Re: Re: The sensitive issue of the title “Architect” and the Building Control Bill
Home › Forums › Ireland › The sensitive issue of the title "Architect" and the Buildin › Re: Re: The sensitive issue of the title “Architect” and the Building Control Bill
CK,
Your first paragraph is unclear.
“I do not think that the RIAI Lobbying campaign is illegal because the RIAI as a double statute. It is the registration body for architects in Ireland but it is also a professional body representing its members, those using the letters MRIAI after their names.”
The RIAI is a private body with a statutory appointment.
It is questionable in terms of good governance to do this.
It does not appear to be illegal, merely not good practice.
The RIAI allege this is accepted in Europe – its still not good.
Your fourth paragraph appears to open up a wider debate:
“If the RIAI lobbying campaign is legal, it is surely against the ethic and incompatible with the statute of the architects registration body of Ireland.”
Again, it is a little unclear, but the gist of seems to be that engaing in political lobbying to support its own aims is at odds with the terms of reference of a statutory registration body.
Others would appear to share a similar view.
I understand that the head of the Assessment Board, a Barrister, has refused even to meet the Architect’s Alliance because she was [correctly, IMO] concerned that it could be seen to compromise the Assessment Board’s impartiality.
I realise that the Registrar has taken a pro-active stance, in keeping with his interpretation of the ideals of the RIAI to promote architecture.
This is fine up to a point, the possible consensus and agreement that discussions with the AAoI or any other interest groups might engender outweighing any allegations of collusion or behind-the-scenes negotiations that the simple minded might proffer.
However the road the Registrar set foot on when he decided to offer CPD points for MRIAI’s to do a course in political lobbying must have everyone who was mentioned in a Flood Tribunal module chortling with glee. The highest competent authority in the land on Architecture – a profession sprinkled with Green and Labour T.D.’s – is opening the Pandora’s Box that they must agree has led to so many corrupt and inappropriate planning decisions during the Tiger years.
RIAI President Paul Keogh must be spinning on his pedestal so soon after delivering his firebrand inaugural speech
In it, he declaimed against the poor planning decisions, such as those that have resulted in ghost estates scattered in unlikely places throughout Ireland.
After all, wasn’t it political lobbying of Councillors in remote rural locations that promoted the “build them and they will come” mentality that overturned sound planning practice throughout Ireland?
Mind you, its not as if the RIAI are strangers when it comes to political lobbying themselves, although it may be more concentrated in the lofty reaches of the Seanad than the Dáil.
- It was political lobbying that got the Building Control Act 2007 passed into law, to the great benefit of the RIAI.
- It was political lobbying that brought some balance to this situation with the publication of John O’Donoghue’s Building Control Amendment Bill 2010.
- It will be the recent call to Members of the RIAI to do CPD-rated courses in political lobbying that will expose the newly minted office of Registrar to ridicule in the press.
Those who have benefited by political lobbying cannot complain when they are hoisted by their own petard.
Contrary to what you might think I don’t see any of this as a good thing.
John Graby is the Registrar and must rightly busy himself with calling for consensus, promoting architecture and ensuring registration proceeds in an orderly fashion for the benefit of the public.
But, as Registrar, he needs to stand back from the slippery slope of being seen to promote political lobbying.
Let the Registrar’s views be made known by a few well-placed phone calls to key figures in the profession, the Dáil and the Seanad, rather than via the public domain.
But if after mature reflection its decided to mobilse the rank and file of the RIAI Membership, let RIAI President Paul Keogh take the lead, or one of the other Directors of RIAI Limited.
This is because its a very short step from lobbying for what the Registrar might see is a good cause, and lobbying for planning advantage for a client.
The latter is best kept at huge distance from any building professionals, whose job is to design and help present a development on behalf of their clients.
It seems wholly inappropriate for the Registrar to engage in political lobbying at the end of a decade-long planning tribunal which has yet its issue its report
Let the Political Lobbyist or the Client do the political lobbying – that should not be the architect’s role.
The current CPD rated course for MRIAI’s seems ill-advised and likely to lower the standing of our profession.
ONQ.

