Re: Re: The sensitive issue of the title “Architect” and the Building Control Bill
Home › Forums › Ireland › The sensitive issue of the title "Architect" and the Buildin › Re: Re: The sensitive issue of the title “Architect” and the Building Control Bill
@CK wrote:
Ben,
However you are contradicting yourself when you say that registration protect the public but that it cannot guaranty that all registered architects are doing their job correctly and honestly… You also leave many questions unanswered…
– Why is the RIAI misleading the public with anti-competitive advertising and other actions?
– Why was registration not implemented as to protect existing businesses and regulate the creation of new practice as it was in France?
– Why are all the MRIAI favored by the procedure?
– Who shall regulate non-registered architects?There are many other questions, but those are the most fundamentals…
You have your arguments CK and that’s grand even if I think most of them have more holes in them than a block of swiss cheese…
And I’m not contradicting myself at all. As I said before you can NEVER guarantee that every member of an organisation is always going to practice competently (whether that’s a doctor, solicitor, accountant, teacher whatever). It’s about trying to set standards and procedures that help achieve the highest and most professional level of service possible relevant to whatever the profession is. Are you trying to suggest that there is some sort of magical procedure out there that guarantees that 100% of people operating as architects (or any other profession) are working correctly and honestly all the time… It doesn’t exist.
And to address your recent points:
-The RIAI have been brought up on that point already. I admit the RIAI could have worded the ad differently, from what I know of it (I didn’t hear it myself) they probably should have mentioned that there are people still going through the registration assessment process and it was unfair that these people were discriminated against. That has nothing really to do with the point of registration itself however.
-Why should registration be implemented as to protect existing businesses without any assessment? Why should there be a free lunch for anyone? Pass the assessment and quit complaining. The fees for this seem excessive at first glance but again as someone has mentioned before, try doing the below mentioned 5/6 years and subsequent professional exams in college and tell me how much money you end up spending…
-The MRIAI aren’t favored by the the procedure, it just so happens that to become MRIAI the vast vast majority have done the requisite training: 5/6 years of a recognised architecture design course, 3 years at least post qualification working with an approved architect/office, the completion of a case study, essays, exams interviews… (all of which you continuously conveniently forget to mention because it doesn’t suit your argument).
-To be perfectly honest that’s a bit of a nonsense question, why should non-registered architects be regulated by anyone, they shouldn’t exist: if they’re non-registered they should not be practicing as architects! (provision of architectural services by architectural technologists and other professionals etc. is a different matter and that does need to be looked at)
And whether the RIAI is the right body to administer the registration procedure or not, I’m not sure about that yet, time will tell. Apart from that I really have nothing else to add to this debate, it’s gone around in enough circles at this stage…

