CIE’s €100 million Tara Street Station construction

Home › Forums › Ireland › CIE’s €100 million Tara Street Station construction

Viewing 20 posts - 1 through 20 (of 126 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #710680
    Contraband
    Participant

    -Sorry if this has been posted before-

    This scheme has finally gone before An Bord Pleanála today

    CIE aims high with €100m station plan

    Tuesday July 28 2009

    CIE plans to build a €100m office block….

    This morning, An Bord Pleanala will open a public hearing into plans by the company to redevelop one of the country’s busiest transport centres, which would see a 14-storey office block built above the tracks on a 0.3 acre site.

    …..

    And CIE has insisted it was “confident” the development would go ahead, despite the current economic difficulties.

    Some 10 million passengers go through the station every year, and further growth is expected as Transport 21 projects, including the underground DART, come on stream.

    The 12-metre tall concourse area will cater for up to 14,500 passengers per hour at peak commuter times.

    To fund the development of the station, a landmark office development will also be included over the station, with an office space of 13,000sq m, which sees the overall height of the development total 60.8 metres.

    The scheme will be developed on a phased basis to permit the station to remain open during construction.

    – Paul Melia

    Irish Independent News in Ireland & Worldwide | Irish Newspaper | News Stories Online*****-*****Independent.ie

    Fair enough, nothing ground breaking but pleasing to look at nonetheless. Now is the time to build afterall.

    #808884
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    It looks good hope it doesn’t meet the same fate as many other high rise schemes have recently

    #808885
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Sexy. But those pictures are scarred by the ugly loop line bridge. Can anybody tell me it if would be technically feasible to somehow lower the bridge to the level of regular bridges, thus restoring the vista of the Customs House? I mean while they’re building this thing they could easily dig a little underpass for cars and pedestrians to go under the line. Then if they turned the front of the Customs House into a plaza they could gradually lower the line on that side towards the river, again with a little underpass for pedestrians.

    #808886
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @rumpelstiltskin wrote:

    Sexy. But those pictures are scarred by the ugly loop line bridge. Can anybody tell me it if would be technically feasible to somehow lower the bridge to the level of regular bridges, thus restoring the vista of the Customs House? I mean while they’re building this thing they could easily dig a little underpass for cars and pedestrians to go under the line. Then if they turned the front of the Customs House into a plaza they could gradually lower the line on that side towards the river, again with a little underpass for pedestrians.

    from my back of the envelope calculations i estimate that would cost 59 Billion Euros. Everything is technically feasible but some projects would eh impose a greater burden on the city than others.

    Loop line is a bit like Twink – rusty, old and a pain in the arse, but it’s hard to imagine Dublin without it.

    #808887
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Do I see brise soleil on the north east side of the building?

    Philistines.

    #808888
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    this is PP for a new schedule I’m pretty sure the same building had an earlier PP (the 1st one probably 1620 – spinning it out a bit IE if you ask me)
    but the construction would have meant closing Tara St station and this is forbidden by the laws of physics
    so they’ve reconfigured the design

    must have a good chance of being built seeing that the offices are below the busiest transport node in Eire

    #808889
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @rumpelstiltskin wrote:

    Sexy. But those pictures are scarred by the ugly loop line bridge. Can anybody tell me it if would be technically feasible to somehow lower the bridge to the level of regular bridges, thus restoring the vista of the Customs House? I mean while they’re building this thing they could easily dig a little underpass for cars and pedestrians to go under the line. Then if they turned the front of the Customs House into a plaza they could gradually lower the line on that side towards the river, again with a little underpass for pedestrians.

    probably be more practical to reconstruct every building in the vicinity into the open plan girders style so it’d all match.

    #808890
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Now that they’ve got the advertising off it, there’s nothing wrong with the old Loop Line that a clever coat of paint and some good lighting wouldn’t cure.

    #808891
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @alonso wrote:

    Loop line is a bit like Twink – rusty, old and a pain in the arse, but it’s hard to imagine Dublin without it.

    It’s amazingly easy to imagine! Just picture an interrupted vista up and down the quays without a clunky, stodgy bridge dividing the docklands from the rest of the city.

    #808892
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Exactly! It’s a completely revolting disaster, and it should be a priority. There’s something terribly oppressively ugly about Dublin from O’Connell Bridge up to the Customs House. If they just:
    1.Properly paved the whole area and cleaned it up (esp O’Connell Bridge)
    2.Demolished O’Connell Bridge House and Liberty Hall
    3. Did something about the two buildings on either corner of O’Connell St.
    4.Got rid of the loopline bridge

    it could be quite nice.

    #808893
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @rumpelstiltskin wrote:

    it could be quite nice.

    Not with Eden Quay being used as a bus station by Dublin Bus and it apparently being along the migration path of the city’s heroin junkies.

