done by them.
You’re paranoid.
par⋅a⋅noi⋅a
/ˌpærəˈnɔɪə/ Show Spelled Pronunciation [par-uh-noi-uh]–noun
1. Psychiatry. a mental disorder characterized by systematized delusions and the projection of personal conflicts, which are ascribed to the supposed hostility of others, sometimes progressing to disturbances of consciousness and aggressive acts believed to be performed in self-defense or as a mission.Hmmm – that’s an interesting interpretation of paranoia you are projecting on to my development critique of (C)IE’s proposed scheme. Last time I checked, I was not aware of CIE/IE “out to get me” 🙂
Meanwhile back in the real world I am interested in the notion this is “a very necessary upgrade of the 2nd busiest station in the country”; given that no toilets are provided, I find the term “upgrade” novel. Somebody’s taking the piss – or maybe not if CIE get their way.
I also dispute your interpretation that this will be “done for free”; show me the money as it were, as to who is backing them – and please don’t provide any more conjecture masquerading as “fact”.
What is happening here is the public transport company CIE, is attempting to develop what is primarily a speculative office scheme through their subsidiary company, Irish Rail, claiming it to be an “upgrade” of a railway station. I don’t consider a new railway station without toilets to be an upgrade. What I also note is that a cost of €100m has been put on developing the scheme, without declaring who is going to foot the bill – other than suggesting it’ll be done by some mythical developer. Maybe I am being unreasonable, but at a time of unprecedented vacancies of existing office and corporate space, this to my mind is based on fantasy of a bygone age.
Worse than that, CIE are advancing a €100m scheme at a time when An Bord Snip is recommending saving €55m by closing 240km of railway around the country.
@marmajam wrote:
That’s their job. Well done by them.
Developing spec office blocks amidst unprecedented vacancy – rather than defending what should be their core business interests of keeping railways open and providing public transport? Well if you say so, but I would have to differ 🙂
marmajam, you are so gung-ho about this project – to a point of unnecessarily insulting critics – are there any interests that you would like to declare, just for sake of clarity?
August 1, 2009 at 10:16 pm #808922Anonymous
InactiveI agree with you marmajam. Some people on this site bitch and moan about EVERY SINGLE DEVELOPMENT undertaken in Dublin and elsewhere. It’s soooooooooooo boring. It’s pretty obvious that this building will improve the centre of Dublin generally and clean up a pretty grotty block opposite the Customs House. You’d think people would be happy about it.
- AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

