Re: Re: The sensitive issue of the Grandfather Clause and the title “Architect”

Home › Forums › Ireland › The sensitive issue of the Grandfather Clause and the title "Architect" › Re: Re: The sensitive issue of the Grandfather Clause and the title “Architect”

#813524
Anonymous
Inactive

@Rourke wrote:

heres an excerpt from the above link

“Mr. O’Dowd: This is an important issue. The Bill concerns qualification and people who are deemed to be architects and practising as such. I have received representations from the Group of Independent Architects in Ireland, GIAI, which, with the Architects and Surveyors Institute, ASI, the Incorporated Association of Architects and Surveyors, IAAS, and the Irish Architects Society, IAS, has contributed to a document entitled A Framework for”

So in addition to the RIAI , we now have the following ( newly sprouted?) groups of individuals in the fray who ‘represent the Profession’…

the GIAI, the ASI, the IAAS, the IAS, the Architects Alliance, perhaps 3 or 4 Architectural technician groups also.8 or 10 groups who ‘represent Architects’ in a country of 4 million ( im subtracting a few hundred k emigrants and returning immigrants )

All competing with various Engineers of varying levels of competence from semi retired expert down to a few months in the local tech college , construction technicians , project managers ( in some cases a 2 or 3 day course confers a title of ‘project manager’ ) , Chartered Surveyors , Quantity Surveyors etc

throw in the odd auctioneer, govt planning official, accountant, estate agent , tech drawing teacher , garda, milkman, taxi driver parish priest and whoever else can manage to raise 20 quid to photocopy a house plan from the county councils files and resubmit. No wonder the general public is confused.

There is a lot in what you say Rourke, but you need to open your mind a little.

I have met MRIAIs who were incompetent at soem things and practically trained architects who were very competent at msot things

I have met MRIAIs who were barely competent when they qualified and for whom no amount of CPD can help them keep up with current developments.

This is the current Big Lie beign peddled by the RIAI – that CPD will keep you competent.

Competence is a state of mind, like checking over the latest design mags, reading the latest legislation and case law, visiting buildings, talking with the people installing the newer forms of construction, visiting the latest sites.

There are very few grey heads on the AAI site visits I have attended, yet they too are automatically registered by this Buildign Control Act.

Plus about 20-25% of the RIAI were at one time unqualified,
Conveniently I think the last of them retired a year or so ago.
Which jsut leaves the sweet deal they did with the GIAI and IAS.people.
Perhaps you should direct your ire there if standards are what gets you going.

ONQ.