Re: Re: The sensitive issue of the Grandfather Clause and the title “Architect”

Home › Forums › Ireland › The sensitive issue of the Grandfather Clause and the title "Architect" › Re: Re: The sensitive issue of the Grandfather Clause and the title “Architect”

#813528
Anonymous
Inactive

@wearnicehats wrote:

There is of course the usual sour grapes from Wearnicehats & Co [thanks for that Ruairí Quinn link, BTW] but they have no clue about the real world.

Actually, I do – and, while we’re at it, why should you have the right to cry foul and not me?

I qualified from a five year course, have twenty years experience behind me post qualification and I didn’t get automatically registered whereas some muppet with two years who passes an exam can?

I did a 6 year course and have 19 years experience in 4 different countries. I passed my exams 2 years after leaving college – so that makes me a muppet? I have a recollection that you yourself chose not to register? – apologies if in error

I have known several MRIAIs or more years who were not competent to inspect, never mind certify, yet they are given a pre-eminent position based on an assumption of their competence.Many practically trained architects can run rings around them, but they cannot legally use the title?

As do I but I know many other non-qualified persons who, if they worked for me, would not be allowed near a site or a contract either. They can’t use the title and rightly so. There’s a certain mainland European person who has been very vocal in pressing for the “Bill” on another thread. Judging from what I’ve seen; whilst this Bill may loosen the shackles on many competent non qualified persons, it will evidently also throw open the doors of the odd asylum

If parity is the goal then I have every right to expect those people who have been under the radar to be subject to the same rules as me retrospectively. In my case that’s the cost of 6 years of study, the cost of the subsequent professional exams and the cost of 17 years of professional fees and PII. I am also entitled to my opinion that third level education is as important to a person’s growth as the school of hard knocks

I don’t know. Some people can give it but when it comes to taking it……………

I have no problem with taking it and I used the title legally for 18 years.

What gives you and teh RIAI the right to tell me I can’t use the TItle I earnt?

Haw many FRIAIs do you know who have a clue about the current regs – most will have the good grace to admit in private that they don’t.

Many came from an era when faced with a difficult detailing problem they said “give it to a technician”.

And that is the rick they will perish on when someone who knows the law takes this mess in front of the Hight Court.

Technicians carried the bulk of design responsibility in relation to complaince, yet most MRIAIs think they are on another planet when it comes to design.

There is a lot of gross unfairness in the segregation that exists and just like in England either it gets addressed fairly or its goign to blow up in the RIAI and Government faces.

ONQ.