Re: Re: Metro North

Home › Forums › Ireland › Metro North › Re: Re: Metro North

#795553
Anonymous
Inactive

@PVC King wrote:

When someone argues that a €3bn – €5bn investment is required because it serves a logistics park you know that you are discussing matters with a very dim individual.

Au contraire, when you have someone who jumps on the mentioning of one possible use of the line at one station of it as the justification of the whole line they are the truly dim individual. On top of that, if you actually look at the area in which the Northwood stop will be built it is already quite built up and will be increasingly so as the Metro is completed and serves the area. With the M50, Airport and Metro all in close proximity, this area can only grow and grow.

You previously stated that DCU was the only university in the country without a rail link; lets look at these universities.

Cork – none
Galway – None
UCD – None
Limerick – None
Belfast – Very long walk from Botanic station
Jordanstown – None
TCD – already served – but by accident and not design.

Well whatever about that, Maynooth has a rail connection, Trinity has a connection and DIT at Grangegorman will have a Luas connection. As a Trinity student, I know of many people who use the DART to get to college and benefit greatly from it. This illustrates how valuable a direct rail link to a university is. If anything you’ve merely emphasised how urgent it is to get every college in Ireland connected to the rail network in some shape or form.

On a related point, you have also failed to respond adequately to my point that if a residential area of similar density to Whitehall/Glasnevin in Maynooth housing a smaller university than DCU can support a heavy-rail line and station then DCU/Whitehall/Glasnevin can support a light-rail line.

In any case, your points about individual stations are nit-picking. The overall catchment area of Metro North is 400,000. Add in the tourists from the airport, those using Metro to connect to something else and all the rest and you have a large and plentiful market for a metro line to serve. Cities with smaller populations and lower densities than Dublin already have metro, we should too.

You miss a number of big pictures; firstly the bigger planning picture i.e. what type of Dublin is wanted going forward and secondly how the bigger planning picture is impacted by the fall out of the Metro North approach to the domestic banking sector between 2002-08 and the resultant inability to raise funds at realistic prices on bond markets.

Your conflation of the banking crisis and Metro North is egregious. Unlike the casinolike carry on of our banks, Metro North is an investment in our future. Unlike the build and borrow now, bother later attitude of developers, Metro North is a long-term project which will serve Irish people for generations.

No, I don’t miss the bigger picture as I have regularly referred to other parts of the overall transport plan for the GDA. Once Metros North and West, the DART Underground, Luas BXD, Luas Line F and the Bray extension are built, we will have a public transport network to be proud of. A transport network which reflects Dublin’s stature as a European capital city.