    #808894
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    4.Got rid of the loopline bridge

    it could be quite nice.[/QUOTE]

    It’s stated regularly enough on here how unfeasible it is to get rid of it. you would need to put the dart underground from Sydney parade to killester to realise the removal.

    #808895
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @tommyt wrote:

    It’s stated regularly enough on here how unfeasible it is to get rid of it. you would need to put the dart underground from Sydney parade to killester to realise the removal.

    There was a design about a decade ago (or more) for a very low impact bridge to replace the Loop Line.

    #808896
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    I would not bother lowering it…
    I would just get rid of it and Tara st station all together
    and put it below oconell st bridge or hawkins house/DOL st

    can anyone see the billboard the size of totem carman on the structure?

    there are two options… it goes to broadstone via granny morning or plugs into metro north or the interconnector…

    there seems to be some photoshop somewhere showing no bridge?

    #808897
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    what is the big white rim on the pub, a big sign for the station?

    #808898
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    @tommyt wrote:

    It’s stated regularly enough on here how unfeasible it is to get rid of it. you would need to put the dart underground from Sydney parade to killester to realise the removal.

    Considering that it “loops” considerably to get to that point in the river in the first place, is there any reason they couldn’t just move it to the other side of the Customs House? Then, with a good shiny modern design and the iron railings removed, it could represents a sort of gateway to the docklands. It’d be pretty simple, you could just run it as an elevated train down Amiens Street from Connolly, and down Moss Street towards Pearse Station. Imagine something as elegant as that Calatrava bridge right behind the classic vista of the Customs House – I think it would form an iconic image of Dublin.

    #808899
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Council objects to Tara Street office ‘slab’ above station

    DUBLIN CITY Council is opposing plans by Iarnród Éireann for a €100 million redevelopment of Tara Street station in Dublin, including the construction of a 15-storey office block on the site. The two State bodies are also at loggerheads over the payment of development contributions and a levy to fund the Metro North in the event of planning permission being granted. An Bord Pleanála yesterday began an oral hearing into Iarnród Éireann’s plans to redevelop the Dart and mainline station, the second-busiest in the country.

    …

    However, the council, in its observation to the board, has likened the proposed tower to “a large slab form” sitting poorly in the skyline. While not opposed to development on the site, it says the current proposal is not capable of being amended and should be rejected. The proposed development will reach 60.8 metres into the Dublin skyline, slightly higher than Liberty Hall and almost twice the height of the Custom House. Iarnród Éireann told the hearing, chaired by inspector Karla McBride, that the loss of any floors from the office tower would significantly reduce its commercial viability.

    A 10-year planning permission is being sought as construction is likely to take longer than the normal five years allowed. The Department of the Environment has also expressed concern about the proposed development and has called for the provision of a nesting platform for peregrine falcons as part of any planning permission. The development envisages the demolition of Tara House and other buildings but Kennedy’s pub, a four-storey protected structure on George’s Quay, will survive.

    Iarnród Éireann called on the board not to impose levies on the development to fund Metro North and to reduce the normal development contributions due to Dublin City Council as part of planning permission.

    There’s more but it’s a long article so I only quoted parts of it. It’s hard to imagine the thinking behind one state agency applying a development levy to another state agency, especially when they’re both part of the DoT. This is just bureaucratic money shuffling and will probably end up in the courts with the taxpayer funding both sides.

    There is one final oddity:

    However, Iarnród Éireann does not intend to provide any toilets or bicycle parking in the station because of the “confined” nature of the site. Ms McBride said it wasn’t logical to expect cyclists to park their bikes at other stations if travelling from Tara Street.

    #808900
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Since when has DCC been concerned with architectural quality? The permit derelection of large swathes of the city while permitting the sort of crap that lines the quays.

    The hag of heinretta street comes to mind as a perfect example of DCCs concern for architectual quality.

    #808901
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Anyway all these projects are linked…

    so some of the DOT information submitted for MN is going to overlap here.
    That means in order of 500 or more bicycle spaces if my memory is spot on…
    and bikes on trains? have to wait and see…

    toilets would also be expected if it was the second busiest station in the state.

    We have a station here that is i’m guessing the 30th busy one and it has toilet’s open at peak hour only

    #808902
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    http://www.tarastreetstation.ie/#a5

    http://www.tarastreetstation.ie/pdf/Volume3/Part%20One%20Visual%20Impacts/View%2016A%20-%20O%27Connell%20Bridge%20(North).pdf

    Car lift is interesting wohr? some of those columns look like a pain in the arse…
    If you count escalators this station will rank 6 or 7 in a few years…
    Is the lift big enough for a bike?

Viewing 20 posts - 1 through 20 (of 126 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.